Voters deserve better than cat and brat memes
Digital tech was always going to play a big role in the 2024 presidential election campaign. AI deep fakes and viral memes have been long touted as having the potential to swing election outcomes. And the respective Democratic and Republican campaigns have not disappointed in terms of digital engagement.
But is the real story one of social media and AI creating a smokescreen that confounds critical public discourse and derails cogent discussion?
Harris’s online army of superfans, the K-Hive, moved early after Biden’s withdrawal to make the vice president’s womanhood, blackness and propensity for laughter assets rather than hindrances to her electability. Video montages of Harris, set to pop songs from Charli XCX’s album “Brat” or Chappell Roan’s “Femininomenon,” have posed a problem for Trump. Harris’s gender and race have been deployed boldly and positively, leaving the Republican campaign flailing.
The response has been to target politics instead — not Harris’s actual politics, but a nonsensical caricature of the vice president as a communist military dictator, in an AI-generated image shared by Trump on Truth Social and X in mid-August. Elon Musk, who has become a staunch supporter of Trump, shared a similar fake image of a uniformed Harris in September, contravening the rules of his own platform.
These AI images are ultimately unconvincing, appearing too glitzy — perhaps too real to be real on a visual level — and risible in terms of political realities. A good portion of the electorate no doubt appreciates that Harris is no friendlier to Soviet communism than Trump. Only a handful of diehard Trump supporters would believe otherwise.
What, then, is to be gained from sharing memes that are so lacking in credibility? In short, an attempt (often successful) to derail rational discourse and access emotions.
For this same reason, unsubstantiated viral claims over Ohio immigrants stealing and eating wildlife and family pets (including the feline variety) have been perpetuated by Trump and running mate JD Vance. This is a reminder that memes about cats will confound whatever hopes we ever had that the internet might provide a space for civil and intelligent political discussion.
Since Trump doubled down on the cat-eating story during the presidential debate, it seemed that cat lovers were being subjected to racist opportunism. However, after the presidential debate, Taylor Swift signed off her Instagram endorsement of Harris with “Childless Cat Lady,” in solidarity with the VP, a reference to Vance's 2021 remark about "childless cat ladies" running America. It seems this feline tale has a way to go yet.
As simultaneously bizarre and funny as all this seems, the combination of cats and communism belies a cynical reality about society today. A great many people are stressed, tired, financially broke, mentally ill and addicted to quick consumerist fixes, with social media providing a crucial hit of dopamine that is both constant and never enough. The traumatized (which includes many of us, to a greater or lesser degree) are especially vulnerable.
With people already hooked into a cycle of scrolling, posting, checking for likes and follows, then repeating, the insertion into their feeds of emotive topics (cats, communism, war, nuclear annihilation, race, gender, trans issues, abortion and so on) serves to further disrupt their ability to make informed choices. When accompanied by clear lies, misleading images and barefaced bigotry, such messaging can leave voters incensed, disenfranchised and disinclined to engage. Which apparently might be the best chance Trump and Vance feel they have.
Neither side is innocent of this, however. The Democrats’ embrace of Kamala as “brat” is hardly the epitome of sound political discussion. It may be more positive as a statement, with brat-ishness implying confidence, boldness and swagger. But it does nothing to level up wealth in deprived rural areas or provide sound living wages to the poorest workers.
This election's result is far from certain, despite a dangerous triumphalism from the Democrat camp (or is this what “brat” means?). Whoever wins, the loser will be a beleaguered, broken-down and internet-addicted public. The U.S. deserves more from its campaigning politicians and its social media platforms.
Mike Watson is a media and art theorist and educator born in the U.K. and based in Finland. His latest book is “Hungry Ghosts in the Machine: Addiction, Digital Capitalism and the Search for Self,” out Sept. 27.
Date: |
Topics
-
ABC News - Sports
Italy's Luna Rossa showed two skippers are better than one on the America's Cup yachts
Italy's Luna Rossa Prada Pirelli surprised its rivals at the last America's Cup by showing up with two helmsmen to steer its foiling yachts10 hours ago -
BBC News - Top stories
Red Roses don't deserve low crowds - coach Mitchell
John Mitchell says that his England team deserve more than 'non-crowds' as concerns grow over ticket sales at the WXV tournament in Canada10 hours ago -
Financial Times - World
Starmer reveals what needs to get ‘worse’ before it gets better
PM points to disruption caused by building and hints at need to ‘properly fund policies’ ahead of expected tax rises in Budget11 hours ago -
Inc. - Business
AI Could Eliminate Your Employee's Job – Or Make It Better
Business leaders must be honest about how generative artificial intelligence will affect their employees.10 hours ago - Artificial Intelligence -
The Hill - Politics
We need to have a talk about making the federal bureaucracy work better
At a dinner in Washington, a group of politicians and NGO leaders discussed the challenges of running a federal agency and the importance of having the right people in place to "turn around the ...8 hours ago -
CBS Sports - Sports
Five throws from Week 4 in college football that deserve your attention: Shedeur Sanders, Cam Ward go bananas
Both from the eye point and the EPA metric, these are throws that stood out in Week 4 in college football, with Shedeur Sanders making the list twice for two different wow plays.1 hour ago - College Football -
The Hill - Politics
Harris looks to capitalize on momentum with Asian American voters
Vice President Harris is showing signs of strength among Asian American voters as her campaign ramps up its outreach to the country's fastest-voting demographic. A Tuesday poll from AAPI Votes and ...4 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
Harris gives speech on plans for the economy in swing state Pennsylvania – live
The vice-president has lately been campaigning on creating an ‘opportunity economy’. The only vice-presidential debate before the November election is scheduled for next Tuesday, where Ohio’s ...27 minutes ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Judge approves $600 million class-action settlement in East Palestine derailment
A federal judge on Wednesday signed off on a $600 million payment from the Norfolk Southern railroad to settle claims related to the infamous 2023 derailment of a train carrying hazardous chemicals ...35 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Walz to attend Minnesota-Michigan football game
Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz (D) is adding some pigskin to his campaign trail schedule, heading to Saturday's football game between the University of Minnesota and the University of Michigan. Vice ...38 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Putin issues new nuclear threat against the West
Russian President Vladimir Putin on Wednesday made new threats to use nuclear weapons against the West, suggesting that any nuclear power supporting a country that attacks Moscow would be seen as ...53 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Republican former NC governor: Robinson a 'ticking time bomb'
Former North Carolina Gov. Pat McCrory (R) said the state’s GOP gubernatorial candidate Mark Robinson is a “ticking time bomb” who might tip the presidential election results in The Tar Heel ...54 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Senate Democrat unveils legislation giving FDA oversight on CBD safety standards
A new bill could make it easier for the federal government to regulate legal hemp products and keep them out of the hands of Americans under the age of 21. Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) introduced the ...1 hour ago