Vice presidential debate: Crucial for Trump and Harris
Except for an occasional resounding soundbite, vice presidential debates haven’t had much impact on presidential elections. Will the faceoff between Republican Sen. JD Vance of Ohio and Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz (D) prove to be any different?
The veep debate may not be a decisive, but it could be dramatic. The confrontation could be the last time voters see a confrontation between representatives of the national tickets. Win or lose in 2024, the GOP will need a new champion in 2028. Vance is trying to set himself up as Trump's successor.
Moreover, successful presidents make good choices, and the debate will showcase the first consequential choices that Trump and Harris have made as aspiring presidents.
The first rule of a vice presidential pick is to do no harm. Like many other choices Trump has made, he struck out swinging on this one. Only Trump could have picked someone as unpopular as Vance. Disgraced Republican North Carolina gubernatorial candidate Mark Robinson must have turned him down. I’m sure former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin would have jumped at the chance to drag Trump down, as she did John McCain in 2008.
A recent national survey for the Associated Press highlights Vance’s deficiencies as Trump’s running mate. There are twice as many voters who dislike as like him. His negatives are even higher than they were in July.
Walz’s popularity offers a clear and compelling contrast to Vance’s negatives. Four out of every ten voters nationally have favorable views of the governor, whereas only three in ten hold unfavorable views. Walz comes across as a grandfatherly figure with a folksy charm which plays well in the northern tier swing states, but Vance profiles as the devil in disguise.
The battle for voters in the electoral combat zone will be a fight to the finish. Both Walz and Vance were nominated to appeal to voters in the battleground states near Minnesota and Ohio in the Frostbelt. If a recent Marist survey in Michigan is any indication, Trump drew the short stick. A plurality of voters there like the Democratic No. 2, while the a plurality dislike Vance.
Trump’s choice of Vance compares unfavorably with the former president’s selection of Mike Pence. Vance represents subtraction by addition. There was a clear rationale for the Pence pick, and it paid off in 2016. Trump had a reputation of being a playboy and needed the support of evangelical Christians. Pence, who wouldn’t even allow himself to be alone with women other than his wife, was just the right guy. Pence’s blessing guaranteed the overwhelming support of the religious right.
But Pence, to his credit, demonstrated that he had a higher calling than loyalty to Trump. Pence signed off on congressional certification of Joe Biden’s Electoral College victory after Trump lost, and it cost him his good standing as a member of Trump-world. Trump wasn’t about to make the same mistake twice, so he picked a running mate who would back him, come Hell or high water.
Rather than adding anything to the troubled GOP ticket as Pence did in 2016 or as Walz does for the Democrats in 2024, Vance has doubled down on his running mate’s darkest instincts. The GOP ticket is a match made in hell.
Veep candidates should take their cues from the candidate at the top of the ticket. But Vance is the tail that wags Trump’s dog. Vance first raised the tall tale of Haitian immigrants in Ohio eating peoples’ pets. Trump jumped the shark and embarrassed himself and his running mate by parroting the false charge during his frightful debate performance against Harris.
Vance had one job, to rally the GOP base, but he has done as much or more to rally the Democratic base of female voters. His old remarks about “childless cat ladies” could gin up Democratic turnout in what could be a very close contest. Rather than taking his lead from Trump, Vance works at cross purposes with him. The guy at the top of the GOP ticket is trying to frame himself as a protector of women, whereas Vance gratuitously insulted them.
Usually, in vice presidential debates, the players act more like surrogates than candidates. Vance will viciously attack Harris with a sledgehammer while Walz, with more finesse, will challenge Trump. We might learn as much or even more about the presidential hopefuls than their seconds. We will also discover a lot about the decisions that Harris and Trump might make as presidents from their running-mate selections.
Brad Bannon is a Democratic pollster, CEO of Bannon Communications Research which polls for Democrats, labor unions and progressive issue groups. He hosts the popular progressive podcast on power, politics and policy, Deadline D.C. with Brad Bannon.
Date: | |
Tag: | Donald Trump |
-
The Hill - Politics
How to watch vice presidential debate on Tuesday
Republican vice presidential candidate Ohio Sen. JD Vance and Democratic rival Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz will debate on Tuesday, with the outcome potentially having a major impact on the election.1 hour ago -
ABC News - Entertainment
How to watch the vice presidential debate between Walz and Vance
Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz and Sen. JD Vance of Ohio are meeting Tuesday for their first and only scheduled vice presidential debate5 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
Voters need a second presidential debate that looks very different than the first
Former President Donald Trump has claimed that the ABC debate was "rigged" against him, and a second Harris-Trump debate should feature hosts who are there to facilitate discussion, and include ...22 hours ago -
The New York Times - Top stories
McDonald’s, Pelosi, Debate Moderators: Trump Speech on Border Veers Off Course
After reading from prepared remarks on immigration for 10 minutes, Donald J. Trump used the rest of a news conference to talk about everything else on his mind.15 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Inc. - Business
Will Harris or Trump Regulate AI?
Regulation will only happen if Congress passes it. That probably takes a crisis.7 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Trump hits Harris on border ahead of VP's visit
Former President Trump used a last-minute event in New York City to attack Vice President Harris over immigration and border security, just one day before Harris is scheduled to visit the U.S. ...18 hours ago - Donald Trump -
CBS News - Top stories
Trump criticizes Harris over planned border visit
Former President Donald Trump said Vice President Kamala Harris should "save her airfare" ahead of her planned visit to the southern border Friday. He also announced he would meet with Ukrainian ...18 hours ago - Donald Trump -
CBS News - Top stories
Kamala Harris headed to the border, Trump meets with Zelenskyy
Vice President Kamala Harris is visiting the U.S.-Mexico border Friday as former President Donald Trump meets with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy in New York. CBS News' Caitlin Huey-Burns ...2 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The New York Times - Top stories
Inside a Pro-Harris Ad Portraying Trump as Fighting for Billionaires Like Him
A key super PAC backing Kamala Harris makes use of a teacher’s narration and of video of Donald Trump promising to cut the taxes of people he calls “rich as hell.”23 hours ago - Donald Trump
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Israel says it struck Hezbollah HQ in downtown Beirut
Israel’s Defense Forces on Friday said it carried out a strike on Hezbollah’s central headquarters in Beirut, with media reports indicating a large explosion and plumes of orange and black smoke ...38 minutes ago - Israel -
The Hill - Politics
Democrats call for DOJ intervention in Boar's Head listeria outbreak
Two Democrats are urging the Department of Justice to get involved with the fallout of a nationwide listeria outbreak linked to a Boar’s Head plant. Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.) and Rep. Rosa ...40 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
12:30 Report — Harris’s first border trip in 3 years; Helene batters Florida
{beacon} 12:30 REPORT Happy Friday! The Southeast is getting slammed by Hurricane Helene. Yikes, it's a scary storm. Stay safe, my friends. Here’s what we’re covering today: Harris is visiting the ...46 minutes ago - Florida -
The Hill - Politics
Iranian operatives charged in Trump campaign hack
The Justice Department has charged several Iranian operatives in connection with the hack of former President Trump’s 2024 campaign. Prosecutors on Friday unsealed charges against Masoud Jalili, ...46 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Israel is losing, but can win if it adjusts its goals
It can only win if it narrows its aims, matching ends with means.49 minutes ago - Israel