When it comes to race and US elections, ethnicity matters
Political analyst Michael Barone recently recalled how a Boston woman some years ago made her voting decisions: “I just go down the ballot and vote for all the good Irish names.”
For decades, party bosses relied on ethnicity as a means of balancing their tickets.
John Bailey, the Connecticut Democratic Party boss, would fashion his party’s slate of candidates by relying on the “three Is”: Ireland, Italy and Israel. Candidates from those ethnic backgrounds frequently held the top three slots on his Democratic tickets.
Republicans likewise played the ethnic card.
In 1960, Richard Nixon stressed his solidarity with those mostly Catholic countries locked behind the Iron Curtain. American Nationalities for Nixon-Lodge distributed 48,000 foreign-language buttons, held freedom rallies in cities with large Polish populations (including Buffalo and Chicago) and printed thousands of postcards showing the famous Nixon-Khrushchev “kitchen debate.”
In 1979, I interviewed Democratic Connecticut Gov. Ella T. Grasso and argued that ethnicity was becoming passe, thanks to the role television and image makers were playing in political campaigns. Her response was a sharp rebuke: “You’re very wrong. Ethnicity is alive and well and it is a factor in the country.”
She was right.
In our binary world, we often think of race and ethnicity in simple terms: It’s either Black or white; majority (whites) or minorities (other races). But the world has changed.
More than 33 million people chose two or more races when filling out their 2020 Census forms. This rising group of Americans, particularly prevalent among young people, matters in 2024.
A recent Pew Report, for example, found that among all registered voters, 41 percent believed that Kamala Harris’s African and Asian heritage would help her in November. As for Trump, 51 percent said his ethnic background as a white male would make no difference.
The Harris and Trump campaigns have prioritized appealing to racial and gender groups. Kamala Harris has support from Black Women for Harris, White Dudes for Harris and Latinos con Harris Walz. Donald Trump has organized support from Women for Trump, Black Voices for Trump and Latinos for Trump.
For Harris, making those appeals has paid political dividends. For example, 40,000 Black women joined a Zoom call for Harris, while a celebrity-fueled White Dudes for Harris raised $4 million during one internet outing.
However, organizing on the basis of race and gender alone ignores a more complex political reality. Quite often, white voters think of themselves not by race but according to their ethnic heritage.
The Harris campaign has begun a concerted outreach to these voters, including Irish Americans for Harris-Walz and Paisanos for Harris. The latter is led by Rep. Nancy Pelosi (R-Calif.) who, having been immersed in the ethnic politics of Baltimore as a native, understands the need to appeal to ethnic groups.
Voters of Irish and Italian heritage still command large numbers of voters. The most recent U.S. Census found nearly 39 million people in the U.S. were of Irish heritage, while nearly 17 million Americans were of Italian background.
But one overlooked group of voters are those whose ancestries trace back to countries located in central and eastern Europe. The so-called Blue Wall states of Michigan, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania in particular have high concentrations of voters hailing from those countries.
And Nebraska’s 2nd Congressional District, another key 2024 target because it allocates its one electoral vote separately from the rest of the state, has the highest concentration of Czech Americans found anywhere in the U.S.
During the Harris-Trump debate, Kamala Harris made a specific appeal to Polish Americans in Pennsylvania. Noting that should Russia prevail in Ukraine, “Putin would be sitting in Kyiv with his eyes on the rest of Europe starting with Poland.”
Harris then issued this challenge to her opponent: “Why don’t you tell the 800,000 Polish Americans right here in Pennsylvania how quickly what you would give up [in Ukraine] for the sake of a favor . . . to a dictator who would eat you for lunch.” Donald Trump ignored her taunt and even refused to say which side he wanted to win in Ukraine.
This runs contrary to the sentiments expressed by a vast majority of Americans. A recent poll found 63 percent sympathized with Ukraine while only 3 percent sympathized with Russia — a 21 to 1 ratio. And when asked directly which side they wanted to win, 72 percent answered Ukraine.
The Harris-Trump exchange is reminiscent of the 1976 Ford-Carter debate when President Gerald Ford wrongfully asserted, “There is no Soviet domination of Eastern Europe and there never will be under a Ford administration.”
Jimmy Carter immediately pounced on Ford’s unforced error:
“I would like to see Mr. Ford convince the Polish Americans and the Czech Americans and the Hungarian Americans in this country that those countries don’t live under the domination and supervision of the Soviet Union behind the Iron Curtain.”
In an extremely close election, Ford pollster Bob Teeter remembered, “The controversy used up valuable campaign days when there were all too few left when a steady climb had to be sustained.”
As Politico recently recounted, Ford’s remark potentially changed the course of history. Without that error, Ford might have made up the difference with Carter and the Reagan revolution would have never happened.
The Harris-Trump race is extremely close, and appeals to ethnicity matter. Consider: Nearly 9 million Americans of Polish heritage live in the U.S., making Harris’s appeal to the 67 million watching the debate an exercise in very smart politics.
Close elections are won or lost at the margins. The campaign that can best reach voters who strongly identify with their ethnic heritage is a campaign built to win. Right now, give the edge to Kamala Harris.
John Kenneth White (johnkennethwhite.com) is a professor emeritus at The Catholic University of America. His latest book is titled “Grand Old Unraveling: The Republican Party, Donald Trump, and the Rise of Authoritarianism.”
Date: |
Topics
-
GameSpot - Tech
EA Won't Drop Sims 4 Support When Project Rene Comes Out
The next big iteration of The Sims franchise, known as Project Rene , apparently won't be The Sims 5. Or at least it won't function the way numbered entries in the have in the past, with players ...Yesterday -
CBS News - Top stories
Where the 2024 race stands 50 days from Election Day
Monday marks 50 days until Election Day 2024. Peggy Collins, Washington bureau chief for Bloomberg News, and Shelby Talcott, politics reporter for Semafor, join "America Decides" to discuss the ...2 days ago -
BBC News - Top stories
Suspicious packages sent to election officials across US
Colorado's secretary of state says the poster of the letters called themselves the "US Traitor Elimination Army".23 hours ago -
BBC News - Top stories
US election: Do celebrity endorsements work?
Can Taylor Swift, Billie Eilish and Elon Musk swing the vote for Harris or Trump?16 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
More floods are coming to Britain, but you ought to know this: the system that should protect us is a scandal | George Monbiot
A network of public bodies are supposed to safeguard us from flooding. But, like old boys’ clubs, they are bastions of self-interest. Labour’s first stage of government resembles a vast forensic ...19 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
The Switch Up Election Series — DNC chief stresses vitality of Black voters in race for White House
Jaime Harrison made history in 2013 when he became the first African American to serve as the chair of the South Carolina Democratic Party. Just seven years later, in 2020, Harrison moved up to ...8 hours ago -
Financial Times - World
Gore warns US election outcome will determine future of climate action
Former vice-president says voters face ‘clearest choice ever’ in November poll20 hours ago - Climate -
The Guardian - World
US still unprepared for Russian election interference, Robert Mueller says
Former special counsel issues warning in preface to book about 2016 investigation and Trump-Moscow links. US politics – live updates The US is still not prepared for inevitable Russian attacks ...15 hours ago - Russia -
Wired - Tech
US Senate Warns Big Tech to Act Fast Against Election Meddling
In an Intelligence Committee hearing with representatives from Google, Apple, and Meta on Wednesday, senators stressed that foreign influence is far from a solved problem.57 minutes ago -
ABC News - Tech
Elon Musk has often inflamed politically tense moments, raising worries for the US election
As Election Day draws nearer, social media posts by X owner Elon Musk are raising concerns that he will use his immense platform to question the legitimacy of the vote in the U.S. presidential ...Yesterday - Elon Musk
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Newark official wins special election to fill late New Jersey Rep. Payne's seat
Newark City Council President LaMonica McIver (D) has won the special election to fill a vacant House seat representing New Jersey’s 10th Congressional District, according to Decision Desk HQ. ...39 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
RFK Jr. says he's helping Trump pick leaders of FDA, NIH, CDC
Former independent presidential candidate and antivaccine advocate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said that former President Trump wants him to choose leaders for key public health agencies if he wins the ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
EPA retaliated against three scientists, says watchdog
Presented by TerraPower — The Environmental Protection Agency’s internal watchdog has found that the agency retaliated against three staffers for expressing different scientific opinions. {beacon} ...2 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
House GOP torpedoes Speaker Johnson’s funding bill
House Republicans voted down Speaker Mike Johnson's proposal to fund the government, leaving the path to averting a shutdown unclear and putting Johnson in danger of disappointing former President ...2 hours ago - House -
The Hill - Politics
Congress races to patch $3B Veterans Affairs shortfall
Lawmakers are moving quickly to pass emergency legislation to plug a roughly $3 billion shortfall facing the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA), as officials warn veterans' and survivors' benefits ...2 hours ago