Trump judges split over handling 2024 bid inside courtroom
Two high-profile judges overseeing a pair of former President Trump’s criminal cases are taking dueling approaches on how to handle their roles ahead of the 2024 presidential election.
U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan, who oversees Trump’s federal election subversion prosecution in the nation’s capital, has remained steadfast that she won’t consider the election.
“This court is not concerned with the electoral schedule,” Chutkan proclaimed at a hearing last week, adding it’s “nothing I’m going to consider."
But the next day, New York Supreme Court acting Justice Juan Merchan, who oversaw Trump’s hush money trial, agreed to delay the sentencing until after November’s election, explicitly tying it to the contest.
The judge wrote that his decision was intended “to avoid any appearance — however unwarranted — that the proceeding has been affected by or seeks to affect the approaching Presidential election in which the Defendant is a candidate.”
Whether the GOP nominee’s bid to return to the White House should take precedence over the timelines of his criminal cases has always loomed over the historic prosecutions.
Trump’s attorneys have said the cases’ steady schedules hamper the former president’s campaign, a violation of his and voters’ rights. Prosecutors, however, contend that slow walking the cases is just as detrimental.
The striking contrast between the two judges shows how they are grappling with decisions involving the Republican nominee for the White House also being a defendant in their courtrooms as a high-stakes, deadlocked election looms.
“Judge Merchan is overseeing a case where the only thing left is sentencing, and there are questions about sentencing a presidential candidate eight weeks before a presidential election,” said Loyola Marymount University law professor Jessica Levinson. “For Judge Chutkan, she's overseeing a case that's in a completely different place.”
Trump has long employed delay as a legal strategy to defend against his criminal prosecutions. If he retakes the White House in this year’s elections, legal experts expect he will be able to grind all four of his indictments to a halt.
“Donald Trump has already postponed accountability for conduct of which a jury of his peers found him guilty 34 times that began in 2015, almost 10 years ago,” said Norm Eisen, counsel for Democrats in Trump’s first impeachment.
“Adding additional delays here has dishonored the service of those jurors and makes a mockery of the justice system by demonstrating that it can be manipulated by the wealthy and the powerful when ordinary people, particularly the typical defendant, can expect no such special treatment,” Eisen said.
With less than two months until Election Day, the strategy has borne fruit.
Three of Trump’s four criminal prosecutions are tied up in pretrial issues until well after the election.
In the only case that reached trial, Trump’s hush money prosecution, it had seemed the former president was destined for a preelection sentencing. Moments after the jury handed up its guilty verdict, Trump’s lawyers requested the judge announce Trump’s punishment in July.
Things soon changed. Less than two weeks prior to Trump’s original sentencing, the Supreme Court carved out broad immunity for former presidents’ official conduct, casting doubt as to whether the conviction can stand.
Merchan quickly punted the sentencing — and his ruling on immunity — to September, still keeping it before the election.
But soon enough, Trump demanded another delay. After sitting on the request for much longer, the judge ultimately acquiesced and moved it to Nov. 26.
“The Court is a fair, impartial, and apolitical institution,” Merchan wrote in his ruling. “Adjourning decision on the motion and sentencing, if such is required, should dispel any suggestion that the Court will have issued any decision or imposed sentence either to give an advantage to, or to create a disadvantage for, any political party and for any candidate for any office.”
Prosecutors in the case did not oppose either delay, but some legal observers have critiqued Merchan for tying his reasoning to the election.
“I think Trump may have just worn him down a little bit,” said Eisen, who attended the trial.
“Whatever the explanation, he's a good judge. He's a decent person. He tries to do the right thing, and I know he made this decision in good faith. But it's a bad decision,” Eisen added.
Levinson contended Merchan has been lodged between the “proverbial rock and a hard place" with the discretion as Trump’s judge to determine whether moving forward with his sentencing would be in the interest of justice.
“He decided that delaying the sentencing until after the election was in the interest of justice,” she said. “There are competing issues on both sides of the scale, and he weighed them in a certain direction.”
Chutkan, meanwhile, has made discussion of the election taboo in her courtroom in Washington.
At the hearing last week, she jumped at the first hint of hidden campaign subtext, swiveling her chair and letting out an “oh” when she believed Trump’s lawyer began creeping up to the subject.
Chutkan insisted the election was “not going to be a factor” in her decisionmaking about Trump’s case.
“I am definitely not getting drawn into an election,” she said.
But the judge might not have a choice.
If Trump wins the White House in November, it’s expected that his Justice Department would move to dismiss his four-count indictment in the election subversion case. If he loses, his pretrial schedule will likely proceed as planned.
The uncertainty made setting a trial date an “exercise in futility,” Chutkan said, and both parties agreed.
“It has to kind of go both ways," Levinson said. “If you're treating this criminal defendant the same as you’d treat any criminal defendant, then it doesn't matter that this happens to be one of the two people in the entire United States who might, in a few months, have the power to tell an attorney general to stop a criminal case.”
Date: | |
Tag: | Donald Trump |
-
CNBC - Business
Judge rules Trump Media breached stock contract with early investor
Donald Trump will soon be free to start selling his DJT shares, but the Republican presidential nominee recently said he will not do so.1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
NBC News - Top stories
Judge rules Trump Media breached stock contract with early investor
Trump Media breached an agreement with one of the investors that helped the company go public, and must grant the investor a larger share of its stock, a judge ruled.26 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Inc. - Business
Closed Nevada Courtroom Hosts Murdoch Succession Drama
News Corp. patriarch Rupert Murdoch, 93, wants to ensure eldest son Lachlan gets control of family trust, which has major stakes inFox News parent Fox and theWall Street Journal.3 hours ago -
MarketWatch - Business
Deckers stock split takes hold and shares slip
Shares of Ugg and Hoka parent Deckers Outdoor Corp. are down Tuesday after the shoe company’s six-for-one stock split took hold.5 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
Harris holds 6-point national lead over Trump in postdebate polling
Vice President Harris is leading former President Trump nationally by 6 points, according to a polling released a week after the first debate between the major party nominees. The Morning Consult ...8 hours ago - Donald Trump -
ESPN - Sports
Chiles takes bid for bronze medal to Swiss court
American gymnast Jordan Chiles is asking Switzerland's Supreme Court to overturn a ruling that stripped her of a bronze medal in the floor exercise.15 hours ago -
Yahoo Sports - Sports
Yoshinobu Yamamoto bends but doesn't break as Dodgers split series versus Braves
Yoshinobu Yamamoto finds a way to get out of multiple jams and Freddie Freeman hits a three-run home run to lead the Dodgers to a 9-0 win over the Braves.18 hours ago - MLB -
CBS News - Top stories
Jordan Chiles takes bid to reclaim Olympic bronze to Swiss Supreme Court
American gymnast Jordan Chiles is asking Switzerland's Supreme Court to overturn a ruling by the Court of Arbitration for Sport that stripped her of a bronze medal at the 2024 Olympics.19 hours ago - Olympics -
CBS News - Top stories
Israeli official offers safe passage to Hamas leader in bid to end war
Israeli airstrikes killed 16 people Monday, that included a strike on a refugee camp in central Gaza. Israel also faces international pressure to reach a hostage and cease-fire deal with Hamas. CBS ...20 hours ago - Israel
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Secret Service tells Trump it needs to bolster security for him to safely golf
The head of the Secret Service told former President Trump in the wake of a second potential assassination attempt that the agency would need to bolster security for his future golf outings, an ...30 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Rep. Horsford introduces bill to eliminate taxes on tips
Rep. Steven Horsford (D-Nev.) has introduced the Tipped Income Protection and Support (TIPS) Act to eliminate federal taxes on tips and subminimum wages for tipped workers.35 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
McConnell: Government shutdown before election 'politically beyond stupid'
Senate Republican Leader Mitch McConnell (Ky.) is warning colleagues that it would be “politically beyond stupid” for Congress to stumble into a government shutdown a few weeks before Election Day, ...39 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Republicans block Senate Democrats' IVF bill
Republicans on Tuesday blocked a bill that would have created a right to access in vitro fertilization (IVF) treatments and mandated that insurance plans cover the practice, deriding the vote as a ...45 minutes ago - Republican Party -
The Hill - Politics
Hillary Clinton: Trump counting on Americans becoming 'desensitized' to 'outrageous' claims
Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, the 2016 Democratic nominee for president, says former President Trump is counting on Americans to become “desensitized” to his “outrageous” falsehoods. ...46 minutes ago - Donald Trump