The Powell paradox: How the Fed chair’s words keep interest rates higher for longer
The market's continued focus on information suggesting a shift toward a more accommodative monetary policy, paired with its tendency to overreact to any hint of such easing, spawns a self-perpetuating cycle that poses a complex challenge for policymakers. This cycle unfolds as follows: Anticipated lower rates drive up asset markets, increased wealth and spending fuel higher inflation, and the combination necessitates higher interest rates for longer.
The market reacts to various sources of information, including scheduled economic data releases. For example, Friday’s release of a softer-than-expected jobs report again stoked the market's appetite for lower interest rates, pushing the stock market higher.
While some information, such as scheduled economic data releases, is outside the Federal Reserve's direct control, certain information can be influenced, particularly the public statements of key policymakers.
Since late last year, the chair's enigmatic inclinations for lower rates have been a key driver of market sentiment, often leading to a spirited ascent in asset markets in response to his dovish hints. For instance, after the May 3 Federal Open Market Committee meeting, Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell asserted that the Fed would be unlikely to raise rates as its next policy move. Similarly, following the April meeting, he mildly dismissed the inflation data, which was stronger than expected in January and February. Unsurprisingly, Powell’s fodder fueled a market surge.
I use the term “Powell Paradox” to describe the above mentioned instances. Intermittent signs of the chair's dovish tendencies in public statements cause market optimism, which leads to inflationary pressures and higher for longer interest rates. The paradox lies in the contradiction that the very market reactions fueled by Powell's statements contribute to an environment where the Fed must keep interest rates higher for longer to combat inflation.
As a result of the Powell Paradox, several real-world challenges arise, with two significant risks standing out. First, the potential for maintaining higher interest rates for an extended period to combat inflation — partly fueled by the market's reaction to Powell's own statements — could inadvertently push the currently healthy economy into a recession. Thttps://www.cnbc.com/2024/05/01/fed-meeting-today-live-updates-on-may-fed-rate-decision.htmlhis was a prominent concern in the Fed’s April 2024 Financial Stability Report. A recession could mean higher unemployment, decreased consumer spending and increased financial strain for average consumers and businesses.
In addition to the increased risk of recession, higher interest rates resulting from the Powell Paradox may exacerbate pressure on the banking sector. Increased borrowing costs and balance sheet pressures could lead to an uptick in bank failures, particularly if combined with existing vulnerabilities such as commercial real estate exposures or unrealized losses on securities.
This could result in record levels of uninsured depositors, posing a substantial challenge to regulators due to financial system stability risks. For consumers and businesses, instability in the banking sector could translate to difficulties in obtaining credit and increased financial uncertainty.
Addressing the Powell Paradox is crucial, as it poses significant economic and market risks. The Federal Reserve must closely monitor the impact of its public statements on market expectations and price levels, adjusting its communication strategy accordingly. By proactively taking these steps, the Fed can mitigate the paradox's contribution to inflation, demonstrate its commitment to navigating the intricate challenges of the current economic landscape, and ultimately contribute to a more stable economic environment for all.
In doing so, the central bank can ensure that its communications effectively guide market expectations and foster sustainable growth in the long run.
Richard Roberts is professor of economics at Monmouth University and former Federal Reserve executive.
Date: | |
Tag: | Federal Reserve |
Filter
-
How to immunize your bond ETF if interest rates turn higher
Tips to hedge a portfolio against interest rate fluctuations.MarketWatch - Business -
I earn $120,000 a year and have $165,000 in savings. How do I invest in this high-interest-rate environment?
“My husband and I would like to provide our new baby with the best life we can.”MarketWatch - Business -
The Dow crossed 40000 for the first time, a milestone that appeared implausible a little more than two years ago when the Fed began raising interest rates to cool an overheated economy.
The Dow crossed 40000 for the first time, a milestone that appeared implausible a little more than two years ago when the Fed began raising interest rates to cool an overheated economy.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Fed’s Powell tests positive for COVID-19 for second time
Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell contracted COVID-19 for the second time and is working from home while he recovers, the Fed said Friday.MarketWatch - Business -
The Properties High Interest Rates Can't Touch
Competition to buy the world’s most exclusive stores is intense despite modest rent growth.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell working from home after positive COVID-19 test
Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell has tested positive for COVID-19 and is experiencing symptomsABC News - Top stories - Federal Reserve -
Auto incentives are back — but high interest rates weaken deals for buyers
Incentives are coming back to the auto market, but interest rates remain high, corroding the benefits for buyers. Here are three things shoppers can do.CNBC - Business -
European private equity groups forced to keep assets longer
Some firms are struggling to exit investments made when the industry boomed while interest rates were lowFinancial Times - Business -
Brazil's government hikes 2024 GDP forecast, sees higher inflation, terminal rate
Yahoo News - World - Brazil -
The U.S. economy and inflation might be cooling off, but lower interest rates are still far away
Is the economy headed in the right direction? Wall Street investors certainly think so. They drove U.S. stocks to a record high this week. Why the optimism?MarketWatch - Business
More from The Hill
-
White House hits back at Stefanik after she blasts Biden in Israel
The White House hit back against House Republican Conference Chair Elise Stefanik’s (R-N.Y.) speech before the Israeli government’s legislative body on Sunday, when she attacked President Biden for his policy approach to Israel and the war in ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Biden addresses NAACP in Detroit: Watch live
President Biden will give remarks Sunday at a campaign event with the NAACP in Detroit, Michigan, following his commencement speech at Morehouse College, where the president made his first appearance on a college campus since the start of the ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Stefanik blasts Biden in speech to Israel's Knesset
Rep. Elise Stefanik (R-N.Y.) harshly denounced President Biden’s policy toward Israel during a speech to the country’s parliament, the Knesset, on Sunday in Tel Aviv. Stefanik, the highest-ranking Republican to visit Israel since the outbreak of ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Here are the 7 states most likely to flip in the Biden-Trump race
The looming November rematch between President Biden and former President Trump could be decided by just a handful of states. Six months out from Election Day, all eyes are on seven toss-up states — Arizona, Georgia, Michigan, Nevada, North ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Trump suggests he could be a 3-term president if he wins election
Former President Trump suggested Saturday that he could be considered a three-term president if he clinches a win next November. Speaking to the National Rifle Association (NRA) on Saturday, Trump questioned whether he would be a two- or ...The Hill - Politics - Donald Trump