To tackle crime, spend less on prisons and more on people
With two months until Election Day, crime and criminal justice have emerged as core issues for campaigns up and down the ballot. Candidates across the political spectrum are eager to present themselves as tough on crime, particularly in the presidential election.
Last month, former President Donald Trump vowed to “make America safe again” through an increase in policing and the use of the death penalty, while Vice President Kamala Harris has honed a stump speech that positions her as a tough prosecutor who has made a career of holding “convicted felons” accountable.
With campaign rhetoric dominating the news cycle, it can be hard to tell which tactics will lead to real results. But it is clear that people want action: A recent Gallup poll indicates that 79 percent of Americans worry about crime and violence, and the majority of Americans believe our justice system is not tough enough.
Even though violent crime rates have fallen back to their pre-pandemic levels, lawmakers are under pressure to help their constituents feel safe — so jurisdictions from San Francisco to Louisiana are rolling back reforms and increasing sentences.
Instead of ineffective policies, policymakers who are serious about public safety should look at evidence-based solutions rooted in decades of data, which emphasize economic stability, early intervention and community involvement. These options are our best opportunity for long-term community safety.
Community violence intervention programs have proven to be successful models, even in the current political climate. Notably, Philadelphia and Baltimore have implemented holistic community violence intervention programs that have improved public safety.
In Philadelphia, former mayor Jim Kenny and his administration created a group violence intervention program that connected individuals at risk for gun violence to jobs and city services. A 2023 evaluation revealed that this program, which was launched in 2020, reduced shootings among participants by about half.
Baltimore experienced similar success when Mayor Brandon Scott made community violence intervention a cornerstone of his broader violence reduction strategy.
The strategy identified individuals at high risk for violence and then deployed community partners to connect them to community resources. Early studies showed the initiatives reduced homicides and shootings in Baltimore’s Western District by 25 percent and decreased carjackings by about a third. The city paired this strategy with other measures, including a gun buyback program to reduce the number of guns, which is proven to increase community safety.
To signal its support for programs like those in Philadelphia and Baltimore, last year the Biden administration announced a $5 billion investment in community violence interventions.
Community violence intervention programs are promising, but they’re a fraction of the policies that could reduce crime: Research has shown that everything from job programs to continued access to Supplemental Security Income for youth who have aged out of the program to basic income and stable housing could help.
Unfortunately, instead of turning to evidence-based reforms, many cities and states have been returning to policies that simply do not work well. Long sentences increase the prison population, but they do not prevent crime: People who serve long sentences are more likely to commit more crimes in the future.
In addition, high incarceration rates and long sentences are expensive, costing the government and the families of justice-involved people as much as $182 billion a year. That’s more than double what the federal government spends on elementary and secondary education.
Most of these policies — from increased surveillance to lengthy prison sentences to the emphasis on low-level crime — weigh heavily on communities of color. Police are more likely to stop, search and arrest Black people; juries are more likely to convict people of color and communities of color are more likely to face the poverty that creates the conditions suitable for crime.
Studies continue to demonstrate the American public wants smarter, more effective approaches toward crime and criminal justice. To reduce crime and increase public safety, turning toward evidence-based solutions that emphasize early intervention and community involvement offers the best opportunities for success.
By addressing the underlying causes of crime, employing evidence and involving communities, we can create safer, more secure environments for everyone.
Sarah Rosen Wartell is president of the Urban Institute. David Pitts is vice president for justice policy at the Urban Institute.
Date: |
-
The Guardian - World
More than 200 inmates escape Nigerian prison in aftermath of flooding
Prisoners fled when the walls of their jail collapsed in the country’s worst flooding in two decades. More than 200 inmates escaped from a prison in north-east Nigeria in the aftermath of the ...1 hour ago -
ABC News - World
Authoritarian Belarus president pardons 37 political prisoners out of more than 1,300
Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko has pardoned 37 people serving prison sentences for what his office described as "extremist” crimes4 hours ago -
Yahoo Sports - Sports
Vikings top Christian McCaffrey-less 49ers for upset win after dominant showing from Justin Jefferson
Justin Jefferson, who hauled in a wild 97-yard touchdown catch in the first half, left the game early with a quad injury.23 hours ago - NFL -
The New York Times - Business
Boeing Will Cut Spending as Strike Takes Financial Toll
More than 33,000 Boeing workers went on strike last week after rejecting a tentative contract the company had negotiated with their unions.2 hours ago -
BBC News - Top stories
EU firefighting planes to help tackle Portugal wildfires
Several fires broke out across Portugal over the weekend, forcing residents to flee and motorways to shut.2 hours ago - European Union -
Yahoo News - World
Prisoners flee after Nigeria floods damage jail
8 hours ago - Nigeria -
BBC News - Top stories
Prisoners flee after Nigeria floods damage jail
The state governor says that jihadist fighters may be among those who have fled.8 hours ago - Nigeria -
The Guardian - World
At least 16 killed in Israeli airstrikes on Gaza, Palestinian officials say
Five women and four children said to be among dead with strike hitting residential building in crowded Nuseirat camp. Middle East crisis – latest news updates At least 16 people have been ...2 hours ago - Israel -
BBC News - Top stories
Dad's knife crime vow after air cadet son's murder
Frank Shani's son Nathaniel was murdered a year ago by two boys aged 14 and 15.14 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
Suspect in apparent Trump assassination attempt charged with federal gun crimes
The suspected gunman in an apparent second attempted assassination of former President Trump has been charged with federal gun crimes. Ryan Wesley Routh, 58, appeared in federal court in West Palm ...3 hours ago - Donald Trump
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
It took years, but elite colleges are learning the value of institutional neutrality
Whatever one thinks of the war in Gaza, divestment should be avoided because it violates institutional neutrality and thereby damages the college or university as an institution.44 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
55 Democratic lawmakers ask Biden administration to expand Arctic protections
Sen. Ed Markey (D-Mass.) and Rep. Jared Huffman (D-Calif.) led a letter from more than 50 congressional Democrats calling on the Interior Department to expand federal protections in the Arctic. The ...58 minutes ago - Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Harris meets with Teamsters as both parties court coveted endorsement
Vice President Harris joined the International Brotherhood of Teamsters for a roundtable Monday, as anticipation swirls around whom the union will endorse in the presidential race. Teamsters ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
Suspect in apparent assassination attempt of Trump has long history of legal troubles
The suspect in an apparent attempted assassination of former President Trump has long had run-ins with the law, court records show, a history that could be a factor as he stares down federal ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Bad actors already have your data, but there's something you can do about it
The NPD breach was one of the largest on record. It will not be the last.1 hour ago