The Memo: Trump’s turbulent tariff moves pose risks with voters

President Trump eased his newest tariffs on Wednesday after two days during which those levies roiled financial markets.

But the latest tweak only adds to the uncertainty over what Trump’s longer-term policy will be.

The shadows of doubt — and the belief even among many conservatives that sweeping tariffs will raise prices for American consumers — pose real political dangers for the president.

White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt confirmed to reporters Wednesday that Trump would exempt the three major automakers — General Motors, Ford and Stellantis — from paying tariffs on imports from Canada and Mexico for one month.

But that was a modest-sized asterisk next to Trump’s imposition, starting Tuesday, of 25 percent tariffs on imports from Mexico and Canada, and a doubling of tariffs on Chinese imports from 10 percent to 20 percent.

A near-immediate compromise deal on those tariffs, flagged as a possibility on Tuesday by Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, had not materialized at the time of going to press Wednesday.

Now, huge swathes of the economy are on a roller-coaster ride, waiting to see whether there are more exemptions for specific industries, whether Trump will suspend the tariffs once again and, if he does not, how the nations affected will respond.

China hit back at this week’s tariff announcement threatening that “if war is what the U.S. wants, be it a tariff war, a trade war, or any other type of war, we’re ready to fight till the end.”

The political danger here for Trump is broader than the battle over tariffs.

The volatility itself could, in time, fuel voter doubts about his core competency. That, in turn, could undercut his standing with the small but vital share of the electorate who still do not have an opinion set in stone about him.

An Economist/YouGov poll released Wednesday found the nation split almost evenly on how it views Trump. The poll found 47 percent of Americans viewing him favorably and 50 percent unfavorably, most of them hewing to a “very” favorable or unfavorable view.

But Trump’s political fortunes might well rest with the roughly 1 in 5 Americans who view him less emphatically, one way or another.

Those are the voters who Democrats have not been able to win over by their frequent claims that Trump is an aberrational danger to the fabric of the republic.

But ham-fistedness or chaos on the president’s part could alienate those voters in the end.

After all, back in 2020, a key factor in Trump’s defeat was voter concern over his handling of the COVID-19 pandemic. According to exit polls, voters who saw COVID-19 as the most important issue backed former President Biden over Trump by more than 20 points.

Beyond tariffs, there have already been other missteps in Trump’s first six weeks back in power that have raised the competency question.

Many of them relate to the government-slashing effort spearheaded by Elon Musk.

In mid-February, a significant number of employees — up to 350, according to The Associated Press — were fired from the National Nuclear Security Administration. The vast majority of those firings were rescinded the next day, presumably amid concerns about whether nuclear safety would be compromised.

The Department of Agriculture saw a similarly chaotic U-turn during the same period, initially firing some employees working on the avian flu outbreak.

A department spokesperson acknowledged to NBC News at the time that several people were “notified of their terminations” but that they were “working to swiftly rectify the situation and rescind those letters.”

Musk’s quasi-official Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) has also been caught making significant errors as it has sought to provide proof of its savings.

Most notably, DOGE misstated savings from one canceled contract at $8 billion, when the correct sum was $8 million. Reuters reported Tuesday that “in the last two weeks alone, DOGE has deleted hundreds of claimed savings, including some of the largest items that it had previously boasted about.”

On Ukraine, Trump’s approach has primarily been questioned on the grounds of the policy itself rather than competency.

But the infamous Oval Office clash between Trump, Vice President Vance and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has caused tremors across Europe, as leaders try to figure out how to best deal with the American president’s volatility.

To be sure, the dangers to Trump should not be overstated.

He is riding high for several reasons: November’s election victory, Republican control of the Senate and the House, his iron grip on the GOP, and the general sense that Democrats are struggling to get traction in their political battle against him.

Furthermore, some of the policies that elicit most angst among liberals are popular with the broader public.

The Economist poll and a separate survey from CBS News both showed significant support for his approach on immigration, for example.

His actions on that topic were viewed favorably by a 13-point margin in the Economist poll and by an 8-point margin in the CBS News poll.

But, for all his current momentum, Trump’s political strength is not as robust as he or his allies claim.

Polling and data site 538 puts him already underwater in terms of favorability, being seen negatively by 48 percent of Americans and positively by 46 percent.

That is thin ice on which to skate if the tariffs issue, or anything else, calls Trump’s core competence into further question.

The Memo is a reported column by Niall Stanage.

Topics

Trump's tariffs risk economic turbulence - and voter backlash

Trump is making a high-stakes bet that could either reap major political dividends, or seriously undercut his second term.
BBC News - 2d
Trump’s Next Tariff Moves

In his address to Congress, the president made clear that his new trade levies were here to stay, acknowledging it might create “a little disturbance.” Analysts forecast what that might look like.
The New York Times - 16h
Foreign investors in Peru’s state oil company risk nation’s turbulent politics

In a region notorious for political instability, the South American country presents an extreme case
Financial Times - 16h
Greenpeace Goes to Court in $300 Million Suit That Poses Bankruptcy Risk

In a closely watched case, the owner of the Dakota Access Pipeline is claiming the environmental group masterminded protests that hurt the company’s business.
The New York Times - Feb. 25
Trump tariffs on Canada, Mexico raises risks, tough choices for businesses

U.S. businesses are bracing for the impact of President Trump's new tariffs on Canadian and Mexican goods. After months of threats and pushed deadlines, Trump said Monday he would go ahead with ...
The Hill - 1d
How Trump's Canada and Mexico tariffs risk higher prices on cars

President Donald Trump’s decision to impose a 25% tariff on all imports coming into the U.S. from Canada and Mexico is expected to take a particular toll on the U.S. auto industry.
NBC News - 1d
Trump puts tariffs on thousands of goods from Canada and Mexico, risking higher prices

President Donald Trump has moved forward with a plan to put sweeping tariffs on all goods coming into the United States from Canada and Mexico, threatening a trade war with its closest trading ...
NBC News - 1d
'Tariff taskforce': Pharma firms scramble to prepare even as Trump levies risk flouting WTO rules

Europe's pharmaceutical firms are rushing to prepare for the potential fallout of U.S. import duties, even as analysts warn that levies on the sector could break global trade rules.
CNBC - 1d
The Memo: Trump’s jabs at Ukraine divide GOP

President Trump ratcheted up his attacks on Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky on Friday, deepening the first real schism of his second term within the GOP. Appearing on the "Brian Kilmeade ...
The Hill - Feb. 22

More from The Hill

Walz calls Trump address 'reality TV'

Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz (D) on Wednesday slammed President Trump’s address to Congress in an interview on CNN, referring to the speech as “reality TV.” “Look, it was what I expected, it was reality ...
The Hill - 4h
New Mexico Democrat says 'This is not normal' sign at Trump address was 'an SOS to the world'

Rep. Melanie Stansbury (D-N.M.) said during an interview that her “This is not normal” sign she held up near President Trump right before his Tuesday night speech to Congress was an “SOS to the ...
The Hill - 4h
House Republicans gush over DOGE in meeting with Musk

Billionaire tech mogul Elon Musk met with House Republicans Wednesday night to update them on work done by the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), as the newly created group takes ...
The Hill - 5h
Is Social Security money going to 'millions' of people listed as old as 149?

Trump drew laughs during his congressional address Tuesday when he alleged that the Social Security Administration (SSA) had millions of beneficiaries listed at 140 years of age and older. But is ...
The Hill - 5h
I was fired for insisting that transgender people exist

We all have a stake in rolling back this cruel assault on trans people and on fundamental principles of civil rights.
The Hill - Feb. 11