The West is failing to rise to the challenge of Russia’s threat
Norwegian Minister of Foreign Affairs Espen Barth Eide recently told a Ukrainian journalist that “I think we should all be honest and say: Nobody does enough” to help Ukraine defeat Putin’s Russia. Eide had in mind the countries of NATO, which is currently celebrating the 75th anniversary of its founding on April 4, 1949.
Let’s look more closely at Eide’s statement. The logical proposition underpinning it is this: If you believe, as Eide and most NATO countries claim to, that Putin’s Russia is an existential threat to Europe, then you will do everything possible to counter that threat by helping Ukraine win.
Now consider the “contrapositive,” whereby the negation of the conclusion logically implies the negation of the premise: If, as Eide says, one is not doing everything possible to help Ukraine, then it follows that one does not consider Putin’s Russia to be an existential threat to Europe.
The conclusion is inescapable: NATO countries talk about the Russian threat, but their dilly-dallying, their insufficient support of Ukraine and their unwillingness to impose truly punitive sanctions all testify to the fact that they don’t really mean what they say.
In this respect, Hungary’s tinpot authoritarian prime minister, Viktor Orbán, and his counterpart in Slovakia, Robert Fico, are being honest. They openly support Putin because they share his totalitarian values and admire his hard-knuckled regime. Ditto for Donald Trump and his MAGA Republican base. Why worry about Ukraine and Russia if a Russian victory means only that “family values” will triumph and lucrative commercial relations with Russia can resume?
Some instances of Putinophilia are less explicable. Consider the well-known Columbia University economist Jeffrey Sachs, who still believes that NATO wanted to accept Ukraine into its ranks and that the U.S. engineered a “coup” during the Revolution of Dignity of 2014. Not only is there absolutely no evidence to support his claims — if anything, NATO suffered from “Ukraine fatigue” and couldn’t even begin to imagine Ukrainian membership in anyone’s lifetime — but to reduce Ukrainian “people power” to a CIA plot is not only preposterous, but deeply insulting to the millions of Ukrainians who took to the streets and risked their lives in 2014. Small wonder, alas, that Sachs is a regular on some of the crudest Russian propaganda talk shows.
At this point, critics of Putin, like me, will jump into the fray and insist that Russia is a mortal threat, not just to Ukraine, but to all of Europe, the United States and indeed the world. We’ll also insist that this is so obviously, so manifestly the case that only a dolt would fail to recognize that Putin is the 21st century’s answer to Adolf Hitler. Our arguments are legion, and few have made the case for immediate assistance to Ukraine better than Yale University historian Timothy Snyder.
And yet, not only do the Orbáns and Ficos and their cheerleaders remain unpersuaded, but evidently so too do the Americans and most Europeans, including Eide’s Norway. The Baltic states definitely see the threat — their geographic proximity to Russia makes sure of that. French President Emmanuel Macron has recently seen the light and gone over to the side of Putin’s strongest critics, albeit rhetorically, but even Poland, which is one of Ukraine’s most steadfast allies, doesn’t seem to get that blocking its border to Ukrainian trucks and ruining Ukraine’s economy is no way to show its understanding of the Russian threat.
The U.S. is the biggest hypocrite. Except for a small group of Trump’s diehard supporters in Congress, the American political class claims to overwhelmingly support Ukraine and to comprehend the magnitude of the Russian threat. And yet, Washington has proven to be incapable of subordinating election politics and personal ambitions to the distinct possibility that a Ukrainian defeat would spell continued Russian expansion and World War III — and the deaths of thousands of Americans.
It’s hard not to conclude that most Western states just don’t really believe that Putin is Hitler. How is that possible?
It may be that policymakers and publics are just hoping that it’s all a bad dream and that all will be well when they wake up. Unfortunately, if Putin has his way, their sleep may prove to be permanent.
It may also be that democracy’s wheels turn slowly and that aid to Ukraine will come, eventually. But back in the 1940s, the United Kingdom and the United States evinced the requisite political will, adopted radical measures and managed to turn out phenomenal numbers of weapons in the shortest of times.
In other words, it may all come down to leadership, a point that Atlantic Council President Fred Kempe emphasizes in his columns. The West lacks a Winston Churchill or Franklin D. Roosevelt to mobilize their nations and meet the Russian threat squarely and unflinchingly.
The irony is that Putin is a serial bungler, a strategic nincompoop who could easily be outmaneuvered and outfoxed by a Western leader with the guts to try. Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelensky has, for all his faults, risen to the occasion and, despite his lack of political experience, managed to rally the nation and say no to Putin. So it’s possible for strong leaders to emerge even today. And Zelensky proves that one doesn’t have to be a heavyweight to punch like a heavyweight.
Unfortunately, President Joe Biden has failed to lead the world against Putin. Donald Trump has demonstrated that he can’t lead, period.
That may leave the fate of Ukraine and the West in Monsieur Macron’s hands. Can he rise to the occasion and become Charles de Gaulle?
Alexander J. Motyl is a professor of political science at Rutgers University-Newark. A specialist on Ukraine, Russia and the USSR, and on nationalism, revolutions, empires and theory, he is the author of 10 books of nonfiction, as well as “Imperial Ends: The Decay, Collapse, and Revival of Empires” and “Why Empires Reemerge: Imperial Collapse and Imperial Revival in Comparative Perspective.”
Date: | |
Tag: | Russia |
Filter
-
Russia to hold nuclear drills following 'threats' from West
Yahoo News - World - Russia -
Russia to hold nuclear drills following 'threats' from West
Russia will hold tactical nuclear weapons drills in response to recent comments by France and the UK, the Kremlin said.BBC News - Top stories - Russia -
Russia to Hold Drills on Tactical Nuclear Weapons in New Tensions With West
Russian officials claimed the order was in response to comments from the West about the possibility of more direct involvement in Ukraine. NATO called Russia’s announcement “irresponsible.”The New York Times - Top stories - Russia -
How Humans Failed Racehorses
An exploration of the troubled state of horse racing in the U.S.The New York Times - Top stories -
6 Ways Businesses Can Fail From the Beginning
Dramatically increase your startup's chances for success by pairing due diligence with intentionality in your planning and focus.Inc. - Business -
Lopetegui in West Ham talks amid Moyes uncertainty
West Ham hold talks with Julen Lopetegui and could make a decision on boss David Moyes' future before the end of the season.BBC News - Top stories -
Chris Mason: Evening of drama as Labour squeak West Midlands win
Labour won with just over 1,500 votes more than the Tories in an incredibly close race.BBC News - Top stories -
Chelsea thrash West Ham to stay on track for Europe
Chelsea strengthen their chances of securing European football next season as they cruise to victory against West Ham at Stamford Bridge.BBC News - Top stories - Premier League -
Moyes 'really sorry' for West Ham display at Chelsea
Manager David Moyes apologises to West Ham fans after watching their side fall to a heavy defeat at Chelsea.BBC News - Top stories -
Lopetegui agrees to become West Ham manager
Julen Lopetegui agrees a deal to become West Ham manager in the summer.BBC News - Top stories
More from The Hill
-
‘RuPaul’s Drag Race All Stars’ strut stuff on National Mall
The cast of “RuPaul’s Drag Race All Stars” took to a different kind of stage Monday morning, sashaying down Washington’s National Mall to promote the ninth season of the Emmy-nominated reality series. The cast of eight “Drag Race” alumni arrived ...The Hill - Politics -
Social Security funds to last longer than expected thanks to sturdy economy
The combined trust funds for Social Security are projected to run out a year later than previously expected, a board of trustees of the program’s accounts said Monday. In the latest report, trustees expect the projected depletion date for the ...The Hill - Politics -
Greene 'going to lose' Johnson ouster effort, Mace says
Rep. Nancy Mace (R-S.C.) sharply criticized Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.) for pushing forward with her effort to oust Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) from his post despite the prevailing consensus in the conference against such an effort. ...The Hill - Politics -
Hormel recalls Planters nuts products in 5 states over listeria concerns
Certain Planters nuts products have been voluntarily recalled in five states due to listeria concerns, the company announced last week. Hormel Foods announced on Friday it was voluntarily recalling some of Planters honey roasted peanuts and ...The Hill - Politics -
US soldier detained in Russia, White House confirms
A U.S. soldier was detained in Russia last week, a National Security Council spokesperson confirmed Monday. “The State Department is actively seeking consular access to this individual, who was not in Russia on behalf of or in affiliation with the ...The Hill - Politics - Russia