This obscure procedure can restore majority rule in the House of Representatives
On April 20, the U.S. House of Representatives voted to provide $95 billion in military and humanitarian assistance to Ukraine, Israel and Taiwan. Speaker Mike Johnson brought the legislation to the floor despite threats from Republican firebrands to oust him for it. The bills passed with substantial bipartisan majorities: 311-112 for Ukraine, 366-58 for Israel, 385-34 for Taiwan. On April 23, in a lopsided 79-18 vote, the Senate approved the legislation, and President Biden signed it the next day.
Johnson’s decision was a remarkable about-face. An opponent of aid to Ukraine before he became Speaker, Johnson subsequently said he would not permit a vote unless Republican demands to secure the southern border were met, and then dismissed a bipartisan Senate plan restricting immigration as inadequate. Despite evidence that Ukraine was running out of ammunition, Johnson did not change his mind when the Senate passed a foreign aid bill in February, with support from 70 members.
Acknowledging he “could make a selfish decision and do something different,” the Speaker now claims he would rather “send bullets to Ukraine than American boys … This is not a game. It’s not a joke. We can’t play politics on this. We have to do the right thing and I’m going to allow an opportunity for every single member of the House to vote their conscience and their will.”
Johnson’s action, albeit belated, may well merit inclusion in profiles in courage. But it also underscores the concentration of power in the office of the Speaker. The MAGA extremists who are trying to hamstring Johnson and who ousted Kevin McCarthy, his predecessor, have a malevolent motive: to augment the leverage of a small minority of one political party in the House. That said, there’s an altruistic reason for curtailing the Speaker’s power: to ensure that when a majority of members in the body support legislation they can “vote their conscience and their will.”
Reforms to enhance democracy in the House should begin with greater use of discharge petitions.
The discharge petition was created in 1910 to reduce the power of Speaker Joseph Cannon, who was also chair of the Rules Committee, who thought he had been, in the words of a 1923 Time Magazine article, “immaculately born into the Constitution by the will of the fathers for the divine purpose of perpetuating the dictatorship of standpatters in the Republican Party.” The discharge petition allowed a majority of members to bring bills that had been languishing in committees to the floor for a vote.
In 1931, the discharge petition was formalized as Rule XV, Clause 2. Dependent on cooperation among Republicans and Democrats, it was expected to be used sparingly. But it was used. In 1938, the discharge petition facilitated passage of the Fair Labor Standards Act, establishing a federal government minimum wage. In the 1950s and ’60s, discharge petitions brought civil rights bills to the floor. In 1970, Rule XV, Clause 2 forced the Judiciary Committee to release the Equal Rights Amendment.
In recent decades, discharge petitions have fallen out of favor — along with bipartisanship and compromise. Since 1993, only two of them have resulted in the passage of legislation. The last successful discharge petition — a reauthorization of the U.S. Export–Import Bank — was filed in 2015.
The Problem Solvers Caucus in the House can play a pivotal role in restoring this tool of democratic governance. The Problem Solvers was founded in 2017 and committed to diminishing partisan gridlock; it has 64 members, 32 of each party. The House won’t get things done, according to co-chairs Rep. Josh Gottheimer (D-N.J.) and Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick (R-Penn.), unless moderates in both parties work together “to help them get across the finish line.”
Problem Solvers have suggested equal representation of Democrats and Republicans on the powerful Rules Committee, proposed that Democrats vote to retain Speaker McCarthy in exchange for an enhanced role in setting the agenda of the House and taken preliminary steps to circulate discharge petitions to bring legislation raising the debt ceiling and the foreign aid bill to the floor for a vote.
The case for judicious use of discharge petitions is compelling. That said, building an effective reform coalition will be difficult. In orientation meetings, leaders of the majority party tell new members that voting against procedural rules to bring bills to the floor or in favor of discharge petitions would put their political careers at risk. Most important, thanks in no small measure to gerrymandering, the number of safe seats in the House has grown, moderates are an endangered species and extremists are too often in the saddle.
As with all foundational and apparently intractable challenges, however, small-D democrats must acknowledge their pessimism of the intellect, while acting on an optimism of the will.
Glenn C. Altschuler is the Thomas and Dorothy Litwin Emeritus Professor of American Studies at Cornell University.
Date: |
Filter
-
Netanyahu says Israel will ‘stand alone’ as White House says major Rafah invasion wouldn’t help efforts to defeat Hamas – live
Prime minister said that Israel will ‘stand alone’ if needed in its attempt to defeat Hamas; White House said that Israel invading Rafah ‘will not advance that objective’. More than 100,000 flee Rafah as Israel steps up strikes, says UNBiden: US ...The Guardian - World - Israel -
The Zeyrek Cinili Hamam Is Restored in Istanbul
The Zeyrek Cinili Hamam, an early-Ottoman-era masterpiece, is restored to its original use as a public bathhouse.The New York Times - Lifestyle -
Colorado-based abortion fund sees rising demand. Many are from Texas, where procedure is restricted
A Colorado abortion fund said Thursday it’s helped hundreds access abortion in the first months of 2024, the majority arriving from Texas where abortion is restrictedABC News - Health - Abortion -
Biden heading to West Coast for major fundraisers
With the 2024 election less than six months away, President Biden is traveling to the West Coast on Thursday night to drum up support. Kevin Munoz, spokesperson for the national Biden 2024 campaign, joins "America Decides" to discuss what the ...CBS News - Top stories - Joe Biden -
Russia launches major offensive in Kharkiv region
Russian troops on Friday launched a major attack on Ukraine's Kharkiv region, forcing Ukrainian troops to reposition and defend against a new front. Russian forces appear to have launched the offensive from the Russia's Belgorod region and are ...The Hill - Politics - Russia -
Second major hospital chain hit by cyberattack
Presented by AstraZeneca — Change Healthcare was struck by a cyberattack earlier this year {beacon} Health Care Health Care The Big Story Second major hospital chain hit by cyberattack The largest Catholic hospital chain in the U.S. confirmed ...The Hill - Politics -
Virginia school board votes to restore names of Confederate leaders to schools
The school board in Shenandoah County, Virginia, early Friday approved a proposal that will restore the names of Confederate military leaders to two public schools.NBC News - Top stories -
Restoring a Chair Is Easier Than You Think. Ask the Brownstone Boys.
Jordan Slocum and Barry Bordelon have a lot of practice restoring brownstones in Brooklyn, so refinishing a chair was no big deal. Here’s how they did it.The New York Times - Lifestyle -
Virginia school board votes to restore Confederate names to two public schools
Schools changed their names after 2020 George Floyd protests, but will now revert to old names celebrating slave-state leaders. An all-white school board in Virginia has voted to restore the names of Robert E Lee and other Confederate military ...The Guardian - World -
Virginia school district restores names of Confederate generals to 2 schools
In a reversal experts believe was the first of its kind, Shenandoah County's school board voted 5-1 to rename Mountain View High School as Stonewall Jackson High School and Honey Run Elementary as Ashby Lee Elementary.CBS News - Top stories
More from The Hill
-
Why are economists MIA on today’s biggest fiscal catastrophes?
Economists are now strangely silent while watching public policies unfold that are neither equitable nor efficient.The Hill - Politics -
Sanders says Americans don't 'want to be complicit' in 'starvation' in Gaza
Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) on Sunday doubled down on his opposition to further U.S. aid to Israel, suggesting Americans do not want to be "complicit" in the starvation of children in Gaza. "Well, I understand...look, every Republican as I ...The Hill - Politics -
Bruising Maryland Senate primary comes down to the wire for Democrats
A photo finish could be in store in Maryland this week as Rep. David Trone (D-Md.) and Prince George's County Executive Angela Alsobrooks (D) fight for supremacy in what has turned into potentially the bloodiest primary on the Senate map this ...The Hill - Politics -
Senate Democrat defends criticism of US report on Israel war conduct
Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.) doubled down on his criticism of the U.S. report on Israeli war conduct released last week. The State Department released a report late Friday night concluding it was “reasonable to assess” Israel has violated ...The Hill - Politics - Israel -
Graham, Welker clash on Biden response in Israel
Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) clashed with NBC News anchor Kristen Welker after he maintained Israel should do "whatever it takes" to defeat Palestinian militant group Hamas in Gaza, while comparing Israel's wartime conduct to the U.S. dropping ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden