The federal debt is on the table this election. Candidates have differing approaches
The upcoming presidential election portends massive consequences for economic policy, ranging from immigration to climate to trade. Yet one issue is not routinely underappreciated: the election's impact on our national debt.
Americans should be concerned. Rising government debt means higher interest rates on car loans, credit card debt and mortgages. It means less available investment for growing companies and entrepreneurs, and a higher risk of a financial crisis, like the one that brought down the economy in 2008. And it potentially means fewer dollars to shore up shortfalls in Social Security and Medicare.
Unfortunately, our debt outlook is worsening. Debt as a share of the economy has been rising for decades but has been skyrocketing since the turn of the century. Sharp cuts in taxes on corporate profits and investment income, coupled with growing entitlement spending and periodic stimulus programs, have propelled the federal debt to roughly the same size as our economy. Without corrective action, it will get worse: the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects debt will exceed 150 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) over the next several decades.
It’s instructive to clarify each candidate’s record on debt. Under President Trump, public debt as a share of GDP increased steadily for three years but accelerated when the pandemic hit—ultimately increasing from about 75 percent to 98 percent over the course of his administration. Biden has fared better, with debt staying roughly constant at around 96 percent of GDP for the bulk of his time in office.
It would be unfair to pin the entire difference on each president’s policy agenda. Much of the run-up in debt under Trump was due to sweeping pandemic-era stimulus and a downturn in taxes during the 2020 recession. And President Biden’s debt record has benefitted slightly from elevated inflation, which tends to drive down debt as a share of GDP in the short run.
But it would also be unfair to excuse administration policy entirely. President Trump’s signature legislative achievement was a budget-busting $2 trillion tax cut, with a price tag that will grow to over $5 trillion if extended for another ten years. On the contrary, President Biden’s signature legislation—the Inflation Reduction Act— is projected to lower the debt by $238 billion over a decade.
If elections are about looking forward, debt hawks have some reason to be optimistic. The CBO scored both presidents’ most-recent budget as reducing the debt. According to CBO, Trump’s final budget would have lowered the debt by about 6 percent over a decade, while Biden’s last budget would push down the debt by slightly more—around 7 percent.
The candidates diverge sharply in their approach to debt reduction. Trump proposed roughly $600 billion in cuts to health, including cuts to doctors’ payments through the Medicare program. And although not specified in his final budget, the former president has signaled that would aim to extend the 2017 tax cut—which would more than evaporate any potential debt reduction.
Biden wants to take a different tack. Under his budget, federal spending on health programs would rise by $600 over the decade, while also directing another $100 billion to federal education programs. Biden’s budget would pay for this extra spending by raising tax rates on corporations and households making more than $400,000—lifting revenues by about $1.7 trillion over the decade.
The differences could have marked consequences for households’ financial situations, especially because Social Security and Medicare serve tens of millions of Americans across the country. But outside of these entitlements, the fundamental fiscal tradeoff has been articulated: Trump wants lower taxes on corporations and wealthy taxpayers, coupled with less health spending. Biden wants the opposite, also backing a plan that will lower the debt more than Trump. It’s up to you to choose which approach is better.
Ben Harris is vice president and director of Economic Studies at The Brookings Institution.
Date: |
Filter
-
As it happened: London mayor hopefuls in BBC debate
Four of the candidates vying to become the city's mayor have taken part in a BBC London hustings.BBC News - Top stories -
Taxes, Tariffs and Debt: Investors Start to Fear the Presidential Election
Around the country, investors are getting jittery about the coming Biden-Trump rematch and peppering financial advisers with questions about what the contest will mean for their portfolios.The Wall Street Journal - World -
Trump held his tongue on Ukraine aid. McConnell says it may have made the difference.
The Senate Republican leader told ABC News he'll keep fighting GOP isolationism.ABC News - Top stories - Donald Trump -
This election season will have a destabilizing effect on US-China relations
Electoral math risks pulling the U.S. and China into direct conflict. In a worst case scenario, that could mean the brink of war.The Hill - Politics -
Tourist fined for approaching walrus in Norway
The man went near the animal on an ice floe near the world's northernmost settlement in Svalbard.BBC News - Top stories -
‘A lot would have to go wrong for Biden to lose’: can Allan Lichtman predict the 2024 election?
The professor on his famous 13 ‘keys’ to the White House, a method for predicting election results that’s been right nine times out of 10. Sign up for The Stakes: a free newsletter on the 2024 US presidential electionHe has been called the ...The Guardian - World - Joe Biden -
Tories have always had a fear of political extinction. After the next election, they could be right | Samual Earle
Even grandees are bracing for the very worst. But remember, such apocalyptic language around the party is nothing new. There is a morose mood in the Conservative party. It isn’t just that the Tories expect to lose the next election – they fear ...The Guardian - World -
Protests continue at college campuses as graduation approaches
Student protests over the Israel-Hamas war have popped up at many U.S. colleges following the arrest of more than 100 demonstrators at Columbia University this month.CBS News - Top stories -
Dommaraju Gukesh Wins The Candidates’ Tournament
Dommaraju Gukesh, a 17-year-old grandmaster from India, is the youngest player ever to win the Candidates Tournament.The New York Times - Top stories -
Campus unrest: Will protests make a difference?
It's been an upsetting time on American college campuses, where protests over the war in Gaza, fueled by social media, have divided students, faculty and administrators. Why are protests erupting now? And are they effective? Correspondent David ...CBS News - Top stories
More from The Hill
-
Riot police drag away protesters at University of Texas as Gaza tensions flare
State troopers in riot gear moved on Monday afternoon to clear out students attempting to occupy a quad at the University of Texas at Austin. Dozens of protesters were arrested on site, escalating tensions that began on Wednesday when the ...The Hill - Politics -
Jill Stein accuses police of assaulting her at protest
Green Party presidential candidate Jill Stein on Sunday alleged police assaulted her and other demonstrators shortly before being arrested at a pro-Palestinian protest on the campus of Washington University in St. Louis. “Basically, the police ...The Hill - Politics -
US finds Israeli military units violated human rights
Welcome to The Hill's Defense & NatSec newsletter {beacon} Defense &National Security Defense &National Security The Big Story US finds Israeli military units violated human rights The State Department has determined that at least five Israeli ...The Hill - Politics - Israel -
Evening Report — Protests continue to spread on college campuses
A quick recap of the day and what to look forward to tomorrow {beacon} Evening Report © AP Pro-Palestinian protests escalate on college campuses Hundreds of students have been arrested on college campuses across the country as ...The Hill - Politics -
FCC fines wireless carriers
Presented by Microsoft — {beacon} Technology Technology PRESENTED BY The Big Story FCC fines major mobile carriers $200M The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) issued a fine totaling $200 million to the nation’s four largest mobile ...The Hill - Politics