Trump attorney argues Georgia charges target core political speech
Lawyers for former President Trump argued at a hearing Thursday that the charges he faces in Georgia target core political speech and urged the judge to dismiss them under the First Amendment before the case heads to trial.
Trump attorney Steve Sadow asserted that statements linked to campaigns and elections have always been found to be at the “zenith of protected speech.”
“But for protected First Amendment speech, President Trump would not be charged in RICO or the other counts,” Sadow said.
“Take out the protected speech, and you don't have an underlying basis for which to charge him,” he continued. “And since that violates the Constitution as applied to the charges here, and his speech here and his position here, this is ripe for a constitutional challenge.”
Trump contested the November 2020 election he lost to Joe Biden through a wide swath of legal challenges but also a number of speeches starting on election night in which he would not accept the results that projected President Biden's eventual victory.
Trump falsely ascertained the election was "stolen" and "rigged" against him. No evidence of mass fraud was ever found by officials.
That included in the state of Georgia, where lawyers and political allies embarked on a campaign to overturn the election results, including a phone call in which Trump pressured Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger (R) to "find" an exact number of votes in order for Trump to win.
Trump faces 10 charges in Georgia, but Judge Scott McAfee dismissed three counts against him due to a lack of detail earlier this month. He and a dozen allies are accused of attempting to subvert the state’s election results to keep Trump in power. Trump has pleaded not guilty.
Thursday marked the first hearing in the case since McAfee found Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis’s (D) once-romantic relationship with Nathan Wade, a top prosecutor on the case, created an appearance of a conflict of interest. The judge allowed Willis to proceed once Wade resigned, rejecting the defense's request to toss the historic indictment.
As Trump prepares to appeal that ruling, McAfee indicated he will continue moving ahead with resolving the remaining pretrial matters.
Sadow urged the judge to make a determination on the First Amendment issue imminently, though the judge suggested a more appropriate time might be during the trial, when defense counsel would ask for a directed verdict in their favor.
“Do we go through the whole trial — God forbid, there should be a conviction — and then we go back to try and determine as applied?” Sadow said. “I'm suggesting the reason it's right now, and the reason why we don't even get to a trial, is because it's unconstitutional [for] an accused — be it the president of the United States, former president or anyone else — to stand trial on protected speech.”
Beyond Trump’s First Amendment defense, McAfee also heard Thursday from an attorney for David Shafer, the former Georgia Republican Party chair, who asserts various deficiencies with his charges.
Shafer is charged over his alleged involvement in the scheme to send an alternate slate of electors purporting Trump won Georgia in 2020. Shafer faces counts including forgery and impersonating a public officer.
Craig Gillen, Shafer’s attorney, pushed back on the notion of describing Shafer as a “fake elector.” Among other arguments, Gillen urged the judge to dismiss some of the charges or remove language from the indictment characterizing Shafer’s Electoral College documents as “false” votes while describing the Biden electors as “lawful.”
“There's no place for it in what they have done not only in the indictment, but in their pleadings and statements they've made outside to the media,” Gillen said.
“What they have tried to do is they want to have ingrained in the minds of the community and of jurors, a concept that if you are not a Democratic elector on December the 14th, casting your vote at some other part of the State Capitol, then you are a fake elector,” Gillen continued. “And that is a pejorative term not necessary for the charges and should be stricken.”
“Nowhere in this indictment is the phrase ‘fake elector’ — it does not exist,” Fulton County prosecutor Will Wooten said. “Literally not in the indictment. So, I'm not really sure what we're talking about, removing something from the indictment that's not there.”
In the indictment, prosecutors described Shafer and others as “Trump presidential elector nominees” who cast “false” votes.
Neither Shafer nor Trump were present in the courtroom Thursday. The former president has yet to attend a hearing in his Georgia case, while Shafer has shown up for multiple previous proceedings.
McAfee did not rule on any motions during Thursday’s hearing.
Updated at 12:50 p.m. EDT
Date: | |
Tag: | Donald Trump |
Filter
-
Tough questions as Supreme Court debates Trump's immunity claim
Justices push lawyers for both sides on whether a president can be criminally prosecuted for acts while in office.BBC News - Top stories - Donald Trump -
NFL scout believes 49ers could target Georgia receiver at No. 31
One longtime NFL scout believes the 49ers could target a surprise wide receiver with the No. 31 pick in the first round of the 2024 draft.Yahoo Sports - Sports - NFL -
Trump trial: Defense attorneys begin cross-examination of David Pecker
The New York criminal trial of Donald Trump resumed with testimony from former National Enquirer publisher David Pecker.CNBC - Business - Donald Trump -
Trump Attorneys Say Tabloid Publisher Supported Former President for Business, Not Votes
The cross examination of the prosecution’s first witness came after the publisher outlined a secret agreement with Trump and lawyer Michael Cohen to buy up negative stories about the former president.The Wall Street Journal - World - Donald Trump -
Trump attorney unpacks Supreme Court presidential immunity hearing
Attorneys representing former President Donald Trump argued to the Supreme Court on Thursday that all presidents should have total immunity from criminal prosecution. Will Scharf, co-counsel to Trump, joins "America Decides" to discuss the arguments.CBS News - Top stories - Donald Trump -
Trump has good day arguing immunity but that doesn't nix Jan. 6 prosecution: ANALYSIS
At Trump's Supreme Court immunity hearing, a majority of justices clearly didn’t buy the full sweep of his assertion of executive power -- but that may not matter muchABC News - Top stories - Donald Trump -
Third witness puts Trump's financial web in spotlight
A banker's testimony allows the court to take a deep dive into the $130,000 payment made to Stormy Daniels.BBC News - Top stories - Donald Trump -
Trump 2020 'Fake electors' charged with crimes in Arizona
A state grand jury in Arizona indicted the “fake electors” who backed then-President Trump in 2020. A month after the 2020 election, 11 Trump supporters signed a certificate claiming to be Arizona’s 11 electors even though Biden won the state.NBC News - Politics - Donald Trump -
Trump allies charged in Arizona electors scheme
Arizona’s attorney general charged several Trump allies, including his former chief of staff Mark Meadows and former personal lawyer Rudy Giuliani, for the so-called "fake electors" scheme in 2020. NBC News Correspondent Vaughn Hillyard joins Meet ...NBC News - Politics - Donald Trump -
Stellar Blade - All Body Core And Beta Core Locations
There are a lot of ways to improve Eve's capabilities in Stellar Blade. One method, in particular, involves looking for her fallen comrades, which then grants her permanent boosts. Here's our guide on how to increase Eve's energy and HP by finding ...GameSpot - Tech
More from The Hill
-
Trump slams RFK Jr. in latest social media rant: 'Wasted protest vote'
Former President Trump came out swinging against independent presidential candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. Friday, despite weeks of amping him up over his likely November rival, President Biden. In a series of post on Truth Social, Trump suggested ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
RFK Jr. threatens to challenge TikTok ban: It's just a 'smoke screen'
Independent presidential candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. threatened to challenge a potential TikTok ban Friday, as efforts to block the video app in the U.S. came closer to reality earlier this week. “I’m going to file a lawsuit challenging the ...The Hill - Politics - Tiktok -
White House rips 'dangerous, appalling statements' from Columbia protest leader
The White House heavily criticized comments that resurfaced this week from a student leader of the pro-Palestinian protests at Columbia University. “These dangerous, appalling statements turn the stomach and should serve as a wakeup call. It is ...The Hill - Politics -
Freight train derails, catches fire near New Mexico-Arizona border causing road closures
A freight train detailed and caught fire, resulting in the closure of a nearby interstate, the Arizona Department of Transportation announced on Friday. "I-40 EB is closed at milepost 357 due to a train derailment in New Mexico," the Arizona DOT ...The Hill - Politics -
Paramedic sentenced to 4 years of probation for Elijah McClain's death
A Colorado paramedic has been sentenced to four years of probation for his role in the 2019 death of Elijah McClain. Jeremy Cooper, a former Aurora Fire Rescue paramedic, was convicted on Dec. 22 of criminally negligent homicide. He was the last ...The Hill - Politics