We need a new playbook to oppose Trump’s war on medical science
It has been a brutal few weeks for anyone who cares about American medical science.
First, we watched as the safety of thousands of study subjects and years of carefully conducted research were endangered by decimation of the U.S. Agency for International Development. Then we got front-row seats to Trump and Elon Musk’s hatchet attack on federally funded medical science at home.
At the National Institutes of Health, the cuts were so severe that experts called it “an apocalypse for American science.” At the Centers for Disease Control — the agency that works to protect the country’s public health — mass firings were carried out in a way that Dr. Georges Benjamin, executive director of the American Public Health Association, called “destructive to the core infrastructure of public health.”
And lest we forget, vaccine skeptic and conspiracy theorist Robert F. Kennedy Jr. took a victory lap through the Senate and was sworn in to lead the Department of Health and Human Services, where he can now use his bully pulpit to undermine experts and promote wacky ideas — for example, that Lyme disease is actually a military bioweapon.
Put together, these events don’t look coincidental, but more and more like part of a coordinated attack on American medical science.
Yet despite the existential threat to American health, resistance from our leaders has been remarkably light. During the Kennedy nomination process, while grassroot physicians and medical scientists were writing letters and circulating petitions, our leaders — professional societies, heads of laboratories, deans of medical schools — stayed mostly mum. When they did muster some courage to speak, it was with anodyne statements designed not to offend.
Flummoxed doctors and scientists like myself are scanning the newswire looking for signs of an organized response from those who have some power to push back. Yet, with a few exceptions, we find ourselves mostly disappointed. What gives?
Some of this is no doubt naked self-interest. Who wants to risk putting their name — or their federally funded research lab — on an enemies list?
But some of the silence comes from a well-meaning but misplaced hesitancy to avoid being seen as “political.” After all, one reason doctors and scientists are respected by the public is because we speak the universal truth of science, and don’t let ourselves get sullied in day-to-day partisan mud fights.
But, from the first moments of the new Trump administration, it should have been obvious that the old playbook was not going to be enough. Standing quietly by, doing our work in the background and leaving it to others to explain to Americans what’s at stake is not going to cut it.
No one who is paying attention can believe Trump’s actions at the CDC, NIH and USAID are about saving tax-payer money. If that were the case, we would see a detailed review and a methodical accounting of budgets and programs, followed by a plan for reducing costs while protecting these institutions’ missions. Instead, we are getting the bull in the proverbial china shop smashing and toppling things over — just to show everyone that he can.
In fact, it seems the arbitrariness of the cuts is the point. What better way to show kingly power — and stick it to those pointy-headed scientists — than by governing with edicts that don’t make sense?
Fighting back against Trump’s war on medical science is going to require scientists and physicians to update their playbook. Individuals will need to continue to bravely speak to the public directly and explain what is happening, and why it matters. But the leaders of the medical establishment must get off the sidelines, leverage their authority and put their organizations’ reputations on the line.
Will an organized opposition from America’s doctors and scientists to Trump’s war on medical science make a difference? I don’t know, but we need to find out.
David Oxman practices intensive care medicine and is an associate professor of medicine at Sidney Kimmel Medical College in Philadelphia
-
Culture wars: Trump’s takeover of arts is straight from the dictator playbook
US president’s attempt to control or dismantle cultural institutions plays into a long history of authoritarians using arts to push their agenda. In 1937, leaders of Germany’s Third Reich hosted ...The Guardian - 5d -
Can we lower toxic polarization while still opposing Trump?
I am highly critical of Trump because I believe he amplifies us-versus-them hostility.The Hill - 5d -
If we want to win the 5G war with China, we need to fully embrace American capitalism
The race to dominate 5G technology is a decisive battle for economic supremacy in the 21st century. Unfortunately, the U.S. has fallen behind.The Hill - 6d -
Look at Donald Trump and his gang of broligarchs – and tell me we don’t need a wealth tax | Brian Cox
I played a fictional billionaire on TV. It’s time world leaders got serious about taxing the real ones. Brian Cox played Logan Roy in HBO’s Succession and is a supporter of Patriotic Millionaires ...The Guardian - 2d -
3 Years Into Russia-Ukraine War, Trump Ushers in New World for Putin
Fresh possibilities have emerged for President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia with a change of power in Washington.The New York Times - 3d -
President Trump’s Cuts to Medical Research
How government cuts are slowing research.The New York Times - 2d -
Los Angeles district attorney's office to oppose new trial for Menendez brothers
Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman announced his office will oppose a motion for a new trial in the Menendez brothers' case. Hochman went through his office's analysis of the ...CBS News - 5d -
Los Angeles DA opposes new Menendez brothers trial
The Los Angeles district attorney said he does not support a new trial for Erik and Lyle Menendez, who are serving life sentences for the 1989 murders of their parents. CBS News reporter Jasmine ...CBS News - 5d -
The playbook for bombing hospitals in war: deny, deflect, justify. The law must close these loopholes | Maarten van der Heijden
Cynical actors exploit the legal ambiguities around targeting healthcare facilities, as seen in Gaza. Unequivocal protections are needed. Hospitals in Gaza have “turned into battlegrounds”, the ...The Guardian - 1d
More from The Hill
-
Flavor Flav objects after getting namechecked in Congress: 'Don't drag me into negative politics'
Flavor Flav is attempting to stop the clock when it comes to lawmakers namechecking him in Congress. "I voted against the budget yesterday, not because I'm not for decreasing taxes, but because [of ...The Hill - 13m -
Flavor Flav objects after getting namechecked in Congress: 'Don't drag me into negative politics'
Flavor Flav is attempting to stop the clock when it comes to lawmakers namechecking him in Congress. "I voted against the budget yesterday, not because I'm not for decreasing taxes, but because [of ...The Hill - 13m -
Duffy announces 'supercharge' of air traffic controller hiring amid staff shortage
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said Thursday he would implement plans to create a “supercharge” in air traffic controller staffing amid shortages. “This staffing shortage has been a known ...The Hill - 24m -
Duffy announces 'supercharge' of air traffic controller hiring amid staff shortage
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said Thursday he would implement plans to create a “supercharge” in air traffic controller staffing amid shortages. “This staffing shortage has been a known ...The Hill - 24m -
Johnson says approach to IRA repeal will be 'between a scalpel and a sledgehammer'
Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) indicated this week that his approach to repealing the Democrats’ climate, tax, infrastructure and health care bill will be neither delicate and precise nor a total ...The Hill - 37m
More in Politics
-
Flavor Flav objects after getting namechecked in Congress: 'Don't drag me into negative politics'
Flavor Flav is attempting to stop the clock when it comes to lawmakers namechecking him in Congress. "I voted against the budget yesterday, not because I'm not for decreasing taxes, but because [of ...The Hill - 13m -
Flavor Flav objects after getting namechecked in Congress: 'Don't drag me into negative politics'
Flavor Flav is attempting to stop the clock when it comes to lawmakers namechecking him in Congress. "I voted against the budget yesterday, not because I'm not for decreasing taxes, but because [of ...The Hill - 13m -
U.K.'s Starmer says his country is ready to put "boots on the ground" in Ukraine
During a meeting with Prime Minister Keir Starmer, President Trump accepted an invitation from Britain's King Charles to visit that country.CBS News - 17m -
U.K.'s Starmer says his country is ready to put "boots on the ground" in Ukraine
During a meeting with Prime Minister Keir Starmer, President Trump accepted an invitation from Britain's King Charles to visit that country.CBS News - 17m -
Trump says peace negotiations between Ukraine and Russia are moving 'pretty rapidly'
During a press conference with the prime minister of the United Kingdom, President Trump said peace negotiations between Russia and Ukraine are ongoing and moving "pretty rapidly" as Ukrainian ...NBC News - 20m