Tennessee legislators score a groundbreaking win for transparency
Tennessee lawmakers recently passed first-in-the-nation legislation that could change how state agencies interact with the federal government. Despite this groundbreaking legislation passing unanimously — certainly a feat in today’s hyper-politicized world — it has received little to no attention.
The Volunteer State’s new law is quite simple: The Tennessee Department of Education must disclose all federal guidance it receives to state lawmakers. Most people read that and don’t find anything objectionable — it sounds like an improvement in transparency in government. But they also don’t see anything groundbreaking or significant.
This stems from the fact that most of us don’t exactly know what federal guidance is, or at the very least why it is so important. In my six years as a state representative in Michigan, I don’t remember anyone talking about federal guidance. In fact, I’m willing to wager that the vast majority of elected officials don’t know the impact that guidance has on state government. I certainly didn’t.
Many understand that federal regulations and rules, even though not voted on by Congress, have the force of law. These usually go through a formal process governed by the Administrative Procedures Act, which requires, among other things, a public comment period.
Federal guidance, however, has no formal process. It also does not carry the force of law.
Guidance usually comes in the form of a memo or "Dear Colleague" letter from a federal agency. For the most part, it is benign and uncontroversial. Often, these memos can be helpful — for example, providing clarity to a business owner on how to comply with a confusing regulation. However, more and more often, the federal government is using guidance as a subtle way to push a political agenda without going through the more difficult and time-consuming process of actually changing the rules.
This creates the most problems for state agencies, since they rely heavily on federal guidance. Many federal programs, such as Medicaid, are administered through the states. Naturally, the states need to ensure that they are in compliance with federal requirements, or else they risk losing federal funding.
As you can imagine, when they receive a letter from the federal government providing instructions on what to do, they are apt to follow it. Few stop and ask themselves whether that’s actually the law — it’s easier just to do what you’re told. Federal bureaucrats, knowing this, are therefore less likely to bother with the hassle of changing regulations, since they can just send a letter requesting compliance with their whims.
What’s even more problematic is that the public rarely sees this guidance. Currently, no federal law requires public disclosure of these communications. It’s a perfect storm of unaccountable bureaucrats setting policy in the shadows and state agencies complying without raising a fuss.
That’s why Tennessee’s new law, while so simple, is also so important. It brings to light what is currently hidden. If the federal guidance being given to Tennessee’s Department of Education is entirely lawful, then there is certainly no harm in making it public. If the guidance is stretching the bounds of the feds' legal authority, then it is imperative that lawmakers be made aware and push back against federal overreach.
Elected officials have a duty to protect the rights of their constituents. It’s not just their job to pass legislation. They need to serve as a constitutional check on the executive branch in their state as well as against the federal government. Lawmakers are unable to do this if they are kept in the dark on the federal guidance that’s being pushed in their state. This simple act of transparency allows elected officials to perform their most basic and fundamental duties.
Tennessee is leading the way, and other states should also look to adopt the Tennessee model. However, the Volunteer State and others should expand this beyond just the Department of Education. It’s in the interest of the public, for the sake of the rule of law, to know what the federal government is telling state agencies.
At a time when it seems that there is little that the political left and right can agree on, it’s encouraging to see lawmakers in Tennessee come together in a unanimous vote for more transparency. Let’s hope other states take notice.
Steve Johnson is the Center for Practical Federalism Fellow at State Policy Network.
Date: |
Filter
-
PGA Championship: Xander Schauffele drains dramatic birdie on 18 to win first career major
Xander Schauffele hit a six-foot putt on 18 to win the 2024 PGA Championship.Yahoo Sports - Sports -
The Extraordinary Power of Transparency in Leadership
Have you ever envisioned a workplace where secrets are as outdated as fax machines? Welcome to the bold world of transparency, where the open book management style isn't just a policy but a practice...Inc. - Business -
House passes DC crime legislation that would impact sentencing laws
Politico - Politics -
Transparency calls for probe of possible foreign influence in Germany
Yahoo News - World -
House passes TICKET Act in an effort to increase transparency in pricing
The House passed the Transparency in Charges for Key Events Ticketing Act on Wednesday in an effort to increase price transparency for consumers.NBC News - Top stories -
Xbox’s latest Transparency Report details AI usage in player safety
Xbox has released its fourth Transparency Report, in which it details updates on its safety measures and how its incorporating AI.VentureBeat - Tech -
Clark scores 22 points, but Fever fall to Liberty
Caitlin Clark tallied 22 points, 8 assists and 6 rebounds, but the Indiana Fever fell to the New York Liberty on Saturday 91-80, dropping to 0-3 on the season.ESPN - Sports -
Schauffele gets another major scoring record and sets the pace at PGA Championship
Xander Schauffele has set the PGA Championship record with a 62ABC News - Sports -
‘More than capable’: Taylor backs City’s scoring ability for WSL decider
‘They can score three or four in five or six minutes’Manchester City manager upbeat before Villa showdownGareth Taylor has backed his side to score enough goals to overhaul Chelsea on the final day of the Women’s Super League season. Manchester ...The Guardian - World -
Weka scores $140M to supercharge AI workloads with ‘dynamic data pipelines’
With this funding, Weka will augment its cash reserves from previous rounds and work towards scaling the business to meet the demand for AI infrastructure in the wake of the generative AI boom.VentureBeat - Tech
More from The Hill
-
The other war: Cuban mercenaries in Ukraine
Fed up with humiliation and mistreatment, Cuban soldiers of the 428th regiment, based in Donetsk, carried out an operation to kill their own regiment's commander.The Hill - Politics - Ukraine -
Biden's proposed tax hike would crush workers and the economy
Biden is eager for more hard-earned money from U.S. taxpayers, and he is willing to drive businesses overseas again by raising corporate tax rates.The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Morning Report — Vulnerable Senate Democrats break with Biden
Six months out from Election Day, some vulnerable Democrats are looking at President Biden’s poll numbers with concern. Some Senate Democrats are distancing themselves from Biden’s ailing brand after polls show him trailing former President Trump ...The Hill - Politics - Joe Biden -
Schumer tees up round two for bipartisan border bill
Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) is tee-ing up a second attempt at passing the bipartisan border bill — after Republicans blocked it earlier this year — a move that comes as the situation at the southern border remains top of mind for ...The Hill - Politics -
Democratic group targets Republicans over IVF in Arizona
A Democratic super PAC is targeting Republicans over the issue of in vitro fertilization (IVF) in the battleground state of Arizona as Democrats ramp up their attacks on reproductive access ahead of the 2024 election. Progress Action Fund, which ...The Hill - Politics - Republican Party