Trump voters are starting to get burned by DOGE’s chainsaw

At some point, you have to stop feeling bad for people who repeatedly stick their hand in the fire and act shocked when it burns. Come on, folks — how many times do you need to touch a stove before you realize it’s hot?

Take Bradley Bartell, a Wisconsin man who voted for Trump in 2024 and is now devastated because ICE has detained and may deport his Peruvian wife. He “knew they were cracking down,” he says. “I guess I didn’t know how it was going down.”

Really, Bradley? You voted for the guy who said he was going to round up immigrants, but somehow you didn’t get the memo?

Then there’s David Pasquino, a vet who worked for Veterans Affairs until Trump’s so-called “efficiency” cuts came around. Now he’s complaining about the “chainsaw” they used instead of a “scalpel.” Now, he feels “betrayed.”

Did you think being a veteran would save you from the guy who refers to fallen service members as “losers” and “suckers,” David?

And Jennifer Piggott, who proudly flew a Trump campaign flag outside her home, was abruptly fired from her job at the Treasury Department’s Bureau of Fiscal Service in Parkersburg, West Virginia. “I feel a little bit betrayed,” she told Reuters.

These aren’t isolated incidents. This is a self-inflicted catastrophe. That same anger is also appearing in town hall meetings held by Republican members of Congress — at least the ones who still dare to hold such events.

For those of us who spent years waving red flags, the temptation is to yell, “Told ya so!”

Now, don’t get me wrong. Reveling in someone else’s misery is, at best, bad form. No decent person wants to rub salt in the wounds of someone who just lost their job (to DOGE), their farm (Trump’s tariffs are not doing farmers any favors) or their spouse (to deportation). It’s ugly.

But what are we supposed to do when people repeatedly ignore every warning and only wake up when they’ve been slammed in the face with the consequences? Are we supposed to act like it wasn’t obvious? Are we supposed to feel bad that reality is turning their nice, shiny fantasies into a dumpster fire?

Sure, there’s a certain karmic justice in all of this. But karma makes for a terrible political strategy. Because, as much as it might seem like these personal reckonings should spark some soul-searching, that’s not how the real world works.

People don’t typically experience hardship and say, “Wow, I miscalculated.” Instead, they think, “This isn’t fair. This isn’t supposed to happen to me.”

And then they seek out an external villain — the “deep state,” immigrants, the media, you name it. Admitting you were wrong is more difficult than doubling down.

So here’s the question: Will these personal wake-up calls matter? Will they make people take a long, hard look in the mirror and realize they were duped by Trump? The short answer is: It depends.

The hardcore Trump base won’t abandon ship just because prices didn’t come down and their brother-in-law lost his government job. They’ve stuck with Trump through every storm and are in it for the long haul.

But let’s not forget, Trump didn’t win 77 million votes just from his base. He also tapped into support from Americans who were fed up with the system. Economic issues like inflation and general frustration with the Biden administration helped fuel his rise. Latino men, young people and casual “low information” voters — people who have rarely leaned toward Republicans — decided to take a chance on him.

These are the folks who figured, “What the heck, maybe he’ll fix things.” Now, they’re the ones getting hit the hardest and possibly regretting their decision.

As buyer’s remorse starts to spread, it’s like watching a slow-motion trainwreck. As Nate Silver and Eli McKown-Dawson pointed out, Trump’s approval rating is dropping. He is now 5 points underwater, with 47 percent approval and 52 percent disapproval.

While Trump is losing support among some of his voters, he is unlikely to lose all of it in today’s polarized world — especially with media bubbles filtering out inconvenient news and views.

A February Vanderbilt poll shows that 52 percent of Republicans now align more with MAGA than the traditional GOP, an increase from June 2023. However, most non-MAGA Republicans will also stand by their man, no matter what he says or does.

The real shift may come from “soft” supporters — those who joined Trump’s movement in 2024. These are the folks who might abandon ship if Trump keeps starting fires that scorch them too.

The question isn’t whether Trump will lose his base. He won’t; that’s a given. It’s whether enough of those fair-weather voters, the ones who thought they could just kick back and enjoy the show, will wake up.

But don’t hold your breath. Some people still refuse to learn — even after they get burned. Because, really, what did you expect?

Matt K. Lewis is a columnist, podcaster and author of the books “Too Dumb to Fail” and “Filthy Rich Politicians.”

Topics

Here's the biggest news you missed this weekend

Voters wary about the economy, DOGE and Democrats President Donald Trump’s election to a second term sparked an upswing in positive feelings about the direction of the nation, but voters are ...
NBC News - 2d
Gov't expert on Musk, DOGE's "slash-and-burn exercise"

In the opening weeks of the Trump administration, drama has been in high gear, thanks in part to Trump campaign funder and government disrupter Elon Musk, who has moved to quickly eliminate ...
CBS News - 3d
60 percent of voters unhappy with DOGE handling of federal workers: Poll

A majority of voters are unhappy with the Department of Government Efficiency’s (DOGE) handling of federal workers, according to a new poll. When asked about “the way Elon Musk and DOGE are dealing ...
The Hill - 5d
Government expert on Elon Musk and DOGE's "slash-and-burn exercise"

Trump campaign funder and government disrupter Elon Musk has used unprecedented power to quickly eliminate thousands of federal jobs and shutter entire programs and agencies, using tactics that ...
CBS News - 3d
Trump Looms Over Greenland’s Election, but Voters Have Other Concerns

President Trump keeps saying he wants to “get” Greenland. On Tuesday, Greenland votes for a new parliament that could shape its future relations with the United States.
The New York Times - Mar. 10
Poll: Voters like the idea of DOGE, but Elon Musk and his early results raise red flags

Voters are open, narrowly, to an effort to tackle inefficiencies in government.
NBC News - 3d
Steve Kornacki: Voters sour on Trump’s handling of the economy in NBC News poll

A new NBC News poll shows President Donald Trump with a job approval rating as high as he’s ever had. But doubts loom in voters’ minds, especially over the economy and government cuts, NBC News ...
NBC News - 3d
Why Social Security’s Future Could Be in DOGE’s Hands

Trump promised that Elon Musk’s DOGE wouldn’t touch Social Security. But DOGE is already making cuts to the agency.
Inc. - Mar. 9
These Trump Voters Say They Feel Deceived

And how unchecked innovation enabled the ruse.
Inc. - Mar. 12
DOGE Could Substantially Increase Wait Times for Patents and Trademarks

The already lengthy backlog is getting much longer. If the agency downsizes through DOGE, that could get worse.
Inc. - 3d
Hundreds of federal offices to start to empty this summer due to DOGE cuts: AP

Federal agencies will begin to vacate hundreds of offices nationwide this summer under a frenetic and error-prone push by DOGE to scrap leases it says waste money.
CBS News - 5d
Voters boo Nebraska Republican over Musk, Ukraine, Trump tariffs during raucous town hall

Rep. Mike Flood’s (R-Neb.) town hall turned raucous Tuesday night as he fielded questions from voters about Elon Musk, President Trump’s tariffs, the White House’s posture towards Ukraine and more, ...
The Hill - 15h
Chainsaws, coffeemakers, gum: How the E.U. is targeting U.S. products with retaliatory tariffs

The European Union is planning new tariffs on a wide range of U.S. imports next month in response to President Donald Trump’s new taxes on imported aluminum and steel that went into effect Wednesday.
MarketWatch - Mar. 12
Get out, get back, get real: What inspectors general should learn from DOGE

DOGE, created with a focus on efficiency and waste reduction, has identified $105 billion in taxpayer savings, and IGs should consider reforming their practices to include separate headquarters and ...
The Hill - 6d
Poll: Trump faces early challenges on the economy as a united GOP backs big change

Voters are starting 2025 sour on the state of the economy and President Donald Trump’s handling of it so far, even as his election to a second term sparked an upswing in positive feelings about the ...
NBC News - 3d
Browns: Kenny Pickett to get a fair shot to win starting QB gig

After coming to the Browns from the Eagles, Kenny Pickett is going to get a fair shot to win the starting QB job in Cleveland
Yahoo Sports - 5d
Trump defends Elon Musk, DOGE cuts to federal workforce

President Trump defended Elon Musk and DOGE over the weekend after reported rifts between Musk and Cabinet members. CBS News White House reporter Olivia Rinaldi has more.
CBS News - Mar. 10
Karl Rove: Trump claims of DOGE 'fraud' discoveries will backfire

Republican strategist Karl Rove said President Trump’s claims that the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) has discovered “hundreds of billions” in government “fraud” will backfire when ...
The Hill - Mar. 10
The Nigel Farage v Rupert Lowe prize fight is getting ugly. Has Reform reached its breaking point? | Marina Hyde

It’s great for those who enjoy a punch-up on the right, but as the zealots duke it out, think of the voters who trusted them. How soon before one of Reform’s MPs starts touting himself as the ...
The Guardian - Mar. 11
How DOGE is already changing the spending process in Congress

The Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) has done significant work in exposing wasteful government programs, but this has created a difficult situation for the Trump administration as they ...
The Hill - Mar. 12
DOGE chief Elon Musk says he's running businesses 'with great difficulty' as Tesla shares tank

The Tesla CEO Musk said he expected to realize $1 trillion in government savings for the Trump administration as part of the DOGE project.
CNBC - Mar. 11
Musk outlines DOGE work in rare TV interview

Tech billionaire Elon Musk offered new details about the work of President Trump’s Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) on Monday, while doubling down on the group’s efforts amid mounting ...
The Hill - Mar. 10
Trump administration briefing: judge incredulous at deportations defense; Doge workers break into building

White House denies violating judge’s order with Venezuela flights; Elon Musk’s Doge workers break into non-government agency – key US politics stories from Monday at a glance. The Trump ...
The Guardian - 1d
Howe to get Freedom of Newcastle and club announces date of trophy parade

League Cup celebrations continue, with Blyth's Dan Burn nominated for the Freedom of Northumberland.
BBC News - 1d
DOGE likely subject to open records law, judge rules

The Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) is likely covered under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA), a federal judge ruled late Monday, rejecting the Trump administration’s position that ...
The Hill - Mar. 11
Vance: Musk has made some ‘mistakes’ with DOGE’s federal worker firings

Vice President Vance said during an interview that senior President Trump adviser Elon Musk has made some “mistakes” with the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) firings of federal ...
The Hill - 4d
Bannon says Musk deploying DOGE 'shock troops': 'Not pretty,' but 'pretty effective'

Former Trump adviser Steve Bannon has acknowledged that Elon Musk's "shock troops" in the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) are making progress in reshaping the government, despite his ...
The Hill - 2h
Warned Off Meeting Voters, Republicans Who Do Confront Anger and Unease

In a deeply conservative district and a more liberal one, two Republicans found uncertainty and anxiety about the Trump administration’s agenda and their support of it.
The New York Times - 1d
Trump and DOGE Create Anxiety but Opportunity for Federal Contractors

By cutting federal employees, the Trump administration may increase its reliance on firms that take in billions through government contracts.
The New York Times - 4d
How Trump Is Helping Liberals Abroad

Voters are rallying behind some leaders who oppose President Trump’s tariffs, threats and insults. There’s a theory that explains why.
The New York Times - 6d
Poll: As Trump and courts clash, voters weigh whether each branch of government has too much power

As a federal judge presses President Donald Trump's administration over whether it violated an order halting deportations, in a growing clash between the presidency and the judicial branch, more ...
NBC News - 9h
Democratic Party hits new polling low, while its voters want to fight Trump harder

The Democratic Party has reached an all-time low in popularity in the latest national NBC News poll, as it searches for a path forward after a painful loss to President Donald Trump — and as the ...
NBC News - 3d
What to watch as inaugural TGL postseason gets underway

The top-seeded Los Angeles Golf Club gets the playoff started Monday against New York Golf Club.
ESPN - 1d
Musk having ‘great difficulty’ running businesses amid DOGE obligations, Tesla stock slide

Tech billionaire Elon Musk admitted he is having “great difficulty” running his various businesses as he juggles an advisory role in the Trump administration and leads the Department of Government ...
The Hill - Mar. 11
The Key Reason Trump’s Poll Numbers Are Sagging

A central mystery of Trump’s presidency is whether his actions are in step with what voters want or whether he is going rogue on America.
The New York Times - 1d
Fired Federal Workers Get Last Words in With Scathing Letters of Resignation to DOGE

Departing officials, including disabled veterans, defend themselves and thousands of fired federal colleagues’ work with defiant, indignant letters, creating a written record of a tumultuous time.
Inc. - Mar. 10
'Grief made me start hoarding - I slept in bed stacked with boxes'

Jayne started to hoard to cope with the grief after her husband died, now she's getting help.
BBC News - Mar. 10
60 percent oppose Trump plan to close Education Department: Survey

A majority of voters are against President Trump’s plans to close the Education Department, according to a new poll from Quinnipiac University. The survey released Thursday found 60 percent of ...
The Hill - 5d
Why Trump's rapidly changing economic policies are raising stagflation alarms

If there was one thing President Donald Trump was supposed to represent to many voters, it was the prospect of an upturn in their economic fortunes.
NBC News - Mar. 11