'What's in it for me' has gone too far, and Trump and Musk make it worse
On March 23, 250 years ago, almost four weeks before the Battle of Lexington and Concord, Patrick Henry rose at the Second Virginia Convention to call on Virginia to arm for the Revolutionary War that he saw as inevitable. He finished declaring emphatically, “give me liberty, or give me death!”
Today, Henry’s speech has become a favorite of the Tea Party, MAGA and other conservative groups.
They deeply misunderstand Henry, seeing his speech as simply a call for personal liberty, to do what one wants: my rights, my freedom, regardless of others. Henry’s famous call-to-arms, sadly, has played a role in Americans’ fixation on “what’s in it for me.”
The fixation on personal liberty over the interest of others (or what Founders would have called “license”) has become a bedrock of our society and exacts a great price on our communities and all of us.
Henry and the other Founders would be appalled.
I was reminded of this with the flood of news and social media stories about MAGA supporters angry, bitter and confused because the Trump administration is hurting their farms, revoking their loans or business contracts, deporting family or friends, firing nurses at their VA hospital, firing friends — the list seems endless.
Among the most interesting of these stories is the comment from Jesse Watters, a Fox network host. Watters, a major MAGA supporter, has cheered Trump’s efforts to burn to the ground large parts of the government. But when a friend of his lost his job, Watters suddenly seemed to wake-up, as if someone had thrown cold water in his face. He reminded his listeners that we “need to be a little bit less callous” as millions face loss of jobs, loss of business, loss of services, loss of benefits, etc.
He is right, but these stories point to something even more fundamental.
If you asked Americans, especially conservatives, what ails the nation, many will quickly come to talking about the decline of community. And they are right.
From the loss of churches that were at the center of neighborhoods, to the decline of civic organizations that used to unite people across differences, to the sad phenomenon of “bowling alone” (when the nation used to be filled with bowling leagues), American communities have suffered.
We have turned inward, fed by the screens at which we stare.
In fundamental ways, this sad phenomenon is the result of the growth of “classic liberalism” — a focus on my rights, my interests. The alternative philosophy, prominent among America’s Founders, is “classic republicanism,” focused on service to community and human virtue.
This focus on liberalism has been at the root of attacks on the federal government. Since at least Ronald Reagan, people have been fed, over and over again, the story that the government is the problem, or worse, the enemy. If a government policy does not seem like something I want, or if it is something that I don’t see the need for, or something that I would not approve of, the government is wrong and needs to be cut down to size.
Watters is right. We need a little compassion, a little empathy.
There are many government programs that I don’t need, perhaps don’t want, but they are part of a government that serves neighbors and co-citizens, created by our elected representatives for the good of our people.
Take, for example, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau that Elon Musk, with President Trump’s apparent indifference, is seeking to eliminate. It protects vulnerable consumers from bank overcharges, fraudulent loans, and the like.
The Trump administration has already dismissed several of the bureau's enforcement actions against big banks for defrauding consumers of billions of dollars.
I suppose I don’t need the bureau. We have financial advisers who watch these things; we only take out mortgage loans reviewed by lawyers.
I suppose I could even complain that it is costing me money — some small infinitesimal part of my tax dollars (although, in fact, it has made money for taxpayers by collecting billions of dollars in fines from fraudulent financial practices). But all of this misses the point.
I may not “need” the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, but millions of Americans do — my neighbors.
The same is true of almost all government functions. I don’t need the Occupational Safety and Health Administration regulations protecting workers from exploitative work practices, but others do. My grandfather, a steelworker, could tell horrific stories about abuses before the unions and government got involved.
I don’t need an educational loan now, but millions do.
And these government systems strengthen our nation. Paying to educate American students, for example, makes for a more vibrant economy, a more informed electorate, a more engaged community. We all pay the price when our educational system is inadequate, and we all share the benefits when our citizenry is well-educated.
Of course, this does not mean that we have to agree with everything that the government does. Or that we shouldn’t work for reform and improved efficiency.
Should we oppose government action of which we disapprove? Absolutely. Reform government inefficiency, locate real fraud and remove it? Overwhelming support.
But indiscriminate destruction of agencies that our friends and neighbors rely upon, agencies created by Congress and signed into law, all at the direction of the richest man in the world and his enabler? It is un-American, dangerous and, as Watters belatedly realized, shows a callousness to our neighbors.
Watters is right. We need to start with some compassion for our neighbors. Our communities, and our nation, depend upon it.
While millions are cheering Musk’s efforts to take a meat ax to the government, because they don’t yet see how it will affect them (although they will, in time), we all need to try to understand how these changes impact our neighbors and communities.
John Ragosta, Ph.D. JD, was formerly acting director of the Robert H. Smith International Center for Jefferson Studies at Monticello. His most recent book is “For the People, For the Country: Patrick Henry’s Final Political Battle.”
-
Elon Musk targeted me over Tesla protests. That proves our movement is working
I’ve always believed the people are powerful. Now we know the world’s richest man does too. On Saturday morning, I woke up to a nightmare of notifications. On Sunday, it got worse. Elon Musk had ...The Guardian - 6d -
Schumer on voting for funding bill: Trump, Musk 'damage' could be 'much worse' under shutdown
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) said in a Sunday podcast episode that “damage” from President Trump and tech billionaire Elon Musk could be “much worse” under a government shutdown. ...The Hill - 2d -
Half say Trump policies making economy worse: Poll
Half of Americans in a new poll say President Trump’s policies have made the U.S. economy worse in his first seven weeks in office. In a CNN poll released Thursday, 51 percent of respondents say ...The Hill - 6d -
Is Trump’s ‘Golden Age’ a bridge too far?
It will take more than the president — no matter how serious his commitment — to fully deliver on a promise like this.The Hill - 5d -
Trump Has Gone From Unconstitutional to Anti-Constitutional
Where all this goes is still up to us.The New York Times - 3h -
What Elon Musk’s Suit Says About Trump and Power
When Elon Musk puts on a nice suit, it has a way of looking like a demotion.The New York Times - Mar. 11 -
Trump buys Tesla to 'make a statement' about Musk backlash
President Trump said Tuesday he was buying a Tesla vehicle as he doubled down on his support of Elon Musk, who has come under mounting scrutiny for leading the Trump administration's government ...The Hill - Mar. 11 -
I was always terrified of confrontation. Then I hit my 40s | Arwa Mahdawi
If I see someone making my neighbourhood a worse place to live, I walk straight up to them and … have a little word. What is happening to me?. Some people buy sports cars when they have a midlife ...The Guardian - 1d -
Every Move I Make, She’ll Be Watching Me
At 50, am I too old to be sharing my location with my mother?The New York Times - Mar. 7 -
Elon Musk Seeks to Put $100 Million Into Trump Political Operation
Elon Musk has signaled he wants to make some donations not just to his own super PAC, which is called America PAC and has spent heavily on President Trump in the past, but to an outside entity.The New York Times - Mar. 11 -
Detroit Pistons coach J.B. Bickerstaff rips NBA refs: 'Disrespect has gone on far enough'
Detroit Pistons coach J.B. Bickerstaff ripped the refs after Saturday's game saw Cade Cunningham ejected for lining up in the key.Yahoo Sports - 3d -
Tesla faces backlash over Elon Musk's ties to Trump and far-right support
Tesla shares have plunged more than 47% since President Trump's inauguration as criticism mounts over Elon Musk's involvement in the administration and his statements backing far-right views. ...CBS News - Mar. 11 -
Elon Musk Has Wanted the Government Shutdown
Sources tell WIRED that Elon Musk has wanted a government shutdown in part because it would potentially make it easier to eliminate the jobs of hundreds of thousands of federal workers.Wired - Mar. 11 -
What we know so far
One person is missing, one man arrested, and jet fuel has leaked into the sea, raising environmental concerns.BBC News - Mar. 11 -
Musk: 'They basically wanna kill me because I’m stopping their fraud'
Tech billionaire Elon Musk, a close adviser to President Trump, said his life was in danger over his heavy involvement in the administration and some may want him dead because he is "stopping their ...The Hill - 8h -
Democrats’ hatred of Trump makes them their own worst enemies
Hatred of Trump has become their go-to position on just about everything; it’s what energizes them. It’s what dictates what they say and do.The Hill - Mar. 12 -
Bannon says Musk deploying DOGE 'shock troops': 'Not pretty,' but 'pretty effective'
Former Trump adviser Steve Bannon has acknowledged that Elon Musk's "shock troops" in the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) are making progress in reshaping the government, despite his ...The Hill - 5h -
Trump’s Embrace of Russia Leaves Europe in Emotional Shock
It remains to be seen how far President Trump’s embrace of Russia and abandonment of traditional allies will go. But “the West” may be gone.The New York Times - Mar. 8 -
Messi returns as Inter Miami cruise into Champions Cup quarter-finals
Two more Concacaf Champions Cup ties will meet their conclusions this evening as the competition starts to move into it's business end. Here is what has gone down so far in Kingston and Alajuela. C...Yahoo Sports - 5d -
NHS England abolition shows ‘we have to take difficult decisions’, says Starmer – UK politics live
PM says he is ‘bringing management of the NHS back into democratic control by abolishing the arms length body NHS England’. Starmer is now talking about regulatation, and giving examples of where ...The Guardian - 6d -
From European qualification to the bottom four: What has gone wrong at Cercle Brugge this season?
Last season, Cercle Brugge were one of the stories of the Belgian Pro League. The young side under Miron Muslic battled their way to European qualification playing a high tempo pressing game that ...Yahoo Sports - 2d -
How do watches and warnings differ, and which weather alert is worse?
When it comes to severe weather events like tornadoes and flash floods, what's the difference between a watch and warning, and which is worse?CBS News - 5d -
Senate Dems brace to vote for a bill they hate — to block Elon Musk
Democrats appear on the cusp of voting to avoid a shutdown because they fear the consequences of standing up to the Trump administration could be worse.Politico - 5d -
Vance: Musk has made some ‘mistakes’ with DOGE’s federal worker firings
Vice President Vance said during an interview that senior President Trump adviser Elon Musk has made some “mistakes” with the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) firings of federal ...The Hill - 4d -
Elon Musk Is Making Republicans Sweat and Giving Democrats a New Target
His unusual governing arrangement with President Trump is opening Republicans up to being yoked politically to Mr. Musk, who polls show is broadly unpopular.The New York Times - Mar. 8 -
March Madness bracketology: Will Texas make it to the tournament? Here is what experts say
Texas has bounced around on the bubble, but will the Longhorns make the tournament? Here is what experts say Selection Sunday eve.Yahoo Sports - 3d -
Why Trump’s Tesla Showcase Mattered to Elon Musk
A lot has changed since former President Joseph R. Biden Jr. snubbed Elon Musk at an event in 2021.The New York Times - 6d -
Trump defends Elon Musk, DOGE cuts to federal workforce
President Trump defended Elon Musk and DOGE over the weekend after reported rifts between Musk and Cabinet members. CBS News White House reporter Olivia Rinaldi has more.CBS News - Mar. 10 -
Can Trump and Musk Convince More Conservatives to Buy Teslas?
President Trump rallied support for Elon Musk’s car company, but there may not be enough conservatives willing to buy electric cars to make up for the Democrats who now shun Teslas.The New York Times - 18h -
Pistons' J.B. Bickerstaff: 'I'm disgusted by the way that game was officiated' after Cunningham ejected
“The disrespect has gone far enough, and I’m not going to allow our guys to be treated the way they were tonight.”Yahoo Sports - 3d -
How an obscure US government office has become a target of Elon Musk
Rightwing campaign propelled by tech billionaire accuses General Services Administration’s 18F of being a far-left cell. Never miss global breaking news. Download our free app to keep up with key ...The Guardian - 3d -
Trump Poses With a Tesla, a Move Aimed Solely at Helping Musk
President Trump has spent years bashing electric vehicles. But with Elon Musk by his side, he said he would buy a bright red one.The New York Times - Mar. 12 -
Pro-Israel group says it has ‘deportation list’ and has sent ‘thousands’ of names to Trump officials
Betar US is among far-right groups supporting Trump effort to deport students involved in pro-Palestinian protests. A far-right group that claimed credit for the arrest of a Palestinian activist ...The Guardian - 5d -
LinkedIn co-founder has known Elon Musk for years. Here’s what he says Americans don’t understand about the Tesla CEO.
Elon Musk takes a hammer-and-nail approach to everything, LinkedIn co-founder Reid Hoffman says.MarketWatch - Mar. 11 -
What leverage does Trump have over Putin in Ukraine negotiations?
The Russian president remains unwavering in his demands, making wider sanctions and tariffs ineffective. Ukraine’s agreement to support a US proposal for a 30-day ceasefire in its war against ...The Guardian - Mar. 12 -
Poll: As Trump and courts clash, voters weigh whether each branch of government has too much power
As a federal judge presses President Donald Trump's administration over whether it violated an order halting deportations, in a growing clash between the presidency and the judicial branch, more ...NBC News - 11h -
Why Isn’t Ukraine in NATO, and What Has Trump Said?
The mutual-defense alliance has been central to Ukraine’s war against Russia, but the future is uncertain with President Trump back in office.The New York Times - 5d -
The Democrats must make a choice
If they want to fight Trump, they have to know what they stand forFinancial Times - 2d -
Trump spokesperson: 'We played a little game of catch me if you can' on deportations
A White House spokesperson asserted the federal judge who ordered the Trump administration to turn around flights with Venezuelan migrants headed to El Salvador was "too slow." “The president will ...The Hill - 1d
More from The Hill
-
House bill lets Secret Service cover local costs of protecting Trump
A bill introduced in the House would allow the Secret Service to reimburse local law enforcement agencies for the costs of protecting President Trump. Rep. Tom Kean Jr. (R-N.J.) reintroduced a bill ...The Hill - 50m -
FBI warns of possible Outlook, Gmail cyberattacks
The FBI is warning users of popular email services such as Outlook and Gmail that they could be subject to cyberattacks by ransomware called Medusa, which has impacted more than 300 victims from a ...The Hill - 56m -
Purdue Pharma asks bankruptcy judge to accept new settlement plan
Purdue Pharma has filed a new bankruptcy plan as part of a $7.4 billion settlement to resolve thousands of lawsuits over the company's alleged role in the opioid crisis, months after the Supreme ...The Hill - 57m -
Advocates to rally in DC for Trans Day of Visibility amid Trump administration rollbacks
Transgender rights advocates from across the nation will gather on the National Mall this month in celebration of Transgender Day of Visibility, an annual commemoration of trans people worldwide. ...The Hill - 1h -
Hillary Clinton: Trump administration 'has thrown in its lot with the autocrats'
Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton told an audience in Berlin, Germany, on Tuesday the Trump administration “has thrown in its lot with the autocrats.” “Autocracy is on the march," Clinton ...The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
House bill lets Secret Service cover local costs of protecting Trump
A bill introduced in the House would allow the Secret Service to reimburse local law enforcement agencies for the costs of protecting President Trump. Rep. Tom Kean Jr. (R-N.J.) reintroduced a bill ...The Hill - 50m -
FBI warns of possible Outlook, Gmail cyberattacks
The FBI is warning users of popular email services such as Outlook and Gmail that they could be subject to cyberattacks by ransomware called Medusa, which has impacted more than 300 victims from a ...The Hill - 56m -
Purdue Pharma asks bankruptcy judge to accept new settlement plan
Purdue Pharma has filed a new bankruptcy plan as part of a $7.4 billion settlement to resolve thousands of lawsuits over the company's alleged role in the opioid crisis, months after the Supreme ...The Hill - 57m -
Advocates to rally in DC for Trans Day of Visibility amid Trump administration rollbacks
Transgender rights advocates from across the nation will gather on the National Mall this month in celebration of Transgender Day of Visibility, an annual commemoration of trans people worldwide. ...The Hill - 1h -
Hillary Clinton: Trump administration 'has thrown in its lot with the autocrats'
Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton told an audience in Berlin, Germany, on Tuesday the Trump administration “has thrown in its lot with the autocrats.” “Autocracy is on the march," Clinton ...The Hill - 1h