What Netanyahu should have conveyed to the international community at the UN
Hundreds of Hamas terrorists and civilians from Gaza assaulted, looted and destroyed my home, Kibbutz Nir Oz, on Oct. 7.
They murdered 51 people in our community of a little more than 400. They kidnapped 79 others, including my 36-year-old son, Sagui.
Twenty-nine are still hostages in Gaza. We do not know if any of them are still alive. Our world stopped that day; it can resume only after the hostages return.
Nir Oz’s survivors are among more than 150,000 Israelis internally displaced by Hamas’ attack in the south and Hezbollah rockets in the north. Israel now faces multiple threats from Iranian proxies.
The only way to return our hostages alive (or perhaps at all) is to negotiate with Hamas, the homicidal captor of our loved ones. Hostage families have warned for months that our government’s military pressure strategy will fail in its stated goal of forcing Hamas to agree to a deal. No army can rescue hostages from tunnels guarded by suicidal fanatics. The Israel Defense Forces’ recovery in recent weeks of 12 bodies of hostages who were alive for months in captivity has debunked Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s core hostage policy. Further, close-quarter military action will only result in the murder of more hostages.
The vast majority of Israelis have been appalled by our government’s repeated moving of the goal posts in the negotiation process with Hamas. It claims that Israeli control over the Philadelphi Corridor is of vital national interest, despite our military and clandestine services’ dismissal of this argument.
The recent escalation of conflict with Hezbollah can surely be justified on military grounds. But targeted killing of its leaders and widespread bombing in Lebanon have only added to fears that our government’s unclear path, without a stated strategy, will lead to the death of all the hostages.
Since Oct. 7, Israel has been at war with satanic terrorist organizations, in Gaza, Lebanon and Yemen. Our greater threat, however, comes from within. As Israel approached the one-year anniversary of “Black Saturday,” Netanyahu’s speech at the UN marked a low point for our hostages and our country. Why? As a patriotic Israeli, I must ask, “What was his goal and his intended audience?”
Israel did not need this speech. The only possible justification for it would be as a dramatic platform to announce some breakthrough; major progress toward an agreement to free our hostages or the announcement, finally, of a strategic vision for post-Hamas Gaza.
Netanyahu could have begun the long road toward improving Israel’s international image by sincerely addressing the suffering of Gaza’s civilian population since Oct. 8. Instead, he repeated his worn-out cliches about the hostages and his fantastical goal of “Total Victory” over Hamas. This was followed by a torrent of accusations — against UN member countries and the UN itself. He peppered the speech with childish maps and offensive comparisons of the current conflict to the Holocaust.
Israel cannot ask for the world’s support as a “victim” (as Netanyahu claimed) while our army lays waste to cities in Gaza, whatever the cause. Claiming that our critics act solely out of antisemitic motivations only deflects from Israel’s responsibility to offer real strategic vision. The prime minister also mentioned nothing in his speech about the immense debt our country owes to the United States for its steady support amid this controversial war.
Netanyahu’s speech only amplified the ugliest part of Israeli politics: leaders unwilling to take any accountability for the situation in which Israel finds itself and unable to offer a workable vision for a better future.
Exactly at a time when Israel needs partners to leverage Hamas in favor of a ceasefire-for-hostage deal and encourage moderate Arab countries toward cooperation with Israel after the war, Netanyahu deepened existing anti-Israel antagonisms. The only applause came from a cluster of staff and supporters in the gallery. He only harmed Israel’s national interest.
Who then was the intended audience? One commentator speculated that this exercise in political theatre was directed toward Donald Trump. In truth, the only audience for the speech was his own domestic political base, always ready to embrace the populist “us against the world” narrative that Netanyahu has peddled since he emerged into Israeli politics in the mid-1980s.
When speaking on the UN’s center stage, here is what Netanyahu should have said, “We call on you to join us in ending the disastrous war in Gaza. This requires direct pressure on Hamas. It must be forced to agree to a ceasefire and hostage release. Only then can Gazans reconstruct their lives with the help of the international community. Gazans must no longer be used by Hamas as human shields in its deadly Holy War against Israel.
“We don’t yet know the contours of peace with our Palestinian neighbors. We do know that we must not go back to Hamas rule over Gaza or Israeli control over Gazans. Well-intentioned international partners can help us create a better future for our region. But first our hostages must come home.”
Jonathan Dekel-Chen is a history professor at Hebrew University and a U.S. citizen. He is the father of a hostage who has been held by Hamas terrorists in Gaza.
Date: |
-
Sports - The New York Times
A Goalie and His Painkiller Addiction: ‘Tramadol Should Have Killed Me.’
Chris Kirkland, who played for England and Liverpool, opens up about piecing his life back together.1 hour ago -
Top stories - NBC News
What Netanyahu's threat of Gaza-like destruction signals about Israel's goals in Lebanon
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's warning that Lebanon could face Gaza-like destruction fueled fears about Israel's invasion targeting Hezbollah.7 hours ago - Israel -
World - Yahoo News
UN says conditions in Lebanon 'deteriorating at alarming rate'
6 hours ago -
Lifestyle - The New York Times
What Is the Best Size For a Purse? Big vs. Small Handbags
A reader wonders if it’s better to carry a small bag or a large one. Our critic explains the relationship between purse size and power.2 days ago -
World - The Guardian
Former foreign policy adviser to three UK PMs appointed as UN aid chief
Tom Fletcher becomes sixth Briton in a row to take up post despite calls for it to be subject to open competition. A former foreign policy adviser to three prime ministers including Gordon Brown ...4 hours ago - United Kingdom
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
House Democrats’ campaign chief defends vulnerable members keeping distance from Harris
NEW YORK — Rep. Suzan DelBene (D-Wash.), the House Democrats’ campaign chief, is defending vulnerable lawmakers who have kept their distance from Vice President Harris while campaigning. Speaking ...24 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Breaking up Google
Welcome to The Hill's Technology newsletter {beacon} Technology Technology The Big Story DOJ eyes Google breakup after antitrust victory The Department of Justice (DOJ) is considering asking a ...31 minutes ago - Google -
Politics - The Hill
Lake brushes off polls showing her trailing Gallego
Republican Kari Lake said voters shouldn’t trust polling showing her trailing Rep. Ruben Gallego (D-Ariz.) in the Arizona Senate race, calling internal polling “the good stuff.” “No, I don't think ...39 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Watch live: Tim Walz holds campaign rally in Arizona
Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, the Democratic vice presidential nominee, is rallying voters in the critical swing state of Arizona on Wednesday evening. Earlier in the day, Walz campaigned in the Phoenix ...46 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Why Hurricane Milton became so intense so fast
Click for the latest from The Hill {beacon} Energy & Environment Energy & Environment The Big Story Why Hurricane Milton became so intense so fast Hurricane Milton is set to make landfall late ...48 minutes ago