The Biden-Harris rent control ruse would worsen the housing shortage, raise costs
The Biden-Harris administration’s nationwide rent-cap proposal to limit annual rent increases to 5 percent for large landlords regardless of their expenses or inflation will exacerbate the shortage of available housing units and disincentivize new housing construction.
Rent control in New York, San Francisco and other cities reduced investment in rental properties, led to fewer units being available at all price levels and drove more Americans into homelessness. A nationwide cap on rent increases would replicate these terrible results on a vastly larger scale.
The Biden-Harris plan would eliminate depreciation write-offs for landlords with at least 50 rental units unless they agree not to raise rent more than 5 percent annually for two years. The proposal would apply to existing units and exempt new units as well as those that undergo “substantial renovation or rehabilitation.”
Like other Biden-Harris proposals, rent control caps are a virtue-signaling measure, not a practical solution. If they were adopted, growth in the housing stock would slow as capital investment would be diverted from developers to more profitable ventures. And it would disproportionately affect new renters, who would be charged more than they would otherwise to make up for landlords’ lost income from units subject to this rent control policy.
The economic repercussions of this misguided policy extend beyond the housing market. A nationwide rent cap could also impede labor mobility, because if housing costs in a given area increase, it could become more difficult to find workers willing to relocate. At the same time, fewer existing units will become available for newcomers because current residents will face the incentive to remain in their rent-controlled units longer than they might otherwise.
A cap on rent increases could also reduce property tax revenues due to a decline in the assessed value of rent-controlled properties. The strain on local government budgets would reduce funds available for education, public safety, infrastructure and other services.
An October 2020 Senate Budget Committee report found that federal programs intended to help Americans afford housing were hindered by duplication and overlap. Former Budget Committee Chairman Michael Enzi (R-Wyo.) noted that, in 2019, “Washington spent over $50 billion on housing, guaranteed about $2 trillion in home loans and provided billions more through the tax code, yet more than half a million people in this country were homeless on a single night.” Rather than fixing the existing federal housing programs that fail to meet their objectives, the proposed rent cap is a simplistic and predictably ineffectual attempt to treat the symptoms of the housing crisis without addressing its cause.
The announcement of rent caps allows the Biden-Harris administration to claim to be “doing something” about affordable housing in an election year. The White House doesn’t seem to understand that the most effective way to solve the affordability crisis and render the housing market more accessible is to lift regulations that constrain the housing supply.
The road to affordable housing is paved with evidence-based, supply-oriented policy, not more economically illiterate dictates from the top. Policymakers should focus on tearing down the regulations that block capital from flowing into new property developments that would increase the housing supply.
For example, they should reform zoning laws to allow accessory dwelling units, reduce minimum parking requirements, lift height, lot coverage, and setback restrictions, and remove other impediments to construction in order to meet local housing needs. Rent control, like other price controls, has never made housing more plentiful or accessible.
Alec Mena is state government affairs associate for the Citizens Against Government Waste.
Date: | |
Tag: | Joe Biden |
Topics
-
The Wall Street Journal - World
How California's Rent Control Hurts Renters
There was no way for me to recoup any investment I had planned to make in the property.Yesterday - California -
Politico - Politics
House Dem campaign arm is touting its post-Biden ground game
September 3 - Joe Biden -
The New York Times - Business
The Customized Drink Is Out of Control
As cafes grant us the power to cobble together ultra-personalized beverages filled with syrups, powders, fruit chunks, boba and plenty of caffeine, we’re all soda jerks now.1 hour ago -
The Wall Street Journal - World
Kamala Harris's Down-Payment Boost Isn't for Buying Houses
The logic is political.Yesterday - Kamala Harris -
The Wall Street Journal - World
These Millionaires Can Afford Their Dream Home. They're Renting Instead.
While still relatively small in number, millionaire renters in the U.S. are on the rise, a reflection of how the calculus around homeownership has changed for even the wealthiest in the U.S.10 hours ago -
ESPN - Sports
Alvin Kamara's 4 TDs have Saints in control vs. Cowboys
It was the most touchdowns Kamara has scored in a game since a six-touchdown game against the Minnesota Vikings in 2020.Yesterday - NFL -
Wired - Tech
This Brain Implant Lets People Control Amazon Alexa With Their Minds
Neuralink rival Synchron is connecting its brain–computer interface with consumer technologies to allow people with paralysis more functionality.8 hours ago -
ABC News - Entertainment
Control of the Murdoch media empire could be at stake in a closed-door hearing in Nevada
A probate court in Nevada is set to begin reviewing evidence this week in a behind-closed-doors dispute that could determine who will control Rupert Murdoch’s media empire after his death16 minutes ago -
CBS News - Top stories
The Climate Election: Rising home insurance costs, explained
The cost of insuring your home is going up, and some homes are "essentially uninsurable" due to rising climate change risks. In Nebraska, the most expensive state for premiums, the cost is nearly ...3 hours ago - Climate -
The Wall Street Journal - World
The 'Yimby' movement that favors undoing zoning and other rules to help build new housing has gained momentum with the Harris campaign adopting some of its ideas.
The ‘Yimby’ movement that favors undoing zoning and other rules to help build new housing has gained momentum with the Harris campaign adopting some of its ideas.20 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
'Hamilton' cast records 'Election of 2024' to urge voter registration
The cast of “Hamilton” has posted a video urging people to check their voter registration status ahead of National Voter Registration Day, which takes place on Tuesday. The artists performed a song ...27 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
China releases jailed American pastor after 18 years in prison
An American pastor jailed in China for more than 18 years was released this week, the State Department said on Monday. David Lin, 68, was arrested in China in 2006 and sentenced to life in prison. ...33 minutes ago - China -
The Hill - Politics
Pennsylvania Supreme Court affirms Cornel West will not appear on state ballots
Academic and activist Cornel West, who is running for president as an independent candidate, won't be on the ballot in Pennsylvania, the state Supreme Court decided on Monday in upholding a lower ...35 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Amazon requiring workers to return to office
Amazon will require workers to return to the office five days a week starting next year, marking the company’s latest shift in its in-office working policy following the pandemic. In a memo on ...44 minutes ago - Amazon -
The Hill - Politics
It took years, but elite colleges are learning the value of institutional neutrality
Whatever one thinks of the war in Gaza, divestment should be avoided because it violates institutional neutrality and thereby damages the college or university as an institution.1 hour ago