They still want 'one big, beautiful bill.' They're nowhere close.
House Republicans are still far from finalizing several key details of a budget blueprint that Speaker Mike Johnson is pledging to advance in the House next week, with negotiations expected to continue through the weekend as the Senate races ahead with its own plans.
While House GOP leaders trumpeted tremendous progress coming out of a White House meeting with President Donald Trump on Thursday, key holdouts on Trump’s sweeping agenda of tax cuts, border security and energy initiatives indicated Friday that they remained unconvinced about the level of spending cuts in the bill.
Separately, Republican tax writers continue to struggle with the ballooning costs of Trump’s wishlist, which includes not only an extension of his 2017 tax cut package, but also new income tax exemptions for tips, overtime earnings and Social Security benefits.
Meanwhile, Senate Budget Chair Lindsey Graham released a plan Friday that would get border and energy policies out the door first and save the thorny tax questions for later. That is directly at odds with House leadership plans to roll everything into a single bill.
House Republican hard-liners continued to push for deeper spending cuts. One prominent budget hawk complained that several key lawmakers were cut out of the White House meeting.
Leadership “failed to talk to us,” said Rep. Tim Burchett (R-Tenn).
“They go to the White House and they take all the people that are going to be for it, and there’s four of us that are pretty consistent, and we’ve let our views be known,” said Burchett, naming Reps. Andy Biggs (R-Ariz.), Victoria Spartz (R-Ind.) and Thomas Massie (R-K.y.) as the other critical holdouts.
“No surprise to me, because nobody ever wants to share any time with the president,” Burchett said.
Johnson, who had previously said Republicans would release a plan Friday, will now work through the weekend with other leaders to try to finalize an agreement. Senior Republicans aren’t expecting any final details until Monday — adding another delay to the speaker’s ambitious timeline.
Leaving the Capitol on Friday, Johnson confirmed in a brief interview that he hadn’t yet spoken with Burchett or similar holdouts. “We’re gonna get everybody there,” he quickly added.
Asked about the group saying they still have concerns about the level of spending cuts, Johnson replied: “Everybody does.”
Winning over Burchett and Massie is particularly critical. Neither lawmaker has ever voted to increase the debt limit, and Massie recently decried the fact that the GOP was considering enacting tax cuts at all.
In an interview Thursday night, Massie was noncommittal about Johnson’s latest plan, saying he’d have to “see if it's reasonable at the end of the day.”
But Johnson is now trying to wedge a debt limit hike into the massive budget package after Trump again pressed for it to be dealt with quickly during the White House meeting Thursday, according to two people who were in the room who were granted anonymity to discuss the private meeting.
That’s on top of the difficult tax-related issues that House Republicans have to sort through. Trump on Thursday announced new proposals to increase taxes on Wall Street money managers and sports team owners, alongside reiterating his desire for the income tax exemptions he campaigned on.
All of that adds to the pressure on the Ways and Means Committee to assemble a tax package that can remain fiscally palatable to Republicans who do not want to add to federal budget deficits. Already, leaders are looking at counting economic growth effects alongside spending cuts to keep the overall package’s costs in line.
GOP leaders had tentatively decided on Thursday they’re going to provide instructions to the House Ways and Means Committee that would allow tax writers $4.7 trillion leeway to enact Trump’s tax policies, according to a person familiar with the discussions who was granted anonymity to discuss the private deliberations.
The number has not been finalized and could change as negotiations continue.
“I think it’s getting the Ways and Means [budget] instruction just right,” said House Republican Conference Vice Chair Blake Moore (R-Utah) of the biggest obstacle to getting a plan finalized. “I think we’re all committed to finding the necessary spending reform and spending reductions.”
A longer-standing issue also hasn’t been resolved.
Rep. Mike Lawler (R-N.Y.), who has been pushing to increase the deduction for state and local taxes, commonly known as SALT, huddled with Johnson for several hours Thursday night. Blue-state Republicans have indicated that they won’t vote for a tax bill without an increase to SALT, but other members in the conference detest the deduction and say that any increase to the $10,000 cap needs to be paid for.
Lawler said on Friday that no agreement on SALT had been reached yet.
“The whole tax bill has to be paid for,” Lawler said. “It’s not just SALT. The president wants to do tax on tips and that has to be worked out.”
No matter what Congress’ official revenue scorer, the Congressional Budget Office, says about the costs on the GOP’s tax bill, Republicans have emphasized that they will be running their own economic models to determine how much growth would be stimulated by the various tax provisions. That, in turn, would lower the cost of their plan.
House Majority Leader Steve Scalise indicated Friday that Republicans were close to coming to an agreement on what those growth numbers look like. Notably, head rebel Rep. Chip Roy (R-Texas) sounded optimistic Friday. But he added there was more work to do.
“I think we’re in the ZIP code. There’s still some variables that I’m trying to study to figure out whether I think that’s correct. The levers are what are your assumptions on growth,” Roy said. “We need enough cuts, in my opinion, to sort of go hand in hand with the taxes.”
Topics
-
Angela Merkel Is Retired. But She’s Still on the Ballot.
If anything unites the parties in Germany’s election campaign, it is running away from the former chancellor, whose legacy voters have soured on.The New York Times - 28m -
Super Bowl Quiz: How Closely Did You Watch Philadelphia’s Win?
These questions will test your knowledge of the Eagles’ performance and how it fits into N.F.L. history.The New York Times - 1h -
Rockwell Automation crushes profit estimates but says customers are still cautious
Rockwell’s numbers eased investor concerns after the company missed sales estimates in three of the last six quarters.MarketWatch - 1h -
Kendrick Lamar's Super Bowl show was one big tease
The star hinted that he might not play his smash hit Not Like Us, but gave viewers plenty to absorb.BBC News - 10h -
Jeff Koons: Big ideas and big art
Controversial art world giant Jeff Koons works with teams of craftsmen to create his complex sculptures. His latest idea? He tells Anderson Cooper he plans to send artwork to the moon.CBS News - 14h -
Acting CFPB Chief Closes HQ, Stops Supervision
The decision to shutter the office comes less than 24 hours after Trump’s acting CFPB chief suspended all activities.Inc. - 17h -
Bill Belichick and his girlfriend troll the Falcons
For a guy who's supposedly all in with college football, Bill Belichick has spent plenty of time this week hanging around the NFL's marquee event.Yahoo Sports - 21h -
I'm a Beauty Writer, and These Are My 8 Favorite Products (2025)
Not all cosmetics are created equally. As a beauty writer, here are some standouts I’d recommend to a friend.Wired - 1d -
OpenAI Close to Deal that Values Company at $300 Billion
The Japanese conglomerate SoftBank would invest up to $40 billion in the maker of the chatbot ChatGPT.The New York Times - 2d -
Spaniards, still angry after floods, are struggling to rebuild
Yahoo News - 7h -
Why speculators are still running wild when money is no longer free
Something even bigger than AI and the Trump effect is at workFinancial Times - 9h -
Email Bill Murray live during the game. Yes, the Real Bill Murray
Bill's in a jam, and he wants your help. Got advice? A theory? A wild hunch? Email it to Billhimself@yahoo.com. He'll hit you back.Yahoo Sports - 14h -
Who performed 'America the Beautiful' at Super Bowl 2025? Get to know Lauren Daigle and Trombone Shorty
A look at who took the field ahead of the actionCBS Sports - 15h -
European football: Barça close in on leaders after thrashing Sevilla
Three goals and red card for Barça in second half McTominay scores but Napoli held 1-1 at home Barcelona earned a hard-fought 4-1 win at struggling Sevilla on Sunday thanks to goals by ...The Guardian - 16h -
Super Bowl 59: Heat's Erik Spoelstra wants Pat Riley to throw 'big ass party' if Chiefs pull off three-peat
Riley has the term 'three-peat' trademarked, so he's in line for a big payday if Kansas City beats the EaglesCBS Sports - 17h -
Russell Vought Orders Consumer Protection Bureau’s Headquarters Closed for a Week
The order to shutter the agency’s headquarters follows another order issued Saturday by Mr. Vought, who also leads the Office of Management and Budget, telling agency employees to halt nearly all ...The New York Times - 17h -
Super Bowl 2025: Andy Reid to break one of Bill Belichick's NFL playoff records when Chiefs face Eagles
The Chiefs head coach will have this record all to himselfCBS Sports - 18h -
Doctors, Nurses in Oregon Still on Strike
This is a MedPage Today story. As the strike by nearly 5,000 healthcare workers from Providence Health in Oregon reaches the 3-week mark, representatives from the Oregon Nurses Association (ONA) ...ABC News - 18h -
‘Anora’ Wins Big at Producers and Directors Guild Awards
The film that takes those two major industry prizes almost always goes on to win the best-picture Oscar.The New York Times - 23h -
Serbia and Albania move on from ‘drone’ game but tensions still simmer
Rivals will co-host the 2027 U-21 European Championship, years on from flashpoint that sparked a diplomatic incident. It was far more than a football flashpoint when, on a night in Belgrade that ...The Guardian - 1d -
R. Kelly accusers file petition seeking $9M singer still owes
Several of R. Kelly's victims filed a petition seeking to collect the more than $9 million still owed after they won a civil judgment against the disgraced singer.NBC News - 1d -
Woman's deepfake betrayal by close friend: 'Every moment turned into porn'
Australian teacher Hannah Grundy was left to track down the man posting deepfake pornography of her.BBC News - 1d -
The Los Angeles wildfires are finally contained, but Californians still aren’t safe
The smoke may be temporary, but toxic air pollution is an ever-present danger with effects that linger for generations.The Hill - 1d -
Emery hails Rashford's Villa move: 'Big potential'
Aston Villa boss Unai Emery has insisted that new loan signing Marcus Rashford has trained "fantastically" despite Manchester United's willingness to part ways.ESPN - 2d -
Australia close on series triumph after swatting aside Sri Lanka resistance
Sri Lanka 257 and 211-8;Australia 414 after day three Tourists only trail by 54 runs in the second Test Australia need only two wickets and a bit of gusto from the top order to defeat Sri Lanka ...The Guardian - 2d -
Nonalcoholic booze scores big ahead of the Super Bowl
Zero-proof beer sales are surging just as another major brand touts its newest boozeless brew during Sunday’s big game.NBC News - 2d -
The Suns' Big 3 is still together after the trade deadline, so the search for success continues
Kevin Durant, Devin Booker and Bradley Beal are still members of the Phoenix Suns after a tumultuous trade deadlineABC News - 2d -
Trump wants to deregulate. Progressives should help him.
From Jimmy Carter to Ted Kennedy, progressives once saw the wisdom of cutting red tape — especially if the tape tied the hands of consumers and would-be competitors in order to privilege industry ...The Hill - 2d -
Beauty stocks post major losses after a week of worrying results
Several beauty stocks tanked this week, as companies such as E.l.f. Beauty and Estee Lauder reported disappointing earnings and cut guidance.CNBC - 2d -
Chappell Roan was one of the 25 million uninsured Americans — here’s why health coverage is still out of reach for some artists
Chappell Roan used her Grammy acceptance speech to call out record labels for not providing better protections for artists struggling to afford health care.CNBC - 2d -
Why Trump wants an American sovereign wealth fund
The US does not really need a state investment vehicle — it is one alreadyFinancial Times - 2d -
Here's where the jobs are for January 2025 — in one chart
Health care and retail were strong areas for the U.S. economy in January.CNBC - 2d -
How Emma Hayes wants to revolutionize U.S. soccer
Emma Hayes, still in just her first year as head coach of the USWNT, is challenging long-held norms in women's soccer and pushing for a game built around female athletes.Yahoo Sports - 3d -
Black Entrepreneurship Has Grown 22 Percent. It’s Still Not Enough
Shark Tank’s Daymond John cites several reasons why the numbers still don’t reflect population baselines.Inc. - 3d -
One of Europe's most-wanted fugitives spotted at religious service
Jos Leijdekkers — also known as "Omar Sheriff" and "Chubby Jos" — is accused of trafficking cocaine and ordering a murder.CBS News - 4d -
'It got a little messy': Stephen Stills and Graham Nash on CSNY's early days
A new live album documents the first tour by Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young. 'We were a brand-new band just learning to play,' says Stephen Stills.Los Angeles Times - 4d
More from Politico
-
Capitol agenda: Johnson falls behind in budget race, Gabbard and RFK Jr. coming up
Politico - 2h -
Inside the House GOP clash over tax cuts
Hardliners are squaring off against their top tax writer as Republicans try to assemble a package President Donald Trump's priorities.Politico - 13h -
Jim Jordan backs Elon Musk’s authority to cut federal government
“It's something that people evaluated and voted for on November 5,” the Ohio Republican said.Politico - 21h -
As Trump steamrolls Washington, courts flex their power to slow him down
Numerous federal district judges around the country have blocked major portions of Trump's early agenda — but Supreme Court showdowns loom.Politico - 1d -
JD Vance Aced His First Test. The Next One Will Be Tougher.
The vice president wrangled a few holdout senators. Now he’s faced with taming an unruly House.Politico - 2d
More in Politics
-
DOJ asks court to lift Treasury order that limits DOGE access
President Trump’s Justice Department moved Sunday evening to lift a judge’s expansive ruling that prevents non-civil servants from accessing the Treasury Department’s payment systems, such as Elon ...The Hill - 37m -
Super Bowl halftime performer detained after unfurling Sudanese-Palestinian flag
A performer in Kendrick Lamar’s Super Bowl halftime show was detained late Sunday after showing a Sudanese-Palestinian flag on the field. The NFL confirmed to The Associated Press that the ...The Hill - 38m -
Trump’s nitwitted Gaza plan
Let’s move the 2 million permanently out of Gaza. But where? And how? And who will take them? Unclear.The Hill - 53m -
Trump ramps up NFL kickoff criticism after Super Bowl
President Trump ramped up his criticism of this season's new NFL kickoff rules in the wake of the Super Bowl late Sunday night. The NFL, to protect player safety, instituted new rules this year ...The Hill - 1h -
Senate Democrats launch portal for whistleblowers in Trump administration
Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) and Sen. Gary Peters (D-Mich.), the ranking member of the Senate Homeland Security Committee, said they are launching a new portal for whistleblowers ...The Hill - 1h