Trump and Vance's pet-eating claims pose dilemma for endangered House Republicans
NEW YORK — One New York House Republican has spread a viral but false claim about migrants eating pets. His neighbor, another vulnerable GOP freshman, has rejected it.
Now, both want to move on — but Donald Trump, JD Vance and mountains of memes stand in their way.
New York Rep. Marc Molinaro last week gave oxygen to the debunked rumor that Haitian newcomers to Springfield, Ohio, abduct and eat cats and dogs — posting it to X, Instagram and Facebook as one of a multitude of attacks meant to challenge his Democratic rival’s commitment to border security.
Two congressional districts to the south, Rep. Mike Lawler, whose constituency includes a sizable Haitian American population, released a statement urging his fellow Republicans to refrain from circulating unsubstantiated rumors. It was attributed to a spokesperson and blamed no one by name.
Both staked out their positions before the presidential debate, but neither can escape it now that Trump has thrust the racist trope into the national spotlight by musing about it onstage. His running mate, Vance, continues to defend it, telling CNN he’s been able to “create” a media focus on how immigration can overwhelm communities. And MAGA social media accounts are still circulating AI-generated art of Trump rescuing and embracing kittens and ducks.
There have been real-world implications for Springfield, including bomb threats that have closed schools and disrupted life there.
Molinaro and Lawler are battling for reelection in two of the country’s most competitive House races — and two of the six in New York that will help determine which party controls the narrowly divided chamber next year. Their divergent approaches reflect the challenging landscape that swing-district Republicans across the country must now navigate as Trump and Vance push the false narrative. The differences in their handling of the claim also speak to some of the contrasts in their campaigns.
Lawler is facing a Black challenger in former Rep. Mondaire Jones. And he's confronting the reality that some of his Haitian American constituents believe Trump and Vance are targeting them simply because they’re Black immigrants.
“We didn’t come to the United States looking for racist people to keep insulting us,” said Renold Julien, the leader of a community center aiding Haitians in Lawler’s district. “We come here to make a living. We come here because we have been forced out of our country.”
The painful and dangerous claim has spread like wildfire via TikTok, other social media memes and audio remixes thanks to Trump’s debate remarks.
“In Springfield, they’re eating dogs, the people that came in. They’re eating the cats,” Trump told the voting public as Vice President Kamala Harris shook her head incredulously at their recent debate.
Earlier that day, Molinaro posted a screenshot from Springfield featuring a Black man holding a goose and an accompanying message about a killed cat. He stood firmly by it on X after his Democratic opponent, Josh Riley, demanded he apologize.
In an interview, Molinaro then turned every question about his posts into a volley of attacks alleging Riley would surrender the southern border to criminals.
When pressed by POLITICO about it, the vulnerable Republican argued the Springfield claim is based in some truth about some Black immigrant cultures.
“Google Manlius,” Molinaro said, a reference to a popular swan that, according to police, was stolen, killed and eaten last year. “Listen, there are desperate people in the world who were allowed into this country with no capacity to support themselves.”
While his line of rhetoric has been challenged as racist, Molinaro’s focus on the broader migrant issue is not surprising. In the mid-Hudson Valley’s heated rematch, border security has emerged as a central theme.
Riley has hit Molinaro for his opposition to the bipartisan border bill, which died in the Senate — in large part due to Trump’s opposition to it. Molinaro has in turn attacked Riley’s work as a Senate attorney challenging Trump’s border policy. And both have blasted President Joe Biden and spotlighted migrant crime.
In an interview with POLITICO, Riley was similarly intent on focusing on the border, arguing he would work toward a solution and saying Molinaro is lying about his record.
“It’s beneath the office to pedal and traffic in dangerous and racist conspiracy theories,” the Democrat said. “We have real, big, serious challenges that we need to solve.”
Trump and Vance’s continued promotion of the pet-eating claim is harder to pivot away from in Lawler’s lower Hudson Valley district, where support from Haitian New Yorkers could mean the difference between winning and losing in what’s expected to be a tight race.
After Molinaro’s posts, but before the debate, Lawler’s office issued a mild rebuke — and perhaps the only one from a House Republican.
“He encourages his colleagues to exercise great restraint when spreading unfounded theories and claims based off of posts on Facebook,” Lawler’s spokesperson Nate Soule said in a statement.
Lawler declined POLITICO’s request for an interview. His campaign said his statement was not aimed at Molinaro.
Jones, meanwhile, told POLITICO that the Springfield claim is “gross” and “racist.”
“It’s sadly par for the course in Republican politics,” he said in an interview.
It’s also offensive to Haitian Americans in the district, “a community that Mike Lawler purports to be trying to make inroads in — for political purposes anyway,” Jones said.
Jones hosted a news conference Tuesday with leaders of Haitian descent to condemn Republican rhetoric.
Julien, the director of the Konbit Neg Lakay community center, told POLITICO he reached out and initiated the event because he had not heard from officials of either party since the Springfield claim went viral.
“It is a reminder that politically, Haitians in the United States, we don’t really have a lot of friends,” Julien said. “But it is not about Republican or Democrat, the thing is you’re talking about humanity.”
Date: | |
Tag: | Donald Trump |
Topics
-
ABC News - Top stories
Postmaster general rejects Trump claims about ability to handle mail-in ballots
Louis DeJoy said Trump is "wrong" to claim they might be deliberately misplaced.1 minute ago - Donald Trump -
ABC News - Top stories
Fact-checking JD Vance's claims about Haitian migrants in Springfield, Ohio
Sen. JD Vance, Donald Trump's 2024 running mate, continues to fuel the firestorm surrounding Springfield, Ohio, with false claims about Haitian migrants.16 minutes ago -
The New York Times - Top stories
Top Georgia Republican’s Texts Highlight the Party’s Deep Divide on Trump
Messages sent by Lt. Gov. Burt Jones of Georgia, a Trump ally, show the state party’s leadership fracturing in real time after the 2020 election.2 hours ago - Donald Trump -
NBC News - Top stories
Inside Trump and Vance's 'buddy level' relationship
Despite digressions involving cats and a hiccup on abortion policy, Donald Trump has grown close to JD Vance, talking with him almost every day and cheering on his frequent TV appearances.4 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Kellyanne Conway: Trump would choose JD Vance again
Kellyanne Conway has suggested that former President Trump does not regret picking Sen. JD Vance as his running mate and would make the same decision today if given the opportunity.5 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
The House is stumbling toward another shutdown — and another Trump loss
When will conservatives learn? Shutdowns don’t win elections.7 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The Guardian - World
With their lies about Haitian immigrants, Trump and Vance have reached a new low | Moustafa Bayoumi
If Trump and Vance can’t take responsibility for their actions now, why would they take responsibility for the country later?. During his debate with Kamala Harris on 10 September, Donald Trump ...20 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Trump vows to travel to Springfield following false pet-eating claims
Former President Trump pledged to travel to Springfield, Ohio, after false claims that he and his running mate, Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio), have made about Haitian immigrants eating pets in the city. ...23 hours ago - Donald Trump -
NBC News - Top stories
House Republicans reject their own funding bill with a shutdown around the corner
House Republicans are expected to derail their own plan to avert a government shutdown, which they've tied to a Donald Trump-backed bill on noncitizen voting.Yesterday -
The New York Times - Top stories
Trump’s Bogus Claims About Haitians Are Part of a Bigger Agenda
The Springfield fable is part of a crusade to throw immigrants out of the country.Yesterday - Donald Trump -
CBS News - Top stories
House task force briefing on Donald Trump Secret Service protection
The House of Representatives task force investigating the assassination attempts against Former President Donald Trump is being briefed on the Florida golf course incident. CBS News' Nicole Sganga ...Yesterday - Donald Trump -
The Guardian - World
Teamsters decline to endorse election candidate – but claim majority backs Trump
Decision to not make endorsement for first time in nearly three decades comes in wake of scrutiny of its president. The Teamsters International, a powerful US transportation workers union that ...Yesterday - Donald Trump -
CNBC - Business
Republican House speaker floats deregulation and tax cuts — not tariffs — to pay for Trump proposals
Republican Speaker Mike Johnson is hours away from a House vote on his six-month funding bill, less than two weeks away from a partial government shutdown.Yesterday - Donald Trump -
CNBC - Business
111 Republican former officials endorse Harris, say Trump is 'unfit to serve'
Kamala Harris' campaign has netted Republican endorsements from numerous Trump administration officials as well as from figures such as Dick Cheney.Yesterday - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
The Trump-Vance plan for Ukraine is insane
This is the imposition of a Russian veto on Ukrainian foreign policy.Yesterday - Ukraine -
The New York Times - Top stories
Trump Knows What He’s Doing in Springfield. So Does Vance.
When you start talking about people “poisoning the blood of our country,” this is where you end up. And it’s not over.Yesterday - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Haberman: Trump campaign 'perfectly happy' with Vance in 'attack dog' role
New York Times senior political correspondent Maggie Haberman said Tuesday that she thinks former President Trump’s campaign is "perfectly happy” letting his running mate, Ohio Sen. JD Vance (R), ...Yesterday - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Donald Trump's ties to Laura Loomer spell trouble for the Republican Party
Donald Trump has once again reactivated his sizable corps of yes-men and yes-women, to re-inflate his fragile ego.Yesterday - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Watch live: House Republican leaders give remarks amid spending battle
House Republican leadership is slated to deliver remarks Wednesday following a closed-door meeting amid the party's effort to avert a government shutdown. Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) told The Hill ...Yesterday -
The Hill - Politics
Republican Ohio governor: Trump, Vance comments about Haitian migrants 'very hurtful'
Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine (R) said Tuesday that unsubstantiated comments from former President Trump and his running mate Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio) about Haitian migrants eating household pets are “not ...Yesterday - Donald Trump -
Financial Times - Business
Trump, Vance and American blood and soil
A myth about migrants eating pets masks a calculated political betYesterday - Donald Trump -
CBS News - Top stories
JD Vance echoes Trump, blames Democrats for apparent assassination attempt
Former President Donald Trump held a town hall in Michigan while Vice President Kamala Harris spoke to the National Association of Black Journalists in Philadelphia Tuesday. Trump and his running ...2 days ago - Donald Trump -
The Guardian - World
Trump appears at town hall in Michigan; Walz says Trump lost thousands of North Carolina jobs – live
Donald Trump will speak at town hall in Flint; Kamala Harris running mate suggests Trump’s ‘concept’ of a healthcare plan is ‘weak’. As far as the election campaign is concerned, this week the ...2 days ago - Donald Trump -
The New York Times - Top stories
Senate Republicans Block I.V.F. Bill Again, Breaking With Trump
Democrats brought up the measure again to highlight Republican opposition to abortion rights and make the case to voters that the G.O.P. stance threatens access to reproductive health care.2 days ago - Donald Trump -
Politico - Politics
House passes $3B veterans funding patch as Republicans scoff at massive VA shortfall
2 days ago - Republican Party -
The New York Times - Top stories
Harris Condemns Trump’s False Claims About Haitian Migrants Eating Pets
“This is exhausting, and it’s harmful,” Kamala Harris said during an interview. “And it’s hateful, and grounded in some age-old stuff that we should not have the tolerance for.”2 days ago - Donald Trump -
BBC News - Top stories
Ex-agent explains why protecting Trump is such a challenge
The amount of time he spends outside, the exuberance of his fan base and the number and size of rallies are among difficulties.2 days ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Hillary Clinton: Trump counting on Americans becoming 'desensitized' to 'outrageous' claims
Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, the 2016 Democratic nominee for president, says former President Trump is counting on Americans to become “desensitized” to his “outrageous” falsehoods. ...2 days ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Vance calls out Democrats, media after apparent Trump assassination attempt
Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio) slammed Democrats and the media Tuesday over their rhetoric about former President Trump, just days after the former president faced a second apparent assassination attempt. ...2 days ago - Donald Trump -
Politico - Politics
Trump and Vance's pet-eating claims pose dilemma for endangered House Republicans
Now, they can’t escape it with Trump, Vance and AI-generated memes keeping the myth alive.2 days ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Watch live: Vance courts voters in Michigan after second Trump assassination attempt
Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio), former President Trump's running mate, will deliver remarks Tuesday at a campaign event in Michigan, just days after a second assassination attempt was made on Trump's life. ...2 days ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Most Trump supporters believe false claims about Haitian migrants: Poll
A YouGov poll found that more than half of Trump-backers believe that Haitian immigrants in Ohio are eating people's pets, despite no evidence of this being true.2 days ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Teachers union to launch ads in battleground states calling out Trump, Vance
One of the nation's largest teachers unions is launching ads in battleground states to go after former President Trump and his GOP running mate, Ohio Sen. JD Vance. The American Federation of ...2 days ago -
The Hill - Politics
The Memo: Attempt on Trump’s life reverberates in White House race
The 2024 presidential election campaign took another dramatic lurch Sunday, when the Secret Service foiled an apparent assassination attempt against former President Trump. On this occasion, unlike ...2 days ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Trump-Taylor Swift feud may pose risks in tight election
The escalating feud between former President Trump and Taylor Swift could impact November’s election as Democrats seek to use Swift’s endorsement of Vice President Harris as a turnout mechanism. ...2 days ago - Donald Trump -
CBS News - Top stories
Violent threats surge in Springfield, Ohio, after Trump, Vance false claims
The town of Springfield, Ohio, has been on edge ever since former President Donald Trump's baseless debate comments that Haitian immigrants there are eating pets. CBS News congressional ...3 days ago - Donald Trump
More from Politico
-
Politico - Politics
House GOP opposition tanks Johnson’s short-term funding plan
Ahead of the vote, former President Donald Trump re-upped his demand that Republicans use a government shutdown threat to ding Democrats on a measure requiring proof of citizenship for registered ...Yesterday -
Politico - Politics
Secret Service tells House task force that agency has increased Trump’s security
Yesterday -
Politico - Politics
Hours before vote, Trump again presses House GOP on short-term spending bill
Yesterday - Donald Trump -
Politico - Politics
Johnson dodges on government shutdown if spending bill fails
Yesterday -
Politico - Politics
Passage prospects dim as Johnson’s spending plan heads to House floor
Yesterday