The next trade protection report should tell the US to defend intellectual property
On Feb. 19, the Office of the United States Trade Representative held hearings on the challenges that America’s innovative industries face in protecting their intellectual property rights abroad.
The hearings were part of a review published as an annual document called the Special 301 Report. The report has some teeth.
It names and shames countries that don’t fully protect American intellectual property, or afford market access to goods and services that rely on it. The report also provides for audits of recalcitrant trade partners to encourage them to make timely and measurable progress.
The Biden administration’s Special 301 reports, however, did not fulfill these statutory requirements. The 2023 report turned a blind eye to some of the most egregious violations of U.S. patents. The 2024 report practically encouraged them.
Biden gutted these reports to pander to the far left of his party, which erroneously believes that intellectual property only benefits a few corporations.
The 2025 report needs to show things will be different. To this end, it should call out countries that are tilting the scales on intellectual property rules, such as by abusing compulsory licenses or implementing unfair patenting restrictions.
Trump’s America First Trade Policy memo calls for a study to identify “any unfair trade practices by other countries and recommend appropriate actions to remedy such practices.” The 2025 report must do exactly that on intellectual property.
Intellectual property drives the American economy. It directly or indirectly accounts for 63 million high-paying jobs and 41 percent of U.S. GDP. The fact that these statistics were in the 2023 report, but not included in the 2024 report, shows the depth of Biden’s retreat on intellectual property.
The need for a course correction in the 2025 report is obvious. For starters, consider the case of compulsory licenses.
Under Trump 1.0, Special 301 reports in 2018, 2019 and 2020 warned that they should not be considered “as a tool to implement industrial policy ... or as undue leverage in pricing negotiations.” The 2023 report dropped this language. The 2024 report didn’t even talk about compulsory licenses.
This was hard to square with the facts. Stakeholders had warned that Malaysia used compulsory licenses to promote its medical tourism. Likewise, Indonesia employed one, even though the rights holder had entered into a voluntary license with a generic manufacturer to supply Indonesia’s market.
In a press statement announcing the 2024 report, Trade Representative Katherine Tai explained the deafening silence on these and other cases. The Biden administration would continue “its policy of declining to call out countries exercising flexibilities of the Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights Agreement, including with respect to compulsory licenses.”
In light of this, it was not surprising that Colombia issued its first compulsory license immediately after the 2024 report, or that the European Union rushed to finalize legislation to consolidate compulsory license authority on dubious grounds.
Under Trump 2.0, USTR needs to finish what it started in 2018 and target all abuses of compulsory licenses.
Then there’s the restrictive patentability criteria. Under the rules of the World Trade Organization and U.S. free trade agreements, countries are supposed to patent novel ideas on a nondiscriminatory basis, including with respect to the field of technology.
However, too many countries have intellectual property regimes that tolerate the theft of U.S. ideas to benefit their domestic industries. As with compulsory licenses, these regimes serve industrial policy goals through policies that are tantamount to forced technology transfer.
In the 2020 report, for example, U.S. Trade Representative raised specific concerns about patentability criteria in Argentina, India and Indonesia. It said India “continues to apply restrictive patentability over questionable patentability criteria to reject pharmaceutical patents” and hadn’t “established an effective system for protecting against unfair commercial use,” including the unauthorized use of test data submitted for marketing approval.
In the 2024 report, these concerns were scrubbed, even though nothing had changed.
The 2025 report should do what the 1988 Trade Act requires of it: call out and correct for abuses of American intellectual property.
Then there’s the out-of-cycle reviews. These are repeat audits that put trade partners on notice, raising the prospect of enforcement actions. Under Trump 1.0, out-of-cycle reviews were used almost 10 times, including to encourage compliance with US trade agreements. The Biden administration virtually retired the tool.
The 2025 report must clearly signal that the U.S. takes intellectual property seriously again. This is essential in the run-up to the July 2026 joint review of the US-Mexico-Canada Agreement. Future reviews of all other U.S. trade agreements, as called for in Trump’s America First Trade Policy memo, will benefit immeasurably from this information too.
Intellectual property, not tariffs, is the future of U.S. manufacturing. It’s also why America’s exports of services are in such high demand around the world. That’s the message the 2025 Special 301 report must convey for the first time in years, with a promise to back these words with deeds.
Marc L. Busch is the Karl F. Landegger Professor of International Business Diplomacy at the Walsh School of Foreign Service, Georgetown University.
-
Rams comfortable with Jimmy Garoppolo at QB should Matthew Stafford be traded, per report
Who would replace Stafford if he were to be traded?CBS Sports - Feb. 25 -
Defending Europe without the US
European capitals are attempting to fill the security gapFinancial Times - Feb. 21 -
Which N.H.L. Star Will Be Traded Next?
One month after shocking the hockey world by trading for Mikko Rantanen, the Hurricanes could consider dealing him again.The New York Times - Feb. 25 -
Budapest Pride should be held indoors for ‘child protection’, says Orbán official
Prime minister’s chief of staff says event this year should be taken off streets. Hungary’s Budapest Pride should be held in a “closed venue” this year rather than on a city centre avenue as in ...The Guardian - Feb. 26 -
Economic partnership will protect the Ukrainian people and the US taxpayer
Trump’s bold international leadership aligns interests and benefits allFinancial Times - Feb. 22 -
Can Europe afford to defend itself without the US?
Also in this newsletter: The EU’s peace offering in Trump’s trade warFinancial Times - Feb. 21 -
What's next for US and Ukraine relations?
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy traveled to England to meet with British Prime Minister Starmer at Downing Street on Saturday.ABC News - 4d -
Germany’s Merz says Europe can no longer rely on US protection
Frontrunner for chancellor suggests possible nuclear co-operation with the UK and FranceFinancial Times - Feb. 21 -
The US must protect vital information from enemies like China
Congress should prioritize passage of the DETERRENT Act.The Hill - Feb. 23 -
Murkowski joins Democrats supporting measure granting protections to Ukrainians in US
Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska) joined Democrats on Thursday to support a measure that would grant Ukrainians in the U.S. temporary guest status, allowing them to stay in the country until ...The Hill - 6d -
Trump: Iowa should pass measure removing protections for transgender people 'as fast as possible'
President Trump is urging Iowa to finalize legislation that would remove protections for transgender people, following the lead of his executive order.The Hill - 5d -
List weekly accomplishments or resign, Musk tells US federal workers
The weekend email comes as Elon Musk leads an effort to aggressively curtail the government workforce.BBC News - Feb. 23 -
Ukraine still 'ready' to sign US minerals deal, Zelensky tells BBC
Ukraine's president tells reporters that despite a fractious White House meeting, he is prepared for the deal to go ahead.BBC News - 3d -
What Tesla’s tarnish tells us about America Inc
Elon Musk’s company, like the US itself, seems like a sellFinancial Times - 2d -
Are They a Great Job Candidate or Just Using AI? 5 Questions to Tell
Hiring managers are worried about job candidates using AI. Here’s how to tell if someone is leaning on AI during an interview.Inc. - 17h -
What’s the Secret to a Long-Lasting Marriage? Tell Us Yours.
If you and your partner have been married for 30 years or more and have advice for an enduring marriage, we want to hear from you.The New York Times - 17h -
Manchester United coach Ruben Amorim tells players to expect summer exits: Who should leave Old Trafford?
There are numerous players on high wages that are offering very little on the pitchCBS Sports - 3d -
Lebanon’s government wins confidence vote, says only armed forces should defend country in war
Lebanon’s new government has won a confidence vote in Parliament, with the support of Hezbollah’s bloc, even though the government statement adopted took a swipe at the group’s weaponsABC News - Feb. 26 -
US star John Legend defends playing Rwanda concert during war
'We shouldn't punish people when we disagree with their leaders', he told the BBC.BBC News - Feb. 24 -
IAEA defends use of Russian-controlled route to Ukraine nuclear plant
Yahoo News - 2d -
Use Apple Invites to Organize Your Next Event
Apple’s new event planning app lets you gather friends and family in one place—even if they’re on Android.Wired - 5d -
The US is losing its next generation of health scientists
The U.S. research and training infrastructure is under attack by the Trump administration, and there have been destructive consequences.The Hill - 3d -
Another report Suns will trade Kevin Durant this offseason
Durant said, "I want my career to end on my terms."Yahoo Sports - Feb. 27 -
Sabres Young Star Generating Trade Interest: Report
Photo Credit: © James Guillory-Imagn ImagesYahoo Sports - 5d -
Report: Rams to trade Jonah Jackson to Bears
The Rams have found a trade partner for offensive lineman Jonah Jackson.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Why The Montreal Canadiens Should Still Trade Pending UFAs
The Montreal Canadiens must remember why rebuilding NHL teams sell pending free agents at the trade deadline.Yahoo Sports - 14h -
NFL offseason storylines to watch: Aaron Rodgers’ next team and trades galore
As the NFL gathers for the combine, we look at the plots that will dominate the news cycle in the coming weeks and months. Stafford and the Rams are in another contractual standoff, with Los ...The Guardian - 6d -
NFL offseason storylines to watch: Aaron Rodgers’ next team and trades galore
As the NFL gathers for the combine, we look at the plots that will dominate the news cycle in the coming weeks and monthsYahoo Sports - 6d -
China tells Trump it will 'fight till the end' in trade war 'or any other type of war'
China has vowed not to back down from President Trump's escalating tariff war or "any other type of war."The Hill - 12h -
Deebo Samuel traded: Could Brandon Aiyuk be next? GM John Lynch says 49ers listening to trade offers for WR
What a past year it's been for Aiyuk and San FranciscoCBS Sports - 4d -
Israel's military failed to protect civilians, first report on 7 October attack says
The report says the military "failed in its mission to protect Israeli civilians" during Hamas's attack.BBC News - 6d -
Trump to defend trade war in Congress speech as commerce chief says he will meet Canada and China halfway – live
Top Trump adviser says president will defend his trade war while Howard Lutnick, his commerce secretary, says he will find middle ground. US consumers warned to brace for higher prices China ...The Guardian - 1d -
Mike Green tells reporters at NFL combine he left Virginia after being accused of sexual assault
NFL draft prospect Mike Green says he transferred from Virginia to Marshall after being accused of sexual assault for the second timeABC News - Feb. 26 -
Evening Report —Trump, Musk defend DOGE as federal workforce braces for more cuts
{beacon} Evening Report TRUMP FIRST 100 DAYS © Andrew Harnik, Getty Images Trump, Musk defend DOGE as federal workforce braces for more cuts PRESIDENT TRUMP AND ELON MUSK united to defend the work ...The Hill - Feb. 26 -
Ref reports 'Die' chants made at Real Madrid defender Raúl Asencio in Copa semifinal
A referee says Real Sociedad fans chanted “Die” at Real Madrid defender Raúl Asencio during the first leg of the Copa del Rey semifinalsABC News - 6d -
US-China trade rule change hangs in the balance
Questions are swirling about the status of a trade rule that President Trump canceled and then reinstated earlier this month after it proved unworkable, leading to logistical confusion, an outcry ...The Hill - Feb. 25 -
Trump says US is working on trade deal with the UK
US President suggested that Britain could escape tariffs if agreement struckFinancial Times - 6d -
What is at stake in the US-UK trade talks?
President Trump has raised the prospect of a deal that could help Britain avoid tariffsFinancial Times - 5d -
The US Is Considering a TP-Link Router Ban—Should You Worry?
Several government departments are investigating TP-Link routers over Chinese cyberattack fears, but the company denies links.Wired - Feb. 21
More from The Hill
-
New Mexico Democrat says 'This is not normal' sign at Trump address was 'an SOS to the world'
Rep. Melanie Stansbury (D-N.M.) said during an interview that her “This is not normal” sign she held up near President Trump right before his Tuesday night speech to Congress was an “SOS to the ...The Hill - 34m -
House Republicans gush over DOGE in meeting with Musk
Billionaire tech mogul Elon Musk met with House Republicans Wednesday night to update them on work done by the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), as the newly created group takes ...The Hill - 1h -
Is Social Security money going to 'millions' of people listed as old as 149?
Trump drew laughs during his congressional address Tuesday when he alleged that the Social Security Administration (SSA) had millions of beneficiaries listed at 140 years of age and older. But is ...The Hill - 1h -
GOP lawmaker holding town hall despite advice to avoid them: 'I trust my constituents'
Rep. Chuck Edwards (R-N.C.) said Wednesday he’s holding a town hall despite House Republicans being recently pushed to avoid in-person town halls and do phone or livestreamed ones instead. “I'm ...The Hill - 1h -
Major VA job cuts planned under Trump
{beacon} Welcome to The Hill's Defense & NatSec newsletter {beacon} Defense &National Security Defense &National Security The Big Story Major VA job cuts planned under Trump The Department of ...The Hill - 2h
More in Politics
-
New Mexico Democrat says 'This is not normal' sign at Trump address was 'an SOS to the world'
Rep. Melanie Stansbury (D-N.M.) said during an interview that her “This is not normal” sign she held up near President Trump right before his Tuesday night speech to Congress was an “SOS to the ...The Hill - 34m -
House Republicans gush over DOGE in meeting with Musk
Billionaire tech mogul Elon Musk met with House Republicans Wednesday night to update them on work done by the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), as the newly created group takes ...The Hill - 1h -
Is Social Security money going to 'millions' of people listed as old as 149?
Trump drew laughs during his congressional address Tuesday when he alleged that the Social Security Administration (SSA) had millions of beneficiaries listed at 140 years of age and older. But is ...The Hill - 1h -
GOP lawmaker holding town hall despite advice to avoid them: 'I trust my constituents'
Rep. Chuck Edwards (R-N.C.) said Wednesday he’s holding a town hall despite House Republicans being recently pushed to avoid in-person town halls and do phone or livestreamed ones instead. “I'm ...The Hill - 1h -
Major VA job cuts planned under Trump
{beacon} Welcome to The Hill's Defense & NatSec newsletter {beacon} Defense &National Security Defense &National Security The Big Story Major VA job cuts planned under Trump The Department of ...The Hill - 2h