Trump’s Panama Canal plan is another loser for America’s maritime industry

Less than 30 minutes into his second term, President Trump abandoned the pretext of isolationism he had adopted during his campaign and laid out the first steps for a 21st-century expansion of the American empire. His target? The Panama Canal.

Trump tapped into a familiar set of grievances in his inauguration speech as justification for taking back the waterway, claiming that “American ships are being severely overcharged.” He also claimed, despite Panamanian denials, that China was surreptitiously operating the canal.

Like many of Trump’s claims, this one is off-base. Although there are concerns about the Chinese government’s involvement in infrastructure projects near the canal, China has no control over the canal itself.

But China does have the power to cripple U.S. shipping and our access to key supply chains — and it doesn’t need the Panama Canal to do it.

Starting about 45 years ago, the U.S. government began abandoning polices that had, going back to colonial times, ensured that that America maintained a viable shipbuilding industry and merchant marine. But in the 1980s and ’90s, the U.S. abandoned these policies in favor of a radical free-market approach. Meanwhile, China and peer nations continue to heavily subsidize their shipyards and favor their domestically flagged ships.

The result was the near-complete collapse of the American shipping industry. At the end of World War II, American vessels controlled over 60 percent of global shipping capacity. Today, the largest American shipping corporation controls a mere 0.2 percent of shipping capacity.

Nearly 90 percent of American cargo is shipped by just three major ocean carrier cartels composed entirely of foreign corporations. The U.S. has also stopped building ships, producing less than 1 percent of the world’s vessels. Many of our largest port terminals are controlled by foreign corporations.

By contrast, China produces 95 percent of the world’s shipping containers, 86 percent of the world’s truck chassis, 80 percent of the ship-to-shore cranes in U.S. ports and over half of the world’s oceangoing vessels. On top of that, China also owns the world’s fourth-largest shipping company and the world’s most dominant shipping logistics management platform.

Thanks to deregulatory, laissez faire maritime policy, the U.S. has abandoned the oceans, allowing China and foreign shipping corporations full control over our channels of commerce. If an American business seeks to access world markets, it is at the mercy of a volatile shipping industry almost entirely controlled by extractive foreign shipping cartels, which themselves are at the mercy of China.

The harms are not merely theoretical. The U.S. saw the deleterious effects of an ocean-shipping supply chain monopolized by unregulated foreign cartels during the pandemic. Amid skyrocketing freight rates, American businesses struggled to import key goods, leading to a contraction of industrial production, further exacerbating inflation. Farmers and other exporters saw relationships with foreign buyers that took years to develop fracture because foreign shipping lines refused to ship their cargo.

One dairy exporter stated in testimony before the House of Representatives that “over 99 percent of our 2021 ocean shipments have been cancelled and rebooked for a later date at least once, if not twice, and in some cases up to 10 times or more.” The dairy exporter also noted that “over 100 bookings this year have been cancelled and rebooked 17 times. This equates to a five-month delay for customers.”

As in most areas, Trump and his surrogates have vacillated about maritime policy, but early indications are that he will continue the destructive, laissez-faire approach. In early January, Trump suggested that it might be better for the U.S. to continue outsourcing shipbuilding capacity, rather than to invest much-needed resources to build them at home.

Trump’s plans to shrink the federal workforce, and Elon Musk’s plans to cut spending by $2 trillion, would cripple the ability for an already-hamstrung Maritime Administration and Federal Maritime Commission to identify and address key vulnerabilities in the supply chain. Political stunts like the now-rescinded funding freeze cause serious uncertainty when planning large, capital-intensive projects such as vessel construction or port modernization. Finally, Trump’s broad promises to deregulate will leave American shippers without protection against the whims of foreign shipping cartels.

Rather than learn from his predecessors, Trump seems poised to repeat their mistakes. The last 45 years of deregulatory maritime policy has left our economic security wholly dependent on the goodwill of China and foreign shipping cartels. Attempting to reclaim the Panama Canal while continuing on the path of radical deregulation does not serve to make the U.S. more safe, prosperous or economically secure.

Arnav Rao is a transportation policy analyst at the Open Markets Institute.

Topics

Navy Aircraft Carrier Collides with Merchant Ship Outside Suez Canal

Yahoo News - 1h
How Trump's immigration crackdown is affecting people across America

ABC News correspondents deployed across the U.S. to see the varying impacts of the Trump administration's crackdown.
ABC News - 3h
U.S. Deports Migrants From Asia to Panama

The move could herald a new front in the Trump administration’s plans for mass deportations, one that allows for more rapid removal of migrants whose home countries are reluctant to accept them.
The New York Times - 3h
Myanmar Refugees’ Dreams of Living in America Dashed by Trump Orders

President Trump’s moves to pause refugee resettlement, freeze foreign aid and suspend funds to promote democracy have added more chaos to one of the world’s most urgent humanitarian crises.
The New York Times - 20h
House Freedom Caucus plans to throw another tax plan into the mix

Politico - 2d
President Trump stops the global assault on America’s steel industry

President Trump's new Steel Tariffs 2.0 aim to end foreign producers' exploitation and circumvention of trade laws, protecting America's steel industry and national security.
The Hill - 2h
Why Mexico’s industrial heartland is not afraid of Trump’s tariff threats

Business leaders believe US president needs Mexican manufacturers to win battle with China
Financial Times - 10h
ETF industry braces for winds of change under Donald Trump

The temptation to move beyond traditional buy-and-hold vehicles is likely to increase, industry observers say
Financial Times - 16h
Trump picks oil industry vets for key posts in energy, environment

{beacon} Energy & Environment Energy & Environment The Big Story Trump picks oil industry vets for key posts in energy, environment President Trump has selected people with significant ties to ...
The Hill - 23h
How America's chief consumer-protection agency came into the Trump administration's crosshairs

When the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau made an appearance in the Heritage Foundation’s Project 2025 blueprint, the conservative group’s plan was simple: Abolish it entirely.
NBC News - 1d
Trump picks oil industry vets for key posts at energy, environment agencies

President Trump has selected people with significant ties to oil and other industries for key posts at the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the Interior Department, according to the ...
The Hill - 1d
Trump’s Gaza proposal is reckless. Here is a feasible plan.

Instead of such headline-chasing chicanery, what is needed is a serious, enforceable regional security arrangement — one that anchors stability in Arab-state involvement, coordinated security ...
The Hill - 1d
Rich retirees win if Trump ends taxes on Social Security benefits — but there are plenty of losers

Well-off retirees stand to gain thousands of dollars in tax savings every year if President Donald Trump succeeds in his bid to exempt Social Security benefits from income taxes, while younger ...
MarketWatch - 1d
This is why Trump’s tariff plan has upended the car industry, and it’s not over yet

“No one is breathing easy”: Trump may have paused his plan to slap 25% tariffs on products coming from Canada and Mexico, but the U.S. auto sector is still reeling.
MarketWatch - 1d
Trump’s Plan to Remake the Federal Work Force

One of President Trump’s first executive orders claims the power to fire, and hire, tens of thousands of career civil servants across the government. Astead W. Herndon, a national politics reporter ...
The New York Times - 1d
‘Cost and chaos’: Trump’s metal tariffs sweep across corporate America

Executives grapple with uncertainty and price volatility even before levies come into effect
Financial Times - 1d
Apple changes Gulf of Mexico to Gulf of America based on Trump's order

Apple has changed the name of the Gulf of Mexico to the Gulf of America on its maps after an order by President Donald Trump was made official by the U.S. Geographic Names Information System
ABC News - 1d
Ford CEO says Trump's tariffs are causing 'chaos' in auto industry

President Donald Trump’s tariffs, both implemented and just threatened, are causing “chaos” for the U.S. automotive industry, according to Ford Motor CEO Jim Farley.
NBC News - 2d
America Is Full of People Trump Doesn’t Like

If, according to the president, so many people in the United States are the wrong kind, who makes up the right kind?
The New York Times - 2d
Dozens of US organizations condemn Trump Gaza plan

Social justice organizations based in the U.S. issued a joint statement Monday condemning President Trump’s plans to redevelop the Gaza Strip, effectively displacing Palestinians from their ...
The Hill - 2d
What are the ramifications of Trump's Gaza plan?

President Trump has said the U.S. is committed to buying and owning the Gaza Strip, despite the Palestinian Authority saying the land is not for sale. Matthew Kroenig, an expert with the Atlantic ...
CBS News - 2d
Trump's proposed buyout plan for federal workers in limbo

A federal judge is weighing extending the pause on President Trump's "deferred resignations" for federal workers. Weijia Jiang is following the latest developments at the White House.
CBS News - 2d
Trump signs order to impose 25% tariffs on steel and aluminum — here are the likely winners and losers

Perhaps unsurprisingly, the biggest winner of the trade tariffs is likely to be the U.S.
CNBC - 2d
Another Republican senator goes against Trump's 'poorly conceived' NIH funding cuts

Collins said Kennedy “promised” that as soon as he was confirmed he would “re-examine this initiative” that he says was “implemented prior to his confirmation.”
ABC News - 2d
How far is Trump willing to go on Gaza plans?

President Trump is insisting on his Gaza plans and comparing them to a real estate development for the future. CBS News senior White House correspondent Weijia Jiang reports.
CBS News - 3d
UK steel industry fears ‘devastating blow’ from Trump tariffs; Brussels vows to react; FTSE 100 hits record high – business live

US president says 25% tariffs on steel and aluminium imports to be introduced this week as Chinese tariffs come into effect. Trump to announce 25% aluminum and steel tariffs as China’s levies ...
The Guardian - 3d
Trump’s nitwitted Gaza plan

Let’s move the 2 million permanently out of Gaza. But where? And how? And who will take them? Unclear.
The Hill - 3d
Can America's specialty farmers fill demand if Trump's tariffs hit niche crops?

Many of the specialty foods Americans enjoy are almost entirely imported from abroad. The few growers who cultivate these items domestically say it’s a tough business.
NBC News - 3d
Trump recognizes Feb. 9 as first ever 'Gulf of America Day'

President Trump announced that Sunday was the first ever "Gulf of America Day," following an executive order that set in motion the process of changing the name of the Gulf of Mexico. The president ...
The Hill - 3d
This Isn’t the Donald Trump America Elected

He is making us a corrupted, brittle superpower.
The New York Times - 4d
Trump is reviving ‘Star Wars’ and calling it the ‘Iron Dome for America’

The Trump executive order notes that developing a missile defense system is part of a strategy of “peace through strength.”
The Hill - 4d
Trump’s Gaza proposal dashes shipping industry’s Red Sea hopes

Traffic had risen after the Houthis said they would stop targeting most vessels following the Israel-Hamas ceasefire
Financial Times - 4d
A Trump peace plan for Ukraine?

Reports suggest a proposed US peace plan could be unveiled this week.
BBC News - 5d
Trump says America was at its richest in the late 1800s. Here are the facts.

As President Donald Trump promises that more tariffs will be coming, he has made an effort to give history lessons to explain his fondness for imposing taxes on imports. Here’s what historians make ...
MarketWatch - 5d
Graham's plan for Trump tax cuts

Welcome to The Hill's Business & Economy newsletter {beacon} Business & Economy Business & Economy The Big Story Graham rolls out plan to tackle Trump agenda Senate Budget Committee Chair ...
The Hill - 5d
Trump, the Panama Canal and China’s Role: What We Know

The canal’s two biggest ports are operated by a Hong Kong company with global reach. The Trump administration sees a Chinese threat to U.S. security.
The New York Times - 6d
Panama's president rejects U.S. claim of a deal for free canal passage

Panama's president says the State Department's claim of an agreement granting U.S. warships free canal passage was "based on a falsity. And that's intolerable."
CBS News - 6d
Trump Media Is Moving Into the Financial Services Industry

The parent company of Truth Social said it had applied for trademarks for investment products that would allow supporters to invest in the “patriotic economy.”
The New York Times - Feb. 6
Trump’s Tariff Plan Is Looking Potentially Disastrous for Inflation

Here’s why Trump’s opening tariff salvo will likely hurt U.S. consumers.
Inc. - Feb. 6