The relationship between presidential and Senate voting
I’m going to date myself, though my intent is analytical, not autobiographical.
The first Senate campaigns for which I served as pollster were those of then-Rep. Al Gore (D-Tenn.) and the late Sen. Carl Levin (D-Mich.) in 1984.
A presidential election occurred the same November day. Gore performed 19 percentage points better than Democratic nominee Walter Mondale, while Levin exceeded Mondale’s vote in his state by 12 points.
The next cycle, I polled for three key Senate candidates who were then House members. Colorado’s Tim Wirth did 15 points better in his state than Mondale had done two years before. The late Harry Reid surpassed the presidential nominee’s vote by 18 points in Nevada, while South Dakota’s Tom Daschle exceeded the Democratic presidential vote in his state by 15 points.
Senate and presidential votes seemed largely disconnected — and it wasn’t just my clients.
In 1986, 59 percent of Senate races were won by the party that lost the 1984 presidential contest in that state. In fairness, it was the peak year for presidential/Senate mismatches, but through the late 90s, mismatches were greater than 30 percent.
By 2020, things changed dramatically: Just one Senate election that year produced a mismatch between the party of the Senate victor and the winner of the state’s presidential contest.
2022 also yielded just a single mismatch between the party of the Senate winner and the party of the 2020 presidential victor.
Today, the presidential vote seems like a near perfect indicator of the Senate vote.
My Mellman Group colleague Edward Wu and I examined this phenomenon from a different perspective.
We looked at the difference between the Senate vote and the presidential vote (or the previous presidential vote for a midterm) over the course of full Senate cycles. One third of the Senate stands for election every two years, so over three two-year cycles, all 100 senators face the voters.
During the 1984-88 Senate cycle of my polling youth, on average, Democratic Senate candidates outperformed their presidential nominee by over 9 points.
By the 2018-22 Senate cycle, that average difference plummeted to 1.6 percentage points.
Of course, averages can obscure as much as they illuminate. So, let’s dig a bit deeper into the data to capture some important nuance.
During the three latest Senate election years, no Democrat ran more than 23 points ahead of their presidential candidate.
Only 26 percent of Democratic Senate candidates ran 5 points or more ahead of the presidential nominee.
Over half (52 percent) ran within 3 points or less of their presidential candidate.
Numbers like these give Democrats heartburn about retaining control of the Senate. Fighting in solid Trump states like Montana and Ohio seems almost quixotic.
However, while winning these states will be quite difficult, the data offers some basis for hope.
Take Montana. Winning reelection will require Sen. Jon Tester to run at least 11.2 points ahead of Vice President Harris’s current poll average (as per 538.com).
That’s admittedly rare — it happened only four times since 2018. But it’s squarely in the realm of the possible.
In fact, one of the four previous cases was Tester himself, who bested Hillary Clinton’s 2016 showing by nearly 15 points.
If Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-Ohio) overperforms Harris’s current polling average in his state by the same margin he outperformed Clinton in 2016, he too will be reelected.
That said, there’s no question that presidential and Senate votes are becoming increasingly correlated. Why?
Correlation is not causation, so this does not necessarily imply that presidential voting is somehow causing Senate voting.
More likely the similarity in vote emerges from fundamental political facts of life I’ve pointed to here on several occasions — partisanship and polarization.
Most people have a partisan and/or ideological identity that puts them on one side of the political divide or the other. Increasingly, those identities are mutually reinforcing (Republicans are conservative, Democratic are liberal), rendering them even stickier.
Those political identities do far more to structure our thinking about candidates and issues than anything else.
Polarization makes it even harder for people to escape the gravitational pull of partisanship. Democrats dislike Republicans more than ever before (at least since the advent of polling), while Republicans also dislike Democrats more than ever.
Crossing the lines drawn by those identities has become more psychologically costly and therefore increasingly rare.
In response to the same partisan pressures, presidential, Senate, House and even gubernatorial votes are becoming more highly correlated.
The precise strength of that correlation across states will go far in determining which party controls the Senate in 2025.
Mark Mellman is a pollster and president of The Mellman Group, a political consultancy. He is also president of Democratic Majority for Israel.
Date: |
-
Top stories - The New York Times
Book Revives Questions About Trump’s Ties to Putin
The journalist Bob Woodward cited an unnamed aide saying that Donald J. Trump had spoken to Vladimir V. Putin as many as seven times since leaving office. Multiple sources say they cannot confirm ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Lifestyle - The New York Times
Is the Election Affecting Your Relationships? Tell Us About It.
If this political season is influencing your marriage, friendships or dating life, for better or worse, we want to hear about it.Yesterday -
World - The New York Times
Netanyahu Rebukes Macron’s Call for Arms Embargo on Israel
The French leader said countries should stop supplying weapons to Israel, arguing that providing arms while demanding a cease-fire is inconsistent. That drew the Israeli leader’s fury.Yesterday - Israel -
Top stories - The New York Times
Chappell Roan Seeks the Line Between IRL and URL
The rising pop singer has been transparently navigating the demands of fame — onstage and online — as she’s grown from cult queer-pop hero to zeitgeist-shaping star.Yesterday -
Top stories - ABC News
Helene will not derail presidential election: Officials
Georgia and North Carolina election officials said Monday that the presidential election in November will not be derailed by the damage left by Hurricane Helene.22 hours ago -
World - Yahoo News
Mozambique's presidential election: Here's what to know
Yesterday -
World - ABC News
Mozambique's presidential election: Here's what to know
Mozambicans are expected to turn out in large numbers on Wednesday for an election that will choose a successor to President Filipe Nyusi after his two termsYesterday -
Politics - The Hill
Hurricane Milton may be October surprise in presidential battle
The intensification of Hurricane Milton into a Category 5 storm headed straight for Florida will pose a serious test for the Biden-Harris administration, which has already been stretched by the ...Yesterday -
Politics - The Hill
Evening Report — Hurricane politics roil presidential race
🗳️ Plus: Polling static amid campaign chaos {beacon} Evening Report © AP Photo/Chris O'Meara Hurricane politics roil presidential race Hurricane Milton is on a collision course with Florida’s ...17 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
What ‘peace’ in Ukraine on Russian terms would actually mean
To impose Russia’s peace on Ukraine through diplomacy would lead to two major consequences.1 hour ago - Ukraine -
Politics - The Hill
Most in new poll say economy most important issue in election; Trump gets edge
Most voters in a new survey rank the economy as the most important issue ahead of the election, now less than a month away, and former President Trump has an edge over Vice President Harris on the ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Either Trump or Harris will win in spite of themselves
The 2024 election is shaping up to be a battle for the leftovers, with Donald Trump and Kamala Harris competing for the support of the middle-of-the-roaders who don't like either of them.2 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
‘Catastrophic’ Hurricane Milton nears Florida, life-threatening storm surge expected
Hurricane Milton is barreling toward central Florida Wednesday in what experts say is a “catastrophic” storm that will bring life-threatening rain and wind to the state’s western coast. The ...2 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Walz: 'The Electoral College needs to go'
Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, the Democratic Party's vice presidential nominee, suggested Tuesday night that the Electoral College should be abolished during two West Coast campaign stops. Walz ...2 hours ago