Trump team rejects Bragg's 'Dark Dream Scenario' for hush money case

President-elect Trump’s attorneys condemned Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg’s (D) suggested alternatives to dismissing Trump’s hush money criminal conviction, going as far to call one of them “unhinged” and “absurd” Friday.

It remains unclear if New York Judge Juan Merchan will consider the new filing, as he previously wrote he would only accept one written brief from each side. It is currently up to the judge to determine how to proceed in the case.

With his return to the White House imminent, Trump has argued the court is compelled to wipe the jury’s verdict finding him guilty of 34 felonies and dismiss the case in its entirety. Bragg pushed back in a filing earlier this week, instead suggesting the judge could freeze the case or make other accommodations that would keep the jury’s guilty verdict intact.

"DA Bragg’s interest in maintaining the jury’s verdicts as a notch in whatever belt he plans to wear to campaign events in 2025 is not a basis for interfering with the Executive Branch,” Trump attorneys Todd Blanche and Emil Bove replied Friday, referencing that Bragg is up for reelection next year.

The attorneys, whom Trump has nominated to senior Justice Department roles in his next administration, in particular condemned Bragg’s alternative suggestion that the judge could treat the case as if Trump had died.

In that scenario, the court would terminate the proceedings after updating the case file to note the verdict removed the presumption of innocence, Trump was never sentenced and that his conviction was neither affirmed nor reversed on appeal.

Blanche and Bove called the district attorney’s office’s (DANY) proposal “unhinged,” “absurd” and a “Dark Dream Scenario.”

“As a further illustration of DA Bragg’s desperation to avoid legally mandated dismissal, DANY proposes that the Court pretend as if one of the assassination attempts against President Trump had been successful,” they wrote.

Trump’s lawyers also invoked Sen. John Fetterman’s (D-Pa.) suggestion this week that Trump deserves a pardon and that the case was “weaponizing the judiciary,” saying the Democratic senator’s summary “is apt.”

The New York jury convicted Trump this spring on 34 counts of falsifying business records stemming from a 2016 hush money payment to porn actor Stormy Daniels to stay quiet about an alleged affair with Trump — who denies the affair and any wrongdoing related to the payment — during his campaign. Prosecutors accused Trump of illegally concealing the payment with the intent to unlawfully influence that year’s election.

Following last month's election, Trump’s legal team has looked to toss the case and his three other criminal indictments that hadn’t reached trial, insisting his status as president-elect provides him the same protections as a sitting president against criminal prosecution.

Special counsel Jack Smith agreed to dismiss his two federal indictments of Trump on election interference and documents charges, and Trump has meanwhile asked courts in Georgia to do the same in his state election interference case.

Topics

Trump's lawyers, seeking to dismiss hush money case, slam DA for 'thuggish tactics'

The only path forward in Donald Trump's hush money case is vacating his conviction and dismissing the case, lawyers for Trump argued in a court filing Friday.
ABC News - 6h
Manhattan DA suggests non-prison sentence for Trump in hush money case

Donald Trump's sentencing in his hush money case could be delayed until he leaves office, rather than the case being dismissed outright, prosecutors argued in a filing.
ABC News - 3d
New York prosecutors say Trump's conviction in "hush money" case should stand

Manhattan prosecutors say Donald Trump's election in November shouldn't mean his conviction in May needs to be vacated.
CBS News - 3d
Bragg lays out alternatives to dismissing Trump's hush money conviction

Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg’s (D) office opposes dismissing President-elect Trump’s hush money charges but would accept halting the proceedings while he is in office, according to court ...
The Hill - 3d
Prosecutors fight Trump’s latest push to dismiss criminal hush-money case

Prosecutors file paperwork and argue that Trump’s position as president-elect does not grant him legal protection. Manhattan prosecutors filed paperwork to fight Donald Trump ’s most recent push ...
The Guardian - 3d
Citing Hunter Biden pardon, Trump asks judge to dismiss his criminal hush money case

Donald Trump's criminal hush money case should be dismissed because it "threatens the functioning" of the U.S. government, Trump's attorneys argue in a new filing.
ABC News - Dec. 4
Trump attorneys urge judge to dismiss hush money case citing Hunter Biden pardon

NBC News’ Vaughn Hillyard reports on President-elect Trump’s legal team urging Judge Juan Merchan to dismiss the New York City hush money case citing Hunter Biden’s pardon.
NBC News - Dec. 4
Trump cites Hunter Biden pardon in request to dismiss hush-money case

Lawyers file paperwork to formally request dismissal after judge in November put sentencing on hold indefinitely. Donald Trump ’s lawyers have filed paperwork pushing for dismissal of his ...
The Guardian - Dec. 3
Trump urges judge to toss hush money case, citing Hunter Biden pardon

Lawyers for President-elect Donald Trump urged the judge who presided over his conviction for falsifying business records to dismiss the indictment against him, citing the language President Joe ...
NBC News - Dec. 3