Trump’s attack on law firms targets democracy’s front lines of defense

President Trump’s assault on major U.S. law firms has no historical precedent, but there is one exceptionally powerful literary antecedent.

In William Shakespeare’s “Henry VI, Part Two,” the rebellious Jack Cade plots to seize the throne of England.

“When I am king,” he declares, life will be grand. Tankards will hold more ale, the price of bread will fall by over half, and “there shall be no money; all shall eat and drink on my score.”

Predictably, there is an irrational side to Cade’s grandiosity. It would be a “felony to drink small beer,” and his subjects would be required to wear identical clothing. Then, the people will have to “worship me their lord.”

The great obstacle to Cade’s scheme is quickly recognized by his murderous henchman, Dick the Butcher. “The first thing we do,” he famously says, “is kill all the lawyers.”

It’s not that Dick is fed up with pettifogging and hyper-technicality. Rather, he realizes that lawyers would provide the last defense against Cade’s intended tyranny.

Should he succeed, it is Cade’s plan to “burn all the records of the realm; my mouth shall be the parliament of England.” But first, he would have to eliminate the lawyers standing in his way.

If that sounds familiar, it’s because many of the same lines — demagogic promises, royal pretensions, autocratic rule — could be written today, describing Trump’s efforts to govern through executive orders. Like Dick the Butcher, he understands that lawyers can thwart his ambitions.

The initial targets of the president’s purge have been three law firms — Perkins Coie, Covington and Burling and Paul Weiss — which drew Trump’s wrath by representing or employing his adversaries.

Perkins Coie represented the Hillary Clinton campaign in 2016. Paul Weiss had Mark Pomerantz, who later joined the Manhattan District Attorney’s prosecution of Trump, as a former partner. Covington and Burling represented former Special Counsel Jack Smith, although not in relation to the Trump investigations.

Trump’s orders removed security clearances from the firms’ lawyers, making them ineligible to represent clients in sensitive cases. He also directed federal agencies “to terminate any contract” for which the firms have been hired and prohibited paying private contractors who work with the firms, apparently including their clients.

The Perkins Coie and Paul Weiss orders also instructed agencies to limit law firm employees' “official access from Federal Government buildings,” evidently including courthouses, when it would “threaten the national security of or otherwise be inconsistent with the interests of the United States.”

The qualifying terms — “national security” and “interests of the United States” — were left dangerously undefined, presumably to be invoked at some unnamed official’s whim or discretion.

Dick the Butcher never got a chance to knock off England’s lawyers, but Trump’s retribution campaign is well underway, with the potential to destroy the firms that displease him.

Business clients have solid economic reasons to avoid attorneys on the president’s hit list, especially when their own government contracts may be jeopardized by hiring the wrong firm. Both Paul Weiss and Perkins Coie began losing clients immediately following Trump’s orders.

The danger extends beyond the embattled law firms. Attorneys play a crucial role in protecting individual rights and democracy itself. If lawyers are too intimidated to challenge authority, personal liberty will inevitably suffer. Nobody can rely on the rule of law if lawyers are punished for defending it.

Perkins Coie has challenged Trump’s executive order in court, rightly arguing that it violates multiple provisions of the Constitution, including the First Amendment, by punishing the law firm for its public positions and associations adverse to the president.

The order likewise violates the Fifth and Sixth Amendments, which guarantee the right to counsel. The constant fear of executive retribution compromises lawyers’ ability to provide independent representation to their clients.

Fortunately, the first court to consider the issue has thus far ruled for Perkins Coie, preliminarily blocking the executive order. Trump’s “exertion of extraordinary power” casts “a chilling harm of blizzard proportions across the legal profession,” said U.S. District Judge Beryl Howell, who then set the case for hearing on a permanent injunction.

Unfortunately, winning in court may not be enough. Trump has shown little regard for judges who rule against him, and the three executive orders appear to be the first of many. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission has already announced the investigation of another 19 major law firms for their DEI policies.

Even if every law firm wins every case, few lawyers can afford to risk provoking Trump’s wrath. The "in terrorem" effect will be unavoidable, as the fear of losing clients threatens to compromise every decision lawyers make. Many big law firms already appear to have been intimidated into silence about Trump’s executive orders.

Paul Weiss got the message. Trump rescinded the executive order after the firm’s chair accepted his demands, including the commitment of $40 million in pro bono attorney time for several Trump administration initiatives, and an agreement not to reject clients based on their political views.

According to the White House, Paul Weiss also acknowledged the “wrongdoing” of former partner Mark Pomerantz — whose offense had apparently been, in his words, “working as a prosecutor to uphold the rule of law.”

If that seems like extortion and coercion, well, let’s just say that law firms are businesses with strong incentives to survive.

Trump’s own butcherish henchman left no doubt about the consequences of resistance. “He’s going to put those law firms out of business,” said Steve Bannon. “What we are trying to do is put you out of business and bankrupt you.”

As the late Justice John Paul Stevens once observed, “disposing of lawyers is a step in the direction of a totalitarian form of government.”

And here we are.

Steven Lubet is the Williams Memorial Professor Emeritus at the Northwestern University Pritzker School of Law.

Topics

Trump executive order targets Chicago law firm Jenner & Block

President Donald Trump issued an executive order Tuesday targeting Chicago law firm Jenner & Block. The firm also has an office in Washington, D.C.
CBS News - 12h
Trump Targeting Law Firms Raises Constitutional Concerns

The way Trump targeted the firms could go against of the U.S. Constitution’s First Amendment.
Inc. - Mar. 9
Judge blocks 'unlawful' Trump order targeting Clinton 2016 law firm

A federal judge entered an emergency order barring the Trump administration from implementing parts of its executive order targeting the law firm Perkins Coie.
ABC News - Mar. 12
Law Firm Bends in Face of Trump Demands

Paul, Weiss — one of three law firms targeted by President Trump as part of his retribution campaign — said it resolved the conflict by agreeing to a range of commitments.
The New York Times - 5d
Trump signs order targeting law firm that employed Mueller team prosecutor

President Trump on Tuesday signed an order targeting a law firm that previously employed Andrew Weissman, a former federal prosecutor who worked on then-special counsel Robert Mueller’s team. The ...
The Hill - 17h
Legal community shaken by a powerful law firm's decision to give in to Trump's demands

President Donald Trump rescinded his executive order targeting Paul Weiss — after the law firm agreed to certain conditions.
NBC News - 4d
Law firms divided over response to Trump orders

The diverging paths taken by three law firms targeted by the Trump administration show a major divide over how the legal community is responding to a White House ratcheting up the pressure. The ...
The Hill - 1d
Trump rescinds order targeting Paul, Weiss citing commitments from law firm

President Trump on Thursday rescinded an executive order he signed less than a week ago targeting the Paul, Weiss law firm, citing an agreement with the firm that includes pro bono support for the ...
The Hill - 5d
Trump’s battle with Washington law firm Perkins Coie, explained

The battle between President Trump and a prominent Washington law firm has taken a new turn this week, as a judge intervenes to pause Trump’s actions. The controversy kicked off when Trump targeted ...
The Hill - Mar. 14
Trump pulls security clearance of Paul Weiss law firm

President Trump has continued his attack against prominent law firms, pulling the security clearances of attorneys at New York-based Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP (Paul Weiss), and ...
The Hill - Mar. 15
Trump suggests law firms 'want to make deals' after rescinding Paul, Weiss order

President Trump on Friday defended a series of executive actions he’s taken to target major law firms associated with individuals he holds grudges against, one day after one of those law firms ...
The Hill - 4d
Democracy Is on the Line in Israel and America

The rule of law is in danger in both America and Israel if some red lines are not drawn and defended.
The New York Times - Mar. 17
Law firm sues Trump administration after executive order targeting its attorneys

Perkins Coie has filed suit against the Trump administration over an executive order that targeted the firm for its work representing Clinton's 2016 campaign.
ABC News - Mar. 11
Attorney urges major law firm to resist Trump attacks in viral resignation letter

An attorney resigned from the law firm Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom, posting a sharply critical resignation letter that called on the company to stand up to President Trump' amid a ...
The Hill - 3d
Judge blocks parts of Trump executive order targeting law firm Perkins Coie

U.S. District Judge Beryl Howell issued a temporary restraining order that stops three parts of Trump's executive order from being implemented against the law firm Perkins Coie.
CBS News - Mar. 12
The Nonprofit Caught in the Fray of Trump’s Attacks on Big Law

A federal inquiry into D.E.I. practices at 20 law firms zeroed in on SEO, a decades-old program that helps students land jobs on Wall Street.
The New York Times - 4d
The Nonprofit Caught in the Fray of Trump’s Attacks on Big Law

A federal inquiry into D.E.I. practices at 20 law firms zeroed in on SEO, a decades-old program that helps students land jobs on Wall Street.
The New York Times - 4d
The Nonprofit Caught in the Fray of Trump’s Attacks on Big Law

A federal inquiry into D.E.I. practices at 20 law firms zeroed in on SEO, a decades-old program that helps students land jobs on Wall Street.
The New York Times - 4d
At Paul Weiss, Panic, Poachers and a Fight for the Bottom Line

Fears that competitors could take its top rainmaking talent added to the law firm’s worries about a Trump executive order that targeted it.
The New York Times - 3h
At Paul Weiss, Panic, Poachers and a Fight for the Bottom Line

Fears that competitors could take its top rainmaking talent added to the law firm’s worries about a Trump executive order that targeted it.
The New York Times - 3h
At Paul Weiss, Panic, Poachers and a Fight for the Bottom Line

Fears that competitors could take its top rainmaking talent added to the law firm’s worries about a Trump executive order that targeted it.
The New York Times - 3h
Trump’s Revenge on Law Firms Seen as Undermining Justice System

The president’s use of government power to punish firms is seen by some legal experts as undercutting a basic tenet: the right to a strong legal defense.
The New York Times - Mar. 12
Trump signs executive order targeting 3rd law firm

President Donald Trump signed an executive order suspending security clearances of Mark Pomerantz and those who work at Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison.
ABC News - Mar. 15
Equal Employment Opportunity Commission targets law firms over DEI practices

The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) has sent letters to 20 top law firms demanding information about their employment practices, a sign it plans to target their diversity, equity and ...
The Hill - Mar. 18
The law must not bend to Trump’s crusade of political retribution

Lawyers must not sit on the sidelines as firms and judges are attacked merely for doing their jobs.
The Hill - 6d
Trump rescinds order targeting law firm after it makes $40m promise

Paul, Weiss promised $40 million of free legal work to the White House and to change its diversity policies.
BBC News - 4d
Trump Signs Executive Order Targeting New Law Firm, Jenner & Block

An executive order underscored the extent to which the president, who faced four indictments after he left office, aims to exact a price from anyone associated with past investigations of him.
The New York Times - 10h
How a Major Democratic Law Firm Ended Up Bowing to Trump

Paul Weiss was targeted by an executive order from President Trump. Its chairman, who had worked against Mr. Trump during his first term, then went to the Oval Office and cut a deal.
The New York Times - 4d
Trump's law firm memo and wildfires burn in the Carolinas: Morning Rundown

Trump escalates assault on law firms. Wildfires burn in Carolinas. U.S., Russian renew Ukraine peace talks on tricky footing. Gen Z discovers millennial cringe.
NBC News - 2d
Trump’s Big Law crackdown sends chill through legal industry

Executive orders encompass firms’ diversity policies as well targeting those who acted for his opponents
Financial Times - Mar. 12
Paul Weiss Deal With Trump Faces Backlash From Legal Profession

Paul Weiss, a law firm targeted by President Trump, reached a deal to settle a conflict. Many in the legal field are condemning the agreement.
The New York Times - 3d
Trump instructs DOJ to sanction law firms over 'vexatious' litigation against government

President Trump instructed the Department of Justice (DOJ) on Friday to sanction attorneys and law firms if they engage in “frivolous, unreasonable and vexatious” litigation against the U.S. ...
The Hill - 3d
Sen. Lindsey Graham rebukes lawyers who defended Trump foes: "I hope they pay a price"

President Trump has targeted several law firms by terminating security clearances and other executive actions.
CBS News - Mar. 16
Trump widens war on legal industry with order targeting Jenner & Block

White House says law firm ‘abandoned the profession’s highest ideals’ and ‘condoned partisan lawfare’
Financial Times - 15h
Judge temporarily blocks parts of Trump order targeting Perkins Coie

A federal judge on Wednesday temporarily froze parts of President Trump’s executive order targeting the law firm Perkins Coie, which claims its past work for Democrats made it a subject of ...
The Hill - Mar. 12
‘The authoritarian playbook’: Trump targets judges, lawyers … and law itself

Attacks on key US institutions seek to stifle dissent, exact revenge and subordinate them to the president, experts say. Never miss global breaking news. Download our free app to keep up with key ...
The Guardian - 2d
Paul Weiss Chair Says Deal With Trump Adheres to Firm’s Principles

In an email message, the law firm’s chairman, Brad Karp, reassured employees that its deal with President Trump was in keeping with its principles.
The New York Times - 4d
Trump targets lawyers who he says file 'frivolous' lawsuits against his administration

A new memo from Trump authorizes the attorney general and the homeland security secretary to sanction law firms that file lawsuits they deem “frivolous."
NBC News - 2d
Trump, Big Law, and an “Existential Crisis”

The president’s clash with some of the nation’s biggest law firms appears to be far from over, potentially splintering the legal community even further.
The New York Times - 1d

More from The Hill

Trump is a defining issue at home and abroad

President Trump's actions have united Canadians against him, leading to a significant shift in support for the Liberal Party over the Conservative Party in the polls.
The Hill - 57m
Trump orders declassification of FBI’s Russia investigation

President Trump on Tuesday signed a memorandum directing the declassification of FBI files related to the investigation into his 2016 campaign's potential ties to Russia. The memorandum calls for ...
The Hill - 16h
In Trump versus the Constitution, Congress is backing the wrong side

We urgently need our courts and our elected officials, Democrats and Republicans, to reaffirm the checks and balances designed to prevent abuses of power by any president.
The Hill - 1d
Carville on Schumer CR vote: ‘This might turn out to be a wiser decision than people think’

Democratic strategist James Carville weighed in on Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer’s (N.Y.) decision to vote in favor of the House GOP-led continuing resolution, saying it might turn out to ...
The Hill - Mar. 18
Trump is reversing Nixon’s strategy to split China from Russia

The opening that Donald Trump sees is the one Richard Nixon saw half a century ago.
The Hill - 1h