Try as he might, Trump can’t kill clean energy

President-elect Donald Trump has called global warming “a canard,” “a hoax” and “nonexistent.” He once said that the idea that global warming is caused by fossil fuel emissions was “created by and for the Chinese to make U.S. manufacturing non-competitive.” Asked why sea levels are rising, Trump replied that “scientists have no idea what’s going to happen. It’s weather.”

Pressed to acknowledge that climate change plays a role in the frequency and severity of wildfires, Trump declared, “It’ll start getting cooler. You just watch.” During his first term, he blamed a catastrophic round of wildfires in California on bad forest management: “You have forests all over the world. You don’t have fires like you do in California.” Neither then nor now did Trump mention California’s new normal: prolonged droughts and fierce winds.

Trump has promised that as soon as he returns to the White House, he will withdraw (again) from the Paris Climate Accords; “drill, baby, drill” for oil and gas; and “rescind all unspent funds” related to clean energy in the Biden administration’s Inflation Reduction Act. He may also end subsidies for electric cars, school buses and offshore wind facilities, encourage fossil fuel extraction on public lands, instruct the Department of Energy to change emissions regulations and delay loans and grants from the CHIPS and Science Act and the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act.

Trump’s actions, and the rhetoric that accompanies them, will almost certainly slow the transition to clean energy. But these days not even a U.S. president can kill that transition — especially when a majority of Americans believe that climate change has already caused substantial damage to the country. And Trump is fighting against market forces, technological innovation and pork-barrel politics.

Clean energy policies are deeply embedded in the global economy, with China often leading the way in the development of new technologies. In 2023, 90 percent of new capacity throughout the world came from clean energy sources. Stringent European Union regulations compel multinational corporations in the U.S. and elsewhere to prioritize renewables and decarbonization in their supply chains. As costs for wind, solar and electric continue to decline and economic growth is decoupled from fossil fuel use, a backward-looking U.S. will find it increasingly difficult to preserve and develop markets in industrial and industrializing countries.

The U.S. now spends about $2 trillion per year on clean energy projects, more than twice the amount allocated for new supplies of oil, gas and coal. Heat pumps now outsell gas furnaces. In 2023, Americans added three times as much solar capacity as natural gas. Automobile companies are spending billions on electric vehicles, charging stations and lighter and smaller batteries; utilities have acquired vast amounts of renewables.

Every dollar the government allocates for “green” technologies generates $5 to $6 dollars in private investment. Several states and localities now require a higher percentage of electricity to come from clean energy sources. Michigan, Maine, Massachusetts and Minnesota have recently made their climate action portfolio standards more robust.

Many large-scale projects have broken ground or are about to be launched. Two days after Trump was reelected, for example, the Department of Energy finalized a $475 million loan for a battery recycling facility. Clean energy employs about 3.3 million people, one out of every 50 workers in the U.S.; their wages on average are 21 percent higher than those of workers in other occupations.

Meanwhile, fossil fuel companies, which are already producing more oil and gas than ever before in the U.S. and selling a lot of it to other countries, may ignore “drill, baby, drill” cheerleading because creating more supply will depress prices.

The principal beneficiaries of Biden administration climate action appropriations, by a whopping margin, are Republican congressional districts in red states. Texas is the biggest winner in the clean energy boom, and Florida is second. Rural areas in these states are eager to set aside land for solar panel manufacturing facilities, electric vehicle plants and lithium refineries. And the cost of labor there is lower than it is in blue states.

Not surprisingly, then, in August 2024, 18 Republican members of the House urged Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) not to repeal tax credits that have created tens of thousands of jobs in their districts. And Johnson has indicated that he will take a scalpel, not a sledgehammer, to existing clean energy policies.

With their tongues partly in their cheeks, some industry experts predict that with Trump in the White House, financial firms will no longer use the terms “climate,” “sustainability” or “E.S.G.” (environmental, social and governance) when they broker deals. Instead, they will emphasize the need for “transition finance,” “resilience,” “critical technology” and “energy security.”

Many experts emphasize that the transition to a world powered by clean energy is well underway. The only question to be asked, albeit with understandable apprehension, is how long it will take to happen.

Glenn C. Altschuler is the Thomas and Dorothy Litwin Emeritus Professor of American Studies at Cornell University.

Topics

Trump vowed to declare a national energy emergency as soon as he takes office — here's how he might do it

Trump has promised to flight inflation by slashing energy costs.
CNBC - 4h
Trump moves inauguration inside, 'vast majority' of ticketed guests can’t attend

Trump's inauguration will be moving indoors Monday due to the freezing weather expected in Washington, D.C.
ABC News - 1d
Washington DC residents flee ahead of Trump inauguration: ‘I can’t be here’

Republicans and conservatives meanwhile are pouring in for celebrations with hotels being nearly 70% booked. Alejandra Whitney-Smith has plans for president-elect Donald Trump ’s inauguration ...
The Guardian - 1d
Italy, Albania and UAE sign clean energy deal across Adriatic Sea

Yahoo News - 2d
'It can’t be bought': Greenlanders respond to Trump's options for their country

Nuuk residents said that Greenland could not be bought, after President-elect Donald Trump refused to rule out the use of force to take control of the Arctic island.
NBC News - Jan. 9
How ‘Tariff Man’ Trump Might Start Slowly When He Imposes Import Duties

Trump aides are reportedly discussing a plan to restrict pledged duties on all imports to an initial list of products considered critical to national security, reducing the risk of resurgent ...
Inc. - Jan. 7
Ben Johnson will be in demand, but he might not want to leave Detroit

Most assume Johnson will take a head-coaching job. He might not.
Yahoo Sports - Jan. 5
The Trump Administration May Find It Can’t Do Without Diversity

Diversity was a virtue in the Biden administration. The Trump administration may discover the same thing.
The New York Times - Jan. 4
Biden is trying to weaponize the Clean Air Act on his way out of the White House

President Biden’s Department of Justice filed an unusual brief in Sunoco v. Honolulu.
The Hill - Jan. 4

Try as he might, Trump can’t kill clean energy

Topics

Related

Trump vowed to declare a national energy emergency as soon as he takes office — here's how he might do it

Trump moves inauguration inside, 'vast majority' of ticketed guests can’t attend

Washington DC residents flee ahead of Trump inauguration: ‘I can’t be here’

Italy, Albania and UAE sign clean energy deal across Adriatic Sea

'It can’t be bought': Greenlanders respond to Trump's options for their country

How ‘Tariff Man’ Trump Might Start Slowly When He Imposes Import Duties

Ben Johnson will be in demand, but he might not want to leave Detroit

The Trump Administration May Find It Can’t Do Without Diversity

Biden is trying to weaponize the Clean Air Act on his way out of the White House

More from The Hill

Three Israeli hostages released by Hamas in good health

Trump says he won’t let TikTok stay dark

Johnson vows there will be ‘hell to pay’ if Hamas violates ceasefire deal

Live updates: TikTok goes dark in the US, Gaza ceasefire begins, Trump to take office

Johnson says he plans to uphold the law around TikTok ban

More in Politics

Three Israeli hostages released by Hamas in good health

Trump says he won’t let TikTok stay dark

Johnson vows there will be ‘hell to pay’ if Hamas violates ceasefire deal

‘The guns in Gaza have gone silent’: Biden hails success of Israel-Hamas ceasefire

Live updates: TikTok goes dark in the US, Gaza ceasefire begins, Trump to take office