Why China’s economic woes should raise concern for the West
The West might be hoping domestic economic strains facing China will curb its appetite for global competition, even foreshadowing a retreat. But the opposite seems much more likely: an intensification of Beijing’s geopolitical assertiveness, worsening relations with the U.S. and its allies, possibly to a dangerous degree.
The Chinese economy is expected to slow significantly over the next two years, as it faces a series of domestic challenges, including a prolonged downturn in the real estate sector as well as its demographic decline. You would think, then, that in the near-term, at least, Beijing might be more focused on its economy than consolidating its global posture. Yet, Chinese government actions of late, coupled with the leadership’s mindset, suggest otherwise.
Investors and economists appear to have little confidence in Beijing's recent measures to deal with economic headwinds. Critically, Beijing seems reluctant to put in place a substantial stimulus package to boost domestic consumption, akin to the spending it delivered to tackle economic downturns in 2015 and the global financial crisis. The likely reason for the Chinese leadership’s reluctance is that it would face strong internal political challenge, as significant institutional and economic changes would be required.
In order to generate sufficient stimulus funds, Beijing would need to amortize large amounts of non-performing investments, such as property and infrastructure projects that do not seem to be generating enough returns — overcapacity a key reason. The only other option would be to implement reforms that switch China’s growth model from one led by investment in infrastructure and property to one driven by consumption or other, more productive, sectors, such as hi-tech.
But there are problems with this. While China has been trying to reorientate its economy towards innovation, there’s insufficient capacity in this sector to absorb the capital required for such a shift. For this reason, China would instead need to boost domestic consumption, likely problematic for the Chinese leadership.That’s because it would have to transfer funds from the government and state-backed sector to households to raise their incomes. This would necessarily mean devolving power and control to ordinary Chinese citizens; something Beijing has been desperate to avoid doing over the past decade.
Given its aversion to restoring the economy in this way, Beijing will sooner or later realize (if it has not already) that its ability to project power globally will become progressively limited. In recent years, China has invested heavily in its capacity to exert geopolitical and geoeconomic influence, by both strengthening economic ties with other countries and building its own military capacity.
In response, the U.S. has been bolstering its military alliances, particularly in the Indo-Pacific: increasing military deployment in South Korea and signing a new agreement with the Philippines giving the U.S. access to more military bases there. And, at the same time, Western countries are trying to contain Beijing on various other fronts, such as by tightening legislation and screening around Chinese investments.
With funding for its military likely to start diminishing, Beijing’s window of opportunity to act decisively overseas, not least over Taiwan, is beginning to close. And there are two reasons why it feels it has to act while it still can.
Firstly, Chinese President Xi Jinping’s reluctance to roll back on his ambition for China to become a truly global super power rivaling the U.S.; and secondly, the need for Xi to demonstrate to his people, increasingly dispirited by the economic slump, that the country remains a force on the world stage, able to project power and thus protect Chinese interests. China’s ambition to “reunify” Taiwan lies at the heart of Xi’s narrative of “national rejuvenation,” underlining why Beijing would contemplate, sooner rather than later, resolving the island’s future — once and for all.
Given its declining economic strength and related concerns over losing global influence, Beijing may suspect the West of trying to take advantage of China, possibly prompting it to pre-empt any real or imagined attempt to do so. For this reason, the risk of a major crisis involving China and the U.S. will only increase further in the coming few years, not diminish.
What we might see is China becoming much more assertive. This could take the form of bigger military exercises around already-established flash points, such as the South China Sea and Taiwan, as well as other antagonistic actions. We are already beginning to witness this. In 2023, China announced a three-day, no-fly zone in airspace northeast of Taiwan, subsequently limiting it to just 27 minutes. That raised international concern about possible wider disruption to commercial aviation in the area. Other combative posturing could involve Beijing providing more military and economic support to autocratic friends, such as North Korea, Iran and Russia, in defiance of the West.
China may also choose to use economic levers to up the ante with the West. For instance, it might ban export of critical minerals — such as cobalt, lithium and magnesium — to Western nations, including the U.S. These are critical for innovation and development in the high-tech, renewable energy and defense industries. Such a ban would likely result in global shortages, undermining the economies of countries unable — or who struggle — to find new sources in other parts of the world. And despite recent skepticism around China’s economic prospects, the country remains a major market for many multinational firms, whose activities China could threaten to limit or obstruct to gain leverage over its geopolitical adversaries.
That said, should China aim to intensify its rivalry with the West, it will likely err on the side of caution and not deliberately seek direct confrontation, initially at least. This could change if its economic power continues to wane, and its ability to compete dissipates. Then, there is a real risk of Beijing throwing off its restraint, particularly if Donald Trump is elected president in the U.S. He may seek to robustly challenge China over Taiwan, Chinese trading practices or relations with U.S. enemies. That might trigger a hostile act, which, if mishandled by a Trump administration, could lead to a dangerous, possibly catastrophic escalation.
Barbara Kelemen is an associate director at Dragonfly, the geopolitical and security intelligence service, where she leads the Asia team based in Singapore.
Date: | |
Tag: | China |
Topics
Filter
-
Airbus posts drop in earnings raising fears it may struggle to profit on Boeing’s woes
Airbus posted a 25% drop in earnings as higher costs eroded its margins, even as its sales increasedMarketWatch - Business -
New crash test results raise concern for some small SUVs
The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety has updated its testing of vehicles’ ability to avoid crashes. The results show there is some concern for smaller SUVs, as most models did not do well.CBS News - Top stories -
EU Raises Competition Concerns Over IAG, Air Europa Tie-Up
IAG’s planned €400 million acquisition of Air Europa could reduce competition, the EU said, concerned that customers could face increased prices and lower quality service.The Wall Street Journal - World - European Union -
EU Raises Competition Concerns Over IAG, Air Europa Tie-Up
IAG’s planned €400 million acquisition of Air Europa could reduce competition, the EU said, concerned that customers could face increased prices and lower quality service.The Wall Street Journal - Business - European Union -
Tensions ratchet up between China and the west
Also in this newsletter: new weapons for Ukraine, German recovery, the value of loyaltyFinancial Times - World - China -
This isn’t ‘some brink’ for the U.S. consumer despite concerning economic data, says TCW
A resilient consumer isn’t likely to turn into a wrecking ball for the U.S. economy, according to Peter Van Gelderen at TCW.MarketWatch - Business -
Biden promise to rival China on shipbuilding faces a big economic problem
President Biden wants to bring shipbuilding back to the U.S. in economic rivalry with China and to boost domestic steel. Economic reality isn't on his side.CNBC - Business - Joe Biden -
China factory profits slip as overcapacity troubles economic recovery
US and EU have raised alarms about Beijing’s plans to use manufacturing to boost lagging growthFinancial Times - Business - China -
China factory profits slip as overcapacity troubles economic recovery
US and EU have raised alarms about Beijing’s plans to use manufacturing to boost lagging growthFinancial Times - World - China -
'It's on everybody's mind': Morehouse faculty and students raise concerns about Biden's graduation speech
Morehouse College’s leadership is set to hold a call on Thursday to address concerns over having President Joe Biden as the school’s commencement speaker next month.NBC News - Top stories - Joe Biden
More from The Hill
-
Speaker Johnson slams reports that ICC is considering arrest warrants for Israeli leaders
Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) on Monday slammed reports that the International Criminal Court (ICC) is planning on issuing arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and other senior Israeli officials. In a statement, Johnson ...The Hill - Politics - Israel -
Bob Bakish steps down as head of Paramount
Bob Bakish is stepping down as head of media conglomerate Paramount, the company announced on Monday. Bakish's resignation comes as the massive legacy media brand is negotiating a potential sale with Skydance after months of fielding offers from ...The Hill - Politics -
Pelosi accuses MSNBC host of being 'apologist for Donald Trump'
Former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) accused MSNBC's Katy Tur of being an "apologist" for former President Trump on Monday. During an appearance on the network, Pelosi touted President Biden's record on the economy, saying, he "created 9 ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
Trump-RFK Jr. feud heats up as polls tighten
A fiery battle between former President Trump and Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is heating up as polls begin to show that the third-party candidate represents just as much of a threat to the former president as President Biden. “RFK Jr. is a Democrat ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
AT&T, Verizon, T-Mobile hit with $200M FCC fine for sharing user location data without consent
The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) issued a fine totaling $200 million to the nation’s four largest mobile carriers after concluding an investigation that found the companies illegally shared access to customers’ location data, the agency ...The Hill - Politics