To fight inflation, we should look for ways beyond the Fed’s policies
Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell and the Fed Board have had people guessing since December about when they will cut interest rates. Cuts appear further off now because Powell is afraid that inflation may be heating up. This worry increased when the Consumer Price Index (CPI) on April 10 confirmed what the Personal Consumption Expenditures Index (PCE) had shown on March 29, that inflation may be stuck at a level the Fed thinks is too high.
The PCE is the Fed’s preferred inflation index. What it suggests in 350 rows of data is important. It is that Powell and the Board are not paying enough attention to detailed information about the sources of inflation in that index. Average PCE prices were 2.5 percent higher in February 2024 than in February 2023, which is higher than the Fed’s 2.0 percent target. What should be getting Powell and the Board’s attention is the PCE’s data showing which goods and services are driving the average up.
The surge in prices caused by COVID-related supply chain and energy issues in 2022 and early 2023 is over. Inflation in goods that make up 33 percent of the index is way down. It is services like health care, housing and insurance that are pushing the average up.
U.S. health care costs have risen faster than the averages for decades and rose about 52 percent more than the average from February 2023 to February 2024. The result is that per capita expenditures for health care in the U.S. were $12,555 in 2022, compared to $6,651 in an average of other developed countries.
Why do health care prices outstrip the average year after year? It is largely because they are set by thousands of local hospitals that don’t compete on price, and don’t make their suppliers do so. Middlemen, suppliers and hospitals make opaque deals for the purchase of pharmaceuticals, devises like stents, medical machinery, disposables and services that inflate prices. The complex arrangements around insurance plans are similarly inflationary.
Housing prices, rents and utility costs also are rising faster than average inflation. Local regulatory bodies and zoning rules inflate prices and existing owners make it hard to develop less costly options like in-fill houses and apartments. Rents and home prices also are pushed up by rising interest rates engineered by the Fed.
Housing and health care each are 17 percent of the PCE so their impact on average inflation is significant. It is important to recognize that the drivers of inflation have changed over the years. Autos, steel and machine tools were the culprits during the post-World War II period. There also were legal price-fixing arrangements in important sectors carried over from the Great Depression. Most economists and political leaders then believed that corporations and interest groups with the power to set prices were primary causes of inflation.
Telecommunications are an example of how near monopolies and government regulators set prices in the post-war period. Telecom was dominated by the original AT&T, aka “Ma Bell.” It controlled 80-85 percent of the market. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) allowed it to prevent newcomers from offering services if Ma Bell could show that they were not needed.
AT&T kept price-cutting challengers out by marshalling stables of lawyers to block them. Government leaders and the courts in the 1970s and ’80s, however, came to side with challengers and consumers, allowing them to take on the monopolist. Prices of telecom services fell dramatically as did prices for trucking, rail and airlines services, energy, finance and other areas that were opened to competition in the late ’70s, ’80s and ’90s.
Concern about monopolies and oligopolies powering inflation was shared by Republican and Democratic administrations. Presidents Harry Truman, John F. Kennedy, Lyndon Johnson, Gerald Ford, Ronald Reagan, Jimmy Carter and congressional leaders all took political risks to roll back monopolistic arrangement in a roster of industries.
The Fed played a more limited role in fighting inflation during that period than it does today. It had been discredited during and after the stock market crash, and the Treasury and several New Deal agencies filled the vacuum. The Fed’s successes in recapturing power, beginning in the 1950s, have drastically altered the way economists and political leaders think about the economy and inflation.
The conviction today is that inflation fighting is about Fed policies rather than price-fixing and structural issues in sectors like health care, housing and insurance. Sectoral views of the causes of inflation don’t get the attention that presidents and Congress gave them in the earlier era.
The obvious problem is that almost total reliance on the Fed to defeat inflation by slowing the economy will not work in sectors where price-fixing and structural issues are its principal causes. Worse, slowing the economy to fight inflation when the U.S. faces severe political, economic and geo-political challenges that demand money and resources is courting problems that are much bigger than modest inflation.
Paul A. London, Ph.D., was a senior policy adviser and deputy undersecretary of Commerce for Economics and Statistics in the 1990s, a deputy assistant administrator at the Federal Energy Administration and Energy Department, and a visiting fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. A legislative assistant to Sen. Walter Mondale (D-Minn.) in the 1970s, he was a foreign service officer in Paris and Vietnam and is the author of two books, including “The Competition Solution: The Bipartisan Secret Behind American Prosperity” (2005).
Date: |
Topics
Filter
-
There was no time for a wedding – so we eloped. Maybe you should too
Financial pressure prevented a ceremony, and our families weren’t thrilled. But my wedding day was still beautiful. I got the phone call that would change my relationship at 4.45 on a Wednesday evening. It wasn’t my ex calling with a sexual health ...The Guardian - World -
Meow Wolf supercharged the way we experience art. Is L.A. ready for the wild ride?
Experimental art collective Meow Wolf aims to turn Los Angeles' most ritualistic experience — that is, the act of going to the movies — into an interactive, art-driven wonderland.Los Angeles Times - Entertainment -
The Fed Is Looking for a Job Market Cool-Down. It Just Got One.
Wage growth and hiring slowed in April, evidence of the job market slowdown that Federal Reserve officials have been waiting on.The New York Times - Business - Federal Reserve -
The Fed Is Looking for a Job Market Cool-Down. It Just Got One.
Wage growth and hiring slowed in April, prodding investors to slightly increase their bets on rate cuts this year.The New York Times - Top stories - Federal Reserve -
Fed still trying to assess if recent hot inflation readings mean economy is ‘overheating,’ Goolsbee says
“Everybody’s just got to take a step back and try to figure out ‘is that a sign that the economy is overheating, or is that a sign of some other thing’?” Goolsbee said.MarketWatch - Business - Federal Reserve -
The UAW Has a Gaza Policy
Auto workers chief Shawn Fain signals the union’s solidarity with violent protesters.The Wall Street Journal - World -
RBA’s policy options are running short, says JBWere
With inflation proving sticky, the Reserve Bank of Australia doesn’t have the option of simply holding interest rates higher for longer, with further increases now looking likely, a leading forecaster says.MarketWatch - Business -
OPEC+ Likely to Extend Output Curbs Beyond 2Q, JPMorgan Says
OPEC and its allies are likely to extend their voluntary production cuts beyond the second quarter at their upcoming meeting in June, according to JPMorgan.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Bombardier Sets Course Beyond Jet Making for Future Growth
The Canadian business-jet manufacturer said it plans to focus on three segments—defense, aftermarket services and selling pre-owned certified aircraft—as key pillars to grow its revenue and cash reserves in the coming years.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Technology may offer ways to prevent wrong-way traffic deaths
The devastating impact often happens in darkness, on a highway, at high speed.NBC News - Top stories
More from The Hill
-
Hope Hicks offers dramatic testimony in Trump trial: 5 takeaways
Former President Trump’s trial closed out the week in dramatic style as former aide Hope Hicks took the stand. Hicks, who served as press secretary in the early, ramshackle days of Trump’s first campaign for the presidency, went on to become his ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump -
International court pushes back on 'threats' as it weighs Israel-Hamas arrests
The International Criminal Court (ICC) pushed back against “threats” Friday as it faces intense pressure following reports of possible arrest warrants for Israeli and Hamas officials over their conduct in the Oct. 7 attack and war in Gaza that has ...The Hill - Politics - Israel -
Biden adds carveout to EV credit restrictions
Welcome to The Hill's Energy & Environment newsletter {beacon} Energy & Environment Energy & Environment The Big Story Biden issues flexible guidance for EV components The Biden administration granted leeway for qualifying for electric vehicle ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Biden awards Medal of Freedom to 19 recipients, including Pelosi, Clyburn
President Biden on Friday awarded the Medal of Freedom to 19 recipients, including top longtime Democratic congressional leaders, calling them “an incredible group of people.” “Nineteen incredible people whose relentless curiosity, inventiveness, ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Iowa will face lawsuit if it acts on immigration law, DOJ warns
The Department of Justice (DOJ) warned Iowa on Friday that the state will face a lawsuit if it implements an immigration law that forbids people from being in the state if they were previously denied entry into the United States. The DOJ informed ...The Hill - Politics