To save Georgian democracy, Biden should sanction the country's oligarchs
New U.S. visa and financial sanctions imposed this month against the Georgian government and representatives of the ruling party, Georgian Dream, fell short because they failed to include the man responsible for Georgia’s authoritarian and pro-Russian direction, the oligarch Bidzina Ivanishvili.
The new sanctions imposed by the Biden administration came on top of others implemented earlier this year for corruption, antidemocratic behavior and human rights abuses. The sanctions were well warranted, but they don’t go far enough.
The U.S. should make clear it will use its financial leverage against Ivanishvili himself and his party should they continue on a path that would be disastrous for the Georgian people and the U.S.-Georgian relationship.
Ivanishvili made his fortune doing business in Russia before returning to his homeland and securing victory for his Georgian Dream party in 2012 parliamentary elections. Since 2012, he has been the power behind the throne, calling the shots despite holding an official position for only the first of those 12 years. During that time, he has sought to improve ties with Moscow, despite Russia’s continued occupation of 20 percent of Georgian territory after its invasion in 2008. Direct flights between Georgia and Russia have been restored, bringing thousands of Russians to Georgia, and trade between the two countries is booming.
His ruling party has also adopted Russian-style legislation — a law requiring domestic nongovernmental organizations receiving foreign funding to register as “agents under foreign influence,” despite huge protests against the law. It also enacted a Russian-style law banning same-sex marriages, adoptions by same-sex couples, and transgender medical treatments. Ivanishvili recently suggested that the previous government, led by former President (and now political prisoner) Mikheil Saakashvili, not Russia, was responsible for the bloodshed of 2008 and the Russian occupation that followed.
Ivanishvili announced his formal return to Georgian politics shortly after the European Union announced last December that it would grant candidacy status to Georgia — many months before critical elections in October.
On the campaign trail, his fire-breathing speeches promised dire antidemocratic and anti-Western consequences if the opposition wins the Oct. 26 parliamentary elections. He has claimed that the United States and Europe (“the Global War Party”) are funding the leaders of the opposition and directing them to reinstall Saakashvili’s “insane and sadistic regime” and open a “second front” with Russia.
Ivanishvili asserted that the ruling party would prevent such an outcome “at any cost,” a not-so-veiled threat to resort to election manipulation.
Suggesting that the entire pro-Western opposition is aligned with Saakashvili, he promised a “Georgian Nuremberg trial” against it soon after the elections. He said he would impose on the pro-Western opposition the “harsh political and legal judgment it deserves” for Saakashvili’s “bloody rule.” Asked who in particular would be banned and prevented from entering parliament, his prime minister, Irakli Kobakhidze, named names — all the main opposition parties.
Georgian Dream already controls all three branches of government. By promising to outlaw the opposition and cripple civil society and independent media, Ivanishvili and Kobakhidze are in essence describing an anti-Western totalitarian regime ruling a pro-Western population.
Instead, the U.S. must tell Ivanishvili that if he rigs the October election in his favor, or carries out his threat to ban the opposition, he and his billions will face the full brunt of Treasury Department financial sanctions.
In truth, sanctioning Ivanishvili is something that should have been done months ago, including back when he and his stooges in the government and parliament were launching nasty rhetorical attacks against the previous U.S. ambassador and members of Congress. If we convince him we will impose costly personal sanctions if he carries out his implicit threat to change the election results — and his explicit threat to ban all opposition and turn Georgia into an anti-Western dictatorship — we could deter him from doing so.
In addition, with concerns rampant about election rigging and with civil society under attack, international election observers will need to be vigilant in calling out any fraud and abuse. The United States and its allies must stand firm against legitimizing a fraudulent election.
Georgia Dream remains the leading vote getter but does not appear likely to win a majority of the vote, according to recent polls ahead of next month’s parliamentary elections. That could open the way for a coalition of opposition parties to unite and defeat Georgian Dream, although those parties are struggling to unite completely.
Polls consistently show that the people of Georgia remain very pro-American, pro-European Union, pro-NATO and pro-democracy. Georgia, once a vibrant democracy in a difficult neighborhood, has become a problem instead of a partner, but one over which the United States and the European Union both have considerable interests and influence — if they choose to exercise them.
Dangling the threat of painful, targeted sanctions now could save the people of Georgia from the pro-Russian, authoritarian future the oligarch has promised them.
Ambassador (ret.) Ian Kelly is Ambassador in Residence at Northwestern University and a former U.S. ambassador to Georgia and to the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe. David J. Kramer is executive director of the George W. Bush Institute and a former U.S. Assistant Secretary of State for Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor.
Date: | |
Tag: | Joe Biden |
-
World - The New York Times
In a Year of Elections, Democracy is on the Line
Experts at the Democracy Forum in Athens this week will explore the global challenges to democracy and attempt to weigh how endangered it really is.12 hours ago -
World - The New York Times
Can Mainstream Media Save Itself?
A panel at the Athens Democracy Forum explores how and whether traditional news organizations can regain the influence and trust that once defined them.12 hours ago -
Sports - ESPN
Freshman Williams' dramatic TD catch saves Tide
Ryan Williams' 75-yard touchdown catch, complete with an electrifying spin move and dash to the end zone, helped Alabama hold on for a thrilling 41-34 win over Georgia.3 hours ago -
Top stories - BBC News
'Heroes' save animals after land 'sacrificed' in floods
The owner of a smallholding believes her property was flooded because drainage pools for a nearby main road were not being properly managed.2 hours ago -
World - The Guardian
Japan’s magic bullet: 60 years of the train that helped rebuild the idea of a country
Over just a few days in 1964, the launch of the shinkansen and the Tokyo Olympics trumpeted the emergence of a new economic and democratic power. At 6am on 1 October 1964, two trains set off in ...12 hours ago -
World - ABC News
Climate change and harsh weather in France bring challenges to Chablis wine country
Unusually wet conditions across France have wreaked havoc on many wine-growing regions this year after years of challenges to vineyards and wine quality caused by drought and heat12 hours ago - Climate -
Politics - The Hill
America should welcome India’s rise as a space power
The situation sets up an interesting dynamic that the United States and India both can use to their mutual advantage.6 hours ago -
Politics - Politico
AOC says Eric Adams should resign
3 days ago -
Top stories - CBS News
President Joe Biden on Jimmy Carter's 100th birthday
On the occasion of Jimmy Carter turning 100, President Biden honors the former president and humanitarian for his decades of public service, as well as his hopeful vision of our country and ...6 hours ago - Joe Biden
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Lawmakers race to avoid farm bill disaster
The stopgap farm bill is set to expire next week — and the congressional coalition that the massive legislation has relied on for half a century is on the verge of breaking down. Now congressional ...28 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Stanley McChrystal: 'I'm voting for character. I'm voting for Kamala Harris'
Retired Gen. Stanley McChrystal said Sunday he is voting for Vice President Harris because of her “character,” sidestepping questions about former President Trump’s fitness for the highest office. ...59 minutes ago - Kamala Harris -
Politics - The Hill
Trump attacks Harris over immigration, calls for her to be impeached
Former President Trump ratcheted up his attacks against Vice President Harris over immigration, calling for her to be impeached over the weekend. “Kamala’s Illegal Migrants. It’s the biggest crime ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Another senior Hezbollah commander, Ali Karki, confirmed killed in Friday airstrike
Hezbollah confirmed that another one of its top commanders, Ali Karki, was killed in an Israeli airstrike on Friday. The Iranian-backed Lebanese militant group said Karki was killed alongside the ...1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
The Kids Online Safety Act was a good start, but app stores need accountability too
Congress has introduced the "App Store Accountability Act" to make app stores and devices safe for kids by requiring age verification, parental consent, transparency requirements, and industry ...1 hour ago