When it comes to deportations, why are the media hiding the ball?
Few things are so unhelpful as the journalist who buries the lede.
There has been a lot of that lately, especially insofar as the Trump administration's immigration crackdown is concerned.
Take, for example, the case of the Georgetown University researcher arrested in Virginia last week over his alleged ties to terrorism. Badar Khan Suri reportedly spread Hamas propaganda online while having “close connections to a known or suspected terrorist, who is a senior advisor to Hamas,” according to the Department of Homeland Security.
This is pretty serious stuff, which is why the coverage has been so maddening. In most reports, the allegations against Suri are buried so deep as to be next to the dinosaur bones.
“Trump is seeking to deport another academic who is legally in the country, lawsuit says,” reported Politico on March 19. The subhead adds, “Badar Khan Suri, a fellow at Georgetown, says he is being punished because of the suspected views of his wife, a U.S. citizen with Palestinian heritage.”
The Associated Press ran the same story, but with the headline, “Government cannot deport Georgetown scholar until court rules, judge orders.” The subhead adds, “A federal judge has ordered immigration officials not to deport a Georgetown scholar that the government detained until the court has had a chance to rule.”
NBC News published the headline, “Georgetown University graduate student detained by immigration authorities,” with a subhead that reads, “A lawyer for Badar Khan Suri, who was teaching on a student visa, said Thursday that he is grateful for the support he has received since his arrest.”
These are just a few headlines and news blurbs plucked at random, but they represent the overall coverage. We are immediately provided with the who, what, where and even when — but not with the why. That’s an omission so glaring as to be intentional.
It is possible — but unlikely — for a journalist to forget outright one of the five Ws of lede writing. But the entire newsroom? And for the issue to be spread out over multiple organizations? The word “unlikely” is getting a workout this week.
Now, regarding Suri’s arrest, there are some pertinent details you ought to know. First, he is in the U.S. on a temporary visa. He is an Indian national and married to Mapheze Saleh, a Gaza-born U.S. resident. Saleh is the daughter of Ahmed Yousef, who has served as a senior political adviser for Hamas (although he claims he no longer holds this position).
To recap: A guest in the U.S., who is the son-in-law of a (possibly) former Hamas official, has been arrested and detained on allegations that he promotes agitprop for a designated terrorist organization. Whether the charges hold up is one thing, but these are indisputably the federal government’s allegations against Suri.
Yet, were you to read Politico’s original scoop on the matter, you couldn't find DHS’s justification for the arrest until the ninth paragraph, and that’s only after the reader is told the foreign national “has no criminal record” and merely “[opposes] U.S. foreign policy toward Israel,” or so says his lawyer.
The Associated Press does only slightly better, mentioning the Hamas propaganda in the opening paragraph but failing to note Suri’s connection to Hamas leadership. The Associated Press eventually revealed this connection, but only in passing and only to suggest there’s no there there. And maybe there isn't, but when this familial connection represents half of DHS’s argument against Suri, why save that information for the 10th paragraph, and why note it only in passing?
By glossing over this latter detail and focusing solely on the “propaganda” angle, the Associated Press has effectively reframed the story as a free speech issue exclusively, rather than one that also concerns alleged national security issues.
For NBC News, it took 11 paragraphs before readers learned of the allegations against Suri.
The coverage has been every bit as befuddling and exasperating as the initial coverage of the arrest of Mahmoud Khalil, the 30-year-old Columbia student and legal permanent resident whom ICE arrested and detained over his alleged support for Hamas. If you recall the early coverage of his arrest, there was plenty in terms of human interest — everything from details of Khalil’s marriage to his campus activities. But there was precious little about why the federal government detained him.
It took me multiple articles and independent research to understand DHS’s position — not because the federal government lacked an explanation, but because few media outlets bothered to publish it.
There’s a robust and worthwhile debate to be had about these arrests. Some conservatives have expressed discomfort over the legality of such actions. However, it will be impossible to have the discussion if the media continue to hide the ball on the why of these arrests, ignoring or downplaying the behaviors and factors federal authorities cite as legal justification.
We can’t have the debate if we have only partial information.
Becket Adams is a writer in Washington and program director for the National Journalism Center.
-
Border czar on Columbia arrest: 'Absolutely we can' deport a legal immigrant
Tom Homan, President Trump’s border czar, said Monday that federal authorities “absolutely can” deport a legal immigrant after U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) arrested a Columbia ...The Hill - Mar. 10 -
How social media reacted to UNC's NCAA Tournament loss to Ole Miss
Here's how social media reacted to the UNC basketball program coming up short against Ole Miss in NCAA Tournament action FridayYahoo Sports - 4d -
Trump urges unauthorized immigrants to ‘self-deport’ in new social media campaign
President Trump urged unauthorized immigrants to “self-deport” in a new video for social media campaign, during which he announced the launch of an app that will help migrants voluntarily leave the ...The Hill - Mar. 18 -
Adolescence reveals a terrifying truth: smartphones are poison for boys’ minds | Martha Gill
When a Netflix drama highlights how online influencers can turn a teenager into a killer, it’s time to rethink social media. Every so often, a television drama comes along that has the power to ...The Guardian - 3d -
'We will come straight back up' - Mills
Former Ipswich captain Mick Mills says his former side's inability to perform over the full 90 minutes will cost them but he remains confident they can bounce back next season. "The problem we ...Yahoo Sports - Mar. 17 -
The open-source AI debate: Why selective transparency poses a serious risk
It is misleading to call AI open source when no one can look at, experiment with and understand each element that went into creating it.VentureBeat - 3d -
Wife details arrest of Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil as judge blocks deportation
The wife of Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil said she and her husband were returning to their apartment after breaking their Ramadan fast when immigration agents confronted them and arrested ...NBC News - Mar. 11 -
Hundreds of car collectors come together to support bullied Alabama boy
When a mother who was desperate to show her son that people care and life can be joyful put out a small request on social media, hundreds of muscle car drivers heeded the call.CBS News - Mar. 14 -
Playing it too safe when it comes to investing can easily cost you $10 million
Why young investors should own stocks, not bondsMarketWatch - 5d
More from The Hill
-
Trump could be pushing South Africa closer to China
On Feb. 7, Trump issued the executive order “Addressing Egregious Actions of the Republic of South Africa.”The Hill - 51m -
Congress continues to seek answers on UFOs
UFO whistleblower David Grusch will be advising Missouri Rep. Eric Burlison on the issue.The Hill - 1h -
'Like a forest fire': Where large measles outbreaks will occur, according to an epidemiologist
"What is interesting about this current outbreak is the speed at which it's expanding and increasing," said Dr. William Moss, an epidemiology professor at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of ...The Hill - 1h -
Study links Wegovy to increased hair loss risk
Researchers assessed data from 16 million patients from 2006 to 2020 taking semaglutide-based drugs; the active ingredient in Wegovy.The Hill - 1h -
How Trump is finding workarounds to legal hurdles
There’s a theme emerging in the Trump administration’s battles in courtrooms across the country contesting an array of executive actions facing litigation. As the saying goes, if you can’t go ...The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
Trump signs order requiring proof of citizenship to register to vote
President Donald Trump signed a sweeping executive order on Tuesday that would require people to prove their citizenship when they register to vote by providing a United States passport or another ...NBC News - 37m -
Trump could be pushing South Africa closer to China
On Feb. 7, Trump issued the executive order “Addressing Egregious Actions of the Republic of South Africa.”The Hill - 51m -
Congress continues to seek answers on UFOs
UFO whistleblower David Grusch will be advising Missouri Rep. Eric Burlison on the issue.The Hill - 1h -
'Like a forest fire': Where large measles outbreaks will occur, according to an epidemiologist
"What is interesting about this current outbreak is the speed at which it's expanding and increasing," said Dr. William Moss, an epidemiology professor at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of ...The Hill - 1h -
Study links Wegovy to increased hair loss risk
Researchers assessed data from 16 million patients from 2006 to 2020 taking semaglutide-based drugs; the active ingredient in Wegovy.The Hill - 1h