Trump won't like what happens if Canada becomes our 51st state

President Trump wants to annex Canada and make it America’s 51st state. If he gets his way, here are just a few of the possible “unintended consequences.”

We currently have 50 states that divide up 435 congressional representatives. California, our largest state, has over 39 million people with 52 seats in the House of Representatives. Canada has 41 million people. If Canada were to become a state, Congress would have to add about 54 new House members to represent all those new American citizens. Canada would become one very powerful state.

If Congress doesn’t want to expand the size of the House, it will have to carve up all the other state delegations to give Canada the proportional representation it’s due. Without making the math too complicated, every state delegation except the seven that only have one representative would lose at least one representative, which would diminish those states’ power in Congress accordingly. Once again, Canada’s political power will overwhelm other state delegations.  

Congress could create new states out of Canada’s territories and provinces, which currently number 13. Such a move would still leave Canada with lots of House members, as well as up to 26 new senators.

Then there’s the problem of Canada’s security.

Canada is currently the world’s second largest country by land area, but it is not really that big a terrorist target. Maybe that’s because there aren’t that many people there or maybe it’s because Canadians are generally pleasant people and very accepting of immigrants. Whatever the reason, Canada currently doesn’t seem to be too high up on terrorist attack lists.

However, if Canada were to become part of the U.S., it also would become part of a much more attractive target. It is easy to see why Canada may be safer as it is.

Annexing Canada would be very costly. If Canada became our 51st state, America would have to fund the security of the second largest country by land area in the world. Even the 41 million new taxpayers living in Canada aren’t going to be able to pay for all the security that will be necessary to protect such a large and suddenly appealing target. Instead, other American taxpayers are going to have to contribute significantly to our new state’s defense and security needs. Given all the islands up there and the lengthy Atlantic and Pacific coastlines, that protection will be costly.

Annexing Canada also brings the issue of “socialized medicine” front and center. Many U.S. citizens condemn Canada’s successful national health care as socialized medicine. They believe it is no better than programs many MAGA Republicans have been condemning for years, such as Medicare, Medicaid and the Affordable Care Act (aka Obamacare), which they also label as “socialized.”

All those congressional representatives and senators from our new 51^st state who are happy and healthy under Canada’s health care system will very likely support continuing — and perhaps even expanding — America’s medical safety net. Americans who want to limit or end Medicare, Medicaid and the Affordable Care Act may do their cause considerable harm by adding Canadians to the voting population of the country and of Congress.

Annexing Canada becomes even more problematic when Canadians’ opinions are taken into consideration. Simply put, an overwhelming majority of them do not want to be part of the United States of America. Based on a recent YouGov poll, 73 percent or more Canadians across every sub-group oppose joining the United States.

Canada’s political leadership is also opposed. Former prime minister Stephen Harper said he would accept “any level of damage” to Canada’s economy in order to keep Canada independent: “I would be prepared to impoverish the country and not be annexed, if that was the option we’re facing.” Canada’s prime minister for the last 10 years, Justin Trudeau, replied to Trump’s proposal: “There’s not a snowball’s chance in hell that Canada will ever be the 51st state.” And Canada’s newly elected prime minister, Mark Carney, said, “We will never, in any shape or form, be part of the US.”

Canadian columnist Lorne Gunter makes the point that there is “no authoritative world body the U.S. could go to to approve its takeover of Canada. None exists.”

How would the U.S. do it then? Would we use our military? Given all the enemies and threats that currently exist, is it a good idea to have America transform a neighbor, friend and military ally into a combat foe? If the right set of very bad events takes place, it is entirely possible that the United States could face wars against Canada, Russia and China all at the same time. This is not good planning. Not to mention, if Trump’s trade war destroys Canada’s economy in an effort to get them to submit to annexation, our economy would experience significant damage too.

Bottom line, if Canada becomes a state, then it is a state with all the rights and needs every other state has, from significant congressional influence to opinionated protesters to security concerns and expensive natural disasters.  

Perhaps Trump should be careful what he wishes for.

Marie Aquila is a retired professor of history and social studies methods at Mercyhurst University. She is the author of “Movies as History: Scenes of America 1930-1970.”

Topics

Canada's new PM on Trump's 51st state talk: It's 'crazy'

New Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney shut down President Trump’s talk of Canada potentially becoming the U.S.’s 51st state, characterizing it as “crazy” and vowing the North American neighbor ...
The Hill - Mar. 14
Canadian reporters grill Rubio over Trump's 51st state talk

Secretary of State Marco Rubio on Friday faced pointed questions from Canadian journalists over the seriousness of President Trump’s calls for Canada to become the 51st state and the trade war with ...
The Hill - Mar. 14
White House says Canada would 'benefit greatly' from becoming 51st state

White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters that Canada would "benefit greatly" from becoming the 51st state as tensions continue over tariffs.
NBC News - Mar. 11
How Trump’s ‘51st State’ Canada Talk Came to Be Seen as Deadly Serious

President Trump, in an early February call, challenged the border treaty between the two countries and told Justin Trudeau he didn’t like their shared water agreements.
The New York Times - Mar. 7
Trump Intensifies ‘51st State’ Threats in Attack on Canada

The U.S. president on Tuesday reiterated his claims on Canada’s territory as he increased tariffs, threatening to bring the country’s economy to its knees.
The New York Times - Mar. 12
Trump keeps talking about making Canada the 51st state. Is he serious?

President Donald Trump continued to belittle Canada and threaten it with joining the United States as the economic war with the country continued.
ABC News - Mar. 13
Canadian ambassador to US on Trump's 51st state remarks: 'We take seriously our sovereignty'

Kirsten Hillman, Canadian ambassador to the U.S., said on Sunday that her country takes its sovereignty “seriously” as President Trump appears to be holding firm in his ambitions to make Canada the ...
The Hill - Mar. 16
Rubio says Canada takeover won't be on G7 agenda

Secretary of State Marco Rubio said that talk about the U.S. acquiring Canada will not be a topic of discussion when the Group of Seven (G7) nations meet in Quebec. Asked about President Trump's ...
The Hill - Mar. 12
Trump looms over Canada's election as campaign begins

The country will vote on 28 April as President Trump wages a trade war and says he wants to make Canada the 51st US state.
BBC News - 1d
How Trump's threats have revived Canada's Liberal Party

Justin Trudeau's party was headed for near-certain defeat - until the US president said he wanted to make Canada the 51st state.
BBC News - Mar. 9
The impact on US elections if Canada and Greenland were states

If Canada and Greenland were to become states, Democrats would likely gain a significant advantage in both the House of Representatives and the Senate, as Canadians strongly oppose the idea of ...
The Hill - Mar. 18
Mark Carney, Canada's next prime minister, pledges to take on Trump

Canada's next prime minister, former central banker Mark Carney, is pledging to take on President Trump as the president imposes tariffs and threatens to turn the country into the 51st state. CBS ...
CBS News - Mar. 10
Lutnick: Canada becoming US state 'best way' to merge economies

Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said Wednesday that Canada becoming a U.S. state is the “best way” to merge the two countries’ economies. “The best way, the president has said it, the best way to ...
The Hill - Mar. 12
'See you in four years': Canada flexes economic muscle as tariff negotiations continue

Trump's plans for tariffs and comments about Canada becoming a state has enraged the country's consumers and politicians.
CNBC - Mar. 17
Canada can win trade war with US, foreign affairs minister Mélanie Joly says

Canada is among the countries waiting to see what Trump's 2 April reciprocal tariffs look like.
BBC News - 1d
Rubio Says a Cease-Fire in Ukraine Could Happen in ‘Days’ if Russia Agrees

Secretary of State Marco Rubio said top diplomats from the Group of 7 allies meeting in Canada should focus on ending the war. And he shrugged off President Trump’s threats to annex Canada.
The New York Times - Mar. 13
Trump doubles tariffs on Canadian steel and aluminum; floats 51st state again

Trump adds another 25% to tariff on Canadian steel and aluminum as the trade war between the countries continues to escalate.
ABC News - Mar. 11
Trump's ambassador pick says "Canada is a sovereign state"

"Canada is a sovereign state, yes," Pete Hoekstra said during his confirmation hearing Thursday.
CBS News - Mar. 13
What state football playoffs will look like in new eight-classification NCHSAA

The NCHSAA has given a glimpse of what the state football playoffs will look like with expansion from four to eight classifications in 2025.
Yahoo Sports - 42m
'What's in it for me' has gone too far, and Trump and Musk make it worse

The fixation on personal liberty over the interest of others has become a bedrock of our society and exacts a great price on our communities and all of us.
The Hill - 6d
Mark Carney Becomes Canada’s Prime Minister at Crucial Moment

Mark Carney, a central banker turned politician, steps into his role at a crucial moment as President Trump sets his sights on Canada’s sovereignty and keeps threatening more tariffs.
The New York Times - Mar. 14
'America is not Canada,' new Prime Minister Mark Carney says in rebuke to Trump

President Donald Trump since his second White House term began has said Canada, Greenland and the Panama Canal should become U.S. property.
CNBC - Mar. 14
Judge incredulous in Trump deportation case as administration lawyers argue verbal court order isn’t binding – as it happened

This blog has now closed. You can read more of our US politics coverage here . White House denies violating judge’s order with Venezuela deportations What is the Alien Enemies Act and how is ...
The Guardian - Mar. 18
What Happens When a Hub Like Heathrow Shuts Down

Lots of people need to secure hotel rooms and new travel plans.
The New York Times - 4d
What Trump wants from Zelenskyy and Canada's new leader: Morning Rundown

Trump wants Zelenskyy to change his attitude. Who is Amy Gleason, the new DOGE administrator? DHS performs polygraph test on staff. Canada's new PM Mark Carney.
NBC News - Mar. 10
Canada Gets a New Leader Amid Trump’s Trade War

Mark Carney, Canada’s incoming prime minister, is no stranger to crises. Now he faces what is arguably the challenge of a lifetime: President Trump. Matina Stevis-Gridneff, the Canada bureau chief ...
The New York Times - Mar. 14
State and local tax deduction could change amid Trump's tax cuts debate. Here's what to know.

As lawmakers debate President Donald Trump’s tax cuts, a key deduction could become a sticking point in 2025 tax negotiations, policy experts say.
NBC News - Mar. 13
‘This Is Worse’: Trump’s Judicial Defiance Veers Beyond the Autocrat Playbook

The president’s escalating conflict with federal courts is even more aggressive than what happened in countries like Hungary and Turkey, experts say.
The New York Times - 4d
Mark Carney: 'Canada never, ever, will be part of America'

Canada’s incoming prime minister, Mark Carney, is pledging to continue Justin Trudeau's legacy of standing up to President Trump and rejecting threats to make the nation part of the U.S. “The ...
The Hill - Mar. 10
There’s only one thing in Mark Carney’s in-tray: Trump

Canada’s incoming prime minister warns the US president’s tariffs threaten the ‘greatest crisis of our generation’. When Mark Carney becomes Canada’s prime minister later this week, a list of ...
The Guardian - Mar. 10
Challenged by Trump, Trudeau Rallies Canada as He Leaves Office

After nearly a decade in power, Justin Trudeau steps down on Friday as prime minister amid a trade war and President Trump’s stated desire to annex Canada.
The New York Times - Mar. 14
Mahmoud Khalil’s treatment should not happen in a democracy | Moustafa Bayoumi

The Columbia University graduate’s arrest is an attempt to destroy free thinking while murdering due process. Forced disappearance, kidnapping, political imprisonment – take your pick. These terms ...
The Guardian - Mar. 11
Canada, May I Introduce You to Ukraine?

We already know what happens when great powers feel entitled to their zones of control, and the strong try to dominate the weak.
The New York Times - 2d
What could happen to your student loans without the Education Department

President Trump may sign an executive order aimed at dismantling the Education Department. What does it mean for the 40 million Americans with student loans?
CNBC - 4d
Mark Carney Will Be Canada’s Next Prime Minister. Here’s What to Know.

Mark Carney, a former central banker, now heads the Liberal Party and will soon lead Canada, tasked with responding to President Trump’s threats.
The New York Times - Mar. 10
What happens to gift cards when a chain like Forever 21 or Joann closes stores? Here’s what shoppers can do.

Fabrics giant Joann is closing, and the store has stopped taking gift cards — upsetting many customers. Here’s what shoppers should know.
MarketWatch - 6d
Menaced by Trump, Canada Prepares to Join E.U. Military Industry Efforts

Canada’s draft deal to participate in Europe’s defense industry will bring contracts to Canadian manufacturers and help lessen dependence on the United States.
The New York Times - 5d
Canada should call Trump’s bluff and drop all of its tariffs

Canada could win a trade war with the United States in a counterintuitive way, with a bit of political jiu-jitsu.
The Hill - 5d
It Isn’t Just Trump. America’s Whole Reputation Is Shot.

What happens when a superpower goes rogue.
The New York Times - Mar. 13