We should all be carbon supremacists
A carbon supremacist holds as an ideological tenet that carbon-based intelligences (humans, cats, fish, bees) are superior to silicon-based intelligence, also known as AI. Conversely, silicon-based intelligences exist only to serve carbon-based ones.
I am a carbon supremacist. You should think about being one, too.
In recent years, I have had the following conversation more times than I wish to recall: “Well, it’s really interesting that [name technological advancement here] is now in the market, but it could never do my job because of [insert carefully constructed and ultimately easy to overcome reason].”
I’ve been watching carbon intelligence — humans — continuously redefine what it means to be uniquely human in ways that are neither convincing nor comforting. And in time, I have come to realize two essential truths of our age.
First, continuously moving the metaphorical goalposts is a losing proposition. With each passing advancement, the size of intellectual territory marked as “uniquely human” gets ever-smaller. I’ll refer to this as the humanist argument; it continuously stumbles on its long road toward ultimate demise.
The second truth is that no amount of marketing, demonstrations or suggestions will make me accept silicon-based intelligences as equals. They exist for one thing: servitude.
Now is the time to name this attitude and think this way, lest we find ourselves accidentally on a path to silicon-based intelligence being dominant. As there is no intellectual argument about silicon-based intelligence that will sway my attitude, this is no longer an intellectual discussion; my stance requires a new name: carbon supremacism.
I live in a technological world; my degrees are in electrical engineering and operations research and I’ve even been accused of being a data scientist. I build these machines on a small scale as part of my living.
My fears are not irrational. From my desk, I can see out a window past a grove of trees to the Pacific. But in my near view is a pile of small AI boards that I have been developing for narrow tasks.
My attitude toward the trees in front of me, and toward the carbon-based intelligences that share my living space, is that of partner and caretaker, stemming from love. It matters not a bit to me if you think that our capacity to love is evolutionary or divine; the point is that we have it. Other carbon-based intelligences have it too.
Conversely, my attitude towards silicon-based intelligences on my desk is one of depraved indifference. I do not hesitate to enhance their performance at the cost of their longevity. If beating their little contacts would make them perform better, I would not hesitate. I don’t know, or more importantly, care, what a silicon-based intelligence would want. Silicon intelligences do not have eons of evolution, and it is difficult for me to think they were touched by the divine.
Should a silicon-based intelligence become adequately sophisticated, what would it interpret as “love?” Would it even gain this capacity? Both yes and no are equally dark from a carbon supremacist’s point of view.
What actions do we propose as carbon supremacists? As of now, I believe I’m the only openly declared one, so admittedly I’m still kind of figuring it out. It involves a somewhat adversarial attitude towards AI. Here are some things I think are part of it:
- Carbon supremacists believe at every moment of every day we are either being educated to remain the masters of silicon or being trained to become its servant. If you tune out your math teacher to scroll (name website here), you are collaborating with silicon intelligence toward your own obsolescence.
- Have you noticed that it’s harder to get in touch with an actual human being if you have a problem? It should be a law that a machine has to disclose to humans when it is a machine, and that there be a non-machine option. As a carbon supremacist, I should always have the option to treat with other carbon beings.
- We should think seriously as a society about what it means to be subject to the judgment of a computer (note — you likely already are). It is untenable to declare that humans will never have decisions made about their credit scores or other aspects of their lives made entirely by an AI. However, we should take legislative action to ensure that computers are only allowed to make positive, permissive decisions and can only recommend adverse actions. A carbon intelligence has to approve, enact and if required, explain adverse actions.
Each of these issues will require money, in education and regulation. The path that got us to where we are — particularly the second and third issues — was paved with a well-meaning desire to save money.
Being human is not cost-effective, and the current incentives for business are to continue down the path that we are already on. Therefore, the only way out of this conundrum is through both grassroots action and legislation.
Carbon supremacists should begin by demanding to interact with a human in all transactions, and by making this part of the discussion with our elected and appointed leadership.
Harrison Schramm is a professional statistician and U.S. Navy veteran who sits at the intersection of policy and mathematics. He teaches courses in Logistics and Operations Research at the Naval Postgraduate School.
Date: |
-
MarketWatch - Business
We have $1 million in high-yield savings and CDs set aside to buy a house. Should we move our money if the Fed cuts rates?
We have a lot of cash on hand for a specific purpose, but we won’t be able to live off the income if interest rates drop.1 hour ago -
The Guardian - World
After the Huw Edwards scandal – and all the others – we must have a BBC fit for the modern age | Jane Martinson
The former presenter’s crimes are his responsibility, but the corporation must change so its stars can never again abuse their power. Disgraced, convicted and now sentenced , a chapter has closed: ...10 hours ago -
GameSpot - Tech
All The Upcoming Star Wars Movies
Blast off The Star Wars movie series hasn't seen a new release since 2019's The Rise of Skywalker . While the venerated sci-fi series created by George Lucas is resting, it's far from over. ...2 hours ago -
Inc. - Business
Apple Is All Ears: Making Hearing Aids Affordable
Hearing loss affects millions of people, but hearing aids have been expensive and sales have been dominated by a few companies. The new AirPods are going to challenge the status quo.10 hours ago - Apple -
The Hill - Politics
Why aren’t we treating cybersecurity as an election issue?
Cyberattacks, election interference, human trafficking and more - why aren't we talking about cybersecurity in the 2024 presidential election?9 hours ago -
BBC News - Top stories
What we know about the Hezbollah pager explosions
The attacks left nine dead and thousands injured, but how the blasts occurred remains unclear.7 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
O'Reilly: Trump should ask Harris to co-sign anti-hatred letter
O'Reilly thinks Donald Trump should call on Kamala Harris to co-sign a letter to "tamp down" on political hatred.9 hours ago - Donald Trump -
BBC News - Top stories
What should Celtic expect from 'big underdogs' Slovan Bratislava
BBC Scotland's Liam McLeod profiles Celtic's first Champions League opponent8 hours ago -
CNBC - Business
Here’s what ‘No Spend September’ is and how to know if you should participate
'No Spend September' is a social media trend that involves a full month of cutting nonessential purchases. Here's how you may benefit.4 hours ago -
CBS News - Top stories
Why you should open a long-term CD this week
High interest rates on long-term CDs could be coming to an end this week. Here's why savers should act now.6 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Klobuchar, Warner press tech leaders to take action against election-related disinformation
Democratic Sens. Amy Klobuchar (Minn.) and Mark Warner (Va.) sent a letter to major tech leaders on Tuesday, urging them to take "decisive action" against disinformation related to the 2024 general ...21 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Tensions rise after apparent Trump assassination attempt
Welcome to The Hill's Campaign newsletter {beacon} Campaign Report Campaign Report The Big Story Tensions rise after apparent Trump assassination attempt Another major event has shaken up the ...23 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Evening Report — Trump returns to campaigning after assassination attempt
Presented by the National Council on Aging — 📝 Speaker Johnson pushes ahead in funding bill fight {beacon} Evening Report © UPI photo Trump returns to campaign trail amid outrage over second ...24 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Democrats block Cruz attempt to pass GOP IVF bill
Democrats on Tuesday blocked an attempt by Republican Sens. Ted Cruz (Texas) and Katie Britt (Ala.) to pass a GOP IVF access bill through unanimous consent, repeating a similar showdown that ...29 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
GOP won't force a vote to overturn nursing home staffing rule
Republicans are not planning to force a vote on a resolution to overturn the Biden administration’s plan mandating minimum staffing levels in nursing homes, Sen. James Lankford (R-Okla.) said. A ...30 minutes ago