Trump's mass deportations aren't 'shock and awe'
Once again, the phrase “shock and awe” has become popular — this time in describing the Trump administration’s efforts to remove the “worst of the worst” illegal immigrants arrested for certain crimes.
As the principal creator of the shock and awe military doctrine, dating back to 1995, I am here to tell you that the effort to expel these individuals is many things — among them, justified — but it is not "shock and awe."
Shock was the first intensive reaction generated by our actions. Awe was the means of extending shock for an extended period.
The first misuse of shock and awe came during the Iraq War in March 2003. As the coalition began its offensive against Saddam Hussein, Gen. Tommy Franks, the overall commander, announced a campaign of “shock and awe” was underway.
Franks had been given the book on shock and awe by then-Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld. Rumsfeld was a “rump” member of the team that helped invent shock and awe eight years before.
Rather than read the book, Franks grabbed the headline. On the second day of the onslaught, the United Kingdom’s Daily Telegraph ran a half-page prominently displayed photo of bombs exploding in Baghdad under the headline “Baghdad Blitz.” Shock and awe “disappeared” that day.
What had been the catalyst for "shock and awe" was a combination of Operation Desert Storm and the 1991 Iraq War — in which the world’s sixth largest Army was driven from Kuwait and in 100 hours eviscerated — and the theories of Chinese general and philosopher Sun Tzu, who argued for winning without fighting. Given the massive military superiority of the U.S.-led force in the Gulf, I wondered whether it might not have been used more decisively.
This question led me to form a small group of retired four-star officers who had commanded the air, sea and land components of Desert Storm, along with a very senior former Defense Department civilian. The answer we formulated was that strategic objectives must be based on the ability to use all kinetic and non-kinetic tools to affect, influence and control the will and perception of potential adversaries with a minimum use of force.
Rumsfeld, who became an unofficial member of the group, summarized this in basic terms of “getting the other fellow to do what you want or stop doing what you do not want.”
Shock and awe had four characteristics. The first was to control all aspects of the environment and the land, air, sea, space and cyber domains, meaning that the adversary would see or perceive exactly what we intended and not see whatever we wanted withheld.
Second was as complete knowledge and understanding of the environment and the adversary as possible. Since all the military members of the group had served in Vietnam, we understood how the failure to know and understand the enemy had lost us the war.
Third was rapidity and the necessity of acting far more quickly than the adversary. Last was brilliance in operations as the only acceptable standard in execution of the strategy. Technologies for each of these characteristics were part of "shock and awe."
Ten levels of shock and awe were identified. The first was the equivalent of winning the lottery and the positive aspects of shock and awe to gain control. The most decisive was how nuclear weapons forced the Japanese to abandon suicidal resistance and accept unconditional surrender.
The intent of shock and awe was to render the adversary impotent to taking any action and hence being entirely vulnerable to our will.
That did not mean nuclear weapons were the only or best means to achieve shock and awe. Conventional bombing of Tokyo, Nagoya and Haruna killed more Japanese civilians than the atomic bombs in Hiroshima or Nagasaki.
But the Japanese could not comprehend how two bombs from two aircraft could wreak so much destruction and death. That was shock and awe at work, and it ended the war.
Gen. Colin Powell developed the idea of overwhelming force that became “decisive force.” The crucial difference between that and shock and awe is that military force may or may not have been necessary. Instead, the psychological aspects were crucial to the concept of shock and awe.
Obviously, rounding up illegal immigrants arrested for crimes does not fall under shock and awe. The phrase has simply become too commonplace. The premise of aiming to affect, influence and control will and perception must be the key to a strategy of shock and awe.
Just think how it could be applied to our adversaries today.
Harlan Ullman, Ph.D., is United Press International’s Arnaud deBorchgrave Distinguished Columnist, senior advisor at Washington's Atlantic Council, chairman of two private companies and principal author of the shock and awe military doctrine. His next book, due in 2025, is “The Great Paradox: Strategic Thinking in an Unstrategic World.”
Topics
-
Chicago officials react to Trump's mass deportation raids
Federal officials detained more than 100 immigrants with apparent criminal convictions in Chicago, city officials say. CBS News' Ian Lee has more on what's known about the raids.CBS News - 5d -
Trump’s ‘shock and awe’ is Washington’s new normal — again
Welcome to Washington’s new normal. President Trump promised shock and awe when he was elected, and his Inauguration Day at times felt like an effort to overwhelm his critics, his opponents and a ...The Hill - Jan. 22 -
Stocks set to rise, dollar falls as Trump holds back on tariff ‘shock and awe’
Bitcoin, which soared to a record above $109,000 early Monday, was also pulling back.MarketWatch - Jan. 21 -
The Memo: Trump set to ‘shock and awe’ with executive actions
President-elect Trump is expected to unleash a blizzard of executive orders as soon as he takes office on Monday, seeking to demonstrate he can deliver on the hopes of supporters who elected him to ...The Hill - Jan. 20 -
Trump ally says first 100 days will be "shock and awe"
After Donald Trump sought to overturn his 2020 election loss, and a mob of his supporters attacked the Capitol on January 6, 2021, many believed his political days were over. But now he's back. ...CBS News - Jan. 19 -
Trump ally: First 100 days will be "shock and awe"
President-elect Donald Trump's return to the White House is the culmination of a political comeback that many in both parties believed would never happen. Now, Trump is promising swift action ...CBS News - Jan. 19 -
Trump’s border tsar vows ‘shock and awe’ deportations in first week
Tom Homan said officers will carry out ‘targeted enforcement operations’ against immigrants with criminal recordsFinancial Times - Jan. 18 -
Noem on enforcing Trump's promises of mass deportations
South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem, President-elect Donald Trump's pick to lead the Department of Homeland Security, was asked about enforcing the mass deportation plans promised during the 2024 ...CBS News - Jan. 17 -
'There is going to be shock and awe with executive orders'
Republican Sen. John Barrasso predicted Donald Trump will hit the ground running.Politico - Jan. 12
More from The Hill
-
Carville knocks Democrats for starting 'seventh-string quarterback' Harris
Senior Democratic strategist James Carville on Friday severely criticized former Vice President Kamala Harris, saying that the Democratic Party’s decision to nominate her for president was akin to ...The Hill - 38m -
McConnell on screaming matches with Trump: 'We had a candid relationship'
Former Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell (Ky.) said he had “candid” conversations with President Trump when asked about reports that he and Trump got into “screaming matches” during the ...The Hill - 43m -
Americans optimistic on key economic factors: Gallup
Americans are feeling optimistic that the stock market will rise and that the economy will grow, according to a Gallup poll taken in the weeks just before President Trump's inauguration. Sixty-one ...The Hill - 44m -
Crockett: 'We have a thug in charge of the United States'
Rep. Jasmine Crockett (D-Texas) accused President Trump of acting like a “thug” who is trying to “get rid” of governmental checks and balances by firing or forcing out top FBI officials and federal ...The Hill - 49m -
Christie: Trump FBI purge 'incredibly dangerous' to national security
Former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie (R) said Sunday that President Trump’s purge of the FBI is “incredibly dangerous” to national security. In an interview on ABC News’s “This Week,” Christie ...The Hill - 50m
More in Politics
-
Carville knocks Democrats for starting 'seventh-string quarterback' Harris
Senior Democratic strategist James Carville on Friday severely criticized former Vice President Kamala Harris, saying that the Democratic Party’s decision to nominate her for president was akin to ...The Hill - 38m -
McConnell on screaming matches with Trump: 'We had a candid relationship'
Former Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell (Ky.) said he had “candid” conversations with President Trump when asked about reports that he and Trump got into “screaming matches” during the ...The Hill - 43m -
Americans optimistic on key economic factors: Gallup
Americans are feeling optimistic that the stock market will rise and that the economy will grow, according to a Gallup poll taken in the weeks just before President Trump's inauguration. Sixty-one ...The Hill - 44m -
Fear of FBI mass firings ramp up as Trump administration hopes to reshape the agency
The fear of mass firings at the FBI is ramping up as some agents have pre-emptively packed up their desks after President Donald Trump praised the firing of eight top FBI officials. NBC News’ Ryan ...NBC News - 48m -
Crockett: 'We have a thug in charge of the United States'
Rep. Jasmine Crockett (D-Texas) accused President Trump of acting like a “thug” who is trying to “get rid” of governmental checks and balances by firing or forcing out top FBI officials and federal ...The Hill - 49m