The Memo: Trump, Biden battle over credit for Israel-Hamas deal
It took more than 15 months to get a ceasefire deal in Gaza that might last. But it took no time at all for a political battle to erupt in Washington over who deserves the credit for it.
“The EPIC ceasefire agreement could have only happened as a result of our Historic Victory in November,” President-elect Trump insisted on social media shortly after noon Wednesday. “We have achieved so much without even being in the White House.”
President Biden, first in a written statement and soon afterward in brief remarks at the White House, said the ceasefire deal between Israel and Hamas was based around a framework he proposed last May.
The most striking moment of Biden’s appearance came at its conclusion. A reporter asked whether the “history books” would credit the current president or Trump for the deal.
“Is that a joke?” Biden snapped back.
White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre, pressed on the topic later in the afternoon at her final media briefing, told reporters, “Everybody’s going to want some credit. … What I can say is the president got it done.”
The back-and-forth is inevitable given the striking timing of an agreement that — finally — holds out some hope of an end to a period of catastrophic bloodshed.
The first phase of the ceasefire could come into force almost immediately, with an initial hostage release possibly scheduled for Sunday — the day before Biden leads office and Trump takes power for a second time.
The historical echo from an earlier Middle East crisis is unmistakable.
A generation ago, another one-term Democratic president, Jimmy Carter, tried and failed to free American hostages in Tehran during his final year in office. Carter was defeated by former President Reagan in November 1980. Iran released the hostages on the day of Reagan’s inauguration, Jan. 20, 1981.
The current situation is not quite so clear-cut as the 1981 Iranian move, which was a clear boost for Reagan and a final humiliation for Carter.
Biden is factually correct that the deal announced Wednesday hewed relatively closely to the framework he put forth in May. But the question then becomes — why now?
It seems a stretch to imagine it was pure coincidence a deal that had proven elusive for eight months has snapped into place right as Biden is about to hand over the reins of power to Trump.
Some insiders have argued Trump’s threat that there would be “hell to pay” if the hostages were not released may have helped tug Hamas negotiators over the line.
But Israeli media outlets have also reported Trump’s new Mideast envoy, Steve Witkoff, ratcheted up the pressure on Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to agree to a deal in a face-to-face meeting last weekend.
Chaim Levinson, a columnist with the Israeli newspaper Haaretz, outlined the pressure in the wake of that meeting with a story headlined, “Trump’s Mideast envoy forced Netanyahu to accept a Gaza plan he repeatedly rejected.”
Back in Washington, Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) paid tribute to Witkoff during his Senate Foreign Relations Committee confirmation hearing to become Trump’s secretary of State. Rubio told his Senate colleagues that Witkoff had been “a critical component” in reaching the deal, adding, “He’s been involved in it from Day 1.”
In summary, there are three phases to a deal, which will begin with the release by Hamas of about 33 especially vulnerable hostages, a pause in hostilities and an infusion of humanitarian aid into a devastated Gaza.
So long as Phase 1 endures for at least 16 days of its full six-week scope, negotiations will begin on Phase 2, which would encompass the release of all hostages, the declaration of a “sustainable calm” and an Israeli withdrawal.
A final phase would include the beginning of a substantial rebuilding of Gaza, and the macabre business of exchanging bodies held by the opposing sides.
There is, of course, plenty that could yet go wrong.
Netanyahu could yet run into difficulties with the most hard-line members of his coalition government, notably National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir and Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich.
Israeli President Isaac Herzog — whose office is largely ceremonial — encouraged support for the deal Wednesday.
It's also possible either side could backslide on its commitments, or negotiations as to exactly how to move from Phase 1 to Phase 2 could fall apart.
Biden, in his White House appearance, offered some acknowledgment of the Trump team’s efforts. He said that while “the deal was developed and negotiated under my administration … its terms will be implemented, for the most part, by the next administration.”
Biden added that, in the past few days, "We’ve been speaking as one team."
Biden will turn to his legacy in broader terms in an address Wednesday evening. But he will plainly hope the ceasefire deal can help bind up the wounds that opened between him and younger, progressive voters over Gaza.
Biden’s self-proclaimed “ironclad” commitment to Israel encompassed almost $18 billion in military aid during the first 12 months of the conflict, according to a study from Brown University. Earlier this month, the administration informed Congress of an additional $8 billion proposed arms deal with the Israelis.
The Israeli military campaign following Hamas’s Oct. 7, 2023, attacks has killed more than 46,000 Palestinians, according to the local health ministry, and displaced about 90 percent of Gaza’s population. Around 1,200 Israelis were killed on Oct. 7.
The International Criminal Court has issued arrest warrants for Netanyahu and former Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant as alleged war criminals.
Biden’s Israel policy is also widely perceived as having weighed down Vice President Harris in her election campaign — especially in the key swing state of Michigan, which has the highest concentration of Arab Americans in the nation.
Harris lost Michigan to Trump, even suffering a defeat in Dearborn, a former Democratic stronghold and the first Arab-majority city in the United States.
If a ceasefire holds in Gaza, all sides with be relieved.
But the verdict of history as to who deserves the political credit could be a long time coming.
The Memo is a reported column by Niall Stanage.
Topics
-
Israel and Hamas reach Gaza ceasefire and hostage deal
A ceasefire and hostage deal between Israel and Hamas has been reached in the bloody war in Gaza.CNBC - 1h -
Israel, Hamas Agree to Deal to Pause Fighting in Gaza
The deal would open a pathway to end the 15-month and begin with an exchange of some of the hostages in Gaza for Palestinian prisoners in Israeli jails.The Wall Street Journal - 3h -
Israel, Hamas on Verge of Deal for Gaza Cease-Fire
Progress in cease-fire talks has raised hopes a deal could be reached to release some of the hostages still held in the Gaza Strip and pause fighting that has dragged on for 15 months.The Wall Street Journal - 1d -
Israel and Hamas reach ceasefire and hostage release deal after 'intensive diplomacy'
Secretary of State Antony Blinken had said the U.S. wanted a ceasefire deal in Gaza and all remaining captives released before Donald Trump takes office on Jan. 20.ABC News - 3h -
Israel and Hamas agree to ceasefire, hostage release deal
After intense negotiations, Israel and Hamas have reached a deal that would see a ceasefire and the exchange of hostages in Gaza for Palestinian prisoners.CBS News - 6h -
Palestinians celebrate as Israel-Hamas ceasefire deal announced
Celebrations erupted across Gaza as news spread of an imminent ceasefire announcement, with people rejoicing at the idea of more humanitarian aid coming in, and an end to Israeli airstrikes.NBC News - 8h -
Israel and Hamas could be on the verge of a Gaza ceasefire deal
A ceasefire between Israel and Palestinian militants is being discussed by American, Egyptian and Qatari negotiators, while Gaza and West Bank bombings continue.NBC News - 16h -
Biden says Hamas and Israel 'on the brink' of hostage-release, ceasefire deal
He made the comment in a speech outlining his foreign policy legacy.ABC News - 2d -
Joe Biden says Israel and Hamas on the brink of sealing ceasefire deal
US president says agreement that could pause more than 14 months of fighting matches a proposal he made months ago. Joe Biden has said his administration is on the brink of sealing a ceasefire deal ...The Guardian - 2d -
Ceasefire deal between Israel and Hamas 'on the brink of coming to fruition,' Biden says
Advances have been made in negotiations to broker a deal that would end Israel's deadly assault on Gaza and see the release of hostages held by Hamas.NBC News - 2d
More from The Hill
-
Biden warns of oligarchy forming in US during White House farewell speech
President Biden used his farewell address from the Oval Office on Wednesday to warn Americans of an oligarchy taking shape in the U.S. while issuing warnings of other threats to the nation as he ...The Hill - 51m -
Newsom, Cruz spar over executive order barring predatory real estate offers amid fires
Gov. Gavin Newsom (D-Calif.) and Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) sparred over a California executive order barring predatory real estate offers amid recent wildfires. “Today, I signed an executive order ...The Hill - 51m -
Trump says he won’t hire anyone associated with Haley, Cheneys, other GOP critics
President-elect Trump on Wednesday said he would not consider individuals affiliated with a host of Republican rivals and critics for jobs in his incoming administration, singling out former Vice ...The Hill - 57m -
Biden calls for constitutional amendment on presidential immunity
President Biden on Wednesday said there should be an amendment to the Constitution that makes clear presidents are not immune from crimes committed in office, using his farewell address in part to ...The Hill - 1h -
Trump will 'find a way' to preserve TikTok, Waltz says
President-elect Trump will take action to preserve TikTok upon taking office, his incoming national security adviser said Wednesday, with a deadline looming for the app’s owner to sell or face a ...The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
Biden argues 'oligarchy,' social media are threats to democracy in farewell address
President Joe Biden's farewell address on Wednesday came with a series of warnings for the future of the country, including a rising “oligarchy taking shape” that he said threatens American democracy.NBC News - 35m -
In final address, Biden warns of tech industrial complex, lists threats to U.S.
President Biden delivered his fifth and final address from the Oval Office five days before the end of his single term in office.CBS News - 41m -
Biden warns of oligarchy forming in US during White House farewell speech
President Biden used his farewell address from the Oval Office on Wednesday to warn Americans of an oligarchy taking shape in the U.S. while issuing warnings of other threats to the nation as he ...The Hill - 51m -
Newsom, Cruz spar over executive order barring predatory real estate offers amid fires
Gov. Gavin Newsom (D-Calif.) and Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) sparred over a California executive order barring predatory real estate offers amid recent wildfires. “Today, I signed an executive order ...The Hill - 51m -
Trump says he won’t hire anyone associated with Haley, Cheneys, other GOP critics
President-elect Trump on Wednesday said he would not consider individuals affiliated with a host of Republican rivals and critics for jobs in his incoming administration, singling out former Vice ...The Hill - 57m