The Art of the Sellout: Trump is giving away the store in Ukraine

From the moment President Trump was reelected, it was clear that his approach to Ukraine would be betrayal.

This week, Trump proved it beyond doubt in statements about the war that were not just a capitulation to Russian propaganda but a fundamental misreading of American interests. The reckless shift confirms that the president’s instincts are dangerously misaligned with the realities of global power.

There have always been two ways to look at the Ukraine War. One view holds that Russia is an aggressor and that appeasing President Vladimir Putin would be akin to the infamous Munich Agreement of 1938 — an act of weakness that would only embolden him to push further, perhaps into Moldova, the Baltics or even beyond. Under this logic, Ukraine’s fight is not just about its own survival but about the security architecture of Europe and the credibility of NATO.

The other perspective, to which Trump evidently subscribes, argues that while Russia’s invasion was wrong, Ukraine’s pre-war borders were, to some extent, artifacts of Soviet history — drawn sometimes arbitrarily and not inherently sacrosanct. Under this view, Russia had legitimate fears about a NATO presence so close to Moscow, and the best outcome now would be a negotiated settlement that recognizes some of Russia’s territorial gains while ensuring Ukraine’s security through EU membership and other guarantees.

One can believe in either of these positions. Both are intellectually defensible. But Trump’s approach isn’t just about choosing one framework over the other but about adopting the worst possible execution of any framework at all.

If America’s goal is a negotiated settlement to end the war, it would have to be done carefully, with Ukraine and Europe as central players. Instead, Trump is cutting deals with Putin over Ukraine’s head, sidelining European allies and making concessions before negotiations have even begun.

This is at best amateurish, and at worst a reckless betrayal, not only of Ukraine but also of the very principles of Western leadership.

Even more disturbingly, Trump and his Cabinet puppets have begun echoing Putin’s rhetoric. This week, Trump suggested that Ukraine “started” the war, a blatant falsehood that aligns neatly with the Kremlin’s propaganda. He baselessly claimed that Zelensky has a 4 percent approval rating — another fabrication that Russia’s state media immediately amplified.

Trump even leaned into the idea that Ukraine’s wartime suspension of elections calls its legitimacy into question, a talking point that conveniently mirrors Putin’s recent attempts to delegitimize Zelensky. It is patently absurd not only because the suspension of elections is based in Ukrainian law, but also because Putin is a dictator whose own “elections” are an obvious sham.

Then there was the NATO debacle. Trump’s team has all but stated that Ukraine will never be allowed to join the alliance. Whether or not one believes that Ukrainian NATO membership is "realistic," abandoning it publicly and unilaterally removes a key bargaining chip from the table. It is an unnecessary giveaway — diplomatic malpractice of the highest order. If Trump were truly the master negotiator he claims to be, he would understand that you don’t start by announcing what you’re willing to concede for free.

At least in 1945 at Yalta, President Franklin D. Roosevelt was bargaining with a Soviet Union that was on somewhat equal footing with America. The U.S. had endured a world war, and Stalin’s forces had already occupied much of Eastern Europe. Trump, by contrast, is handing Putin what he wants for free. He is neither recognizing Ukraine’s legitimate need for security nor extracting meaningful concessions from Russia. Instead, he is recklessly giving away American leverage.

Why is Trump doing all this? Among the possible reasons are his long-standing admiration for autocrats like Putin, his deep-seated belief that allies are burdens and his instinctive hostility toward both NATO and the European security order. There’s also the possibility of personal financial entanglements.

Beyond all this, there may be a deeply personal element: revenge. Ukraine played a role in Trump’s first impeachment, and Trump never forgives. That was an insult that must be repaid in kind.

All this points to a bigger problem: Trump is a menace to the global world order that America built and that has more-or-less kept the peace since World War II.

And yet, there is one kernel of strategic truth in Trump’s broader stance. The U.S. does spend too much time cajoling wealthy European nations into paying their fair share for defense. It is absurd that America still carries such a disproportionate burden for Europe’s security. Trump’s crude methods aside, there is a legitimate case to be made that Europe should take more responsibility for its own military capabilities.

However, recognizing this reality does not justify the way Trump is handling the situation. Strategically encouraging European defense autonomy is different than abandoning allies while placating an adversary. Instead of forcing Europe to step up responsibly, Trump is making Ukraine and the region more unstable, all while strengthening Putin’s hand.

Perhaps the most disgraceful aspect of Trump’s position, though, is his attempt to turn American military aid into a transactional shakedown. The administration has suggested that Ukraine should “pay back” U.S. assistance with the nation’s supply of rare earth minerals. This is grotesque. If the U.S. helps Ukraine, it should do so because it of strategic interest or moral imperative, not because it expects some material kickback. Turning military aid into an extortion scheme cheapens America’s role on the global stage. It is a terrible and dangerous message.

So what now? First, Trump needs to stop talking about Ukraine. Every word he utters on this subject undermines American leverage, destabilizes Europe and strengthens Putin’s position.

Second, Europe needs to assume responsibility for Ukraine’s future. If NATO membership is off the table for now, then the EU should make an unequivocal commitment: Ukraine’s accession to the EU will be fast-tracked, with economic and security guarantees that render Russia’s territorial gains hollow in the long run.

America was once the leader of the free world. Trump seems to consider that a job for suckers. If he continues on this abominable path, he won’t just be remembered as the president who betrayed Ukraine but as the man who forever destroyed America’s reputation.

Dan Perry is the former Europe-Africa editor and Middle East editor of the Associated Press, the former chairman of the Foreign Press Association in Jerusalem and the author of two books. He first visited and reported on Russia and Ukraine in the early 1990s.

Topics

Listen: The Ukraine War - How Far Away Is A Peace Deal?

Newscast x Americast x Ukrainecast
BBC News - 1d
Culture wars: Trump’s takeover of arts is straight from the dictator playbook

US president’s attempt to control or dismantle cultural institutions plays into a long history of authoritarians using arts to push their agenda. In 1937, leaders of Germany’s Third Reich hosted ...
The Guardian - 1h
Trump Appears to Back Away From His Gaza Plan

Earlier this month, the president said he favored taking control of Gaza and displacing the Palestinian population of the devastated seaside enclave. But Egypt and Jordan flatly rejected cooperating.
The New York Times - 13h
Ukraine or Russia: Whose Side Is Trump On?

Nick asks former UK foreign secretary Jeremy Hunt.
BBC News - 2d
Trump says he's weighing giving 20% of DOGE savings to Americans

President Donald Trump revealed Wednesday that he's considering sending 20% of the money saved by the Department of Government Efficiency to Americans.
CNBC - 1d
Judge gives go-ahead for the Trump administration to gut USAID's workforce

A federal judge paved the way for the Trump administration to move forward with plans to remove thousands of U.S. Agency for International Development workers from their jobs.
NBC News - 10h
Ukraine war briefing: Trump turnaround as he acknowledges Russia invaded Ukraine

US president earlier drew criticism after saying Kyiv ‘should have never started’ war; Trump predicts Ukraine will soon sign minerals deal with US. What we know on day 1,095. Europe live: latest ...
The Guardian - 7h
Trump to hold meetings on Ukraine with French and British leaders

One day after an angry exchange between Presidents Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, Zelenskyy met in Kyiv with Keith Kellogg, Mr. Trump's special envoy. A planned joint news ...
CBS News - 1d
How Trump's comments on Ukraine are rattling European allies

The diplomatic dispute between President Trump and Ukrainian President Zelenskyy has upended international protocols and rattled U.S. allies in Europe. Charles Kupchan, senior fellow at the Council ...
CBS News - 1d
Trump's Ukraine policy alarming European leaders

There is alarm in Europe as leaders try to come to terms with the major foreign policy shift on Ukraine from the Trump administration. This week President Trump blamed Ukraine for Russia's invasion ...
CBS News - 19h
Watch: Trump speaks on Ukraine to coalition of governors

President Trump gave remarks Friday morning from the White House to the National Governors Association, as scrutiny mounts over his Ukraine rhetoric. His comments follow an address before the ...
The Hill - 14h
Trump's hostility toward Ukraine creates a conservative rift

President Donald Trump’s recent show of hostility toward Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has opened a rift in Republican circles.
NBC News - 8h
In reversal, Trump says Russia attacked Ukraine

President Donald Trump reversed course on Friday and said Russia did in fact invade Ukraine, and that Kyiv would soon sign a minerals agreement with the United States as part of efforts to end the ...
NBC News - 26m
Trump Falsely Suggests Ukraine Is to Blame for the War: What to Know

A look at how the war in Ukraine began, the state of the peace talks and why the country isn’t holding elections.
The New York Times - 2d
Trump says Ukraine started the war that's killing its citizens. What are the facts?

President Donald Trump has blamed Ukraine for starting the war that has cost tens of thousands of Ukrainian lives
ABC News - 2d
Trump calls Zelenskyy a "dictator" after blaming Ukraine for Russia's invasion

"A Dictator without Elections, Zelenskyy better move fast or he is not going to have a Country left," President Trump wrote.
CBS News - 2d
Ukraine should 'tone it down,' sign Trump mineral deal, Waltz says

National Security Adviser Mike Waltz said Thursday that officials in Kyiv "need to tone it down" after a fierce back and forth Trump and Zelenskyy.
ABC News - 1d
Bucha, Site of Massacre, Feels Sting of Trump Shift on Ukraine

Residents of a Ukrainian suburb that was the site of notorious attacks on civilians after Russia invaded are alarmed by President Trump’s warm words for Moscow.
The New York Times - 1d
Zelensky Meets Kellogg, U.S. Envoy to Ukraine, Amid Public Spat With Trump

Keith Kellogg and President Volodymyr Zelensky were expected to discuss possible paths to ending the war and ways to defuse tensions between Washington and Kyiv.
The New York Times - 1d
What are we to make of Trump’s Ukraine policy? | Matt Duss

In Trump’s jungle, the powerful make decisions the weak must simply accept – international law and human rights be damned. It’s been quite a week for US foreign policy. Following a phone call last ...
The Guardian - 23h
Trump's Ukraine envoy calls Zelensky 'embattled and courageous leader'

President Trump's special envoy to Ukraine and Russia called Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky an "embattled and courageous leader" after meetings in Kyiv on Friday, a notable shift from ...
The Hill - 19h
Italy’s Meloni torn between supporting Ukraine and pleasing Trump

Prime minister opts out of G7 call as dream of mediating between US and Europe fades
Financial Times - 19h
U.S. envoy says talks with Ukraine are positive amid Trump criticism of Zelenskyy

Ukraine and European allies are being vigilant after a meeting between U.S. Envoy to Ukraine Keith Kellogg and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy. Kellogg praised what he called a "positive" ...
CBS News - 17h
Levin defends Zelensky, Ukraine amid sharp words from Trump

Conservative pundit Mark Levin of Fox News on Wednesday sought to defend Ukraine President Volodymyr Zelensky, who has come under days of criticism from President Trump over the Ukraine war. Levin ...
The Hill - 16h
Rubio on Trump's Ukraine rhetoric: 'Joe Biden had frustrations with Zelensky'

Secretary of State Marco Rubio defended President Trump's frustration with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky amid ongoing peace negotiations involving their war with Russia and shared that the ...
The Hill - 14h
'Trump is a dark horse': Russians on the invasion of Ukraine, three years on

A BBC team asking Russians about their invasion of Ukraine draws police and state TV attention.
BBC News - 9h
Trump says he's had 'good talks' with Putin but not Ukraine

President Donald Trump said he's had "good talks" with Russia's Vladimir Putin but not with Ukraine, and that he's "sick" of how Volodymyr Zelenskyy has handled the war.
ABC News - 8h
Trump to meet with Polish president, amid discussions about Ukraine war

Polish President Andrzej Duda is expected to meet with President Trump on the sidelines of the Conservative Political Action conference on Saturday.
CBS News - 8h
Trump says Starmer and Macron 'haven't done anything' to end Ukraine war

Trump's criticisms come as the UK and French leaders prepare to visit the White House next week.
BBC News - 6h
Taiwan holds its breath as Trump turns on Ukraine and upends US foreign policy

The mood in Taipei is one of wariness as the new US president takes a blowtorch to diplomatic norms and assurances. It’s a bustling morning at the Dongmen wet market, in inner-city Taipei. Mr Yu is ...
The Guardian - 1d
Trump 'doesn't care' what happens to Ukraine, former foreign minister claims as U.S.-Kyiv relations sour

U.S. President Donald Trump doesn't appear to be concerned about Ukraine's post-war future, the country's former Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba told CNBC.
CNBC - 19h
As Trump sows doubt, U.S. NATO commander oversees war games near Ukraine

Trump appears to pivot away from Ukraine and America's NATO allies, as the alliance rehearses for a theoretical invasion of Europe.
CBS News - 17h
Martin Rowson on Britain desperately clinging to the US while Trump abandons Ukraine – cartoon

Continue reading...
The Guardian - 18h
Trump says he ‘had very good talks with Putin’ and again criticizes Ukraine – live

US president also accuses Kyiv of talking ‘tough’ but having few bargaining chips in latest remarks in feud with Ukrainian president Zelenskyy. French far-right leader cancels CPAC speech over ...
The Guardian - 12h
Trump says he will end the war in Ukraine – but how, and who will benefit? Our panel responds | Olga Chyzh and others

The US president is breaking every negotiating rule in the book, to the bewilderment of his allies. Europe is now at a crossroads Continue reading...
The Guardian - 3h
Why Did It Take a Fire for the World to Learn of Altadena’s Black Arts Legacy?

As Frieze Los Angeles shines a spotlight on art in the city, one community, long facing institutional apathy, calls for marking its memories in the public mind.
The New York Times - 1d
Beloved game veteran Carter Lipscomb passes away

Carter Lipscomb, a game industry veteran with a big personality, has passed away.
VentureBeat - 1d
Bernie Sanders Isn’t Giving Up His Fight

The senator worries that too many Democrats remain reluctant to shake up the system. But he does not regret defending Joseph R. Biden Jr. until the very end.
The New York Times - 13h
As Tourists Swarm Erupting Mount Etna, Italian Authorities Warn Them Away

“A lot of people are trying to get closer to admire this natural phenomenon,” a local mayor warned his community. “But it is extremely dangerous!”
The New York Times - 2d

More in Politics

NYC Mayor Eric Adams' corruption case continues for now, judge rules

A judge in New York City Mayor Eric Adams' corruption case has appointed an outside attorney to argue over the Department of Justice's request to drop the federal charges.
CBS News - 5h
FBI told to transfer 1,500 personnel from headquarters: Reports

The FBI told managers that 1,500 personnel will be transferred from the headquarters near Washington headquarters to offices around the country, including around a third being placed in an Alabama ...
The Hill - 5h
Trump removes Brown, names new Joint Chiefs of Staff chairman

President Trump has fired Air Force Gen. CQ Brown Jr., a four-star pilot, and named Air Force Lt. Gen. Dan “Razin” Caine to be the country’s next chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. “I want to ...
The Hill - 6h
Trump scores big legal wins, but efforts to reshape government still face court hurdles

The Trump administration's efforts to swiftly remake the federal government notched some big wins in court this week — including a ruling that allows its firing spree to continue — but a number of ...
NBC News - 7h
Trump fires chairman of Joint Chiefs of Staff CQ Brown

President Donald Trump fired Joint Chiefs of Staff Chairman CQ Brown Jr., the country's highest-ranking military officer, from his position. This comes amid a wave of administration changes under ...
NBC News - 7h