The Cold War may be over, but our stalemate on nuclear testing must remain strong
![The Cold War may be over, but our stalemate on nuclear testing must remain strong](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/06/nuclear_war_getty_ck.jpg?w=900)
The Pentagon is currently in the throes of a generational modernization program for the U.S. nuclear triad — comprising air, sea and land-based nuclear strike capabilities — that could cost taxpayers an estimated $1 trillion over 30 years.
The effort is vast. It includes the introduction of a new strategic bomber, a new ballistic missile submarine and a new intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM) system. While the B-21 Raider, the newest element of the triad’s air leg, has proven itself a rare example of a cost-effective defense procurement, the modernization program’s sea and land legs haven’t been so fortunate. Progress on the Navy’s new ballistic missile submarine, the Columbia class, has been disrupted by an inadequate defense industrial base, while the upcoming LGM-35 Sentinel ICBM was recently scandalized by the disclosure of fresh cost overruns.
But there’s one worrying dimension of the U.S. modernization effort that has failed to get sufficient attention — the new W93 nuclear warhead and its implications for the future of nuclear testing.
The W93 marks a significant moment in the history of the U.S. nuclear weapons program. It will be the first American nuclear warhead developed in the decades since the signing of the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT) in 1996, which banned all nuclear test detonations of any kind. While the CTBT has never formally entered force, it has had the effect of introducing a global taboo on nuclear testing, one that has commanded the respect of the great powers since the end of the Cold War.
The last U.S. nuclear test (conducted underground) was carried out in 1992. Since 1998, the only nation to have conducted any kind of nuclear detonation is North Korea, infamously a flouter of an otherwise universal norm against testing.
However, that was then. In today’s world of heightened tensions and renewed great power politics, the testing taboo is eroding at an alarming pace, with former President Trump’s national security adviser recently calling for a resumption of nuclear tests.
Right now, none of the three great nuclear powers — the U.S., Russia and China — want to be the first to pull the trigger and break the taboo. But what would compel any of them to do so? The answer is nuclear modernization.
All three powers are undergoing seismic changes to their respective nuclear weapons programs. China is pursuing a substantial buildup and may double its inventory by 2030. Russia is wrapping up a yearslong modernization effort of its own, one that has seen nuclear weapons play a much more prominent role in Moscow’s national security policy. And then there’s the U.S. Navy’s W93 warhead.
The W93, still under development, is slated to replace older W76 and W88 warheads currently used on the Navy’s Trident II D5 submarine-launched ballistic missile. As the first warhead to be developed in the post-testing era, the question has arisen over whether the U.S. can credibly produce and field a reliable thermonuclear warhead without ever testing it first.
The question isn’t unfounded. The quality of the existing U.S. stockpile, which dates back to the latter half of the Cold War, is something of an unknown. Meanwhile, institutional knowledge about sustainment, maintenance and production has atrophied in recent years. To correct this, the U.S. has even taken to resuming the production of plutonium pits — the core of a thermonuclear warhead — just to retain a baseline familiarity with the processes involved.
The W93 adds to this quandary. The tricky work of designing a new warhead will face pressure to endure the rigorous testing that any other weapons system in the U.S. arsenal would, perhaps even more so since credibility and reliability are at the heart of nuclear deterrence. Despite this, the National Nuclear Security Administration confidently asserts that the new warhead “will not require additional nuclear testing to certify.”
One way it has sought to get around this question is by basing many of its key components on older warheads that have been tested, though the extent to which the W93 is an update of a legacy system versus a totally new design is undisclosed.
Another interesting opportunity has arisen to supplant yield testing with simulations at the National Ignition Facility, though this has not given experts ironclad confidence that tests won’t be deemed necessary someday.
External pressures to test are also mounting, with China and Russia revamping old nuclear test sites and the latter also withdrawing its ratification of the CTBT last year. Though the Kremlin said it would respect the testing taboo as long as the U.S. does, it’s clear that the first to test could heighten tensions and invite other countries to conduct tests of their own.
Washington should resist the pressures of this “testing cold war” and hold firm in its confidence in its deterrent. If nuclear testing is to make a comeback, the U.S. shouldn’t be the instigator.
Scott Strgacich is a research associate at Defense Priorities.
Date: |
Filter
-
The Guardian - World
After our first cold water swim our teeth chatter and hands ache – and I imagine the spirit of Mum not far away | Nova Weetman
We’ve been back twice a week since that first morning. It’s still freezing and we’re still slow, but the shock of it has gone. Get our morning and afternoon news emails, free app or daily news podcastWhen my mum died in 2012, I found a box of her ... -
The Guardian - World
Kamala Harris may be our only hope. Biden should step aside and endorse her | Mehdi Hasan
It is with some surprise, reluctance and even trepidation that I write these words: Joe Biden should stand aside and endorse Kamala Harris. I have never been a fan of Kamala Harris.. I was an outspoken critic of her candidacy for the Democratic ...Joe Biden -
Yahoo Sports - Sports
Five first-round picks remain unsigned, including Caleb Williams
With little room for haggling, all deals should be done by now. -
Yahoo News - World
Sulzer Will Deliver Hot and Cold Molten Salt Pumps for China Solar Project
China -
The Hill - Politics
Is our food supply chain at risk?
Any disruptions along the food supply chain can have disastrous consequences. -
Yahoo Sports - Sports
Tricky moves the Lakers must make to build around LeBron, AD
LeBron and Bronny are in the fold and getting paid. LA also has a new coach and its staff is taking shape. But check out the work Rob Pelinka still has ahead of him.NBA -
BBC News - Top stories
Learner driver failed theory test 60 times
The learner, who finally passed, notched up the highest number of fails for a single person in 2023. -
The Hill - Politics
No, there is not a war on America's working class
Let’s stop telling working-class Americans a false narrative of decline. -
The New York Times - Sports
The U.S. Men’s Soccer Coach Must Face His Failures
A massive missed opportunity at Copa América leaves Gregg Berhalter with an uncertain future, a columnist for The Athletic writes. -
The New York Times - Business
You Tested Positive for Covid. Can You Still Travel?
With coronavirus cases on the rise, summer travelers are once again facing difficult questions. Here’s the latest travel guidance from health experts.
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Federal judge issues narrow pause on FTC noncompete ban
A federal judge on Wednesday granted a preliminary injunction on a nationwide ban on noncompete agreements issued this spring, calling into question its future in the face of opposition by prominent business groups. The Dallas-based tax firm Ryan ... -
The Hill - Politics
Gas export projects in limbo
Welcome to The Hill's Energy & Environment newsletter {beacon} Energy & Environment Energy & Environment The Big Story Gas export projects in limbo despite court ruling New gas export projects will likely remain in limbo for many months despite ... -
The Hill - Politics
Clyburn expects ‘mini primary’ for Democrats if Biden withdraws
Rep. Jim Clyburn (D-S.C.) said he would support the idea of a “mini primary” for the Democratic Party to choose a new candidate if President Biden decides to suspend his campaign amid growing concern from voters. Clyburn joined CNN’s Erica Hill on ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Judge blocks Biden administration's new transgender health protections
A federal judge on Wednesday temporarily blocked enforcement of a new Biden administration rule bolstering health care protections for LGBTQ people, handing a preliminary legal victory to more than a dozen Republican-led states that challenged it ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Biden in fundraising pitch: 'No one is pushing me out'
President Biden said nobody “is pushing” him “out” in a fundraising email sent Wednesday as his campaign faces headwinds following a bad performance versus former President Trump in a debate last week. “I'm the Democratic Party’s nominee,” the ...Joe Biden