Want to give Elon Musk a reality check? Confirm Jared Isaacman.
It’s no secret that SpaceX’s Elon Musk has an outsized influence on the second Trump administration, especially with regard to space policy.
Musk has expressed his desire to redirect NASA to a neck-or-nothing lunge toward Mars, leaving all other priorities, including a return to the moon, on the back burner. This desire seems to have had an effect on Trump, who mentioned Mars but left out the moon in his inaugural address.
Recently, Musk advocated deorbiting the International Space Station in 2027, three years early, in order to free up money for Mars. According to Ars Technica, his statement caused consternation and no little anger in Washington. Another space player has taken notice, for obvious reasons.
“The space station has key supporters in Congress, including Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas), in whose state the orbiting laboratory is managed. Cruz has long been an advocate of the space station,” the story says.
How did Cruz react to Musk’s suggestion? Cruz did not say anything on the record initially, but “a key source said Cruz was ‘furious’ with the sentiment from Musk.”
Ars Technica suggested that the Musk statement may complicate the confirmation of Jared Isaacman, a billionaire entrepreneur and private space traveler, as NASA administrator.
A decision to end the International Space Station early would anger the space station’s international partners, who rely on it for their own space research, and also throw a monkey wrench into commercial efforts to replace the orbiting lab with private facilities.
ABC News notes that the space station "is very important in conducting scientific research, developing technologies, promoting STEM education and fostering diplomatic relationships. Deorbiting the station prematurely could end important innovations and studies pertaining to future space missions.”
A pivot away from the moon to go directly to Mars would cede Earth’s nearest neighbor to the Chinese. A Chinese moon would have a catastrophic effect on America’s standing in the world, especially if NASA gets bogged down in a difficult effort to get humans on Mars and, just as important, allow them to survive and thrive on the Red Planet.
Traditionally, the NASA administrator has been the point man for articulating and even crafting space policy. President Trump nominated entrepreneur and private space traveler Jared Isaacman to become chief of NASA. Isaacman has been going the rounds in Washington, preparing for his confirmation hearing before the Senate Commerce Committee, chaired by Cruz.
Recently, Isaacman set forth his vision of a space future that included both the moon and Mars but focused on creating the technology and capabilities necessary to extend human civilization across the solar system.
The technology that Isaacman intends to develop includes, “propulsion, habitability, power generation, in-situ resource utilization and manufacturing” which would unlock “mission optionality from the Moon to Mars and beyond.”
Isaacman also proposes to “create systems, countermeasures, and pharmaceuticals to sustain human life in extreme conditions, addressing challenges like radiation and microgravity over extended durations.”
These ambitions would require NASA and the commercial sector to operate in Earth orbit, on the lunar surface and ultimately on Mars.
Isaacman can use the hearings to publicly articulate his vision for a space future, more expansive and compelling than an all-out Mars effort at the expense of everything else. He can thus sell it to both the public and members of Congress.
Once confirmed, he can explain his approach to President Trump and, just as important, to Musk, with whom he has business and personal ties.
Musk has given benefits to human civilization that are beyond evaluation. His Falcon rockets have lowered the cost of space launch, opening vast opportunities for NASA, the military and the commercial sector. The Starship promises to open the moon, Mars and beyond to human activity.
Musk’s dream of a settlement on Mars is a beautiful, world-changing prospect. But he is mistaken in believing that dream must be pursued at the exclusion of all else. Besides forgoing the economic and scientific opportunities to be found in Earth orbit and on the moon, such an approach would skip the steps that must be taken before humans are sent to Mars to live and work.
The development of technology to preserve human health on the ISS and commercial space stations and resource extraction technologies on the moon will lead to a more sustainable and successful Mars effort.
Isaacman seems to understand that fact. Will Musk?
Mark R. Whittington is the author of, “Why is It So Hard to Go Back to the Moon?” as well as “The Moon, Mars and Beyond,” and, most recently, “Why is America Going Back to the Moon?” He blogs at Curmudgeons Corner.
Topics
-
Elon Musk Is Dangling a $5,000 ‘DOGE Dividend’ Check for Americans
Musk says he will “check with the President” about the plan, but DOGE has already overstated some of its savings claims.Inc. - Feb. 19 -
Chain, chain, chain: political theatre confirms Elon Musk’s Maga hero status at jubilant CPAC
Emboldened and exultant, speakers put less emphasis on baiting liberals and more on spreading the Maga gospel. What do you give the man who has everything? A ballroom full of cheering conservative ...The Guardian - Feb. 23 -
‘We won’t be perfect’: Elon Musk gives DOGE update at Trump’s first Cabinet meeting
During President Donald Trump’s first Cabinet meeting, Elon Musk made remarks about the recent efforts by the Department of Government Efficiency to reduce the government’s deficit.NBC News - 4d -
Elon Musk Zeroes In on the I.R.S.
The tech mogul’s cost-cutting initiative is seeking sensitive taxpayer data, drawing concerns about privacy, potential political retribution and more.The New York Times - Feb. 18 -
‘The Interview’: Ed Yong Wants to Show You the Hidden Reality of the World
The Pulitzer Prize-winning science writer talks about burnout from covering the pandemic and how bird-watching gave him a new sense of hope.The New York Times - Feb. 22 -
‘A pulse check’: Musk and Trump defend email threatening firing of federal workers
Elon Musk called an email instructing government employees to describe recent accomplishments a “pulse check,” and alleged that paychecks for federal workers may have been going to dead or ...NBC News - 4d -
The Showdown Between Elon Musk and Sam Altman
This week, the Uncanny Valley hosts discuss the lawsuits, bidding wars, and power plays over OpenAI.Wired - Feb. 20 -
Elon Musk Is Focused on DOGE. What About Tesla?
Mr. Musk, one of President Trump’s main advisers, has not outlined a plan to reverse falling sales at the electric car company of which he is chief executive.The New York Times - Feb. 20 -
Elon Musk waves 'bureaucracy chainsaw' gifted by Argentina
Argentina's president gifted Elon Musk a chainsaw to symbolise cuts to bureaucracy.BBC News - Feb. 21
More from The Hill
-
Hochul seeks to recruit laid off federal workers with ad in Washington's Union Station
New York Gov. Kathy Hochul’s (D) office is running a digital ad in Washington, D.C.’s Union Station to recruit laid-off federal employees to work for New York State amid the Trump administration’s ...The Hill - 4h -
UK prime minister dismisses calls to cancel Trump visit after Zelensky meeting
British Prime Minister Keir Starmer dismissed calls to cancel President Trump’s invitation for a state visit to the United Kingdom, following the explosive Oval Office meeting with Ukrainian ...The Hill - 5h -
Conan O'Brien swipes at Trump with 'Anora' joke at Oscars: Americans 'excited to see somebody finally stand up to a powerful Russian'
Conan O'Brien is seemingly taking a knock at President Trump at the Oscars, saying audiences are happy to see fictional film characters stand up to "a powerful Russian." "You know 'Anora' is having ...The Hill - 5h -
'No Other Land' Oscar winners call for a different path on Israeli-Palestinian conflict
The filmmakers behind ‘No Other Land,’ which won the Oscar for best documentary, called for a different path forward to resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, in their acceptance speech ...The Hill - 5h -
Why Morgan Freeman wore a glove at the 2025 Oscars
Morgan Freeman has been known to wear a single glove at times.The Hill - 6h
More in Politics
-
Hochul seeks to recruit laid off federal workers with ad in Washington's Union Station
New York Gov. Kathy Hochul’s (D) office is running a digital ad in Washington, D.C.’s Union Station to recruit laid-off federal employees to work for New York State amid the Trump administration’s ...The Hill - 4h -
UK prime minister dismisses calls to cancel Trump visit after Zelensky meeting
British Prime Minister Keir Starmer dismissed calls to cancel President Trump’s invitation for a state visit to the United Kingdom, following the explosive Oval Office meeting with Ukrainian ...The Hill - 5h -
Conan O'Brien swipes at Trump with 'Anora' joke at Oscars: Americans 'excited to see somebody finally stand up to a powerful Russian'
Conan O'Brien is seemingly taking a knock at President Trump at the Oscars, saying audiences are happy to see fictional film characters stand up to "a powerful Russian." "You know 'Anora' is having ...The Hill - 5h -
'No Other Land' Oscar winners call for a different path on Israeli-Palestinian conflict
The filmmakers behind ‘No Other Land,’ which won the Oscar for best documentary, called for a different path forward to resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, in their acceptance speech ...The Hill - 5h -
Why Morgan Freeman wore a glove at the 2025 Oscars
Morgan Freeman has been known to wear a single glove at times.The Hill - 6h