Washington’s best play in the Sahel is cooperating with the juntas
Following months of negotiation between the U.S. and Niger’s junta, the U.S. recently agreed to withdraw more than 1,000 troops from the West African country. The junta’s ascent to power, starting in July 2023, is just the most recent example of a string of coups that have affected Burkina Faso, Mali and Guinea in West Africa’s Sahel region.
In response to these coups, some argue that the U.S. should take a principled stance in defense of constitutional democracy by refusing security cooperation and exerting maximum pressure on ruling juntas to facilitate their return to civilian governance. However, the complex realities in the Sahel necessitate a more pragmatic approach.
As it stands, the juntas need support and engagement now for any chance of democratic rule later. By working with these juntas, Washington has the opportunity to help attenuate and improve the security situation — a critical step toward dismantling key barriers currently obstructing a path to democracy. Engagement will require Washington to make difficult concessions, but it’s worth the risk.
The juntas all face growing terrorist influence in the Sahel. Jihadist groups like Jama’a Nusrat ul-Islam wa al-Muslimin, the Islamic State Sahel Province, and the Islamic State West Africa Province control large swaths of land and are conducting increasingly deadly attacks. Recent analysis shows that across the Sahel, conflict fatalities from political violence increased by 38 percent and civilian deaths by 18 percent from 2022 to 2023. At a recent summit on terrorism, United Nations Deputy Secretary-General Amina Mohammed indicated that the Sahel now accounts for almost half of all deaths from terrorism globally.
The foundation of any democracy rests on the trust citizens place in their government institutions. However, the juntas’ blueprint for fighting the growing jihadist threat — primarily by increasing state violence — is eroding trust and leading to radicalization. The juntas often target ethnic communities, notably the Fulani, on the unfounded grounds that they support the jihadist groups. The recent influx of Russia’s Wagner Group has only exacerbated this violence, as the Wagner mercenaries and the juntas’ security services have abused civilians numerous times.
Participation is another pillar of democracy that is pivotal in advancing the rule of law, social inclusion and economic development. The juntas inhibit avenues to participation, such as voting, as a result of the weakened security landscape. During Mali’s recent constitutional referendum, election observers noted voting centers didn’t open in multiple regions outside the capital due to “insecurity” from terrorist threats. In Burkina Faso, the junta stated that improving security is more important than hosting elections. By helping the juntas mitigate regional terrorism, Washington can help remove this excuse for disenfranchising voters.
The poorly trained soldiers of the Sahel are in no position to improve the security situation to a suitable level that allows democracy to take shape. Washington had previously established security ties with Burkina Faso, Mali, Niger and Guinea but has suspended all collaboration per Section 7008 of the Department of State, Foreign Operations, and Related Programs Appropriations Act. Section 7008 prohibits significant American assistance to governments established through military coups. But little evidence links American military support to the Sahel’s coups, meaning Washington shouldn’t hesitate to restart regional cooperation.
Rather than sitting back and hoping for democracy in the Sahel to suddenly appear, Washington must be proactive and reestablish its security relationship with the juntas. To do so, the U.S. needs to be prepared to offer significant concessions that may appear to reward the juntas’ behavior. Unfortunately, this is the only way for Washington to get its foot back in the door.
Wagner offers the ruling juntas an enticing transactional relationship wherein it doesn’t condition its assistance on things like democratic governance and human rights. The juntas receive much-needed assistance but don’t have to commit to relinquishing power. As such, to get the juntas to break with Moscow and accept American assistance, the U.S. must offer them a deal they can’t refuse.
The U.S. should break from its policy of requiring strict conditions on the security assistance it provides. The juntas may be wary of any excess linkage of conditions to assistance — such as setting deadlines for a return to constitutional rule — as a possible bid to impose and maintain foreign influence. Moreover, American assistance must be more than just “boots on the ground” support in the fight against terrorism, and offer serious investment in training and education for local security forces. Large lump-sums of cash for defense and weapon transfers are insufficient to improve regional security.
While it may appear the U.S. would be handing the Sahel’s putschists a get-out-of-jail-free card, it’s far from the case. In order to give democracy a chance in the Sahel, Washington must do all it can to make the conditions right.
Jonah Brody is program associate at the National Democratic Institute in Washington, D.C., focusing on issues related to violent extremism in the Sahel and littoral states region. Previously he was a risk analyst with Horizon Intelligence, a Brussels-based consulting firm, covering security issues related to terrorism, insurgencies and civil unrest across the African continent. The views expressed are his alone.
Date: |
Topics
Filter
-
Pressure is on! Cooper Flagg already being hailed as college basketball's best player, top 2025 NBA Draft pick
College basketball's best incoming prospect has a heavy burden on his shouldersCBS Sports - Sports - NBA -
A New Centrism Is Rising in Washington
Call it neopopulism: a bipartisan attitude that mistrusts the free-market ethos instead of embracing it.The New York Times - Top stories -
Corner Picks, best soccer bets, odds, predictions: Bayern Munich have something to play for, Aston Villa don't
Corner Picks looks for a late rally with the finish line looming.CBS Sports - Sports -
NBA picks, best bets: Why Knicks vs. Pacers will buck a Game 7 trend, plus Nuggets vs. Timberwolves play
We have a pair of Game 7s in the 2024 NBA playoffs on SundayCBS Sports - Sports - NBA -
Xi assures Putin of continued close cooperation in Beijing
Yahoo News - World - China -
WATCH: Dragon boats to race in Washington, DC
"GMA" looks at an ancient tradition being brought to life at a festival in the nation's capitol this weekend.ABC News - Top stories -
Putin seeks greater energy cooperation with China
Yahoo News - World - China -
Thousands are expected to rally in Washington in support of Palestinian rights
The event commemorates the 76th anniversary of what is called the Nakba.ABC News - Top stories -
Kerry Washington, Adam Kinzinger to help lead poll worker recruitment effort
Kerry Washington and former Rep. Adam Kinzinger (R-Ill.) are teaming up to help lead an effort to recruit election poll workers ahead of November. The former "Scandal" star and the ex-congressman will be among the co-chairs on an advisory council ...The Hill - Politics -
New Disney Lorcana Ursula's Return Set Up For Preorder, Including Cooperative Card Game
Lorcana is gearing up for another expansion, with Ursula's Return arriving on May 31. Preorders are now available for a variety of Ursula's Return items, including starter decks, booster packs, and more. The most intriguing addition might be the ...GameSpot - Tech
More from The Hill
-
The other war: Cuban mercenaries in Ukraine
Fed up with humiliation and mistreatment, Cuban soldiers of the 428th regiment, based in Donetsk, carried out an operation to kill their own regiment's commander.The Hill - Politics - Ukraine -
Biden's proposed tax hike would crush workers and the economy
Biden is eager for more hard-earned money from U.S. taxpayers, and he is willing to drive businesses overseas again by raising corporate tax rates.The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Morning Report — Vulnerable Senate Democrats break with Biden
Six months out from Election Day, some vulnerable Democrats are looking at President Biden’s poll numbers with concern. Some Senate Democrats are distancing themselves from Biden’s ailing brand after polls show him trailing former President Trump ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Schumer tees up round two for bipartisan border bill
Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) is tee-ing up a second attempt at passing the bipartisan border bill — after Republicans blocked it earlier this year — a move that comes as the situation at the southern border remains top of mind for ...The Hill - Politics -
Democratic group targets Republicans over IVF in Arizona
A Democratic super PAC is targeting Republicans over the issue of in vitro fertilization (IVF) in the battleground state of Arizona as Democrats ramp up their attacks on reproductive access ahead of the 2024 election. Progress Action Fund, which ...The Hill - Politics - Republican Party