The US sends wrong signals on Israel and democracy
President Biden recently declared that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is not doing enough to reach a deal with Hamas to free the hostages the terrorist organization has been holding since last Oct. 7. This pronouncement was both ill-targeted and ill-timed, proving once again that Washington often doesn’t know when and when not to meddle in the affairs of other nations.
Biden’s rebuke, which he directed against the leader of America’s closest regional ally, came a day after Israel Defense Forces found the bodies of four male and two female hostages in Hamas’ tunnels under Gaza. Hamas executed the six with “multiple close-range gunshots,” in all likelihood when it discovered that the Israeli military was about to rescue them after nearly 11 months.
His rebuke also came 15 years after President Obama took a decidedly different approach toward America’s fiercest regional adversary, at a time when millions of demonstrators across Iran were protesting the results of a blatantly fraudulent election that returned hard-line President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad to power.
In the early days of a government crackdown that left dozens killed, hundreds arrested and thousands beaten, Obama refused to put Washington on the side of democracy-seeking protestors, saying, “[I]t’s not productive, given the history of U.S.-Iranian relations, to be seen as meddling — the U.S. president meddling in Iranian elections.”
Biden and Obama are both Democrats, but this is no partisan affliction. Presidents of both parties have often chastised our democratic allies while refusing to support democratic stirrings in authoritarian lands.
In August of 1991, the Soviet Union seemed on the verge of collapse and its various republics were eying independence, including Ukraine, whose people had suffered for centuries under Russian, Soviet and other outside oppression.
President George H. W. Bush favored ongoing U.S.-Soviet ties and continued global stability over the democratic aspirations of the Ukrainian people when he told Ukraine’s parliament, “Americans will not support those who seek… to replace a far-off tyranny with a local despotism. They will not aid those who promote a suicidal nationalism based upon ethnic hatred.”
What does all this show? That Washington continues to get things backwards. Broadly speaking, the United States advocates the ideals of freedom and democracy. All too often, however, we take our democratic allies to task even though their people have the means to choose, and change, their own government. At the same time, we often fail to put America on the side of those seeking freedom and democracy in authoritarian nations, for fear of complicating relations with their governments.
All that weakens the U.S. abroad. Allies wonder whether we’re a reliable partner; adversaries question whether we’ve got the fortitude to protect our interests; and pro-democracy activists who seek our backing (and perhaps our clandestine help) later remember whether we provided it.
We weaken ourselves in another way as well. All else being equal, a freer, more democratic world is a safer, more prosperous one. Democracies rarely if ever go to war with one another, and they trade and invest more with one another. The more we can strengthen our democratic allies and inspire would-be democrats, the more that Americans will reap the benefits in more security and prosperity.
As we continue sending the wrong signals to allies and adversaries, our timing couldn’t be worse. China, Russia, Iran and other like-minded nations are promoting an authoritarian model of governance around the world as an alternative to U.S.-led democracy. Their efforts — and the growing inability of our own democracy to perform even basic functions — are having a discernable effect.
In February, Freedom House reported that global freedom fell for the 18th straight year in 2023, marking the longest such trend since the nonprofit began tracking political rights and civil liberties around the world in 1972.
As for Israel, the retrieval of the bodies of six slain hostages has ignited public protests as hostage families and others demand that Netanyahu ink a hostage deal with Hamas. The prime minister faces mounting criticism from defense officials and a wide range of Israeli opinion leaders that he hasn’t done enough to make it happen.
Maybe so. But as the angry protests and robust debate in Israel make clear, that’s an issue that Israelis themselves have the power to decide.
The people of Gaza have no such power. Hamas rules the territory with an iron fist, brooking no dissent.
Rather than chastise the leader of a vibrant democracy that’s fighting wars on multiple fronts, America’s leaders should aim their ire at the genocidal autocrats who slaughtered 1,200 Israelis, continue to hold about 100 hostages, threaten to kill them rather than allow their rescue, and – by the way — continue to oppose any deal that would not let them regroup to launch more attacks on the Jewish state.
Lawrence J. Haas is a senior fellow at the American Foreign Policy Council and the author of, most recently, “The Kennedys in the World: How Jack, Bobby, and Ted Remade America’s Empire.”
Date: | |
Tag: | Israel |
-
The Hill - Politics
83 percent of young adults are worried about state of US democracy
The vast majority of young adults say they are worried about the state of U.S. democracy, according to a poll published Tuesday by the Sine Institute for Policy and Politics at American University. ...Yesterday -
BBC News - Top stories
Scotland's wrong and winding road that never was
Almost five miles long, the road up one of Scotland's highest mountains would have had 14 hairpins.20 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
The West must stand with Georgia in the fight for democracy
To guarantee a brighter European future for the people of Georgia, it is vital for the international community to help guarantee truly free and fair electionsYesterday -
BBC News - Top stories
Jones 'wrong' about my leadership ability - Itoje
Maro Itoje says former England head coach Eddie Jones was wrong about his leadership ability as he prepares to take over the captaincy at Saracens.9 hours ago -
ESPN - Sports
Liverpool send 'prayers' after fan dies in Milan
A Liverpool fan who traveled to Italy to watch the Champions League game against AC Milan has died following a road traffic accident, the Premier League club said Tuesday.17 hours ago -
Financial Times - Business
Fed cuts rates by half a point and signals era of easing has begun
US central bank’s decision marks a milestone in its two-year fight against inflation4 hours ago - Federal Reserve -
ABC News - World
Democracy declined for 8th straight year around the globe, institute finds
An organization promoting democracy says last year had the worst decline in credible elections and parliamentary oversight in almost a half-century2 days ago -
Financial Times - Business
Vanguard experiment in shareholder democracy finds investors prefer to defer
Nearly half of participants in pilot programme allowed to vote their shares chose to let the asset manager do it for themYesterday -
The Hill - Politics
Lemon on CNN says Trump should 'stop threatening democracy'
Former CNN anchor Don Lemon returned to the network Tuesday for an interview on "OutFront" with Erin Burnett, in which he said former President Trump’s hate-filled comments are fueling violence ...Yesterday - Donald Trump -
The New York Times - Sports
Brock Purdy’s Detractors Are Lining Up. It’s Time to Prove Them Wrong.
As San Francisco’s injuries pile up, the quarterback needs to lead his team through this rough patch, a columnist for The Athletic writes.20 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Republican Arizona county chair endorses Democrat to replace him
The Republican chair of the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors in Arizona has endorsed a Democrat to replace him. "I am endorsing Joel [Navarro] because he is a man of integrity, because he is a ...59 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Newark official wins special election to fill late New Jersey Rep. Payne's seat
Newark City Council President LaMonica McIver (D) has won the special election to fill a vacant House seat representing New Jersey’s 10th Congressional District, according to Decision Desk HQ. ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
RFK Jr. says he's helping Trump pick leaders of FDA, NIH, CDC
Former independent presidential candidate and antivaccine advocate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said that former President Trump wants him to choose leaders for key public health agencies if he wins the ...2 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
EPA retaliated against three scientists, says watchdog
Presented by TerraPower — The Environmental Protection Agency’s internal watchdog has found that the agency retaliated against three staffers for expressing different scientific opinions. {beacon} ...2 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
House GOP torpedoes Speaker Johnson’s funding bill
House Republicans voted down Speaker Mike Johnson's proposal to fund the government, leaving the path to averting a shutdown unclear and putting Johnson in danger of disappointing former President ...2 hours ago - House