The retaliatory firing of USAID’s inspector general is a travesty
Any question about the motives behind President Trump’s decision to fire 18 independent, nonpartisan inspectors general in the middle of the night three weeks ago was answered by this week’s firing of the inspector general for the U.S. Agency for International Development. These firings were designed to impede and deter independent oversight of the Trump administration, putting taxpayer dollars and program performance at risk.
On Monday, USAID Inspector General Paul Martin did precisely what inspectors general are charged with doing. His office made public the results of an independent analysis designed to promote efficiency and to prevent and detect fraud, waste and abuse — in this case, in USAID programs and operations.
More specifically, the purpose of this report was to “identify risks and challenges to the safeguarding and distribution of USAID’s $8.2 billion in obligated but undisbursed humanitarian assistance funds following the State Department’s pause on foreign assistance programs and subsequent personnel actions by USAID that have substantially reduced the operational capacity of its Bureau of Humanitarian Assistance.”
The report found that both actions severely compromised USAID’s operations and the dollars already allocated to its programs. One particularly egregious example was that over $480 million in food assistance was at risk of spoilage and diversion and, in the absence of personnel to conduct required vetting, the program was exposed to potential involvement by terrorist organizations.
The USAID inspector general’s report serves as Exhibit A on the need for independent oversight. This is exactly the work that the more than 70 federal inspectors general are charged with doing, along with their state and local counterparts across the country.
Just one day after the USAID report was made public, and on the same day that eight of the previously-fired inspectors general rightly filed a lawsuit, the executive branch rebuke came fast and furious. And by email: “On behalf of President Donald J. Trump, I am writing to inform you that your position as Inspector General of the United States Agency for International Development is terminated, effective immediately. Thank you for your service.” Full stop.
This should shock the conscience, for two reasons.
First, as I and others have noted over the last several weeks, evidence-free firings of federal inspectors general are a flagrant violation of the law requiring a 30-day notice to Congress and the enumeration of detailed and case-specific substantive rationale for such terminations.
Second, it is a plainly retaliatory abuse of executive power, inconsistent with democratic norms, including both nonpartisan oversight and public transparency. If an independent oversight professional can be summarily fired for doing his or her job — investigating the actions of the executive branch and making the findings public — there will be a permanent chilling effect on oversight agencies across the country.
Nikolai Gogol’s 1836 play “The Inspector General” satirizes a Russian town in which a corrupt mayor mistakes a visitor for an inspector general who was expected to arrive for a planned oversight visit. Throughout the play, the mayor and his cronies flatter and bribe the visitor in hopes of buying a favorable report. The visitor ultimately leaves, now engaged to the mayor’s daughter. Then, it is revealed that the real inspector is on his way, much to the embarrassment of the mayor for directing his corruption toward the wrong person.
I don’t know Inspector General Martin, but his reputation is well-known in the inspector general community and he was no sham inspector. In the 12-month period preceding last September, his office conducted 67 audits and inspections covering funds totaling more than $58 billion. During former President Joe Biden’s term, Martin’s office identified and reported on the sending of funds by the administration to a terrorism-linked nonprofit organization and about USAID’s failures to apply due diligence in the vetting of international spending more generally.
Neither of these reports reflected well on the Biden administration, but both exemplified an inspector general doing exactly what his job demanded: following the facts where they led. That the findings reflected poorly on the executive branch was — properly — not relevant.
In the final scene of Gogol’s play, the humiliated corrupt mayor breaks the fourth wall, screaming at the audience, “What are you laughing about? You are laughing about yourselves!” And indeed, if we sit idly by as an audience to this illegal and unprecedented weaponization of the inspectors general by an American president, the joke will ultimately be on us.
Lucy Lang serves as New York State Inspector General.
Topics
-
President Trump fires inspector general of USAID
President Trump officially fired the inspector general at the U.S. Agency for International Development a day after his office released a report detailing the negative impact of the Trump ...NBC News - 3d -
White House fires USAID inspector general following critical report
President Trump’s White House fired the inspector general for the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) on Tuesday, a day after the watchdog office issued a report that was critical of ...The Hill - 3d -
Trump fires USAID inspector general as federal shake-up continues
The Trump administration continued its campaign to shake-up the federal government with the firing of the USAID inspector general, a day after USAID released a report detailing the negative impact ...NBC News - 3d -
White House fires USAid inspector general who issued damning report on Trump’s funding freeze – live
Paul Martin reportedly dismissed one day after damning report detailing impact of sudden dismantling of agency. Donald Trump announced he is dispatching Treasury secretary Scott Bessent to ...The Guardian - 3d -
Trump fires USAID's inspector general after his office released a report critical of the administration
Paul Martin's office put out a report Monday detailing the negative impact of the Trump administration’s push for drastic cuts at the agency.NBC News - 3d -
Senate Dems slam USAID inspector general's firing as doing more harm than good on curbing waste
A pair of Senate Democrats slammed President Trump’s firing of the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) inspector general, calling on the administration to bring him back along with ...The Hill - 1d -
Inspectors general fired by Trump sue his administration
Eight fired inspectors general are suing the Trump administration over what they are calling "unlawful and unjustified" termination. Meanwhile, in her first press conference as attorney general, ...CBS News - 2d -
8 inspectors general fired by Trump file lawsuit challenging dismissals
A group of eight former internal government watchdogs who were fired by President Trump filed a lawsuit Wednesday challenging their terminations.CBS News - 3d -
Fired inspectors general sue Trump over their 'unlawful' termination
Eight inspectors general who were fired by Trump filed a lawsuit Wednesday charging their terminations were unlawful and seeking their immediate reinstatement.NBC News - 3d
More from The Hill
-
Democrats nervously wait on Trump response to court rulings
House Democrats howling over the flood of unilateral actions streaming from the White House are voicing confidence that the courts will provide a check on potential abuses of power. They’re less ...The Hill - 54m -
Trump administration ousts over 400 DHS employees in ongoing workforce purge
The Trump administration ousted 405 employees at the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) in an ongoing workforce purge that has affected other federal agencies and departments. The majority of ...The Hill - 1h -
Trump doubles down on reciprocal tariffs, vowing a 'level playing field'
President Trump defended his presidential memorandum proposing reciprocal tariffs in a Truth Social post Saturday, saying the move will ensure a "level playing field for American workers." Trump ...The Hill - 1h -
Sunday shows preview: Trump's Russia-Ukraine moves rattle allies; Dems play defense against DOGE
President Trump’s push to secure a peace deal between Russia and Ukraine has rattled allies over the Atlantic and has unsettled some Republican Senators who want to see Kremlin leader Vladimir ...The Hill - 1h -
Many in new survey suggest news consumption, spending influenced by 2024 election
A new YouGov poll has found that almost half of Americans, 44 percent, are now consuming news differently than they did before the 2024 election while 38 percent have reported a change in their ...The Hill - 2h
More in Politics
-
Democrats nervously wait on Trump response to court rulings
House Democrats howling over the flood of unilateral actions streaming from the White House are voicing confidence that the courts will provide a check on potential abuses of power. They’re less ...The Hill - 54m -
Trump administration ousts over 400 DHS employees in ongoing workforce purge
The Trump administration ousted 405 employees at the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) in an ongoing workforce purge that has affected other federal agencies and departments. The majority of ...The Hill - 1h -
Trump doubles down on reciprocal tariffs, vowing a 'level playing field'
President Trump defended his presidential memorandum proposing reciprocal tariffs in a Truth Social post Saturday, saying the move will ensure a "level playing field for American workers." Trump ...The Hill - 1h -
3 men claiming to be from DOGE show up at SF City Hall, demand records
San Francisco city officials are investigating after three men who claimed to be from the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) showed up at City Hall on Friday demanding records from offices ...CBS News - 1h -
Sunday shows preview: Trump's Russia-Ukraine moves rattle allies; Dems play defense against DOGE
President Trump’s push to secure a peace deal between Russia and Ukraine has rattled allies over the Atlantic and has unsettled some Republican Senators who want to see Kremlin leader Vladimir ...The Hill - 1h