Ukraine needs one more year to win, and Congress can make that happen now
Last month, Ukraine was forced to surrender Avdiivka, an embattled city in eastern Donetsk that I last visited last fall.
Avdiivka’s Ukrainian garrison had beaten back repeated Russian assaults, only for its dwindling munitions stockpiles ultimately to force a surrender. Russian artillery was firing at a rate ten times that of Ukrainian defenders, who were forced to ration shells as Western supplies dried up.
As weakened air defenses expose Ukraine’s cities to attack, the U.S. House of Representatives must vote this weekend to send Ukraine the aid it desperately needs.
The war in Ukraine has entered its third year, and this one could prove decisive. Ukraine has a pathway to a military and diplomatic victory, but so does Russia. Russian President Vladimir Putin is amassing a strategic reserve in preparation for a spring offensive. He feels emboldened after his sham re-election to take even more territory.
Only more artillery shells and air defense missiles will allow Ukraine to halt Russian advances and turn the tide in a war that threatens its very survival. Ukraine wins if it can continue to counter Russia’s onslaught with allied support; Russia wins if the West fails to support Ukraine.
I have witnessed the terrible human toll of the war in Ukraine. But Putin refuses to make peace unless Ukraine surrenders its sovereignty. That leaves Ukraine with no other option but to keep fighting.
Successful Ukrainian military resistance, on the other hand, would likely lead to the liberation of Kherson and Zaporizhzhia and an armistice line closer to the Russian border. Ukraine needs to demonstrate to Putin that he cannot gain more territory militarily, putting itself in a stronger position to negotiate an end to the conflict. The final armistice line should ensure Ukraine’s long-term security and economic viability, with sea lanes open and Western powers guaranteeing Ukraine’s security.
The last year of fighting has seen the two parties embroiled in bitter trench and urban warfare. In 2023, only 200 square miles of territory exchanged hands from Russia to Ukraine, less than a tenth of what Ukraine won in its 2022 offensive. Meanwhile, the death toll from Russia’s brutal war has crossed half a million. Soldiers are safe nowhere as reconnaissance and kamikaze drones dominate the airspace, monitoring any movement in the “death zone” separating Ukrainian and Russian troops.
Russia has caught up to Ukraine’s initial innovation advantage. It is now able to counter any new battlefield innovation from the Ukrainian side within three to six weeks. Most crucially, the Russians have skillfully employed electronic countermeasures against Ukraine’s army of drones.
Russian counter-drone operations have effectively neutralized a significant portion of Ukraine's drone capabilities. At the same time, Russian drone production has surged since the start of the war, now likely outpacing Ukraine’s by a ratio of two to one. As with most protracted wars in modern history, this one will also be decided by who innovates the fastest. War is a crucible of progress, and Ukraine needs the support necessary to give it the time to innovate.
With Western supplies slowing, Ukraine has been forced to ration its use of air defense missiles. As a result, Russian fighter bombers are able to attack relentlessly: reports indicate that more than 100 KAB glide bombs strike Ukrainian positions every day. These massive bombs are dropped 50 km from the front lines to avoid Ukrainian anti-air missiles and devastate anything they hit. Ukrainian commanders told me Avdiivka was lost because of the relentless KAB bombardment — not even the most fortified position can survive a direct hit. These strikes will likely increase as Russia has accelerated production and is now building a three-ton aerial bomb.
When it comes to military aid, the top priority must be to provide Ukraine with more air defense missiles and artillery shells. Russian assault groups have rushed toward the frontline with infantry-laden vehicles in an effort to break through Ukraine’s defenses. Ukraine needs responsive and heavy artillery fire to defend against this onslaught. Providing Ukraine with around $2.5 billion for artillery shells would enable it to sustain its defenses; $7 billion would allow its armed forces to stage substantial counter-offensives.
Additionally, long-range weapons will counter Russia’s firepower advantage by allowing Ukraine to target artillery pieces and ammunition depots behind the frontlines. Ukraine has done this successfully before. In 2022 and again in 2023 Ukraine used a handful of Western-supplied HIMARs to strike Russian depots, supply lines and command centers.
To win, Ukraine will also need large quantities of tanks and mechanized vehicles. If Ukraine is to win the war, it will not be in a single offensive, but rather through a series of smaller offensives, each of which build on the others.
This will be no simple feat. Over the last year, Russia has significantly increased its defense spending and production while maintaining a steady resupply of new recruits. In so doing, it has relied on support from allies — chief among them China — to evade Western sanctions. Oil revenues are higher now than they were before the war, funding Russia’s military output. Russia is now organized on a complete war footing.
Still, its capacity to sustain its current efforts may be dwindling. Russian industry will only be able to produce about one-third of the 152 mm artillery rounds required by its Ministry of Defense for 2024. Supply chain bottlenecks and Western sanctions have driven up the cost of new components by as much as 30 percent. Many of its systems are outdated — six out of seven new Russian tanks used in 2023 were refurbished. While Russia has far outpaced Ukraine’s production of artillery shells, it will start running low on artillery guns next year. Moscow also faces looming manpower challenges and has increasingly relied on convicts and foreign mercenaries to replace its massive battlefield losses.
This weekend, the House will vote on a long-term aid package that was approved by the Senate and includes around $60 billion for Ukraine. Most of this money will remain in the U.S., with over half going directly to the Pentagon and another quarter to U.S. defense companies. The package is a win-win for the U.S. and Ukraine.
To stay in the fight and ultimately press its advantages, Ukraine relies on the support of the free world. Russia is a formidable opponent, constantly improving its military and technological capabilities and continuing to threaten Ukraine’s independence. That Ukrainian fighters are able to hold defensive lines is a testament to their unwavering confidence and their courage in continuing to resist their once and current occupier.
If America comes through, this might just be the year that Ukraine needs to push Russia back and achieve an outcome its people can live with.
Eric Schmidt is former CEO of Google.
Date: | |
Tag: | Ukraine |
Filter
-
Why Musk Now Needs China More Than It Needs Him
China used Elon Musk’s trip to promote its message that it is open to American businesses, despite rising tensions with the U.S.The Wall Street Journal - Business - China -
Trump grumbled he needed more support at trial. Now his allies are showing up.
In the first two weeks of his hush money criminal trial, Trump grew frustrated, convinced his supporters could be doing more to help him.NBC News - Top stories - Donald Trump -
Trump grumbled he needed more support at trial. Now his allies are showing up.
In the first two weeks of his hush money criminal trial, Trump grew frustrated, convinced his supporters could be doing more to help him.NBC News - Politics - Donald Trump -
Big Ten spring football overreactions: It's title or bust for Ohio State, but Oregon can win league in Year 1
One overreaction for each Big Ten team as the dog days of summer arrive ahead of the 2024 seasonCBS Sports - Sports - College Football -
Can a Warning Label Make Us Eat Healthier?
The FDA is considering making food manufacturers put labels on the front of packages to improve American diets.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Scotland’s SNP government wins no confidence vote called by Labour – as it happened
Scottish government wins vote by 70 votes to 58, with no abstentions after debate where Humza Yousaf defended government’s record. Labour has accused Kemi Badenoch, the business secretary, of championing single-sex spaces as part of a “culture ...The Guardian - World -
What Makes a Society More Resilient? Frequent Hardship.
Comparing 30,000 years of human history, researchers found that surviving famine, war or climate change helps groups recover more quickly from future shocks.The New York Times - Science -
What Makes a Society More Resilient? Frequent Hardship.
Comparing 30,000 years of human history, researchers found that surviving famine, war or climate change helps groups recover more quickly from future shocks.The New York Times - Top stories -
Storylines: Can Erceg make good on golden opportunity vs. Pantoja?
The UFC returns to Brazil, but beyond the main event, which fights are considered must-watches?ESPN - Sports -
Looks can be deceiving: NHL 'graybeards' still making an impact
Seasoned pros like Toronto's Mark Giordano and Dallas' Ryan Suter aren't letting age -- or in some cases gray hair -- slow them down.ESPN - Sports - NHL
More from The Hill
-
Gaetz dubs House antisemitism bill a 'ridiculous hate speech bill'
Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-Fla.) labeled the House antisemitism legislation as a “ridiculous hate speech bill” ahead of the vote on Wednesday. The House approved a bill that aims to crack down on antisemitism on college campuses amid ongoing ...The Hill - Politics -
Biden to meet with families of fallen police officers in Charlotte
President Biden on Thursday will meet with families of the police officers who were killed in the line of duty in Charlotte, N.C. The president will travel to Charlotte Douglas International Airport to “pay his respects to the brave law ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
NAACP calls for federal investigation after Black man dies telling police ‘I can’t breathe’
The NAACP has called for the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) to investigate the death of a 53-year-old Black man who died after repeatedly telling police officers he couldn’t breathe as they arrested him. Frank Tyson died after Ohio police ...The Hill - Politics -
Democrats signal further increases to defense funding could come at cost for GOP
Prominent Democrats said Wednesday that any increases to defense spending beyond the budget limits agreed to as part of a bipartisan deal last year must also be met with parity for domestic programs. In remarks to the press on Wednesday, Senate ...The Hill - Politics -
Jewish Democrat on voting against bill: Anti-Zionism not 'inherently' antisemitism
Jewish Rep. Sara Jacobs (D-Calif.) said she voted against the bill that would crack down on antisemitism on college campuses because, in her view, anti-Zionism is not “inherently” antisemitism, and the measure that passed through the House would ...The Hill - Politics