Where Biden went wrong in his confounding debate performance
![Where Biden went wrong in his confounding debate performance](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/06/MixCollage-27-Jun-2024-10-37-PM-9873.jpg?w=900)
The verdicts came quick and harsh in the hours after the Biden-Trump debate Thursday evening. Commentators called it "disastrous," "fumbling" and "devastating" for President Biden. Democratic operatives “panicked” and "scrambled" to limit the damage. Some suggested it might be time for Biden to step aside.
I would choose a different word to describe the event: confounding.
Politically speaking, Donald Trump's jugular was exposed for all to see. But on the most important issues in this election and in the most important moments, Biden seemed unable to go for it.
The No. 1 issue in this election is the future of our democracy. Trump is on record repeatedly describing how he wants to get rid of it, using the Justice Department for revenge, mobilizing the U.S. military to quell demonstrations, punishing dissent, and defying the Constitution. Far-right conservatives have even given him a play-by-play instruction manual on how to organize an autocracy.
In recent months, overwhelming majorities of Americans have said they worry about democracy, a repeat of the Jan. 6 insurrection, political violence and Republicans allowing white supremacist factions and Christian nationalists to dominate their party.
But when CNN moderator Jake Tapper asked Biden on Thursday whether he believes Trump and MAGA Republicans are determined to destroy American democracy, Biden lacked the passion of his remarks days before the 2022 midterm election.
"My fellow Americans," the president said then, "we're facing a defining moment, an inflection point. And we must — with one overwhelming, unified voice — speak as a country and say there is no place — no place — for voter intimidation or political violence in America, whether it's directed at Democrats or Republicans. No place, period. … We'll have our difference of opinion. And that's how it's supposed to be. But there is something else at stake: democracy itself."
The debate was confounding because it allowed Trump's torrent of lies to go unchallenged, except for Biden's weak, rushed and scattered responses. Tapper and fellow moderator Dana Bash chose to watch the clock rather than challenge questionable responses from either candidate.
It was forgivable because their job was to moderate, not enter the debate. However, CNN would have done viewers a great service by following the debate immediately with fact-checking. The network knew Trump's proven propensity to exaggerate, level false accusations and outright lie. There should never again be a presidential debate that allows falsities to linger for hours or days before they are corrected.
This debate was also confounding because Biden gave short shrift to global climate change, even though he’s done more than any previous president to mitigate it. Outside CNN's studios, Americans were being left homeless by wildfires, tornadoes and floods. The Associated Press reported, “Severe weather over days has caused havoc and destruction across the U.S.”
As of June 10, at least 964 tornadoes had struck the country. In April and May, three major outbreaks of more than 100 tornados each leveled towns from Texas and Louisiana to Iowa, killing 32 people.
While Biden and Trump were on stage, historic floods afflicted the Midwest, setting records in South Dakota, Minnesota, and Iowa. Experts predicted the disasters would continue deep into July.
Debate-watchers in New Mexico, North Dakota, Colorado and Montana buckled down for violent derechos (widespread wind storms) with large hail and winds up to 70 mph.
During the debate, large fires were blazing in Alaska, Oregon, California, New Mexico, Washington, Arizona, Utah, North Carolina, Florida, Colorado, Montana, Nebraska and Oklahoma. As of June 28, nearly 21,000 large wildfires had scorched parts of the U.S. this year.
Yet Trump continues to ignore climate change, much like he ignored the COVID pandemic. When Bash asked him about it, the former president avoided answering, claiming he "had the best environmental numbers ever" during his administration. Yet he pulled the United States out of the Paris climate agreement and reversed the climate policies of the Obama administration. He rolled back more than 100 environmental rules during his term. His legacy includes a conservative Supreme Court that is rolling back more.
Finally, the debate was confounding because Biden's handlers apparently coached him to recite long lists of data about his accomplishments. That's what websites are for. Two-minute segments are better spent on big themes and messages, like Trump's threat to democracy, Trump’s felonies and his racist characterizations of immigrants as terrorists, drug dealers and criminals.
After the debate, some Democrats wondered whether Biden should step aside so their convention could nominate a younger and more dynamic candidate. MSNBC reporters interviewed California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) for his reactions; he urged Democrats to work even harder for Biden.
But Newsom's articulate, surgical and damning critique of Trump's record served instead to demonstrate the communication skills Democrats will need to send one of presidential politics' greatest hucksters into retirement.
William S. Becker is a former regional director at the U.S. Department of Energy and author of several books on climate change and national disaster policies, including the “100-Day Action Plan to Save the Planet,” and “The Creeks Will Rise: People Co-Existing with Floods.”
Date: | |
Tag: | Joe Biden |
Filter
-
Politico - Politics
Biden campaign sends memo to House allies to quell fears following debate performance
Joe Biden -
CBS Sports - Sports
NASCAR Chicago Street Race 2024: Shane van Gisbergen returns to the city where his American journey began
The reigning Chicago Street Race winner spoke to CBS Sports about how he launched his U.S. racing careerNASCAR -
The Hill - Politics
On Biden’s debate, Democrats have no one to blame but themselves
Democrats' attempts to protect President Biden from scrutiny has resulted in a lack of viable replacements, leaving them stuck with a senile candidate and no bench for the 2028 election.Joe Biden -
NBC News - Politics
'I'm not leaving': Biden to his campaign staff
President Biden and Vice President Harris met with their campaign staff to reassure them that he is fully committed to being the Democratic nominee despite criticism from his first debate performance. NBC News' Monica Alba reports on Biden's ...Joe Biden -
The Wall Street Journal - World
Biden Can't Spin His Way Out of This
The president’s handlers think he can plow ahead, but his position will only get worse. What a tragedy.Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
House Democrat: 'Biden is going to lose to Trump' after debate
Rep. Marie Gluesenkamp Perez (D-Wash.) predicted in a new interview that former President Biden will lose November's election to former President Trump, adding to a growing group of Democrats questioning Biden's chances after his dismal showing in ...Joe Biden -
NBC News - Politics
Democrats fret while awaiting signs of how Biden will weather debate debacle
Democratic leaders are nervously waiting to see if a fresh round of polling shows that Joe Biden’s support has collapsed and he’s become a drag on congressional races before taking a unified stance on whether he should drop out of the race, ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Smokey Robinson pans 'ridiculous' Biden-Trump debate but says 'age is a number'
Legendary singer Smokey Robinson says after their "ridiculous" debate, he won't be singing "You've Really Got a Hold on Me" about either President Biden or former President Trump. "I'm not comfortable with either one of them, after what we saw ...Joe Biden -
NBC News - Politics
Biden quips that he 'almost fell asleep onstage' at debate
President Joe Biden acknowledged again Tuesday night that he underperformed at last week's debate while saying he “wasn’t very smart” for having traveled extensively in the weeks leading up to the event in Atlanta.Joe Biden -
Financial Times - Business
Katzenberg faces ire of Hollywood donors after Biden debate
Film mogul is central to president’s fundraising efforts but has been accused of concealing Biden’s conditionJoe Biden
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Katie Porter: White House has 'clearly fumbled' response to debate
Rep. Katie Porter (D-Calif.) on Wednesday said the White House "clearly fumbled" its response to the fallout from President Biden's shaky debate performance, as a growing number of Democrats express concerns with their nominee's ability to carry ... -
The Hill - Politics
Biden praises Civil War soldiers, Medal of Honor recipients for 'heroic deeds'
President Biden on Wednesday posthumously awarded the Medal of Honor to two Civil War-era soldiers who he lauded for defending America and the values it was founded upon. Biden, speaking from the White House, praised Pvt. Philip G. Shadrach and ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Biden-Trump race is tight amid debate fallout: Poll
President Biden and former President Trump are in a tight race amid fallout from last week’s presidential debate, according to a new poll from The Economist/YouGov. The poll, conducted between June 30 and July 2, found that Trump garnered 42 ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Evening Report — Can Biden stop the bleeding?
A second House Dem is urging Biden to step aside {beacon} Evening Report Wednesday, July 3 © AP Photo/Evan Vucci Biden tries to rally the troops as Dem panic consumes Washington President Biden began widespread outreach to Democrats on ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
'Lost' creator calls on Dems to stop giving party money until Biden steps down
Damon Lindelof, a co-creator of “Lost” and a notable Democratic Party supporter, called on fellow donors to withhold their money until President Biden ends his reelection bid, citing his struggles in the CNN debate against former President Trump ...Joe Biden