Trump's use of Alien Enemies Act blasted as abuse of power

The White House’s use of the Alien Enemies Act to remove Venezuelans it has accused of being gang members is an abuse of war powers that critics say could open the door to mass deportations from a country President Trump has targeted multiple times in just a few months.

While accusations the White House violated a court order by flying 238 Venezuelans to a Salvadoran prison have generated significant attention, immigration and civil rights advocates say the deportations themselves are just as alarming.

The more than 100 Venezuelans deported for allegedly being in the Tren de Aragua gang had no opportunity to contest the accusation and were shipped to a Salvadoran prison amid questions over whether the U.S. had legal authority to move them there.

Trump is also tapping the infrequently used Alien Enemies Act in a way never seen before, relying on gang membership, not armed conflict, to use the executive’s war powers to deport people.

Those sent to El Salvador include people who were being removed under existing immigration authorities, raising questions about why they were sent to a foreign prison.

The government is paying El Salvador $6 million to imprison all the deportees for a year.

“All of these individuals are already alleged to have been removable under normal immigration law. So we have a bunch of people that the United States already had in physical custody and that the United States already could deport under normal immigration law, that they have instead decided to essentially send to a prison in El Salvador to do hard labor, seemingly entirely on the basis of wanting to get some public relations work done,” Aaron Reichlin-Melnick, an attorney with the American Immigration Council, told The Hill.

“Under what authority is the U.S. government paying a foreign government to imprison and subject to hard labor individuals who have not been subject to normal immigration law proceedings or charged with any crime in the United States? I simply don't see any legal authority for that. The Alien Enemies Act certainly doesn't authorize it. Normal immigration law certainly doesn't authorize it either.”

Civil rights advocates also have major concerns over Trump’s use of the Alien Enemies Act, which was most recently used as the basis for the internment of Japanese Americans during World War II.

“What we’re seeing is a president who is arbitrarily calling migration and narcotics trafficking acts of war and an invasion and predatory incursion, without any actual basis or factual basis for doing so,” said Katherine Yon Ebright, an expert in the Alien Enemies Act and attorney with the Brennan Center for Justice.

“This law was enacted pursuant to Congress's constitutional war powers. It's not an immigration statute. And so, using a wartime authority that is manifestly for responding to armed attacks for peacetime immigration enforcement is as clear of a violation … as we’ve seen from this administration and perhaps any administration.”

The Trump administration has argued the Venezuelans were “terrorists.”

“We removed terrorists from the country this weekend,” border czar Tom Homan said Monday. “I can't believe any media would question the president's ability to remove terrorists from this country.”

Trump’s plans to use the Alien Enemies Act ignited a suit from several Venezuelans already in custody who have denied any connection with Tren de Aragua, which the administration often abbreviates as TdA.

A sworn statement from an official with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) notes that “many” of those removed on the flights do not have a criminal record in the U.S.

“That is because they have only been in the United States for a short period of time. The lack of a criminal record does not indicate they pose a limited threat. In fact, based upon their association with TdA, the lack of specific information about each individual actually highlights the risk they pose. It demonstrates that they are terrorists with regard to whom we lack a complete profile,” Robert Cerna, an acting field office director with ICE, said in a sworn statement.

He added that many have been accused of crimes abroad, while others are suspected of criminal activity in the U.S.

Ebright noted the U.S. already has the power to push for deportations through regular immigration and court processes.

“What the Trump administration is hoping to do is bypass the due process protections that exist in peacetime law and in immigration law,” she said.

“The only reason to rely on the Alien Enemies Act is to bypass that process, to make any Venezuelan immigrant who the president deems to be or designates to be a member of Tren de Aragua without satisfactory evidence — make that person deportable,” she added.

“And it really does echo the World War II history, where we saw the president put 31,000 noncitizens of Japanese, German, and Italian descent into camps because he had ‘deemed them dangerous’ without evidence and without hearings.”

Reichlin-Melnick said it was “extraordinarily unlikely” that those deported would be able to challenge the administration's actions from a Salvadoran prison.

“What we know for sure is that the U.S. government has not given any of these individuals an opportunity to challenge their claim that they are part of a gang,” he said — something that would have been possible while the group was still in ICE custody.

The treatment of the other 101 Venezuelan migrants deported on the flights has also gained scrutiny. That portion of the group was removed using Title 8 immigration authorities – a standard process, but one that has not been used to remove migrants to a foreign prison.

“Yes, some people can be deported to third countries, but I have never heard of a person being deported directly to a foreign prison where they are being held, allegedly on the U.S. demand,” Reichlin-Melnick said.

In just a few short weeks in office, the Trump administration has taken a number of actions seeking to roll back protections for Venezuelans.

In February, Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem purported to end Temporary Protected Status (TPS), spurring a swift lawsuit from advocates who said she had no power to vacate the protection given by her predecessor. Laws governing TPS require analysis of various safety factors both for granting and rescinding the protections.

And Trump has also moved to end protections for Venezuelans as well as Cubans, Haitians, and Nicaraguans who were paroled into the country under the Biden admission.

Reichlin-Melnick called it a turnaround for Trump, noting that in his first term, he gave protections known as Deferred Enforced Departure to some Venezuelans, citing repression under Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro's regime.

“We are talking about more than half a million people. Many of them have been completely law-abiding after arriving in the United States, have followed every requirement of the United States, and have done nothing wrong,” Reichlin-Melnick said of the roughly 600,000 Venezuelans who immigrated to the U.S. in recent years.

“I think this is part and parcel of a broader effort to paint the United States as under siege from migrants and from immigrants.”

Topics

Trump Invoked the Alien Enemies Act to Speed Up Deportations: What to Know

The Alien Enemies Act of 1798 gives the president wartime powers to deport undocumented immigrants with little to no due process.
The New York Times - 1d
Judge expands temporary block on Trump's plan to use the Alien Enemies Act to deport Venezuelans

President Donald Trump on Saturday invoked the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 to target a Venezuelan gang he accused of "unlawfully infiltrating" the United States.
NBC News - 3d
Legal expert on how Trump's use of Alien Enemies Act compares to past cases

President Trump invoked the Alien Enemies Act to justify deporting Venezuelan immigrants, claiming an "invasion" of gang-affiliated individuals. The law, passed in 1798, has only been used three ...
CBS News - 1d
Live updates: Trump blocked from using Alien Enemies Act; Houthis vow retaliation after US airstrikes

A federal judge expanded his ruling temporarily blocking the Trump administration from invoking the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 on Saturday, preventing the removal of Venezuelan undocumented ...
The Hill - 2d
The Alien Enemies Act: What to know about a 1798 law that Trump has invoked for deportations

President Donald Trump on Saturday invoked the Alien Enemies Act for the first time since World War II, granting himself sweeping powers under a centuries-old law to deport people associated with a ...
NBC News - 1d
Trump administration deports immigrants despite judge blocking use of Alien Enemies Act

The White House is disregarding a federal judge's ruling on immigration, claiming the court has no authority. The ruling was meant to block the Trump administration from invoking the Alien Enemies ...
CBS News - 1d
A judge limits Trump's ability to deport people under the 18th century Alien Enemies Act

A federal judge on Saturday blocked the Trump administration from using an 18th century law known as the Alien Enemies Act to deport five Venezuelans, kicking off a blizzard of litigation over the ...
NBC News - 3d
Law professor speaks on legality of deportations under Trump invoking Alien Enemies Act

Professor of law at Georgetown University David Super speaks with NBC News' Gadi Schwartz about President Trump's invoking of the Alien Enemies Act and the legality of the deportations used under it.
NBC News - 23h
Judge blocks Trump from using 18th-century wartime act for deportations

Trump had invoked the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 to deport five Venezuelans, but order halted by judge. Alien Enemies Act: what is it and can Trump use it to deport gang members? Donald Trump ...
The Guardian - 3d
Trump calls for impeachment of judge who blocked Alien Enemies Act deportations

In a social media post, President Trump called for the impeachment of a federal judge who ordered the halting of deportations under the Alien Enemies Act. NBC News' Gabe Gutierrez reports on how ...
NBC News - 11h
Trump invokes Alien Enemies Act in mass deportation effort

President Trump invoked the Aliens Enemies Act (AEA) of 1798 on Saturday, fulfilling a campaign promise and GOP party platform point by initiating a concerted effort to remove Venezuelan ...
The Hill - 3d
What is the Alien Enemies Act Trump invoked to speed deportations?

President Trump has invoked the 18th-century Alien Enemies Act to allow the federal government to detain or deport people from countries deemed foreign adversaries, including targeting cartels as ...
The Hill - 3d
Judge blocks Trump administration from implementing Alien Enemies Act

A federal judge expanded his ruling temporarily blocking the Trump administration from invoking the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 on Saturday preventing the removal of Venezuelan undocumented ...
The Hill - 3d
Judge blocks Trump from using wartime Alien Enemies Act to deport immigrants

Presidents are given the extraordinary power by the 227-year-old law to order the arrest, detention and deportation of noncitizens who are 14 years or older and come from countries staging an ...
CBS News - 3d
Judge blocks Trump from using wartime Alien Enemies Act to deport immigrants

Presidents are given the extraordinary power by the 227-year-old law to order the arrest, detention and deportation of noncitizens who are 14 years or older and come from countries staging an ...
CBS News - 1d
White House touts deportations under Alien Enemies Act after judge block efforts

The Trump administration announced deportations of hundreds of immigrants it alleges are members of a Venezuelan gang to El Salvador under the Alien Enemies Act.
NBC News - 2d
The history of the Alien Enemies Act of 1798

A federal judge heard arguments Monday on whether the White House violated a court order by deporting migrants without proper court hearings. The Trump administration claims it has the authority ...
CBS News - 1d
Judge blocks Trump admin from deporting 5 Venezuelans amid plans to invoke Alien Enemies Act

A federal judge on Saturday preemptively blocked the Trump administration's reported efforts to quickly deport five Venezuelan nationals under the Alien Enemies Act (AEA) of 1798. The move from ...
The Hill - 3d
What to know about Trump's court-defying deportations under Alien Enemies Act

The Trump administration says 261 people were deported to El Salvador on Saturday, 137 of whom were removed under the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 over alleged gang ties. The move came despite a ...
CBS News - 1d
Rubio announces deportations day after judge blocks using Alien Enemies Act

Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced on Sunday that hundreds of members of the Tren de Aragua gang have been deported under the Alien Enemies Act of 1798, even as a federal judge ordered the ...
The Hill - 2d
What is the 1798 law that Trump used to deport migrants?

The wartime Alien Enemies Act has been controversially used to deport Venezuelans to a mega-jail in El Salvador.
BBC News - 1d
What is the Alien Enemies Act that Trump plans on using to deport migrants to Guantanamo Bay?

Multiple U.S. officials familiar with President Trump's immigration plans say he will invoke a 227-year-old wartime law to authorize the deportation of some migrants as soon as Friday. This would ...
CBS News - 5d
Judge orders hearing over Trump deportations under Alien Enemies Act despite court ruling

A federal judge has scheduled a hearing for Monday afternoon on whether the Trump administration violated a court order against using a law passed in 1798 to deport hundreds of undocumented ...
CBS News - 1d
Trump to invoke wartime power from 1798 for Guantanamo deportations

President Trump is planning to invoke a wartime law known as the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 as soon as Friday to authorize the summary deportation of some migrants.
CBS News - 5d
DOJ seeks to boot judge questioning Trump deportations, lawyer warns of 'constitutional crisis'

The Trump administration has used the wartime Alien Enemies Act to deport hundreds of alleged Venezuelan gang members to Central America.
CNBC - 14h
Timeline of Trump’s Deportation Flights, From Alien Enemies Act to Judge’s Order

A New York Times review of flight data showed that at the time of a federal judge’s order, two flights were in the air, and one had not yet taken off.
The New York Times - 14h
DOJ refuses to answer some questions from judge who blocked Alien Enemies Act deportations

The Justice Department on Tuesday refused to answer questions from a federal judge seeking more details on deportations carried out under a rarely used wartime act, leading the judge to issue a new ...
NBC News - 9h
'Many' alleged gang members deported by Trump didn't have criminal records in US: ICE

Many of the noncitizens deported pursuant to the Alien Enemies Act did not have criminal records, an Immigration and Customs Enforcement official said in a sworn filing.
ABC News - 10h
Timeline: Trump's race against courts to deport gang members under Alien Enemies Act

A minute-by-minute timeline of events of the Trump administration's race against the clock to deport alleged members of the Venezuelan gang Tren de Aragua.
ABC News - 1d
Trump calls to impeach judge who ordered halt to Alien Enemies Act deportations

President Donald Trump is expected to speak with Russian President Vladimir Putin this morning as the United States tries to mediate a diplomatic solution to end the war in Ukraine.
NBC News - 15h
Breakdown of Alien Enemies Act and Trump administration's deportation flights against judge's order

The Trump administration has until noon Tuesday to share details with a federal judge about the deportation flights carrying undocumented Venezuelans. The White House carried out the flights even ...
CBS News - 11h
In Speech to Justice Dept., Trump Airs Grievances Against His Enemies

The president, once the target of federal prosecution, says he wants to combat “weaponization” of the department, even as he uses its powers to punish enemies and reward allies.
The New York Times - 4d
White House denies violating judge’s order with Venezuela deportations

Trump administration used Alien Enemies Act to deport about 250 alleged gang members to El Salvador. US politics live – latest updates The White House has denied allegations that it engaged in ...
The Guardian - 1d
White House denies ignoring court order blocking some deportations

A federal judge in Washington, D.C., held a hearing late Monday on the Trump administration's use of the 18th-century Alien Enemies Act. Despite being blocked by the courts, the White House used ...
CBS News - 1d
Judge incredulous in Trump deportation case as administration lawyers argue verbal court order isn’t binding – as it happened

This blog has now closed. You can read more of our US politics coverage here . White House denies violating judge’s order with Venezuela deportations What is the Alien Enemies Act and how is ...
The Guardian - 1d
What Is Tren de Aragua?

A gang with roots in a Venezuelan prison, the criminal group was at the center of President Trump’s order invoking the Alien Enemies Act of 1798.
The New York Times - 3d
Trump administration pushes to have deportation case reassigned to another judge

The Trump administration is pushing to change the judge overseeing a challenge to the president’s invocation of the Alien Enemies Act to carry out swift deportations. The Justice Department made ...
The Hill - 1d
What is Tren de Aragua, Venezuelan gang targeted by Trump for deportations?

Tren de Aragua, commonly known as TdA, is the Venezuelan gang targeted by President Trump in recent mass deportations. On Saturday, Trump invoked the Alien Enemies Act of 1798, the first time it’s ...
The Hill - 1d
Judge blocks deportations under 1798 law, orders flights turned around

A federal judge has blocked the Trump administration from deporting any noncitizens pursuant to the president's recent proclamation invoking the Alien Enemies Act.
ABC News - 2d