There are too many similarities between Trump and Nixon to ignore
Here is a radical thought. Whether history repeats, rhymes or reverts, despite two personalities that could not be more opposite, consider how similar President Richard Milhous Nixon's and Donald John Trump's policy actions are.
Both are disruptors. Nixon was cunning and secretive, too often devious and very insecure. Trump is noisy, boastful and publicly vengeful, calling for “transparency” and concealing his insecurity with braggadocio.
Nixon had “the silent majority” he believed supported him and his views on Vietnam as his political weapon. After the Kent State affair, in which untrained Ohio National Guard members opened fire on students protesting the war, killing four and wounding a dozen others, many of the silent majority blamed the students.
Nixon, faced with ending the Vietnam War, saw the Soviet Union and China as the centers of strategic gravity in setting policy. In these efforts, allies and friends were critical. But aside from a nonexistent plan to end the Vietnam War, his policy was conducted in complete secrecy and guarded by illegal wiretaps and break-ins to prevent leaks.
In this regard, the most sensitive negotiations with North Vietnam and the National Liberation Front were conducted without the knowledge of the U.S. secretary of State and Nguyen Van Thieu’s South Vietnamese government. And when risks were required, Nixon took them.
Balancing China and the Soviet Union required great delicacy, much of which came from National Security Advisor Henry Kissinger. After North Vietnam launched the highly unsuccessful 1972 Easter Offensive, and with Nixon’s breakthrough visit to China in the balance, the president unleashed fearsome air attacks that destroyed the enemy onslaught, questioning the trip. It went forward.
In December 1972, just before the historic trip to the Soviet Union to sign the Antiballistic Missile Treaty, Hanoi backtracked from the peace accords for Vietnam. Nixon, unimpressed, raised the ante with bombings and mining of the north’s key port at Haiphong. North Vietnam relented and Nixon’s trip to China changed the strategic balance of the Cold War with this rapprochement.
The larger goals of Nixon’s foreign policies were to create a detente with the Soviet Union while befriending China to allow a “peace with honor” in Vietnam that would hold beyond the November 1972 election. He created the Nixon Doctrine in which the U.S. assumed responsibility for global stability and regional powers with greater roles in local defense. And he created the Twin Pillars policy in the Gulf aligning Iran under the Shah and the Saudis against the greater Soviet threat.
Domestically, Nixon was equally disruptive. To deal with economic issues, he imposed wage and price controls and severed the dollar from the gold standard. And he created the Environmental Protection Agency as a strong advocate of the environment.
His cabinet was strong and Nixon was anxious to return power to the states, and was defeated by a Republican House. Much of this that was highly disruptive was accomplished without great fanfare.
Trump is bombast. In foreign policy, he thrives in public disruption. He threatens NATO to spend more on defense or else. He bullies and insults Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelensky accusing him of starting the war with Russia as well as being a dictator. He tilts toward Russia’s President Vladimir Putin and China’s Xi Jinping.
And he does so publicly through near-daily press conferences, tweets on his social network, Truth Social, or frequent appearances on Fox News.
Mobilizing Make America Great Again supporters, Trump is using tariffs to make America richer again; by all historical accounts, measures that have failed and are near certain to tank the U.S. and possible international economies.
And he demands unrelenting loyalty from highly controversial members with questionable experience and standing in his cabinet. While Nixon altered government through his cabinet, Trump is using the flamethrower approach of his Department of Government Efficiency and the world’s richest man, chainsaw Elon Musk.
Aside from styles and personalities that could not be more different, the similarities between the two presidents come with one big difference. Nixon was never impeached, as he instead resigned under pressure over Watergate. Trump was twice impeached and not convicted. Yet he is a convicted felon.
Trump’s presidency has 42 months to go. Do not be surprised if Trump shares a Nixonian tragic ending to complete the similarities.
Harlan Ullman Ph.D. is UPI’s Arnaud deBorchgrave Distinguished Columnist, a senior advisor at Washington D.C.’s Atlantic Council, the chairman of two private companies and the principal author of the doctrine of shock and awe. He and David Richards are authors of the forthcoming book, “The Arc of Failure: Can Decisive Strategic Thinking Transform a Dangerous World.”
-
'Tariffs break trust': How Trump's trade policy is putting pressure on U.S. farmers
American farmers could ultimately feel even more pain as a result of President Donald Trump's tariffs on Canada, Mexico and China.CNBC - 6d -
Trump's 'America First' policies are boosting stock markets overseas
President Donald Trump’s policies are sending tremors through Wall Street, but they’re having the opposite effect an ocean away.NBC News - 3d -
Trump administration ignores judge's order to divert 2 flights back to US: Sources
President Donald Trump's administration decided to ignore a judge's order to turn around two flights containing alleged Venezuelan gang members, sources said.ABC News - 1d -
Trump considers four bids to buy TikTok as deadline for deal looms
President Donald Trump is considering four bids to purchase the social media app TikTok. NBC News’ Steve Romo reports on who the potential buyers could be ahead of the pause on TikTok set to expire.NBC News - Mar. 11 -
Why Trump's rapidly changing economic policies are raising stagflation alarms
If there was one thing President Donald Trump was supposed to represent to many voters, it was the prospect of an upturn in their economic fortunes.NBC News - 6d -
Trump economic advisor Kevin Hassett warns of more uncertainty over tariffs
President Donald Trump has shrugged off calls for more clarity about his policies, even as they stoke turmoil in the markets.CNBC - 1d -
Elon Musk could be a bridge between the U.S. and China — but for which country’s benefit?
Tech billionaire Elon Musk’s financial interests in China have raised concern that they could influence his work as a senior adviser to President Donald Trump.NBC News - 2d -
Trump calls arrest of Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil ‘first of many to come’
President says in post his administration ‘will not tolerate’ actions of protesters at Columbia and other US universities. Donald Trump said on Monday that the arrest of a prominent Palestinian ...The Guardian - Mar. 10 -
Stock-market bulls abandoned by Trump won’t be saved by Jerome Powell and the Fed
President Donald Trump signaled to stock-market investors last week that they’re on their own. Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell will likely deliver a similar message when monetary policymakers ...MarketWatch - 2d
More from The Hill
-
Democrats must strike a balance between strength and empathy
Elon Musk has expressed contempt for empathy, calling it a fundamental weakness of Western civilization, and has criticized programs such as Social Security and the funding for fresh food for ...The Hill - 36m -
Interior offers employee buyouts as job cuts loom
The Interior Department will offer buyouts to some employees as it eyes major staffing cuts. In a notice obtained by The Hill, employees were told that they could apply for voluntary early ...The Hill - 36m -
Newsom advances cross-border climate, clean energy partnership with Sonora, Mexico
California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) and his counterpart in Sonora, Mexico, have cemented a bilateral partnership with the aim of bolstering clean energy development and supply chain resilience for ...The Hill - 37m -
Fani Willis violated open records law, judge finds
Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis was found to be in violation of the state’s Open Records Act as outlined in a judge’s Friday ruling ordering her to present requested documents and pay ...The Hill - 42m -
Kinzinger dares Trump to charge him for Jan. 6 panel role: 'Bring it'
Former Rep. Adam Kinzinger (R-Ill.) on Monday welcomed a legal battle with President Trump over the House select committee that investigated the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the Capitol — hours after ...The Hill - 42m
More in Politics
-
Texas midwife, assistant arrested for providing illegal abortions, state AG says
Paxton said that Maria "Dr. Maria" Rojas is a known midwife in Northwest Houston and was taken into custody in Waller County.CBS News - 36m -
Democrats must strike a balance between strength and empathy
Elon Musk has expressed contempt for empathy, calling it a fundamental weakness of Western civilization, and has criticized programs such as Social Security and the funding for fresh food for ...The Hill - 36m -
Interior offers employee buyouts as job cuts loom
The Interior Department will offer buyouts to some employees as it eyes major staffing cuts. In a notice obtained by The Hill, employees were told that they could apply for voluntary early ...The Hill - 36m -
Newsom advances cross-border climate, clean energy partnership with Sonora, Mexico
California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) and his counterpart in Sonora, Mexico, have cemented a bilateral partnership with the aim of bolstering clean energy development and supply chain resilience for ...The Hill - 37m -
Fani Willis violated open records law, judge finds
Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis was found to be in violation of the state’s Open Records Act as outlined in a judge’s Friday ruling ordering her to present requested documents and pay ...The Hill - 42m