Why Israel’s Supreme Court ruling matters to America
![Why Israel’s Supreme Court ruling matters to America](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/06/GettyImages-1257514124.jpg?w=900)
Earlier this week, the Israeli Supreme Court tightened the political noose around Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. It ruled that ultra-Orthodox Haredi yeshiva students would no longer be exempt from military service.
The court did not order the immediate conscription of all 66,000 students currently exempt from service, but it made clear that the process of conscription must start immediately, even if it is to take place gradually. The court also mandated that any religious seminary whose students avoided military service would no longer receive government subsidies, since those funds were tied to the now defunct military exemptions.
It is noteworthy that the ruling was unanimous and included the support of the court’s Orthodox members.
Israel’s ongoing war in Gaza, and the prospect of a second front war against Hezbollah — both of which have drained the country’s military manpower and forced multiple extensions of reserve duty — was a major factor in the court’s ruling. As one judge put it, “in the midst of a grueling war, the burden of inequality is harsher than ever and demands a solution.”
The vast majority of Israelis, including many religious Jews, share that view. As an Israeli taxi driver put it to me a few weeks ago, “I pray daily, and am observant. But I work while these people not only receive government funds, many spend hours each day away from the schools they nominally attend.”
Moreover, the success of the Orthodox Hesder yeshivas, whose students combine religious studies with military service, puts paid to the entire Haredi case for exemption due to Torah study.
Haredi leaders have always insisted that Torah study is as, if not more, important than military service for protecting Israel from its enemies. But the historical record demonstrates that as the number of students has increased dramatically since 1973, Israel’s record on the battlefield since that year has been considerably more mixed.
Not surprisingly, Haredi leaders have reacted with anger over the court’s decision. In the past, some even had asserted that yeshiva students should emigrate rather than serve in the military. Aryeh Deri, leader of the Haredi Shas party, did not go that far, but he did assert that “there is no force in the world that can disconnect the people of Israel from Torah study, and anyone who has tried in the past has failed miserably.”
Deri’s voice is particularly significant, as he is closely aligned with Netanyahu. Netanyahu's government would collapse without Shas support. The Shas leader — who served three years in prison after he was convicted of fraud in 1999 and 22 years later was party to a plea deal over tax offenses — served as a member of the small inner war cabinet that the prime minister created after Hamas attacked Israel on Oct. 7. When Netanyahu dissolved that group after the resignations of former Defense Minister Benny Gantz and former Chief of Staff Gadi Eisenkot, he announced that henceforth, he would consult with a selected group of advisors; Deri was identified as a member of that group.
Netanyahu, desperate to save his government, and Deri and the leaders of the other Haredi parties, seeking to restore their community’s privileges, will no doubt make every effort to have the Knesset pass a new, perhaps watered-down law exempting Haredi students. As a Likud party statement put it, the court’s decision is “relevant for only a short period of time.”
Nevertheless, the prospects for passage of a new law currently appear dim. Several members of Netanyahu’s own Likud party have indicated that they would oppose any new exemptions. The opposition of two Likud legislators forced Netanyahu to withdraw another Haredi-supported bill creating over 1,000 new rabbinical positions at government expense, which does not augur well for any new legislation that revives government support for the Haredim.
The Supreme Court ruling ending government subsidies for Haredi students and their schools affects American taxpayers. The U.S. provides $4 billion annually to support Israel’s defense programs. Budget money is inherently fungible, and therefore Israeli finance officials can divert funds to other projects which, in the absence of American support and in Israel’s wartime environment, they would have been forced to spend on defense. Support for Haredi students, schools and other community programs are among those projects.
More important, however, is the impact of the Supreme Court ruling on prospects for Netanyahu’s survival as prime minister, which are now increasingly dim. Many in Washington would welcome the collapse of the Netanyahu government. It certainly is long overdue.
Dov S. Zakheim is a senior adviser at the Center for Strategic and International Studies and vice chairman of the board for the Foreign Policy Research Institute. He was undersecretary of Defense (comptroller) and chief financial officer for the Department of Defense from 2001 to 2004 and a deputy undersecretary of Defense from 1985 to 1987.
Date: | |
Tag: | Israel |
Filter
-
CBS News - Top stories
The ethical quandary facing the Supreme Court (and America)
Polls show Americans' trust in the Supreme Court has never been lower, especially in light of ethical lapses that lead observers to question the impartiality of the justices. -
CBS News - Top stories
Supreme Court rules on abortion, Purdue Pharma cases
On Thursday, the U.S. Supreme Court released more major decisions on multiple cases as the term nears its end. The justices blocked the $6 billion settlement by the makers of the drug oxycontin because it also shielded members of the Sackler ...Abortion -
The Hill - Politics
READ: Supreme Court ruling in Trump immunity case
The Supreme Court on Monday issued its ruling, a 6-3 vote, in the highly anticipated case to determine whether presidents have immunity in their actions, official and unofficial. Former President Trump’s claimed he had presidential immunity from ...Donald Trump -
CBS News - Top stories
Breaking down the Supreme Court's Trump immunity ruling
The Supreme Court ruled Monday that presidents have immunity from criminal prosecution for official actions undertaken in office, a decision that will likely prevent former President Donald Turmp's election interference case from going to trial ...Donald Trump -
ABC News - Top stories
Supreme Court live updates: Trump, Biden campaign react to SCOTUS immunity ruling
The Supreme Court handed down a historic decision on whether a former president is shielded from criminal liability for "official acts" taken while in the White House.Joe Biden -
CBS News - Top stories
Why the Supreme Court's decision limiting federal agencies is so significant
The Supreme Court overruled a 40-year-old decision that said federal courts should defer to agencies in certain cases. Here's what it means. -
The Hill - Politics
Why Idaho's position in the Supreme Court emergency abortions case is concerning
No one having a medical emergency should be denied care due to the state they live in. Congress made this principle clear 40 years ago, and it may need to do so again.Abortion -
The New York Times - Business
Purdue Opioid Settlement on Verge of Collapse After Supreme Court Ruling
Plaintiffs and the company vowed to renegotiate but the talks will be challenging after the court struck down a provision the Sacklers had insisted on in exchange for $6 billion. -
CBS News - Politics
Supreme Court blocks EPA rule aimed at combating air pollution
The Supreme Court ruled 5-4 to grant the request from Ohio, two other states and energy companies.
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Psaki defends debate prep team: 'Biden was bad'
MSNBC anchor Jen Psaki, who once served as President Biden's press secretary, defended his campaign amid criticism of the president's debate performance last week, instead pinning the blame on the president. Psaki said it is “absurd” to blame ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Head of Trump PAC predicts 'cannibalistic chaos' if Dems replace Biden
The head of the primary super PAC supporting former President Trump said the potential replacement of President Biden as the Democratic Party’s presidential nominee would be “impossible” to carry out and essentially spell defeat for the party in ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Doubts have grown over Biden's mental fitness: Poll
Voters' doubts about President Biden’s fitness to serve in the Oval Office have grown over the past few months, according to a new poll released Monday amid the fallout from his shaky debate performance last week. The latest Harvard CAPS-Harris ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Trump lead over Biden unchanged since debate: Poll
Former President Trump’s lead over President Biden in national polling is unchanged following the debate between the candidates last week, according to a new survey. The Harvard CAPS/Harris poll released Monday, which was conducted after the ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Luttig: Trump, other presidents now 'above the law'
Retired federal judge J. Michael Luttig said former President Trump and other U.S. presidents can now be considered "above the law" after the Supreme Court ruled Monday that core presidential powers are immune from prosecution. “It can never again ...Donald Trump