Trump’s anti-DEI agenda generates wild hypocrisy at US universities

Last week, the Trump administration took unprecedented action against one of this nation’s premier educational institutions, canceling $400 million in federal grants and contracts to Columbia University.

Columbia is being penalized in the aftermath of its handling of responses to the October 7, 2023, terrorist attack on Israel and complaints about antisemitism on campus. Secretary of Education Linda McMahon explained, “Institutions that receive federal funds have a responsibility to protect all students from discrimination. Columbia’s apparent failure to uphold their end of this basic agreement raises very serious questions about the institution’s fitness to continue doing business with the United States government.”

But Columbia is not the only college or university attracting scrutiny from the administration. Last month, the administration opened investigations into allegations of antisemitism at five U.S. universities, including Columbia, Cal-Berkeley, the University of Minnesota, Northwestern and Portland State. It has now added more names to the list, including George Washington University, Harvard, Johns Hopkins, New York University, the UCLA, USC and Wellesley.

Although it has doubled down on its scrutiny of higher education, the White House is trumpeting its plans to scale back the government’s role in American life. On March 6, it criticized former President Biden for adding “nearly $2 trillion in new regulations over his four years in office” and highlighted that Trump “immediately blocked these proposed rules and has initiated an aggressive deregulatory agenda that requires substantial cuts in existing regulations for each new agency rule.”

But apparently, in his view, universities need more regulation, not less.

On Feb. 14, for example, the Department of Education’s Office of Civil Rights issued a “Dear Colleague” letter explaining its interpretation of the Supreme Court’s July 2023 decision ending affirmative action in college admissions decisions. “The law is clear: treating students differently on the basis of race to achieve nebulous goals such as diversity, racial balancing, social justice, or equity is illegal under controlling Supreme Court precedent.”

That letter entirely redefined “the nondiscrimination obligations of schools and other entities that receive federal financial assistance from the United States Department of Education” well beyond affirmative action, and “is an example of the kind of social engineering that conservatives and MAGA loyalists have long criticized.”

On Feb.19, the office issued an FAQ to clarify its letter, doubling down on some of its most expansive readings of the affirmative action decision. While acknowledging that “the facts of the case before the Supreme Court were specifically about racial preferences in university admissions,” it insisted that “the court applied broad reasoning to its decision, which has broad implications for race-based policies in education generally.”

In another less-noticed action designed to roll back anything associated with diversity, equity and inclusion, U.S. Attorney Edwin Martin wrote to the dean of the Georgetown University Law School last month noting that his institution "continues to teach and promote DEI. This is unacceptable.” He then informed the dean that no student from the law school would be considered for a position in his office as long as Georgetown “continues to teach and utilize DEI.”

The Washington Post reported, "It was not immediately clear why Martin, a devout Catholic and lawyer, apparently singled out Georgetown, the nation’s oldest Catholic and Jesuit university with a prestigious law school. But in previous public comments, Martin has cast the school as anti-Trump.”

The Georgetown dean responded with an aggressive First Amendment defense of the school’s right to teach its subjects without government interference. He told Martin, “Your letter challenges Georgetown’s ability to define our mission as an educational institution.”

Without adding more regulations to the Federal Register, the Trump administration is acting in unprecedented ways. The president has said that overregulation “discourages innovation and infringes on the liberties of American citizens.” This also should also apply to colleges and universities.

Austin Sarat is the William Nelson Cromwell Professor of Jurisprudence and Political Science at Amherst College.

Topics

Vance's mother-in-law pushed for DEI at her California university, CBS News finds

The Trump administration has been steadfast in its opposition to diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives. A CBS News investigation finds that those anti-DEI positions conflict with the work ...
CBS News - 20h
The US economy is heading for recession

Donald Trump’s policy agenda is sapping American animal spirits
Financial Times - 4d
Republicans fear time is running out to pass Trump’s agenda

House and Senate Republicans are sinking deeper into an impasse over how to advance President Donald Trump’s vast legislative agenda.
Politico - 11h
The US Army Is Using ‘CamoGPT’ to Purge DEI From Training Materials

Developed to boost productivity and operational readiness, the AI is now being used to “review” diversity, equity, inclusion, and accessibility policies to align them with President Trump’s orders.
Wired - Mar. 6
Trump’s ‘drill, baby, drill’ agenda could keep the world hooked on oil and gas

The US president is making energy deals with Japan and Ukraine, and in Africa has even touted resurrecting coal. Donald Trump ’s repeated mantra of “ drill, baby, drill ” demands that more oil and ...
The Guardian - 1d
‘Baby jails’ and first steps behind bars: Trump’s immigration agenda embraces family detention again

As the US ramps up enforcement, scenes of family separation and despair from Trump’s first term are repeated. The United States has resumed placing immigrant families in detention, re-embracing ...
The Guardian - 1d
How a reverse mortgage affects generational wealth

When used strategically, a reverse mortgage can support generational wealth while allowing you to age in place.
CBS News - 6h
Trump, With More Honey Than Vinegar, Cements an Iron Grip on Republicans

In his second term, President Trump is cultivating warm relationships with G.O.P. lawmakers — and using the implicit threat of ruining them if they stray — to keep them in line behind his agenda.
The New York Times - 2d
Lauren Boebert accused of racism and ableism over her criticism of Al Green

Republican faces backlash for saying Democrat shook ‘his pimp cane’ at Trump during congressional address. The extremist Republican US House member Lauren Boebert has been accused of racism, ...
The Guardian - 3d

More from The Hill

America is breaking its own maritime law — and China knows it

We have a legal obligation under the Merchant Marine Act to maintain sufficient maritime capacity for national defense and commerce.
The Hill - 43m
Oversight Democrats launch review of crypto reserve 'poised to enrich' Trump

House Oversight Democrats are encouraging President Trump to abandon his plans for a crypto reserve, calling it a strategy to enrich himself at taxpayer expense. The reserve, announced by Trump ...
The Hill - 43m
Putin says he's open to ceasefire, but wants to eliminate 'causes of this crisis'

Russian President Vladimir Putin said he is open to a 30-day ceasefire, as proposed by the U.S., but suggested vague terms for his support, including wanting to eliminate the root “causes of this ...
The Hill - 49m
Live updates: Trump meets with NATO leader; judge blasts effort to fire federal workers

The Senate must pass a short-term funding bill before the government shutdown, while the White House has pulled its nominee for the CDC and President Trump has threatened Europe with more tariffs ...
The Hill - 51m
Trump to meet NY gov over pipeline, congestion prices

President Trump said he will meet with New York Gov. Kathy Hochul (D) at the White House on Friday to discuss plans for an energy pipeline that would run through the Empire State. “The governor of ...
The Hill - 54m