What happens when the police lie?
Most Americans understand that the police are allowed to lie to suspects. Whether learned from watching procedurals, news reports or personal experience, it is generally recognized that deceit during suspect interrogations is a routine feature of American policing.
What is less understood are the consequences of accepting such practices, and the extent to which the U.S. stands as an outlier in sanctioning them.
To elicit confessions, police routinely employ a variety of manipulative practices, including lying about the existence of incriminating evidence or falsely implying leniency in exchange for cooperation. These techniques are not tools of a last resort, but core components of interrogation in the U.S. They are taught in some of the most influential police manuals, tolerated by judges and widely accepted as standard practice.
Defenders of these practices are quick to point out that police have tough cases on their hands and must use all methods at their disposal to find the truth. Undoubtedly, deception is an effective technique at times for eliciting confessions from criminals and solving crimes in some cases.
Yet these techniques also have costs. Despite potential investigative advantages, the prevalence of deception has had severe social consequences, not only for the innocent people subjected to such practices, but also for the integrity of the criminal justice system.
First, the use of deceptive interrogation techniques significantly increases the risk of false confessions. The psychological pressure and manipulation inherent in deceptive interrogation tactics can induce even an innocent suspect to admit to a crime. When faced with repeated assertions that incontrovertible evidence exists to secure a conviction — say a DNA test — some suspects begin to doubt their own recollections. Others make a calculated decision that the officers’ minds are made up and confessing is in their best interest.
One study of police detectives estimated that roughly 1 in 20 innocent suspects provides a false confession during interrogation — a staggering number, considering how many interrogations that occur daily.
Unfortunately, once elicited, false confessions are difficult to overcome in court, even in the face of contradictory evidence. As a result, false confessions routinely result in convictions, and indeed, are one of the leading causes of wrongful convictions in the United States. Of the hundreds of wrongful convictions overturned by the Innocence Project, 29 percent involved false confessions. For capital cases, that figure is 61 percent.
The problems with deception extend far beyond the interrogation room. The acceptability of lying to suspects appears to encourage a culture of deception that bleeds over into other aspects of police work where lying is illegal. Numerous studies have documented the widespread nature of police perjury in the United States.
Officers have been known to fabricate consent to searches, invent probable cause, create fictional confidential informants, misrepresent whether Miranda rights were read, or lie about the location of arrests to circumvent Fourth Amendment protections. This type of lying is so commonplace that some officers have invented a name for it: "testilying."
Ultimately, as lying is normalized as an acceptable investigative tool, and officers learn to hone their skills, it fosters a mindset that deception is justified more broadly in the pursuit of justice. This rationale then carries over into other contexts. An officer who is trained to lie to a suspect to get a confession may use the same logic in tweaking the facts on the witness stand to secure a conviction. Since these impermissible lies are rarely identified or punished, officers learn that they can lie with impunity.
In the long run, the pervasiveness of police deception — both investigative and testimonial — undermines the legitimacy of our criminal justice system. The discovery that officers frequently lie, for many, leads to a broader disillusionment with law enforcement. This erosion of trust in turn reduces cooperation with police, as citizens become less likely to report crimes or assist in investigations.
While proponents argue that restricting deception would impede investigations, evidence from peer nations suggests otherwise. The U.S. stands out from other developed democracies in allowing deceptive interrogation techniques. Most developed democracies — including England, France, Germany and Japan — prohibit or heavily restrict police deception during interrogations, with no apparent effect on clearance rates. Indeed, when the U.K. implemented reforms to curb deceptive tactics, studies found no corresponding drop in confession or conviction rates.
Policymakers should question the outsized role deception plays in criminal investigations and consider policies to limit its pervasiveness. This need not require an outright ban on the use of deception in interrogations. Rather, more moderate reforms could prove effective as well such as prohibiting the most coercive techniques, allowing deception only as a last resort, or limiting the use of deception to the most serious crimes.
An effective criminal justice system requires the prioritization of truth and protection of the innocent, just as much as it demands the identification and conviction of the guilty.
Andrew Eichen is the author of “Broken Trust: The Pervasive Role of Deceit in American Policing” for the Cato Institute and a McCourt Scholar, Georgetown’s McCourt School of Public Policy.
Date: |
Topics
-
Top stories - CBS News
When shipping containers lost at sea burst open, what happens?
Over 20,000 shipping containers have fallen overboard since 2010, their contents polluting shorelines and habitats.Yesterday -
Top stories - BBC News
Ten experts analyse what might happen next
A group of experts on whether the map of the region is being redrawn, what comes next, and what can help avert all-out warYesterday -
Sports - Yahoo Sports
What Lynch cleverly said when asked about Adams-to-49ers possibility
49ers GM John Lynch cleverly addressed the possibility of Davante Adams being traded to San Francisco.22 hours ago - NFL -
Top stories - CBS News
What could happen to CD interest rates this October? Here's what experts think.
CD rates have been high for the last two years. But will they remain so now, post-rate cut? Here's what to know.2 days ago -
Top stories - BBC News
Israel has vowed to punish Iran for its missile strikes. How?
Israel is set to retaliate for Iran's missile attack, while Tehran says it will hit back in turn if this happens.3 days ago - Iran -
Sports - CBS Sports
What's happening at AS Roma? Firing a club legend, CEO quitting, 'Yankee, go home' signs and more
It has been an intense start of the season for AS Roma inside but mainly off the pitch2 days ago -
Sports - CBS Sports
What happened to the Cowboys defense? Turning back to the past with Mike Zimmer hasn't panned out
The Cowboys haven't done anything well on defense through four gamesYesterday - NFL -
Politics - The Hill
GOP rep: Pence's life 'wasn't really in peril' when Trump said 'So what?'
Rep. Brian Mast (R-Fla.) said former Vice President Mike Pence’s life “wasn’t really in peril” when former President Trump allegedly said “So what?” on Jan. 6, 2021, in response to an aide alerting ...Yesterday - Donald Trump
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Former NY governor, stepson attacked by group in New York City
Former New York Gov. David Paterson (D-N.Y.) and his stepson Anthony Sliwa were attacked near their Upper East Side home on Friday night. Five unidentified young suspects left the former governor ...33 minutes ago - New York -
Politics - The Hill
Hurricane Helene aftermath poses election hurdles in critical battlegrounds
Hurricane Helene has thrown up new hurdles for voters and election officials alike in Georgia and North Carolina, threatening disruptions to the voting process in two of the most critical ...56 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Watch live: Trump courts voters in Pennsylvania, at site of first assassination attempt
Former President Trump is returning Saturday to Butler, Pa., nearly three months after a bullet grazed his ear at the same site in an attempted assassination. “We never finished what we were ...56 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Harris visits North Carolina after Helene: Times of crisis bring out best of ‘who we are’
Vice President Harris on Saturday traveled to North Carolina to meet with local officials and get an update on the response to Hurricane Helene, which killed dozens of people in the state amid ...57 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Hillary Clinton pushes for stronger social media regulation
Hillary Clinton, former secretary of state, encouraged lawmakers to focus on making the internet a safer place for users during a Saturday appearance on CNN. “There are people who are championing ...1 hour ago