Trump is pondering a shake-up of NASA and its programs
The first major space decision undertaken by the incoming second Donald Trump administration was to pick billionaire entrepreneur and private space traveler Jared Isaacman as NASA administrator.
According to Ars Technica, a five-person committee within the Trump transition team is mulling over policy suggestions that represent major changes to the way the space agency operates.
The policy changes being contemplated include:
- Establishing the goal of sending humans to the moon and Mars, by 2028;
- Canceling the costly Space Launch System rocket and possibly the Orion spacecraft;
- Consolidating Goddard Space Flight Center and Ames Research Center at Marshall Space Flight Center in Alabama;
- Retaining a small administration presence in Washington, D.C., but otherwise moving headquarters to a field center, and
- Rapidly redesigning the Artemis lunar program to make it more efficient.
The ideas are breathtaking in their scope and boldness. However, some of them are likely to run into political headwinds should they be undertaken, either as executive orders or legislation.
The most politically difficult would be closing down NASA Goddard and NASA Ames and folding in their functions at NASA Marshall. From an organizational standpoint, the idea makes sense. NASA has too many centers spread out over the country doing too many redundant functions. Consolation would save money and increase efficiency,
However, the reason NASA has several centers spread out across the country is that it increases congressional support for its programs. If a House member or senator is not moved by a love of science or beating the Chinese back to the moon, he or she might be motivated by the jobs and contracts created by a NASA center in their district or state. They will fight tooth and nail against closing such a source of votes.
Perhaps the best that can be done is to reduce redundancies across the field centers as much as possible. Also, NASA could make its centers more attractive to commercial space investment, such as what already is taking place at NASA Stennis, the Johnson Spaceflight Center and the Kennedy Space Center.
The idea of relocating much of NASA headquarters from Washington to one of the field centers seems odd. What would be accomplished by such a move except to have the various centers fight over which gets the new function? Having the headquarters in Washington, close to Congress and the White House, where space policy decisions are made, would seem to be an advantage.
That leaves the proposals related to the Artemis program. We have already covered the dangers of a pivot to Mars, that attempting to get there by the end of Trump’s second term risks compromising the return to the moon. In any case, Mars in four years is likely impossible.
It is likely not a question of when the Space Launch System and possibly the Orion spacecraft are canceled, but when. Does NASA use already-built hardware to fly the Artemis II lunar flyby mission and the Artemis III lunar landing and then transition to commercial rockets, or does it terminate the legacy hardware immediately and go commercial from the start?
It should be noted that as of this writing, the maiden flight of the Blue Origin New Glenn draws nigh. Also, the seventh test flight of the SpaceX Starship is scheduled to follow soon after. Both will be valuable assets in the quest to return to the moon and, in the fullness of time, send humans to Mars.
Making Artemis more efficient encompasses a lot. It would include collapsing levels of management and streamlining decision-making. Elon Musk’s and Vivek Ramaswamy’s DOGE should get on it with due speed.
Artemis lacks a rationale that everyone can easily understand. Why are we going back to the moon? Why are we going to Mars? What does an Artemis mission statement look like?
We are going back to the moon and on to Mars to advance the frontiers of science, create technology that will be useful in space and on Earth, access natural resources, create new industries, and enhance the political soft power and security of the United States and its allies.
Everything we do must flow from that mission statement.
To put the matter more succinctly, we are returning to the moon, then going to Mars and beyond to make a future that is better than the past, for the benefit of all humankind.
Mark R. Whittington is the author of “Why is It So Hard to Go Back to the Moon?” as well as “The Moon, Mars and Beyond,” and, most recently, “Why is America Going Back to the Moon?” He blogs at Curmudgeons Corner.
-
AI Hardware Is in Its ‘Put Up or Shut Up’ Era
This week at CES, companies of all sizes will show off all their new AI-enabled gadgets. Here’s hoping they don’t all just do stuff your phone already excels at.Wired - 1d -
This space stock is up on new orders for its satellite networking technology
Shares of Gilat Satellite Networks ended Monday’s session up 9.8% after the Israel-based company said that it has received $9 million in orders from major satellite operators.MarketWatch - 8h -
Trump’s tariff policy claims its first victim with Trudeau resignation
President-elect Donald Trump’s tariff policy has claimed its first victim before the president even returned to office.MarketWatch - 15h -
This Colorado Startup Is Challenging NASA in the Concorde 2.0 Race
Boom Supersonic is trying to build a quieter, 21st century supersonic jetliner.Inc. - 3d -
Notre Dame's misfits become the bullies in Sugar Bowl as Irish shake up CFP party with biggest win in decades
Notre Dame went blow for blow with the type of team that once ran it off the fieldCBS Sports - 3d -
The Papers: Sara Sharif's dad 'attacked in prison' and social care 'shake-up'
Friday's papers carry a variety of stories, including news the government is launching a commission to reform social care.BBC News - 4d -
Millions of children lost health insurance in Medicaid shake-up
Children were among the millions of people who lost Medicaid coverage after the government required states to reevaluate every recipient's eligibility. Some have been able to get benefits back, but ...NBC News - 6d -
BA passenger loyalty programme shake-up sparks backlash
Industry figures warn leisure travellers may struggle to gain perks such as access to the airline’s loungeFinancial Times - 6d
More from The Hill
-
Dem Rep. Bera ready to meet Republicans '50-yard-line,' and even '40-yard-line' since they're in majority
Rep. Ami Bera (D-Calif.) said on Monday he is ready to meet Republicans “at the 50-yard-line” and even at “the 40-yard-line” due to them being “in the majority.” “So, the American public clearly ...The Hill - 4h -
Trump says he'll replace National Archives leader
President-elect Trump said on Monday that he’ll replace the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) leader. “We will [have a] new archivist,” Trump told conservative radio host Hugh ...The Hill - 5h -
Biden says 'New Orleans defines strength and resilience' at service for victims
President Biden offered his condolences to the victims of the New Orleans New Year's Day attack, calling the Louisiana city one with a tough spirit at an interfaith prayer service with victims’ ...The Hill - 6h -
A Gaza ceasefire agreement in next 2 weeks? The US is hopeful
Welcome to The Hill's Defense & NatSec newsletter {beacon} Defense &National Security Defense &National Security The Big Story A Gaza ceasefire agreement in next 2 weeks? The US is hopeful The ...The Hill - 7h -
Musk asks his followers if the US 'should liberate the people of Britain from their tyrannical government'
Tech billionaire Elon Musk on Monday asked his followers on the social platform X, which he owns, if the U.S. “should liberate the people of Britain from their tyrannical government.” “America ...The Hill - 7h
More in Politics
-
California sheriff is Trump's blue-state ally
Riverside County, California, Sheriff Chad Bianco says he feels "very good" about President-elect Trump winning the election and calls Democrats' agenda "pro criminal." In the past, Bianco was a ...NBC News - 4h -
Dem Rep. Bera ready to meet Republicans '50-yard-line,' and even '40-yard-line' since they're in majority
Rep. Ami Bera (D-Calif.) said on Monday he is ready to meet Republicans “at the 50-yard-line” and even at “the 40-yard-line” due to them being “in the majority.” “So, the American public clearly ...The Hill - 4h -
Trump says he'll replace National Archives leader
President-elect Trump said on Monday that he’ll replace the National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) leader. “We will [have a] new archivist,” Trump told conservative radio host Hugh ...The Hill - 5h -
Miami Proud Boys leader Enrique Tarrio asks for Jan. 6 Trump pardon
Enrique Tarrio is asking President-elect Donald Trump for a pardon.CBS News - 6h -
Biden meets with families of victims of New Orleans attack
President Joe Biden and first lady Jill Biden met with families, survivors and local law enforcement affected by the New Year's Day attack in New Orleans that killed 14 people and wounded dozens of ...NBC News - 6h