The savings from shuttering USAID aren’t worth the global costs
I recently returned from Ethiopia, where I help to lead a program that has trained essentially all of the pulmonary physicians in that country. During my visit, I spoke at the annual scientific meeting of the Ethiopian Thoracic Society. I have attended that meeting many times; every year there is also a presentation from the leader of the USAID-supported Ethiopian national tuberculosis control program.
Just recently, in fact, USAID announced a major new initiative to control and prevent tuberculosis (including drug-resistant tuberculosis) in Ethiopia, which is classified by the World Health Organization as a high-burden country for tuberculosis.
This year, there was no representative from USAID at the meeting to discuss the tuberculosis situation in Ethiopia or plans to combat the disease. My colleagues in Ethiopia who had organized the meeting told me that their emails and phone calls to their USAID colleagues had gone unanswered.
This of course occurred in the wake of the recent decision in Washington to shutter the agency. Despite assurances that support of vital programs in areas such as AIDS, malaria and tuberculosis would continue, this does not appear to be the case.
Ethiopia is a very poor country and the largest recipient of USAID funds in sub-Saharan Africa, at roughly $1 billion annually, a mere 0.015 percent of the annual U.S. budget. A great deal of that money goes to food aid, but significant funds support efforts in disease control and public health. The consequences of withdrawing support for activities such as the national tuberculosis program could be devastating.
In recent years Ethiopia, with USAID support, has made significant strides in adopting modern tuberculosis diagnostics and in providing new and more effective regimens to patients with drug-resistant tuberculosis. What will happen without continued support of that program? Patients will go longer before their tuberculosis is diagnosed. Their lungs will be more extensively damaged, so that even after cure of their tuberculosis they will be left with life-long pulmonary impairment. Potentially most worrisome of all, rates of drug-resistant tuberculosis will likely rise.
Several years ago, I worked on a project to try to understand the epidemiology of drug-resistant tuberculosis in Kazakhstan, a country with an astoundingly high rate of that particular form of the disease. In fact, the highest rates of drug-resistant tuberculosis are today mostly found in Russia and the countries of the former Soviet Union.
I had a conversation with the physician who was then head of the national tuberculosis control program in Kazakhstan, and I asked him what the genesis of the problem was. He explained to me that at the time the Soviet Union collapsed, there was no money available for the public health authorities to purchase enough antibiotics to allow effective treatment of tuberculosis patients who had fallen ill and to sustain a functioning national tuberculosis program. Prescribing and administration of drugs became erratic and incomplete, which is a recipe for generating drug-resistance.
This was all true. Thousands of patients died from drug-resistant forms of tuberculosis, a disease that is usually quite curable. Thirty-five years later, the problem is still severe in those countries. Although better and more effective drugs and regimens are now available to treat drug-resistant tuberculosis, those drugs are more expensive than older drugs, and they require careful administration and monitoring.
Withdrawal of USAID support will severely threaten tuberculosis control efforts in Ethiopia and in many other countries around the world. Tuberculosis remains largely a disease of countries with limited resources, and aid from the U.S. has been critical making progress in many of those countries. Funds from USAID support the introduction of advanced diagnostic techniques and the purchase of adequate quantities of the safest, most effective drugs to treat all forms of the disease. And of course, as with all infectious diseases, the microorganisms that cause tuberculosis don’t know anything about national boundaries.
Tuberculosis is an ancient disease that over centuries has claimed the lives of millions of people. The modern era of treatment began only in the middle of the 20th century, and now we are able to cure the vast, vast majority of patients with drugs that should be available to everyone, everywhere. Hermann Biggs, a pioneering physician in public health in New York in the early part of the 20th century, famously said, “Public health is purchasable. Within natural limitations a community can determine its own death-rate.”
Withdrawing support for the diagnosis and treatment of malaria, HIV infection and tuberculosis will have predictable consequences. The amount of money that is saved by closing USAID will likely have very little impact in the U.S., but in the countries where that money was to have been spent, the consequences will be enormous and deadly.
Neil Schluger, M.D., Dean School of Medicine, New York Medical College.
| 2d 11:00 AM ET ago |
Topics
-
World Health Organization warns of possible tuberculosis surge because of USAID cuts
Health authorities say that the Trump administration’s gutting of USAID raises the risk of a global surge in tuberculosis cases and deaths.NBC News - Mar. 9 -
Trump’s USAid cuts will have huge impact on global climate finance, data shows
Campaigners say funding halt is a ‘staggering blow’ to vulnerable nations and to efforts to keep heating below 1.5C. Donald Trump’s withdrawal of US overseas aid will almost decimate global climate ...The Guardian - Mar. 10 -
The country that kicked out USAID
Two decades after Eritrea expelled the American agency, other nations must now find a way to survive without itFinancial Times - Mar. 19 -
Ethiopia introduces new tax to fill gap after USAID funding pause
Ethiopia’s parliament is introducing a new tax for all workers as part of measures to fill the financial gap left by the USAID funding pauseABC News - 6d -
Musk and Doge’s USAid shutdown likely violated US constitution, judge rules
Judge halts efforts to fire USAid workers, a major setback in administration’s attempts to bulldoze federal government. Never miss global breaking news. Download our free app to keep up with key ...The Guardian - Mar. 18 -
Musk's efforts to close USAID are likely unconstitutional, judge rules
A federal judge ordered the government to reinstate USAID systems, ruling that the shutdown of the agency led by Elon Musk and DOGE "likely violated the United States Constitution in multiple ways."NBC News - Mar. 18 -
Trump silencing VOA threatens free media in repressive countries, advocates say
Trump’s order to cut funding to Voice of America and several other pro-democracy media outlets has drawn widespread criticism from press freedom organizations.ABC News - Mar. 18 -
USAID order to delete classified records sparks flurry of litigation
U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) employees and outside groups are fighting an order from the agency’s leadership to shred and burn its classified documents as well as personnel ...The Hill - Mar. 12 -
DOGE removes details on canceled USAID contracts from "wall of receipts"
Due to "ongoing litigation," the Department of Government Efficiency removed details from its website on the more than 3,000 USAID contracts it claims to have canceled.CBS News - 4h
More from The Hill
-
Brit Hume scolds administration for 'making a mess' in Signal chat response
Fox News’ political commentator Brit Hume scolded President Trump’s administration for “making a mess” in response to the Signal group chat revelation where top national security officials were ...The Hill - 53m -
Trump administration revokes state and local health funding
The Department of Health and Human Services is canceling tens of billions of dollars in federal grants that state and local health departments were using to track infectious diseases, health ...The Hill - 1h -
Former HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius worries over 'devastating' cuts to research funding
Former Health and Human Services (HHS) Secretary Kathleen Sebelius is concerned about the Trump administration’s recent cuts to research grants through the National Institutes of Health (NIH). ...The Hill - 2h -
Appeals court keeps block on Trump’s sweeping funding freeze
The United States Court of Appeals for the 1st Circuit upheld U.S. District Judge John McConnell’s ruling Wednesday, keeping a block on the Trump administration’s plans to freeze federal loans and ...The Hill - 2h -
GOP fundraiser calls for Witkoff's firing over Putin, Hamas comments
GOP fundraiser Eric Levine called for President Trump’s special envoy Steve Witkoff to be fired over the diplomat’s recent comments about Russian President Vladimir Putin, arguing the president’s ...The Hill - 2h
More in Politics
-
Brit Hume scolds administration for 'making a mess' in Signal chat response
Fox News’ political commentator Brit Hume scolded President Trump’s administration for “making a mess” in response to the Signal group chat revelation where top national security officials were ...The Hill - 53m -
Trump administration revokes state and local health funding
The Department of Health and Human Services is canceling tens of billions of dollars in federal grants that state and local health departments were using to track infectious diseases, health ...The Hill - 1h -
Former HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius worries over 'devastating' cuts to research funding
Former Health and Human Services (HHS) Secretary Kathleen Sebelius is concerned about the Trump administration’s recent cuts to research grants through the National Institutes of Health (NIH). ...The Hill - 2h -
Appeals court keeps block on Trump’s sweeping funding freeze
The United States Court of Appeals for the 1st Circuit upheld U.S. District Judge John McConnell’s ruling Wednesday, keeping a block on the Trump administration’s plans to freeze federal loans and ...The Hill - 2h -
GOP fundraiser calls for Witkoff's firing over Putin, Hamas comments
GOP fundraiser Eric Levine called for President Trump’s special envoy Steve Witkoff to be fired over the diplomat’s recent comments about Russian President Vladimir Putin, arguing the president’s ...The Hill - 2h