Supreme Court won’t weigh Michigan ban on state funding for private schools
The Supreme Court will not weigh whether Michigan’s ban on public dollars for private schools can stand, allowing a decades-old amendment to the state’s constitution to remain intact.
Five families and a parental choice advocacy group sued Michigan over a 1970 state constitutional amendment that bars direct or indirect public financial support for sectarian schools. They claim the provision violates the U.S. Constitution’s guarantee to equal protection.
Despite Supreme Court warnings against “depriving” religious schools of equal opportunity to public benefits, the amendment has survived in Michigan because the state has “cleverly defended” it as targeting any nonpublic school, not just religious schools, the families argued.
“If this Court does not act, Michigan’s workaround will become the loophole through which many states discriminate against religious families and individuals,” lawyers for the families wrote in their petition to the high court.
Michigan is one of 37 states with such a provision, often dubbed Blaine amendments after a former U.S. congressman, James Blaine, whose effort to pass a similar federal measure in the 1800s failed but spurred copycat provisions across the country.
Denying religious schools public funding was a popular stance then, when discrimination against Catholics was abundant, the families said, citing a 2000 opinion in which Justice Clarence Thomas wrote of Blaine amendments that it was an “open secret that ‘sectarian’ was a code for ‘Catholic.’”
But in Michigan’s brief to the justices, state Solicitor General Ann Sherman argued that the state's constitutional amendment is “not a Blaine Amendment” at all; instead, it was a response to scarce public funds being allocated to any nonpublic schools.
“Petitioners attempt to surmount this obstacle by tying the amendment’s passage in 1970 to the Blaine Amendment of nearly a century prior," Sherman said, adding that the families’ suggestion that "animus” against religious schools helped pass the provision is “unwarranted.”
The Michigan families told the justices they each have school-age children for whom they wish to obtain public assistance for private, religious school tuition in the state. Each parent is also a member of the Parent Advocates for Choice in Education Foundation (PACE).
The state, however, argued that the families’ petition to the high court was nothing but a “generalized grievance” about a “legitimate legislative choice” and that they failed to show standing to bring the challenge, noting that their complaint did not allege the parents nor children were Catholic or religious at all.
"Without basic allegations like these, one wonders how petitioners could make out a claim that they are treated unequally on the basis of the protected characteristic of religion,” Sherman wrote.
Date: |
-
Politics - The Hill
Supreme Court won’t revive lawsuit over DOJ school board memo
The Supreme Court won’t revive a lawsuit from parents in Michigan and Virginia who sued Attorney General Merrick Garland after he directed federal authorities to address threats against school ...2 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Supreme Court won’t take up challenge to Jack Smith’s Trump Twitter data access
The Supreme Court on Monday declined to take up a challenge by social platform X, formerly known as Twitter, to court rulings that forced the platform to turn over data on former President Trump’s ...2 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Supreme Court won’t hear Pennsylvania legislators' challenge to executive actions expanding voting access
The Supreme Court decided Monday that it won’t take up a case to restore a lawsuit by Pennsylvania Republicans that challenged executive actions expanding voting access on the basis that only state ...2 hours ago -
Health - ABC News
Supreme Court declines Biden administration appeal in Texas emergency abortion case
Court let stand decision barring emergency abortions that violate law in Texas.40 minutes ago - Joe Biden -
Business - CNBC
Supreme Court rejects Martin Shkreli fine appeal
Martin Shkreli in 2022 was banned from the pharmaceutical industry and ordered to disgorge profits earned from raising the price of the drug Daraprim.36 minutes ago -
Business - Inc.
Supreme Court Will Tackle Workplace Discrimination Case This Term
The high court’s docket includes cases that could recast the threshold for hiring bias claims, as well as suits addressing guns, transgender rights and online pornography.1 hour ago -
Top stories - CBS News
Supreme Court won't decide Texas dispute over emergency abortions
In turning away the case, the Supreme Court leaves in place a lower court order that blocked emergency abortion care if it violates Texas' near-total ban.1 hour ago - Abortion -
Politics - NBC News
The threat of election chaos looms as the Supreme Court returns to action
The Supreme Court returns from its summer break on Monday with a new slate of cases to decide, but it is an issue not even on the docket yet that is the center of attention: the upcoming ...1 hour ago -
Entertainment - ABC News
Supreme Court rejects appeal from ‘Pharma Bro’ Martin Shkreli
The Supreme Court on Monday rejected an appeal from Martin Shkreli, who was once dubbed “Pharma Bro” after jacking up the price of a lifesaving drug2 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Abandon Harris campaign endorses Jill Stein
The “Abandon Harris” group pushing for voters to protest Vice President Harris over the conflict in Gaza is endorsing the Green Party’s Jill Stein in the presidential race. The group, formerly ...27 minutes ago - Kamala Harris -
Politics - The Hill
Schumer: Oct. 7 'will go down in infamy'
Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.), the highest-ranking Jewish elected leader in American history, marked the first anniversary of the Oct. 7, 2023, attacks in Israel as a “day that will ...32 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Trump agenda would add twice as much to national debt as Harris's: Budget group
A new estimate finds that former President Trump’s tax and spending plans could add twice as much to the national debt as those brought by Vice President Harris, amounting to more than $7 trillion ...33 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
How the US can help Lebanon move past Hezbollah
The current ruling class in Lebanon must overcome its own Stockholm syndrome.33 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Charlamagne tha God knocks Republicans over false Helene response claims: 'Everything can't be politicized'
Charlamagne tha God is speaking out against what he describes as "lies created by the GOP" surrounding the federal government's response to Hurricane Helene. "It's actually nuts that at a time like ...40 minutes ago - Republican Party