The challenging but compelling political case for USAID

Political strategists recently opined that Democrats shouldn’t waste time fighting the Trump administration’s decision to eliminate the U.S. Agency for International Development. They argued that the issue isn’t salient enough; the American people have never really supported foreign aid.

Having run the agency back in the 90s when the end of the Cold War, for some, meant ending foreign aid as a “peace dividend,” I do understand the challenge. I would occasionally start my testimony before congressional committees saying that my mother often asks me why we have to spend money overseas when we have so many problems at home.

I could no longer argue that we were fighting communism, but even in the 90s we were facing population growth in the developing world, instability, natural and manmade disasters, infectious disease outbreaks and failed states. It wasn’t easy, but eventually, we put together a bipartisan coalition and USAID prevailed.

One of the challenges in defending foreign aid spending today — beyond the inexplicable hostility expressed by Donald Trump and Elon Musk — is making a compelling case for an agency whose main role is prevention. Rarely if ever does a newspaper headline include the words “crisis averted,” yet, that is what investments in development cooperation do.

One of the many capabilities closed down in the dismantling of USAID is something called the Famine Early Warning System Network. This is a satellite and ground truthing system that detects drought conditions and enables poverty-stricken nations and the international community to take action before a famine destroys a community and destabilizes a region.

In the mid-90s our early warning system reported that 20 million people in East Africa were at risk. I took this information to my weekly meeting with Vice President Al Gore. We arranged a briefing for President Clinton and the National Security Council, and the president’s Greater Horn of Africa Initiative was launched.

I led a delegation to the region and to Europe. The result was a massive food aid infusion and better information sharing among the countries of the region. 20 million people were saved as a famine was averted.

Just a decade before, the American people watched on television as babies died from starvation in Ethiopia and Somalia. Not this time. There were no headlines or television images.

USAID had averted the crisis. The East Africa region continues to be mostly famine free despite periodic droughts.

The politics of today revolves around immigration. Surges of people on the move have activated populist and extreme nationalist movements in the U.S. and Europe.

Considering that the world has added almost 6 billion people since the 1950s, 80 percent of whom live in the developing world, it isn’t surprising that many would be seeking a better life in the underpopulated industrialized world.

There is no disputing the numbers of migrants that have been pushing toward our southern border. But how many have stayed home because they feel they have a secure future in their own country? How many are now prospering and working in meaningful jobs that help them educate, feed and keep their family healthy?

The Biden administration revived programming in the Northern Triangle countries of Central America that had been terminated by the previous Trump administration. USAID invested $450 million in the region in Fiscal year 2022.

The program, called Centro-America Local, improved economic conditions and paved the way for additional foreign investment. USAID estimates that it created 90,000 jobs and significantly diminished the threats of gang violence and government persecution.

There is little data available to demonstrate the extent to which the program inhibited the flow of migrants to the U.S. border, but there is no question that it made an impact.

One may not be able to argue that the crisis was fully averted, but the work of USAID helped. Eliminating that effort is the equivalent of taking an arrow out of the policy quiver.

Perhaps the most politically salient USAID intervention relates to public health. Some 40 percent of USAID’s budget is spent on the ongoing effort to monitor and control infectious disease. New viruses and permutations are multiplying exponentially, most are being spawned as a direct result of the conditions existing in poverty-stricken countries in the global south.

When the acting director of USAID’s global health bureau left the agency a few weeks ago, he released estimates of the impact of leaving the field: 18 million additional cases of malaria and 166,000 additional deaths, 200,000 children paralyzed by polio, 1 million more children suffering from malnutrition and 28,000 new cases of infectious diseases like Ebola and Marburg every year.

Well, Ebola is back in Uganda, and USAID’s effort to treat it there have been terminated. The same is true of the effort to monitor and arrest bird flu, HIV and AIDS, Marburg Hemorrhagic Fever and other viruses.

The politics of closing USAID is about more than the invocation of fear. The agency and its work have been an expression of our national values, of our generosity as a people. It is the most conspicuous manifestation of our nation’s “soft power.”

As polls have shown for many years now, the American people believe that we spend upwards of 25 percent of our national budget on foreign aid. When asked how much should be spent, they usually say less than half that amount. When told that it is less than 1 percent they wonder whether that is enough for the richest nation on earth.

Now Secretary of State Rubio has pronounced that 83 percent of USAID’s programs are to be eliminated — 83 percent of 1 percent of the federal budget. That leaves a few security-related programs and precious little investment in preventing the worst consequences of growing global poverty.

The future without USAID portends few crises averted. The next time a drought produces a famine, we may see a screaming headline that 20 million people have lost their lives.

Perhaps then we will ask ourselves why, and the political finger-pointing will start in earnest.

J. Brian Atwood is a senior fellow at Brown University’s Watson Institute. He served as the administrator of USAID in the Clinton administration.

Topics

The real political challenge in running the NHS

Streeting will find the buck stops with him on the worst challenge of all: the funding crisis
Financial Times - 4d
World Health Organization warns of possible tuberculosis surge because of USAID cuts

Health authorities say that the Trump administration’s gutting of USAID raises the risk of a global surge in tuberculosis cases and deaths.
NBC News - Mar. 9
Judge rules against Musk and ‘Doge’, finding USAid shutdown ‘likely violated’ constitution – US politics live

Federal judge orders halt on any work to shut down USAid and tells Musk’s so-called Department for government efficiency to reinstate workers’ email access. Donald Trump has called for the ...
The Guardian - 1d
USAid employees told to destroy classified documents, email shows

Officials have begun large-scale destruction of classified documents, including using shredders and ‘burn bags’. US politics live – latest updates Officials at the US Agency for International ...
The Guardian - Mar. 11
Government seeks to dismiss Mahmoud Khalil's challenge of detention

The U.S. government has filed a motion to dismiss Mahmoud Khalil's challenge in his deportation case based on jurisdiction issues argued in court. CBS News' Katrina Kaufman has more on the Columbia ...
CBS News - 6d
Lawyer Appointed in Adams Case Says Charges Should Be Dropped

Paul D. Clement also said a judge should not allow the Trump administration to use the court’s authority to compel Mr. Adams’s support in the White House’s mass deportation efforts.
The New York Times - Mar. 8
Trump vents fury about his criminal cases in extraordinary speech at DoJ

In hourlong victory lap, president railed against Biden officials and their ‘bullshit’ case while boosting his lawyers. US politics live – latest updates Taking over the justice department ...
The Guardian - 4d
Judges Overseeing Trump Policy Cases Fear for Their Safety Amid Threats

Federal judges are worried that online threats against judges who oversee high-profile cases challenging Trump administration policies may lead to real-world violence.
The New York Times - 1h
Turkish police detain Erdoğan’s main political rival

Lira and stocks fall as Istanbul’s mayor Ekrem İmamoğlu, a key challenger to president, held
Financial Times - 6h
Public Health Survived the Pandemic. Now It Fights Politics.

Five years after the pandemic began, many local health officials say that the politicization of Covid has left them with fewer tools and fresh challenges.
The New York Times - 6d
Rubio says 83% of USAid programs terminated after six-week purge

Surviving aid to be administered by state department in radical narrowing of definition of US national interest. US politics live – latest updates The Trump administration has taken an axe to ...
The Guardian - Mar. 10
Trump administration briefing: Mahmoud Khalil’s detention, ‘Trumpcession’ fears and gutting USAid

From cries of ‘McCarthyism’ over Palestinian activist’s detention to fears over a ‘Trumpcession’ – key US politics stories from Monday at a glance. The Trump administration’s decision to have ...
The Guardian - Mar. 11
Business school teaching case study: How can Ørsted overcome its US challenges?

The world’s largest offshore wind developer seeks to boost its share price as Trump policies cloud the future of clean energy
Financial Times - Mar. 11
Trump administration pushes to have deportation case reassigned to another judge

The Trump administration is pushing to change the judge overseeing a challenge to the president’s invocation of the Alien Enemies Act to carry out swift deportations. The Justice Department made ...
The Hill - 2d
More than 80% of USAID programmes 'officially ending'

Humanitarian organisations have warned that the end of USAID programmes is already impacting millions.
BBC News - Mar. 10
Supreme Court takes up Colorado conversion therapy case

The Supreme Court granted a Colorado therapist’s request to review her challenge to a state law banning mental health care providers from engaging minors in conversion therapy, a discredited ...
The Hill - Mar. 10
Judge orders Mahmoud Khalil case to be moved from Louisiana to New Jersey

New York judge denies Trump administration attempt to dismiss legal challenge and rules on jurisdiction. Never miss global breaking news. Download our free app to keep up with key stories in real ...
The Guardian - 6h
USAID order to delete classified records sparks flurry of litigation

U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) employees and outside groups are fighting an order from the agency’s leadership to shred and burn its classified documents as well as personnel ...
The Hill - Mar. 12
The GoBlackKnights.com Bracket Challenge Is Back!

GBK is holding a basketball bracket challenge for the Men's NCAA Tournament and we have prizes to offer
Yahoo Sports - 2d
Trump administration says handling of USAID documents 'did not violate' federal laws

A USAID directive to destroy classified documents had been "seriously misapprehended," Trump administration attorneys wrote in a court filing Wednesday.
ABC News - 6d
Rubio: 83 percent of USAID programs to be canceled

Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced Monday that 83 percent of the U.S. Agency for International Development’s (USAID) programs would be canceled, essentially capping a dramatic fall for the ...
The Hill - Mar. 10
Marco Rubio announces 83% of USAID programs terminated

Secretary of State Marco Rubio on Monday announced the cancellation of 83% of USAID programs. Rubio said the remaining programs will be run under the State Department and thanked Elon Musk's ...
CBS News - Mar. 10
DOGE staffer appointed to leading role at USAID: AP

An official from Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) is reportedly taking on a senior role overseeing the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), giving DOGE more ...
The Hill - 4h
Top Trump official tasked with dismantling USAID is out

Pete Marocco, the Trump administration official tasked with dismantling USAID, told staff he is stepping away from his role, according to an email obtained by ABC News.
ABC News - 1h
Judge incredulous in Trump deportation case as administration lawyers argue verbal court order isn’t binding – as it happened

This blog has now closed. You can read more of our US politics coverage here . White House denies violating judge’s order with Venezuela deportations What is the Alien Enemies Act and how is ...
The Guardian - 1d
FTC seeks delay in Amazon trial, citing recent cuts in staff, budget

Lawyer for the Federal Trade Commission says agency needs to seek trial delay in case against Amazon due to staffing and budgetary challenges.
CBS News - 6d
Secretary of state says 83% of USAID programs are being canceled

USAID has been the target of DOGE, the Elon Musk-helmed agency created in an executive order signed by President Trump on his first day in office.
CBS News - Mar. 10
As USAID clears out, official directs employees to use burn bags on documents

A USAID official instructed employees Tuesday on "clearing our classified safes" by shredding documents at the embattled foreign aid agency's Washington headquarters.
ABC News - Mar. 11
Judge finds Musk and DOGE's shutdown of USAID likely unconstitutional

U.S. District Judge Theodore Chuang ruled in favor of a group of more than two dozen unnamed former and current USAID employees and contractors.
CBS News - 1h
Aid operations in Gaza imperiled as millions of promised USAID dollars do not arrive

The Trump administration’s cuts to USAID have frozen hundreds of millions of dollars in contractual payments to aid groups, leaving them paying out of pocket to preserve the fragile Gaza ceasefire, ...
ABC News - Mar. 7
Malnutrition food product sees funding affected by USAID cuts

Plumpynut is a life-saving food product that can bring a malnourished child back to health in just weeks. But the Trump administration's cuts to USAID essentially canceled funding to two American ...
CBS News - Mar. 8
Musk's efforts to close USAID are likely unconstitutional, judge rules

A federal judge ordered the government to reinstate USAID systems, ruling that the shutdown of the agency led by Elon Musk and DOGE "likely violated the United States Constitution in multiple ways."
NBC News - 1d
Musk and Doge’s USAid shutdown likely violated US constitution, judge rules

Judge halts efforts to fire USAid workers, a major setback in administration’s attempts to bulldoze federal government. Never miss global breaking news. Download our free app to keep up with key ...
The Guardian - 1d
A Supreme Court Case Threatens the Church-State Divide

The case invites further fragmentation of public education.
The New York Times - Mar. 9
The country that kicked out USAID

Two decades after Eritrea expelled the American agency, other nations must now find a way to survive without it
Financial Times - 16h
Former USAID employees on cuts: 'We are going to put lives in jeopardy'

Two former employees of the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), who were fired last month, told CNN the 83 percent spending cuts Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced Monday would ...
The Hill - Mar. 10
Spirit win NWSL Challenge Cup in PK shootout

The Washington Spirit won the NWSL Challenge Cup on Thursday defeating the Orlando Pride 4-2 in a penalty shootout, thanks to a crucial save by Aubrey Kingsbury.
ESPN - Mar. 8
Wakefield and Leigh go through in Challenge Cup

Tom Johnstone's two tries sees Wakefield Trinity pull off a Challenge Cup win at Huddersfield as Leigh Leopards power past Batley Bulldogs.
Yahoo Sports - 3d
Disney's "Snow White" will be out next week after series of controversies

The live action remake of Disney's "Snow White" will be out next week, but without some of the studio's typical marketing ahead of the release due to a series of controversies. Fans of the film ...
CBS News - 5d

More in Politics

Trump ratchets up fight against judges, rivals

President Trump has put his foot firmly back on the gas of getting revenge against his political enemies and those who don’t comply with his wishes. The White House on Wednesday escalated its ...
The Hill - 19m
'Ukrainians do not trust this process' as Trump says Zelenskyy agrees to a partial ceasefire

President Donald Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy spoke by phone Wednesday morning, during which Trump says Zelenskyy agreed to a partial ceasefire. NBC News Chief Foreign ...
NBC News - 30m
Fmr. U.S. Trade Representative says it's ‘unclear’ how Trump’s tariffs will solve border problems

Amb. Katherine Tai, the U.S. Trade Representative under the Biden administration, joins Meet the Press NOW to discuss how President Trump’s tariffs are being used as political bargaining tools.
NBC News - 32m
Amtrak CEO steps down amid Musk calls to privatize

Amtrak CEO Stephen Gardner said Wednesday he would resign from his post in an effort to resolve concerns from the Trump administration. “I am stepping down as CEO to ensure that Amtrak continues to ...
The Hill - 36m
Sanders, AOC hit the road for a ‘populist revolt’

☣️ Plus: Trump eyes Ukraine's nuclear power plants {beacon} Evening Report TRUMP FIRST 100 DAYS © Greg Nash Sanders, AOC hit the road for a 'populist revolt' SEN. BERNIE SANDERS (I-Vt.) is set to ...
The Hill - 36m